This conference was organized as part of the research project Opera and the Musical Canon, 1750–1815, based at the Fountain School of Performing Arts, Dalhousie University. Conveners Estelle Joubert and Austin Glatthorn invited researchers from Canada, the United States, Great Britain, Germany and Austria to the beautiful Bohemian town of Český Krumlov, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, to discuss aesthetics, the work concept and canon formation in central European opera c1800. Each presenter gave an hour-long paper, followed by extensive questions and discussions.
The conference opened with a keynote address delivered by Martin Nedbal (University of Kansas). He focused on the ideological approaches that lay behind Italian-, German- and Czech-language productions of Don Giovanni at Prague's Estates Theatre over the course of a century, 1787–1887. Between its world premiere by the company of Domenico Guardasoni and the festively celebrated centenary of its continuous presence on the stage, Mozart's opera served as a means of promoting increasingly nationalistic attitudes on the part of the two ethnic groups living in Bohemia. Archival sources reveal how nineteenth-century Czech-language adaptations opposed the dominant German culture by adhering to the original Italian production, which was associated with the city's prestigious status as a centre of Mozart opera performance, rather than following the singspiel tradition. After this presentation, the first day concluded with a friendly dinner in one of the town's restaurants specializing in delicious regional cuisine.
On the second day participants gathered for the morning session, ‘Canonic Endeavours in Warsaw and Berlin’. My own paper (Anna Parkitna, Stony Brook University) was on the role of Polish adaptations of Italian operas, initiated by Wojciech Bogusławski (1779) and driven by his rivalry with foreign operatic companies, in the creation of a standard repertory at Warsaw's public theatre. I argued that while emerging eighteenth-century operatic practices in the vernacular may have reflected national aspirations stirred by the Enlightenment, this cannot be separated from the trend for retaining highly popular operas in the repertory for longer and repeating them more often. Thereafter Eric Schneeman (University of Texas at San Antonio) investigated operatic canon formation in Berlin during the first half of the nineteenth century within the context of the concurrent construction of the Königliches Museum, which was an element of the Prussian authorities’ plan to protect historical objects of national significance. In the aftermath of the Napoleonic Wars, German critics emphasized the need to preserve operas by Gluck and Mozart in the Berlin opera house and make them models for future generations. During the break between sessions, the participants were offered a guided tour of the delightful baroque theatre at Český Krumlov Castle.
The afternoon meeting was dedicated to the theme of ‘Rethinking Current Paradigms of the Work Concept’. A thorough analysis of the first movement of Beethoven's ‘Tempest’ Sonata, Op. 31 No. 2, from Matthew Head (King's College London) severely challenged Carl Dahlhaus's concept of ‘twin styles’ (as outlined in his Nineteenth-Century Music, trans. J. Bradford Robinson (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989)). The movement draws on a number of operatic topics, and such affiliations allow us to demythologize the ideological associations pertaining to Beethoven's autonomous invention. The last presentation of the day, by Katharina Clausius (University of Cambridge), shone a light on late eighteenth-century opera seria's entanglements with visual art and the Enlightenment literary canon. Using the examples of Mozart's Mitridate, re di Ponto (1770) and Idomeneo (1781), the paper explored the ways in which the seria genre imaginatively reworked the conventions of French neoclassical tragedy. Scholarly conversations continued in a pleasant atmosphere beyond the official sessions during the dinner and evening walks through the picturesque town.
Both morning papers on the third day of the conference concerned late eighteenth-century singspiel versions of The Tempest. During the session entitled ‘Die Geisterinsel’s Entanglements with the Work Concept’ Adeline Mueller (Mount Holyoke College) concentrated on the figure of Caliban in the libretto by Friedrich Wilhelm Gotter (1796) and, more broadly, on Caliban's role in the proliferation of German operatic adaptations inspired by Shakespeare's play. Caliban's humanization, emphasized through his ability to sing, poses questions relating to contemporary reception within a context of revolutionary discourse, and also to later postcolonial interpretations. Adrian Kuhl (Goethe-Universität Frankfurt) presented a paper on the innovative developments within the northern singspiel tradition that mark Johann Friedrich Reichardt's setting of Gotter's text (1798). The composer significantly expanded the instrumental sections and bestowed on them the function of conveying stage action. The effect of dramatic illusion was enhanced by historicized costumes, in accordance with the detailed instructions included in the published libretto.
‘Dance and Melodrama’ began with Elizabeth Rouget (University of Toronto) addressing the collaboration between Jean-Georges Noverre and Niccolò Jommelli at the Württemberg Court in Stuttgart between 1760 and 1767. She emphasized the excellent working conditions, artistic freedom and in particular the presence of many talented dancers at the court of Duke Charles Eugene, all pivotal factors behind Noverre's reform of dance techniques and the emergence of his ballet d'action. Austin Glatthorn (Dalhousie University) then addressed the aesthetic issues surrounding melodrama in the years immediately following the enormous success of Georg Benda's Ariadne auf Naxos and Medea (1775). The end of the 1770s denotes an important turning-point in the history of the genre, inasmuch as it initiated composers’ experiments with the stylistic conventions of melodrama. Glatthorn examined these new developments as evidenced in Benda's Theone and Johann Karl Wezel's Zelmor und Ermide, both composed in 1779.
On the final day, ‘Beyond Criticism’ featured Andrea Horz (Universität Wien), who evaluated the critical category of Wirkung within late eighteenth-century German operatic discourse. In the years 1765–1800 stage effect was becoming an important element of critique in writings by Reichardt, Daniel Gottlob Türk and Christian Gottlob Neefe. Inspired by Kant's conception of genius, Wirkung was considered to be a better criterion for operatic criticism in the case of Gluck than exclusively score-based analyses. In the final presentation, Estelle Joubert (Dalhousie University) pointed out that the inapplicability of the operatic genre to Lydia Goehr's discussion of the work concept and canon creation (The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works: An Essay in the Philosophy of Music (Oxford: Clarendon, 1992)) had resulted in scholarly neglect of opera's contribution to these phenomena. In fact, opera might well have participated in the development of the notion of self-contained ‘works’. One example is provided by Beethoven's Fidelio, which seems (at least partially) to adhere to Goethe's concept of aesthetic autonomy. Following the session, the afternoon was spent on group sight-seeing. A seasonal event at the castle called ‘Baroque Night’ became the perfect way to close this inspiring conference. In a festive mood, the participants enjoyed multiple culinary and artistic attractions, of which the historically oriented performance of the German comic opera Das Orakel by Antonín Laube (1718–1784) at the well-preserved baroque theatre was certainly the most memorable.
