This anthology examines the complex twin effect of time on the trials of core international crimes: on the one hand, access to archives may improve over time, and so the passage of time could improve the amount and quality of documentary evidence. On the other hand, crime scenes could erode over time, and memories of specific events could fade. Time is an especially critical matter in both international criminal trials and domestic trials that address core international crimes, because both typically start only after a considerable amount of time has lapsed since the commission of the crimes. This anthology consists of papers presented at a seminar in Dhaka in 2011 against the backdrop of Bangladesh's decision to investigate atrocities committed during the 1971 War of Liberation. The book is divided into two parts: the first examines the effect of time on evidence production and trials in general; the second part zooms in on the latest developments in Bangladesh as a timely case-study.
Most of the contributors to the first part have hinged their discussions on the three broad areas of difficulty concerning old evidence: passage of time, production of old evidence, and public perception. David Cohen considers issues relating to the vagaries of memory, including the problem of differentiating a witness's testimony from the collective memory of a society, and the effect of trauma on the memory and testimony of a witness. Martin Witteveen addresses similar issues from a slightly different angle. He examines memory in different phases—the encoding, retention, and retrieving of information—and problems relating to criminal investigation and subsequent trials. Anya Topiwala and Seena Fazel resolve the issue of trauma and memory from the viewpoint of a medical expert, asserting that as long as certain interrogation guidelines are followed, the memory of a traumatized victim can still be a valid source.
The production of old evidence raises issues such as how to take witness statements in a sensitive and unbiased manner, case consolidation from witness interviews, and the role of judges in filtering evidence. Several contributors have touched upon this last issue. For example, Andrew Cayley considers the production of old evidence in four areas: crime scenes, documents, witnesses, and expert evidence from the perspective of an international prosecutor. Patrick J. Treanor demonstrates the increasingly important role in international criminal trials of expert reports by historians.
Public perception is another complicated issue. Agnieszka Klonowiecka-Milart considers the effects of collective conceptions, as well as the importance of the first case. Mahdev Mohan provides some in-depth analysis of the messaging effect of international criminal trials. Remarkably, Mohan not only offers a list of highly instructive messages that a trial can send, but also provides recommendations regarding how this can be achieved. He advocates “engaging but not over-burdening” civil society so as to send the message that there is a distinction between judicial and non-judicial actors. Mohan constantly emphasizes the need to be sensitive to victims, who play an important role in shaping public perception.
The second part of this volume contextualizes the three areas of difficulty as regards Bangladesh, where the crimes committed in the 1971 War of Liberation are now being tried before the Bangladesh International Crimes Tribunal. M. Amir-Ul Islam offers a thorough historical overview of the atrocities committed and makes a compelling case for ending the culture of impunity. According to M. Amir-Ul Islam, the forty-year delay in conducting the trials following the establishment in 1973 of the legal framework for the Tribunal is a principal reason for the recurring violence in Bangladesh's recent history. As Bangladesh's Minister of Law, Justice, and Parliamentary Affairs, Shafique Ahmed reassures the audience of Bangladesh's commitment to end impunity for genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes at all levels. Ahmed raises high hopes that the trials will be conducted “in accordance with international legal and human rights standards” and in a manner “that maintains fairness and due process of law”. His optimism is not, however, shared by the following contributor, Md. Shahinur Islam, who raises valid concerns about the standards of these trials; he stresses that the Tribunal is of a purely domestic nature, and its governing legal framework can only be interpreted in the light of the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973. There may be a considerable gap between the 1973 legislation and that of international legal standards. Finally, Otto Triffterer, one of the founding fathers of international criminal law, gives an overview of the historical context of the international legal situation at the time that the 1973 Act was drafted.
Overall, the anthology is to be praised for going beyond theory to consolidate a list of practical advice and solutions. The anthology does not focus only on the effects of old evidence but also on how to apply old evidence in the interests of fair criminal justice. Given that the passage of time is inevitable, it is wise to fight with time, not against it. The anthology is right to note that perhaps the most significant advantage of time is the opportunity it affords a society to form its own perceptions about the trial of core international crimes. As the contributors to this volume rightly stress, for the process to be perceived as just and equitable there must be the utmost respect for the rule that evidence—old or new alike—needs to meet international standards of proof.
