Don O'Leary's detailed overview of the impact of science on religious thinking in Ireland from the nineteenth century to the twenty-first is a welcome contribution to the increasing number of studies of Ireland's scientific history. Defining ‘science’ within the context of this work as generally referring to the physical and natural sciences, in Irish Catholicism and Science the author seeks to address the interaction between Catholicism and science and the question how science related to culture and politics in Ireland in the period under review. Critical to this was the attitude of the Roman Catholic Church (the religion of the majority of the population) to scientific discovery and scientific education. O'Leary also situates this study of the diverse views on the relationship between science and Catholic theology within the international context, devoting chapters to the conflicts that arose when scientific investigations (particularly evolutionary theory) and religious teachings overlapped, to the modernist crisis in the Catholic Church in the twentieth century, and to more recent concerns about the responsibilities of science in contemporary society. Making excellent use of the printed sources, especially Catholic responses to scientific developments as reflected in Irish Catholic periodicals, principally the Irish Ecclesiastical Record (1864–), the Irish Theological Quarterly (1951), Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review (1912–), the Irish Monthly (1873–1954) and The Furrow (1950–), the author takes a mixed chronological and thematic approach to his topic.
Commencing with a chapter on the general political and social background in Ireland in the middle decades of the nineteenth century, O'Leary argues that, although both the government and the various political interests in Ireland were all aware of the importance of scientific and technical education, the poor status of science in Irish Catholic culture can be seen as the result of a clash of interests between British government policy on non-denominational education and the Roman Catholic hierarchy in Ireland. Consequently, due to the juxtaposition of sectional interests, religious beliefs and political allegiances, there was a strong perception that scientific studies were under the influence of those hostile to Roman Catholicism. Evolutionary theory was perceived as a vehicle for agnosticism and by the end of the century, in the author's opinion, Irish Catholic apologists believed that the most influential representatives of science, especially Darwin, Huxley, Tyndall, Spencer and Haeckel, had deceived many people with their pseudo-science.
There is a fascinating chapter on two government commissions of enquiry into university education in Ireland, one in 1903 and the second in 1907. O'Leary makes very good use of the evidence given at these commissions to underline the stances taken by government administrators, scientists, academics and individual Catholic bishops as to the most appropriate system of education that should be provided to satisfy the perceived needs of Catholic students whilst facilitating scientific research and intellectual freedom. The ultimate outcome, the Irish Universities Act (1908), created two new universities in Ireland (the National University of Ireland and Queen's University Belfast), which were, in theory at least, like Trinity College Dublin (TCD), legally non-denominational. This was a compromise to which the Catholic bishops grudgingly gave their consent.
The early decades of the twentieth century saw, in O'Leary's opinion, a decline in science teaching and research in Ireland and, as the century went on, a deep concern among Catholics about how the doctrines of their church could be reconciled with the findings of modern science – although O'Leary contends that generally ‘Roman Catholics accepted that their church was the arbiter of truth and provider of religious certitudes’ (p. 101). In an independent Ireland which had little public appreciation of science or the need to allocate funding for scientific research and education, it was to be the late 1960s before the need to fund and encourage technical education in Ireland was addressed. The continuing tensions and conflict between Catholic theology and science, especially the biological sciences and evolution, continued almost to the present day, leading the author to conclude that ‘religion will continue to find sanctuary in the non-scientific aspects of culture and will prove remarkably resilient, even in scientifically advanced societies’ (p. 239).
Irish Catholicism and Science displays the author's painstaking and meticulous use of his sources and his research is supported by an impressive bibliography. It addresses a new field of research in the history of Irish science, focusing on Irish theological thinking in a period of enormous scientific research and discovery. However, in ways the title is misleading and there is little attention given to the interest and participation of many Irish Catholics in science and scientific developments in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Despite the debates over evolution versus theology in the journals, there was tremendous scientific activity in the various academic institutions and scientific societies in Ireland during the period addressed. In this regard, the author is guilty of some sweeping generalizations. For example, despite his statement that ‘[f]ew Irish Catholics [in the nineteenth century] in Catholic secondary schools or at university level studied science’ (p. 41), in fact Irish Catholics attended TCD, medical schools, the Queen's Colleges and the science courses at the Government School of Sciences and later the Royal College of Science in Dublin. The Catholic University may have been starved of resources by the Irish hierarchy but in the Jesuit University College Dublin (established 1883) which succeeded it, despite equipment and laboratory constraints, professors such as Thomas Preston, John Aiken McClelland and Arthur Conway did remarkable scientific research. Again, in independent Ireland research in the sciences and technologies continued – often related to the development of Irish industry and Ireland's natural resources.
That said, O'Leary deserves great credit and our gratitude for addressing this hitherto ignored field of research and providing an insight into the theological debates and the Catholic religious thinking which formed a significant background to the perception and teaching of science in Ireland in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
