In the late-nineteenth-century United States, anxiety about Chinese immigration reflected the widespread racial belief that, unlike Europeans, Asians were permanently unassimilable. In California, anti-Chinese labor leaders and politicians devoted constant attention to what they depicted as the immoral and dangerous bachelor culture defining San Francisco's Chinatown. Lacking families, opponents argued, Chinese immigrants would never practice the type of domestic arrangements essential to the creation of a civilized nation.
“The perception of a ‘familyless’ Chinese community,” Wendy Jorae notes, “has pervaded the historical scholarship even into the modern era and has rendered the presence of children in early Chinatown largely invisible” (2). Federal legislation—such as the 1875 Page Act, which severely restricted the immigration of Chinese women—shaped Chinese family life in the United States, and, paradoxically, allowed opponents of Chinese immigration to attack Chinese men “for failing to bring their families to America” (43). Still, Chinese children did immigrate to the United States, and adult immigrants managed by both legal and illegal means to bring their families. Jorae explores how different interests created conflicting images of Chinese childhood and used these representations to advance their own political agendas regarding Chinese immigration. Building on this first objective, Jorae also seeks to examine how the “reality” of Chinese childhood both validated outsiders' depictions and contradicted them.
The Children of Chinatown adds to the growing literature on Chinese exclusion with a specific focus on how restrictions affected child immigrants.Footnote 1 Faced with constant scrutiny about whether they were attempting to enter the United States as “paper” sons and daughters, immigration, an unsettling experience for any child, was particularly traumatic for Chinese children. On the passage over—in order to prove that they were born in the United States—Chinese children were required to memorize details about San Francisco's physical layout and other facts that led to intense coaching sessions with adult tutors. After 1900, it became more likely that Chinese children would claim to be born in China to a father with American citizenship. The opening of the Angel Island immigration station in 1910 and the treatment of detained Chinese children, which included invasive medical inspections and verbal and physical abuse, were at the center of the complaints that were registered by the Chinese community in San Francisco about the inhumanity of exclusion laws.
Entry was only one test for Chinese children, and racial discrimination extended to immigrant and Chinese American children alike. This latter group played an important role in challenging the segregation that denied Chinese American children the rights of native-born citizenship, even if their legal successes were few and far between. Although African Americans had achieved integration of San Francisco's public schools by the 1880s, Chinese Americans were segregated in public education until 1947. Not only were Chinese Americans forced to learn in an underfunded and poorly maintained separate facility, they suffered the additional indignity of encountering a state-sponsored curriculum that depicted them as “perpetual foreigners” (127). To counter the state's failure to provide an adequate education to their children, Chinese parents relied on both mission schools and private Chinese language schools.
By exploring how white missionaries interacted with Chinese American children in San Francisco, Jorae examines what Peggy Pascoe called the “relations of rescue” that existed between these two communities in the city.Footnote 2 Missionaries regularly intervened in cases of child prostitution, domestic slavery, and child labor, and through mission schools and domestic training provided Chinese American children with instruction on how to Americanize. As Jorae notes, “Although many Methodist and Presbyterian reformers held, along with their anti-Chinese neighbors, a general disregard for the Chinese lifestyle,” in contrast to anti-Chinese politicians who promoted the removal of San Francisco's Chinese community as a dangerous blight on the city, missionaries “offered a competing image of Chinese children as malleable and capable of reform” (147). Unlike other Progressive Era reformers working mainly with European immigrants, missionaries in San Francisco found their work to be explicitly politicized. The Chinese business community, while expressing reservations about some of the more zealous missionary actions, on the whole embraced them as allies.
By the twentieth century, prominent members of the Chinese community in San Francisco took a lead effort in what Jorae calls “selling Chinese childhood” (187). Marketing postcards and other images to tourists, who had long been fascinated with San Francisco's Chinatown as an exotic space, Chinese community leaders steered depictions of life in Chinatown away from images of opium dens, gambling, and other vices, toward “respectable” photographs portraying Chinese American children celebrating holidays and at play. After the Chinese Revolution in 1911, these efforts complemented the transnational movement to depict Chinese communities on both sides of the Pacific as embracing Western culture and values.
Jorae has managed to unearth some fascinating primary sources, mainly in the form of memoirs and other personal accounts from Chinese Americans. One limitation of Jorae's approach, and a limitation that plagues scholarship that tries to disaggregate experience from discourse in general, is that many of the accounts she uses to document the reality of Chinese childhood invariably conformed to prevailing notions of what was respectable. For example, Jorae does not address the experiences of children in boarding houses, where male Chinese adolescents lived with kin or on their own, working as laundrymen and servants. These domestic arrangements served as a primary object of scorn for reformers and anti-Chinese politicians alike, and one wishes that Jorae would raise the question of whether such living conditions were as corrupting of Chinese youth as respectable society made them out to be.Footnote 3 Still, this book offers an excellent account of how children matter in the history of Chinese immigration.
