Between 1731 and 1736 Herman Boerhaave amalgamated and then separated a sample of gold and mercury 877 times to test whether mercury could be ‘fixed’ in gold. He had designed this didactic experiment to evaluate a theory he had been teaching for twenty-seven years in chemistry courses at the University of Leiden, namely that mercury provided one of the essential components of all metals and that, if isolated and purified, it would bring about the artificial growth of the ‘seeds’ of metal. In other words, it would appear that Boerhaave was testing the possibility of transmutation itself. But, as we might suspect from the state of history of alchemy today, the situation is both more complex and more interesting. At the same time that he was investigating mercury, Boerhaave was beginning to speculate about another substance from mine lore, called ‘Guhr’, as an alternative component of all metals. Like many other (al)chemical practitioners, he had never been an uncritical proponent of alchemical transmutation, and his experiments of the 1730s convinced him not that alchemical transmutation was impossible, but that he had been teaching the wrong theory of metals all those years.
Boerhaave's experiment is recounted in John Powers's outstanding contribution to a volume that began as a 2006 Chemical Heritage Foundation conference on alchemy and now is an eclectic and intriguing collection of twenty-two essays. As such, the volume, edited by Lawrence Principe, gives a sense of the field, including much detailed information useful to historians of alchemy and chemistry. But it will also be of interest more widely to historians of science because it illuminates in important ways the dynamics of early modern natural knowledge-making. While I cannot begin in this brief review to include everything that is valuable in this volume, let me give several examples of these larger insights which many of the essays provide.
Margaret Garber's investigation of the theological dimensions of matter theory in seventeenth-century Prague shows that controversies over transubstantiation – themselves indicative of varying approaches to devotional practice – were fought out in debates about matter theory. Not enough research has been done on the religious aspects of alchemical debates, and her essay, along with that of Dane Daniel on Paracelsian theology, reminds us how fruitful it can be. Several essays illustrate the hybrid nature of (al)chemical theories, showing that sixteenth- and seventeenth-century practitioners could simultaneously hold corpuscular and hylomorphic, and vitalistic and mechanist theories. Taken together, what these essays suggest is that we historians of science sometimes take the wrong approach to ‘theory’ in the early modern period. In this era, when textual authorities and texts were still the building blocks of knowledge production, and much knowledge-making was carried out by a process of compilation – excerpting, commonplacing, and gathering ‘the flowers’ of texts – we probably should not be surprised that what we regard as contradictory theories could be combined and deployed together. We get a vivid sense of how this process worked in an essay by Gabriele Ferrario that follows one of the most important texts of medieval Arabic alchemy, the Liber de aluminibus et salibus, through various incarnations in Arabic, Latin and Hebrew (with interjections in Italian transliterated into Hebrew letters). Ferrario asks: should we think of a practical alchemical book as a fixed unit? My point here is similar: is it useful to think about theories as fixed, coherent wholes in this period?
Another important new trend evident in these essays might be called ‘the material turn’, and is exemplified by the contributions by Marcos Martinón-Torres and R. Werner Soukup. These two essays employ fascinating archaeological evidence of alchemical practice from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, and remind us not just how important mining and assaying was for much of the practice of (al)chemistry, but also how significant were the developments in the production of materials generally. This is obvious in the case of new materials obtained by distillation, for example, but less well known are the materials and processes by which crucibles were produced. Martinón-Torres has found that standardized crucibles were mass-produced by the sixteenth century and helped to fuel a ‘surge in the experimentation with matter’ in this period (p. 161).
A further contribution made by this volume comes in the essays that hint at the reasons for the decline of alchemy. Hjalmar Fors provides evidence of the marginalization of alchemy in the eighteenth century as feminine, just as magic and astrology were viewed as typical of rustics, thus indicating that the ‘pseudo-sciences’ were not abandoned because they were proven wrong but because they were came to be viewed, like wonders and portents, as vulgar and childish. In the same vein, Claus Priesner examines late eighteenth-century secret societies and finds their members both exploiting transmutational alchemy (as a kind of pyramid scheme) and at the same time exhibiting a new sensitivity about letting their alchemical beliefs be known in public. Additionally, Priesner makes the point that around 1800 ‘classical alchemy went into extinction, but … “modern” esoteric alchemy emerged and still thrives’ (p. 264). In the early modern period, one essential function of both astrology and alchemy was their part in the formation of identity and self-knowledge – a realm that psychotherapy deals in today. The discussion of personal traits and qualities in the casting of a horoscope and the spiritual transformation that an alchemist was believed to traverse in reading and practising alchemy were both essential dimensions of these disciplines. Interestingly, both have retained this aspect into the modern world, astrology in popular and wide dissemination, and alchemy in esoteric and private circles.
Many of these same themes also appear in The Salt of the Earth, where we see the shifting combination of Paracelsian with Aristotelian and corpuscular with humoral theories, and watch them resurface in various permutations over the course of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century English natural philosophizing about salts. We meet Guhr again, and we hear about the decline of alchemical theories via derision (in particular, the satirizing of quacks touting the restorative properties of saline spirits). The aim of Anna Marie Roos's book (derived from a still-evident dissertation) is to show that ideas about salts were central to matter theory and medicine, and to chart the way in which the widespread idea of an aerial life-giving salt, derived largely from Paracelsus and Van Helmont, was transformed over the course of two centuries in English natural philosophy, first into the idea of a salt principle present in acids and alkalis, then eventually into an ‘acidifying principle’, and finally modified, via the work of Hales on respiration, to bring forth Lavoisier's oxygen. There are many intriguing aspects to this story, including ideas about the tides being caused by the action of the Sun and Moon on sea salts, the relationship of salts and meteorological effects such as thunder and lightning, the property of salts to modify colour and taste, the importance of saltpetre, and the association of salt and lust. Roos has identified an extremely important component of the history of early modern chymistry, and one hopes that others will follow her lead to flesh out this fascinating area.
Historians of chymistry and medicine will find these books full of valuable information, and historians of science more generally can find much that is suggestive.
