Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T01:47:25.164Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Link between subsonic stall and transonic buffet on swept and unswept wings: from global stability analysis to nonlinear dynamics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 December 2020

Frédéric Plante*
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, 8 rue des Vertugadins, 92190 Meudon, FranceDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Polytechnique Montréal, Montréal H3T 1J4, Canada
Julien Dandois
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, 8 rue des Vertugadins, 92190 Meudon, France
Samir Beneddine
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, 8 rue des Vertugadins, 92190 Meudon, France
Éric Laurendeau
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Polytechnique Montréal, Montréal H3T 1J4, Canada
Denis Sipp
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Université Paris Saclay, 8 rue des Vertugadins, 92190 Meudon, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: frederic.plante@polymtl.ca

Abstract

This paper examines the three-dimensional cellular patterns appearing on wings in subsonic stall and transonic buffet conditions. Unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes simulations are carried out for three-dimensional infinite swept configurations closed by periodic boundary conditions in the spanwise direction. In both flow conditions the occurrence of stall/buffet cells is observed, as well as their convection at a speed proportional to the sweep angle. In transonic buffet conditions, this phenomenon is superimposed to the well-documented two-dimensional buffet instability. These results indicate that the discrepancies between two-dimensional and three-dimensional buffet are caused by the occurrence of buffet cells and that this phenomenon is similar to the one observed at low speed. These phenomena are then studied using global linear stability analysis with the assumption of a periodic flow in the spanwise direction. From these analyses a mode coherent with the two-dimensional buffet is obtained, as well as a mode coherent with two-dimensional vortex shedding in stall conditions. In addition, in both flow conditions an unstable mode reminiscent of stall/buffet cells is observed.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Infinite swept wing configuration.

Figure 1

Table 1.Characteristics of the grids.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Lift curve for the 2-D and 3-D steady solutions (NACA4412, $Re=350\,000$, $M=0.2$, $\delta =0^{\circ }$).

Figure 3

Figure 3.Surface pressure coefficient and skin friction lines of 3-D steady solution with 224 (left-hand side) and 112 (right-hand side) spanwise grid cells (NACA4412, $M=0.2$, $Re=350\,000$, $\alpha =15^{\circ }$, $\delta =0^{\circ }$, $L_z=6$).

Figure 4

Figure 4.Instantaneous surface pressure coefficient and skin friction lines over a swept wing (NACA4412, $M=0.2$, $Re=350\,000$, $\alpha =15^{\circ }$, $L_z=6$): (a) sweep $10^{\circ }$; (b) sweep $20^{\circ }$; (c) sweep $30^{\circ }$.

Figure 5

Table 2.Stall cells convection frequency for several wing spans and sweep angles (NACA4412, $M=0.2$, $Re=350\,000$, $\alpha =15^{\circ }$).

Figure 6

Figure 5.Stall and buffet cells convection model.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Time-averaged wall pressure coefficient for spanwise invariant solution with several sweep angles (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha = 4^{\circ }$).

Figure 8

Figure 7.Instantaneous surface pressure coefficient and skin friction lines for URANS simulations of infinite swept wings with two sweep angles (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =4^{\circ }$, $L_z=6$): (a) $\delta =0^{\circ }$; (b) $\delta =30^{\circ }$ (right-hand side, 112 spanwise grid cells; left-hand side, 168 spanwise grid cells).

Figure 9

Figure 8.Sectional lift coefficient power spectral density (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =4^{\circ }$, $\delta =30^{\circ }$).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Effect of the sweep angle on the global and sectional lift coefficient power spectral density (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =4^{\circ }$).

Figure 11

Figure 10.Extraction of the pressure on a line parallel to the leading edge near ${x^{\prime }}/{c} = 0.43$ (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =4^{\circ }$, $\delta =30^{\circ }$).

Figure 12

Table 3.Buffet cells convection frequency for several sweep angles (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =4^{\circ }$).

Figure 13

Figure 11.Convection speed of stall (NACA4412, $M=0.2$, $Re=350\,000$, $\alpha =15^{\circ }$) and buffet (OALT25, $M=0.7352$, $Re=3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =4^{\circ }$) cells.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Eigenspectrum (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\alpha$ = $15.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$).

Figure 15

Figure 13.Effect of spanwise grid density and the wavenumber on the growth rate of the unstable mode (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\alpha = 15.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$).

Figure 16

Figure 14.Flow visualization of the (a) baseflow and (b) 3-D unstable mode (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\alpha = 15.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$): (a) ${\rho e}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ baseflow; (b) real part of the ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode $(\beta = 4.4) - St = 0.0$.

Figure 17

Figure 15.Effect of the angle of attack on the growth rate of the unstable mode (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$). (a) Upper branch of the lift hysteresis. (b) Lower branch of the lift hysteresis.

Figure 18

Figure 16.Flow visualization of the 3-D unstable mode for several angles of attack on the two branches of the lift hysteresis (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$). (a) Real part of the ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode ($\alpha =18^{\circ }$, upper branch, $\beta = 5$) – $St = 0.0$. (b) Real part of the ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode ($\alpha =20.5^{\circ }$, upper branch, $\beta = 7.5$) – $St = 0.0$. (c) Real part of the ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode ($\alpha =16.78^{\circ }$, lower branch, $\beta = 8$) – $St = 0.0$. (d) Real part of the ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode ($\alpha =16.9^{\circ }$, lower branch, $\beta = 5.5$) – $St = 0.0$.

Figure 19

Figure 17.Effect of the sweep angle on the growth rate and frequency of the 3-D unstable mode (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\alpha = 15.0^{\circ }$; black, stability analysis; red, URANS simulations): (a) growth rate; (b) frequency.

Figure 20

Figure 18.Effect of the angle of attack on the spectra of the 2-D unstable mode (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$, $\beta = 0$).

Figure 21

Figure 19.Flow visualization of the (a,b) baseflow and (c,d) 2-D unstable mode on the two branches of the lift hysteresis (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\alpha = 18.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$, $\beta = 0.0$). (a) The $u$ baseflow; upper branch of the lift hysteresis. (b) The $u$ baseflow; lower branch of the lift hysteresis. (c) Real part of the $\widehat {\rho u}$ eigenmode; upper branch of the lift hysteresis – $St = 0.92$. (d) Real part of the $\widehat {\rho u}$ eigenmode; lower branch of the lift hysteresis – $St = 0.49$.

Figure 22

Figure 20.Effect of the wavenumber on the 2-D wake instability mode (NACA4412, $M = 0.2$, $Re = 350\,000$, $\alpha = 18.0^{\circ }$): (a) growth rate; (b) frequency.

Figure 23

Figure 21.Eigenspectrum in 2-D and 3-D (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha = 4.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$): (a) $\beta = 0$; (b) $\beta = 2{\rm \pi}$.

Figure 24

Figure 22.Effect of the wavenumber $\beta$ on the 3-D mode (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\delta = 0.0^{\circ }$): (a) growth rate; (b) eigenspectrum ($\alpha = 4.25^{\circ }$).

Figure 25

Figure 23.Lift coefficient of the steady 2-D flow (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\delta =0.0^{\circ }$).

Figure 26

Figure 24.Effect of the sweep angle on the 3-D mode (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha = 4.0^{\circ }$; black, stability analysis; red, URANS simulations): (a) growth rate; (b) frequency.

Figure 27

Figure 25.Flow visualization of the (a) baseflow, (b,c) 2-D and 3-D unstable modes (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha = 4.0^{\circ }$, $\delta =30^{\circ }$). (a) The ${\rho e}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ baseflow. (b) Real part of the 2-D ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode $(\beta = 0.0)$ – $St = 0.075$. (c) Real part of the 3-D ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ eigenmode $(\beta = 5.0)$ – $St = 0.356$.

Figure 28

Figure 26.Effect of the angle of attack on the 2-D unstable mode (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\delta =0.0^{\circ }$, $\beta = 0.0$).

Figure 29

Figure 27.Effect of the wavenumber on the 2-D buffet mode (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha = 4.0^{\circ }$): (a) growth rate; (b) frequency.

Figure 30

Figure 28.Snapshots of the surface pressure coefficient and skin friction lines of the URANS simulations (NACA4412, $M$ = 0.2, $Re$ = 350 000, $\alpha = 15.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0^{\circ }$, $L_z = 6$): (a) $t = 68$; (b) $t = 85$; (c) $t = 102$.

Figure 31

Figure 29.Snapshots of the surface pressure coefficient and skin friction lines of the URANS simulations (OALT25, $M = 0.7352$, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha = 4.0^{\circ }$, $\delta = 20^{\circ }$, $L_z = 6$): (a) $t = 68$; (b) $t = 74$; (c) $t = 89$.

Figure 32

Figure 30.Baseflow Mach number field at several Mach numbers and angle of attack (NACA0012, $Re = 10^{7}$, $\delta = 0^{\circ }$): (a) $M = 0.2$ and $\alpha = 18.2^{\circ }$; (b) $M = 0.3$ and $\alpha = 15.0^{\circ }$; (c) $M = 0.4$ and $\alpha = 12.0^{\circ }$; (d) $M = 0.5$ and $\alpha = 7.9^{\circ }$; (e) $M = 0.6$ and $\alpha = 6.15^{\circ }$; ( f) $M = 0.72$ and $\alpha = 3.5^{\circ }$.

Figure 33

Figure 31.Effect of the Mach number and angle of attack on the growth rate of the 3-D mode (NACA0012, $Re = 10^{7}$, $\delta = 0^{\circ }$). (a) Normalized by the chord length. (b) Normalized by the separation height.

Figure 34

Figure 32.Flow visualization of the 3-D ${\widehat {\rho e}}/{\rho e_{\infty }}$ unstable mode (NACA0012, $Re = 10^{7}$, $\delta = 0^{\circ }$): (a) $M = 0.2$ and $\alpha = 18.2^{\circ }$ – $St = 0.0$; (b) $M = 0.3$ and $\alpha = 15.0^{\circ }$ – $St = 0.0$; (c) $M = 0.4$ and $\alpha = 12.0^{\circ }$ – $St = 0.0$; (d) $M = 0.5$ and $\alpha = 7.9^{\circ }$ – $St = 0.0$; (e) $M = 0.6$ and $\alpha = 6.15^{\circ }$ – $St = 0.0$; ( f) $M = 0.72$ and $\alpha = 3.5^{\circ }$ – $St = 0.0$.

Figure 35

Figure 33.Effect of the angle of attack on the 2-D unstable mode (NACA0012, $M = 0.72$, $Re = 10^{7}$, $\delta =0.0^{\circ }$, $\beta = 0.0$).

Figure 36

Figure 34.Effect of the sweep angle on the 3-D mode frequency: (a) subsonic (NACA0012, $M=0.2$, $Re = 10^{7}$, $\alpha = 18.5^{\circ }$); (b) transonic (NACA0012, $M=0.72$, $Re = 10^{7}$, $\alpha = 4.5^{\circ }$).

Figure 37

Figure 35.Effect of the wavenumber of the 2-D buffet mode (OAT15A, $Re = 3\times 10^{6}$, $\alpha =3.5^{\circ }$, $\delta = 0^{\circ }$): (a) growth rate; (b) frequency.

Supplementary material: File

Plante et al. Supplementary Materials

Plante et al. Supplementary Materials

Download Plante et al. Supplementary Materials(File)
File 247.6 KB