This book is intriguing, with a compelling thesis. It is a study of the ‘modernisation’ of public services in Britain over the past decade, with specific reference to employee relations. The ‘New Labour’ government (1997−2010) promoted a distinctive approach to the ‘modernisation’ of the state, one of its principal objectives, a composite of egalitarian ambitions coupled with the promotion of market type relations. For the authors, these measures are exemplars of the Third Way; a version of neo-liberalism with a social focus. Through a richly textured examination, the authors provide a challenging and salutary account of this period of British history. It is a history with lessons.
The prime focus is on public services. Aspects and functions of the state were privatised and out-sourced or contracted-out. The rules that inform and bind the state were recast, or ‘deregulated’ in the names of efficiency, low taxation, ‘freedom’ and a recognition of individual concerns as consumers (no longer university student, welfare recipient, tax payer, patient, although police remain police and military, military). But, it was also a government that was passionate about equality and the state as a model employer. It is a paradoxical shift: in the name of freedom, we are subjects of an authoritarian and demanding state but it is also a state that sought to provide the basis for a more just and egalitarian state as an employer. The means was via ‘a synthesis of market and hierarchy principles with the network governance model’ (p. 32). This model refers to ‘the involvement of a wider range of actors, collaborating within networks, to develop user-centred solutions to the challenges faced by public services’ (p. 29). Thus, the modern state has been transformed and central to this transformation is the fate of those who are employed in the public services.
One of the distinctive features of ‘New Labour’ (a convenient designation in this account) is the attempt to recover the label of model employer, where state workers are employed in relation to ‘best practice’. Historically, collective industrial relations practices in the past resulted in relatively stable and well-organised forms of unionism, committed to forms of partnership and consultation with successive governments. These presumptions were challenged by the Conservative governments of the 1980s and 1990s, with the private sector increasingly invoked as the model employer. With the election of New Labour, the authors demonstrate how these governments promoted forms of engagement with state workers and their unions.
The tensions within this approach to work and employment relations meant that state workers experienced competing and often contradictory pressures. They were ‘managed’ and they were consulted. Equally while unions were consulted, they also were caught by pressures to comply with increasingly intrusive and oppressive managerial and audit practices. For unions, this resulted in tensions between defending established practices and advocating alternative views of the organisation and focus of public services.
This account reminds us that the new Labour period was distinctive. The authors suggest that the New Labour period, a form of populist interventionism, was a staging post in the effective end of traditional social democratic governance. Nonetheless, the New Labour agenda was distinctive and imaginative. In this respect, the authors have presented a challenging and salutary analysis.
But, there is a sting in the tale by Bach and Kessler. The authors lack a theory of social mobilisation. Their presentation of state unions lacks an analytic basis. They review trends in membership, moves to embrace organising strategies, the possibilities of community unionism, engagements with governments as employers and policy makers. However, their account is ahistorical and fails to note where unions came from in the 1970s and 1980s − from staff associations to collective and active unions, able to challenge the state as employer. Such developments provided the foundation for the emergence of activist leaderships in a number of unions across the public services. This recognition draws attention to the reorganisation, capacity building and refocus of purpose that characterised so many state unions through this period, and particularly those in the civil service. After all, it was these unions that effectively challenged and questioned New Labour, highlighting the tensions of populist intervention. An adequate analysis starts from a recognition of the ways unions and workers are caught between pressures to defend the status quo and pressures to develop and define alternative ways of looking at the state.
What this neglect also reveals is that the authors overlook the dimension of power. Paradoxically, the authors do not actually examine the state as employer; rather they consider worker experience and employment relations. While valuable and evocative, it also is critical that we consider the state as employer resting on waged labour, either directly or indirectly employed. Once we take this step, we are engaged in studying the dynamics of exploitation and the commodification of the state employment relation. This provides the analytic basis for the tension between individualism and collective forms of organisation and action. It also presents the foundation for understanding the dilemmas of trade unionism.
In a contrast with the current populist Conservative-led Coalition government (2010−), the authors show how in the name of individual discretion (freedom), the state structure and forms of network governance are being dismantled and dismembered in education, health, welfare and elsewhere. As the authors note, New Labour opened ‘the door’ to ‘organisational fragmentation and extending the use of markets’ (p. 183). The detail of the analysis of ‘New Labour’ and the comparison with the current government should make us rethink and prompt analyses of the way out of the mess we are all in, in the UK, Australia and so on.
This book presents a nuanced analysis. The policies and practices of the New Labour period were marked by a tension between participative state engagement, power and regulation and the authoritarian and deterministic requirements of market society. We should thank the authors for opening up a distinctive line of analysis, challenging, puzzling and thoughtful. Read the book and debate it.
