“This book celebrates the spirit of cooperation and solidarity between the Black Freedom Struggle and the United Farm Workers” (221), explains Lauren Araiza in the acknowledgments that follow her narrative. It is indeed a celebration of various African American civil rights and black power organizations’ supportive efforts on behalf of beleaguered, California-based Mexican American farmworkers enrolled in the National Farm Workers Association (NFWA)/United Farm Workers Organizing Committee (UFW), from the mid-1960s through the early 1970s. The Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC), the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC), the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), the National Urban League (NUL), and the Black Panther Party (BPP) each came to the assistance of farmworker activists by endorsing their protests and boycotts. Their level of engagement varied and explaining that variation is one aim of Araiza's study. Whatever the degree of commitment, she contends, these groups forged important coalitions beneficial to blacks and Mexican Americans alike.
Given what Araiza sees as a common experience of discrimination and economic exploitation, alliances between black and Mexican American groups made sense. Constructing alliances required effort, with some groups more successful than others. The actions of the NAACP and the SCLC, for instance, compare poorly to those of SNCC and the BPP. The national NAACP office was a top-down organization based in New York; uncomfortable with boycotts and even nonviolent forms of protest, and “generally unfamiliar with Mexican American experiences” (81), it attempted to rein in local chapters intent upon greater involvement. Moreover, “patronage from white corporations served as a barrier to the formation of multiracial alliances” (72), Araiza argues, leading to only “tepid” (72) support at best. She similarly concludes that Martin Luther King Jr., and his SCLC, centered in the urban South, were unfamiliar with Mexican Americans and reluctant to embrace the farmworkers’ cause; King's own ambivalence about organized labor and simultaneous dependence on white union financial support, she suggests, contributed to his withholding support. That the NAACP, SCLC, and King were less than enthusiastic about embracing la causa of the farmworkers is clear; their reasons for doing so are less so, for Araiza does not probe deeply enough into individual and organizational motivations.
SNCC and the BPP were, at times, more supportive of farmworkers than their middle-class counterparts. A “shared understanding of the connection between racial discrimination and economic oppression formed the basis of the alliance between SNCC and the NFWA because it enabled them to recognize that African Americans and Mexican Americans were victims of the same oppressive forces” (12). Were they? Neither Araiza nor her activist subjects explore the similarities or differences between the southern sharecropping system and West Coast agribusiness; general allusions to common exploitation substitute for an examination of political economy. The extent to which the “treatment of black sharecroppers was remarkably similar to that of Mexican American farmworkers in California” (13) is asserted, not examined. Whatever the accuracy of the comparison, white Bay Area SNCC activists took the lead in enthusiastically supporting Cesar Chavez and the farmworkers, spreading the gospel of nonviolent direct action, publicizing their cause, and participating in marches and strikes. The national SNCC office was initially oblivious to the UFW but eventually came to “embrace the union's cause wholeheartedly” (30), its members driven by a “rejection of middle-class values such as lucrative employment and material comforts” (41) and a commitment to contesting “economic inequality” (41). The relationship, however, collapsed by 1966 as SNCC gravitated toward black power and pan-Africanism, ousted white (and even Mexican American) members, scorned the Democratic Party (which Chavez cultivated), soured even further on organized labor, and rejected multiracialism. (White SNCC farmworker supporters, in some cases, simply carried on their work as staff members of the UFW.) The “evolution of the organizations along different trajectories ended their alliance” (69), Araiza explains. In contrast, the more Marxist BPP stuck with the farmworkers, as both groups “saw each other as commonly oppressed victims of the ruling class” (97). That connection, too, eventually weakened as Chavez voiced support for Israel (toward which the BPP was hostile) and internal divisions and government repression together destroyed the BPP.
Araiza effectively demonstrates that different African American organizations interacted with the NFWA/UFW in distinct ways. But can their relationships with the farmworkers accurately be called coalitions or alliances? We learn little about what individual farmworkers felt about civil rights or black power activists and their analyses or what, if anything, the UFW did for those groups. What she shows is how groups and individuals – she calls them “bridge leaders” (69) – offered the farmworkers valuable aid: the NUL and NAACP engaged in letter writing; Coretta Scott King and Ralph Abernathy, following King's assassination, praised their efforts and donated mailing lists; SNCC members initially provided indispensable logistical support; and the BPP, “an intimidating presence” (102), picketed stores that carried boycotted grapes and lettuce. What did African Americans receive in return for their support? Did Chavez's participation in an SCLC rally in New York, his endorsement of the mayoral candidacy of the BPP's Bobby Seale, and issuing of a resolution of support for Panthers harassed by police represent a substantial benefit for African Americans? Perhaps “the BPP's alliance with the UFW gave the Party legitimacy among conservative elements of the Mexican American community” (171) while both groups “used the relationship to educate their constituencies on the importance of crossing racial lines to establish class-based solidarity” (165). Perhaps supporting Chavez “enabled Coretta Scott King to step out of her late husband's shadow” (171). As important as these developments might have been, they do not make the case for a “productive” (45) or “successful, mutually beneficial alliance” (97).
Indeed, the case for coalition, powerful or otherwise, is undermined by one revealing example in the book. As a gesture of “solidarity with the farmworkers” (100), in 1968 BPP minister of information Eldridge Cleaver banned his members from drinking Bitter Dog, a popular homemade alcoholic beverage made with lemon juice and red wine. “The flamboyant Cleaver admitted … that he was high (a violation of Party rules),” Araiza notes, “but it is unknown whether sober he was aware that the UFWOC had ended its boycott … more than two years prior, before the BPP was even founded,” and that the “current boycott was against California table grapes,” not wine (100–1). To her credit, Araiza includes this anecdote. But she does not ask how powerful this alliance could be when one of the BPP's key leaders seemed wholly unaware of his ally's current agenda. To March for Others contains much valuable information about individual and organizational support for farmworkers. What it doesn't quite do is demonstrate the existence of strong multiracial alliances.
