The number of theatre scholars studying explicitly religious performance practices is increasing steadily. Representing a range of methodologies and theoretical frameworks, their work demonstrates the value not only of this topic but also of performativity as an analytical lens. Without undercutting this scholarship, Donnalee Dox's new book reveals performativity's limitations as a critical paradigm for exploring the numinous, invisible, and sensed aspects of spiritual practices. Dox argues that by privileging “doing (action) over being (essence) and material forms over people's subjective sensibilities” (xiv), this paradigm situates performances as material representations of spirituality when, in fact, they may be extraneous by-products of spiritual experience.
In her Preface, Dox demonstrates how scholars typically use performativity to interpret the material, visible elements of religious performances, and she acknowledges the valuable insights this affords. Her own study began as one such project—an examination of contemporary, Western, vernacular nonreligious spiritual practices through performativity. Yet as her subject began to resist analysis, Dox realized that because the texts and events she was analyzing “were already structured as performance by the paradigm” with which she began, they would continue to reveal only what “the paradigm promised. Spirituality became the ever-receding referent in the interplay of symbolic codes, frames, and bodies” (xix). By making spirituality material, the critical lens of performance was unable to engage the immaterial, invisible, sensed, but unobserved elements of spiritual practices, and could situate spirituality only as a function of performance. Dox reverses that relationship by examining performance as a function of spirituality and investigating “how people's sense of spirit affects the interpretive frame of performance” (xxiv). Rather than dismantle the paradigm, she suggests how it might expand to accommodate spiritual experiences.
In the Introduction, Dox argues that the performance paradigm cannot capture the immaterial presence of spirituality, in large part because it “binds knowing to showing” (4, original emphasis). She concludes that “the theoretical frame of performativity shows representational strategies, asserting that there is no real to be represented, and that performance itself constitutes presence” (6). The paradigm is constructed through material presence and accordingly can acknowledge spirit only as an absence. Moreover, although methodologies drawing upon phenomenology, cognitive studies, and models of the embodied mind have resisted this emphasis on material presence, they still privilege observation and maintain “the authority of interpretation” (12). Consequently, Dox begins her inquiry from the practitioner's point of view, asking how performance theory can “expand to include the ways people formulate knowledge from internal sensations and allow that knowledge to structure performance” (17).
Chapter 1 expands on Dox's key claims by positioning them against existing discourses and prevailing epistemologies and methodologies. For readers already persuaded by the Introduction, this material may seem redundant, and Dox's tendency to end sections with questions might frustrate readers who are anxious to see her alternative approach applied. That work begins in Chapter 2, where she uses the metaphor of performance as “a membrane between people's inner lives and the materiality of the social world” (60) to examine two practices: Collective Awakening, a neoshamanic drumming practice, and Dancemeditation, a movement-meditation practice. She analyzes these side by side to demonstrate how situating “practitioners’ spiritual sensations within the registers we otherwise assume are performative” (73) challenges how the performance paradigm frames language, subjectivity, material culture, lived experience, and authenticity. Ultimately these practices produce a spiritual epistemology in which inner sensations are the basis for formulating knowledge. Chapter 3 explores how interdisciplinary scholarship on the physiological body can inform the study of spirituality and identity. In particular, she applies theories of embodied cognition and naturalized phenomenology to examine the performer's material body, and argues that neurological links between self and spirituality may help us recognize how certain practices cultivate the sense of a spiritual self that may subvert other social identity categories.
In Chapter 4, the most compelling one in the book, Dox interrogates complex issues, such as appropriation, orientalism, and authenticity, that arise when material and spiritual practices cross cultural borders. Even as Dox validates concerns about repackaging and merchandising ancient and non-Western spiritual traditions, she also illuminates assumptions embedded within those criticisms—assumptions about indigenous peoples and spirituality as essentializing marks of otherness. She proposes that Western practitioners seeking to cultivate spirituality often borrow from non-Western cultures because their own epistemological systems do not accommodate a sense of spirit. Without excusing these appropriative practices, Dox identifies within them a simultaneous reverse critique of how Western intellectual culture uses an axis of difference to marginalize spirituality. After introducing M. Jacqui Alexander's work on African religion in nineteenth-century Trinidad as one alternative methodology that combines “experiential spirituality and analytical-interpretive inquiries” (172), Dox outlines different schemata for rigorously engaging spirituality.
In Chapter 5, Dox concludes her study by summarizing key points and outlining what issues remain unexamined. In addition, she acknowledges that Christian spirituality, as “part of the intellectual tradition that gave rise to performativity,” may be more aligned with this paradigm than other spiritual formulations (198). Throughout her chapters, Dox asserts carefully crafted arguments, even if certain stylistic choices at times limit their presentation. For instance, she often uses a series of questions to introduce new topics, a tactic I found distracting. Each chapter also unnecessarily reiterates arguments from previous ones. However, Dox is keenly aware that “suspicion of spirituality in a contemporary Western context leaves little epistemological space for whatever knowledge might inform or be produced from” the practices she studies (148–9). Her rhetorical choices might, therefore, be the by-products of a rigorous analytical approach designed to persuade her more skeptical readers.
Dox challenges a firmly entrenched paradigm of performance, offering a formidable argument about what scholars ignore, dismiss, or misconstrue by not recognizing assumptions inherent within that paradigm. For scholars of religious performance, she exposes issues many of us have (unconsciously or not) circled around without tackling directly, and she offers us productive ways to address them in future work. However, the value of her conclusions are not limited to work on religious material but are relevant to any study that examines the ineffable elements of performance.
