In the church father Tertullian's treatise against heretics, he memorably asks, ‘What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?’ (Prescription against Heretics 7). Even on Tertullian's admission, ‘Athens’ has quite a bit to do with ‘Jerusalem’. This volume of essays examines the relationship between philosophy and religion in Late Antiquity. Many of the essays would likely frame Tertullian's question as ‘what has Alexandria to do with Jerusalem’, and again, the answers revealed in these scholars’ contributions is that Alexandrian philosophy contributed mightily to Judeo-Christianity.
Philosophical schools in antiquity did not always model groups of inquiry, focusing only on epistemological questions. Different schools of philosophy such as the Pythagorians, Stoics, or Epicureans always venerated, and almost deified, their founders. Philosophies certainly sold themselves on their well-known founders, their tradition, and their success. Depicting Christianity as a philosophy was certainly a tactic patristic authors such as Justin Martyr and Clement of Alexandria employed. It is in this milieu that the famous Roman physician Galen granted Christians the label of a philosophy, for he believed that even if Christianity was misguided, it still provided citizens with a legitimate path to a virtuous life. Later critics would similarly deem Christianity a philosophy, albeit a simple one, as authors such as Porphyry remarked that Christian philosophy is primarily concerned with moral character and traits that can only be described as noble. As the essays in this collection suggest, Christians in Late Antiquity identified their faith as a philosophy; as a true path of inquiry wedded with Hellenistic philosophical tenets.
Dihle inaugurates the book by analysing the reception of Greek philosophy by the Jews and Christians in Late Antiquity. When discussing the reception of philosophy on the Hellenic mind, the map always points towards Alexandria, and usually three representative figures, Philo, Clement and Origen. The emphasis on the Alexandrians sets the tone for the collection; Alexandria obviously had much to do with ‘Jerusalem’. Albrecht, by contrast, examines influence from texts in Latin, such as Augustine's interpretation of Vergil's Fourth Eclogue as predicting the Messiah (City of God, 10.27; Ep. 137.3.12). As Jaroslav Pelikan has pointed out before (in his Jesus through the Centuries: His Place in the History of Culture (1999), 35–6, a source that should be noted in this essay), early Christians mined non-Christian literary sources for proof-texts of Christ. Additionally, the author could have profitably discussed the popularity of the Sibylline Oracles as further evidence of Christian usage of Greco-Roman sources.
Gregory Sterling focuses on the philosophical traditions of the Alexandrian Jews. He focuses on Hellenistic philosophy's inroads to the Jews, whilst posing the question of Judaism's possible influence upon Hellenistic philosophy. Most useful is the discussion of Philo's contribution. The allegorical interpretations of Philo and their impact upon patristic thought are well known; here Sterling offers a detailed yet concise digest of the Philonic understanding of God.
As will become obvious to the reader, many of these essays tread upon similar ground. Many treat the same Greek and Alexandrian thinkers such as Plato, Aristotle, and Philo with the same general brush. Several inclusions here diverge from the pack and prove their merit by including distinctive and valuable treatments of material such as Reinhard Feldmeier's discussion of Jewish apocryphal literature; Adolf Martin Ritter's essay focusing on the patristic evidence and its reflection of philosophy; Ilinca Tanaseanu-Döbler's argument that Clement's use of Plutarch influenced his interpretation of the Temple as symbol; and Hersch-Luipold's section on New Testament connections with philosophy.
Herwig Görgemanns provides a notable and detailed piece concerning the foundations of ‘religious philosophy’ and ‘philosophical religion’. Görgemanns begins by describing the various developing schools of thought during the Hellenistic era such as Epicureans, Stoics, Peripatetics, and Pythagoreans; he also discusses the Orphic mystery cult, and Hermes Trismegistus. This is not unimportant: patristic authors such as Lactantius knew of the Corpus Hermeticum and its allure to Gnostic groups. The subject of Gnosticism is evaluated robustly in Zlatko Pleše's contribution. Pleše states his goal at the outset, to examine how Gnostic literature integrated Greek philosophy and various religious influences during the first three centuries a.d. Pleše thereby shows how Gnostics interpreted scripture and combined that interpretation with their understanding of philosophy. Gnosticism is consistently a subject that confuses both student and non-specialist alike and this is a helpful digest. Devorah Dimant's piece on the Qumran community focuses on its assertion that the group based the authority of the Torah upon a progressive revelation. It offers a compelling insight into the activity of the enigmatic Qumran community, though its fit with the volume's themes as a whole is less clear.
Thum and Kirchschläger launch the section of the volume devoted to more special topics. Thum contributes an article focused on Plutarch's On the E at Delphi; Kirchschläger considers John's gospel, specifically Jesus’ exchange with Pilate, and the nature of truth in John. Jane Heath discusses an enigmatic Pauline passage of 2 Cor 4:7–12 where Paul refers to Jesus as an ‘icon’ of God and Paul as an ‘icon’ of Christ. Heath argues that instead of focusing on the wide range of topics that ‘icon’ could represent (cosmos, saintly life, human being), the best answer is the simplest: Paul may have been referencing material culture. The art historian Ernst Kitzinger helped establish the long-held belief that early Christians were hostile towards art for fear of idolatry. More recent scholars such as Paul Corby Finney, Thomas Mathews, and Robin M. Jensen have suggested that early Christians were not iconophobic at all and Heath's essay contributes to this recent scholarship, as she uses the latter part of her article to illustrate how philosophy shaped the early Christians’ understanding of the ‘icon’ in this context. Christ, encased in dead flesh, was still an image of God for Paul, just as Adam formed out of dust was an image of God. Heath offers a compelling discussion of the relationship between icon and idolatry, as well as likeness and image, and is evidence of the particular fruitfulness yielded by interdisciplinary study.
Fritz Heinrich's essay on Apuleius and Ali Schariati rounds out the volume considering these religious intellectuals. Ali Schariati was the well-known Iranian intellectual who contributed greatly to an understanding of Islam as social justice. Heinrich moves through the biography of Schariati quite clearly, before attempting to establish connections between Schariati and Apuleius: an interesting endeavour, if ultimately unconvincing, and a strange end to the volume.
An exceptionally useful appendix contains primary texts that are mentioned in the volume. The book represents a valuable contribution to the field of religion and philosophy that goes slightly beyond the usual collection of conference proceedings. While the essays exhibit the breadth and scope of philosophy's relationship and contribution to late antique Judeo-Christianity, few pieces will appeal to non-specialists (with the exception of Heath's contribution on material culture), but the book certainly belongs on the shelves of students and scholars of Alexandrian Christianity and readers interested in Greek and Latin philosophical contributions to late antique religion.
