There has been much debate about Muslim ideals and ethics as they relate to war and peace. This is particularly true in the area of politics, international relations, and mass media coverage, in which there is great interest in Muslim militancy and “terrorism” (however defined). Iran has also been of particular interest in these debates, partly due to the Islamic revolution of 1978–79, but also due to Iran's role as a political rival of the United States and its allies in the region, including support for groups such as Hizbullah, Hamas, and Shiʿi in Iraq. Studies and debates often fall into two categories: at one end of a spectrum are studies that endeavor to explain Iran's foreign policy efforts in terms of rational self-interest, thus ignoring cultural or historical particularities that may influence these actions; at the other end are those which explain everything using reductionist notions of Islam or Shiʿism, which are usually treated ahistorically as unchanging and uninfluenced by context. Mohammad Jafar Amir Mahallati's Ethics of War and Peace in Iran and Shiʿi Islam brings a much-needed new dimension to this analysis by avoiding these two extreme approaches. Mahallati acknowledges that Iran does pursue its rational self-interest in ways that are similar to the actions of any other state, and that this is a good starting point for understanding Iran's foreign policy moves. Then, Mahallati adds to this by showing how trends in culture, ideals, and domestic politics in Iran also influence such actions and policies. However, he does so without excessive reductionism and essentialism.
Ethics of War and Peace has three parts. The first part consists of a survey of several cultural and intellectual trends relating to ideals of war and peace in Iran, Shiʿism, and the Persianate world. These include the Shahnameh, classical philosophically oriented thinkers, traditional ideals of chivalry associated with javanmardi and futowwa social organizations, and select modern intellectuals. The second part is a more historically grounded thematic analysis of concepts of war and peace in Shiʿism and in contemporary Iran. Although this section begins with early Shiʿi ideals, it is primarily focused on trends since the Islamic Revolution. The third, and final, section consists of a series of four appendices. The first two appendices consist of two articles translated by the author on jihad and war (Jang) that were previously published in The Great Islamic Encyclopedia (Tihran: Markaz-i Daʾirat al-Maʿarif-i Buzurg-i Islami, 1989-). The third appendix is a statement on the war crimes of ISIS by the Iranian ambassador to the United Nations. The final appendix is an advice manual or guide on ethical conduct for Iraqi soldiers issued by Grand Ayatollah Sistani in Iraq.
We should begin with a few brief words about the last section, which consists of four appendices. While these appendices are not directly integrated into the argument presented in the book, they are informative and contribute new material to the discussion. They are also referenced throughout the book, so having the full text provided at the end is helpful to the reader. The first two are informative reading, as they provide an English translation of two valuable contemporary Iranian scholarly treatments of the themes of war and jihad, which would otherwise not be available to readers who do not read Persian. The fourth appendix is also a translation of a very useful and important primary document on the subject.
Let us turn our attention now to the first section, which is fascinating and informative, despite raising some methodological questions. The analysis of the symbolic and ethical treatment of war and peace in the Shahnameh is effectively done, demonstrating that, rather than simply glorifying masculine, heroic warfare, this epic poem includes diverse views of war and peace. The survey of ideas presented by classical thinkers is also well done, and shows the author's familiarity and mastery of the texts and ideas under discussion. Mahallati demonstrates that thinkers such as Farabi, Miskawayh, and Tusi articulated well-developed theories of just war, based on concepts of justice and objective ethics, rather than more simplistic notions of holy war, or religiously sanctioned war. The chivalry section is also very interesting, and is under-studied in the scholarly literature on Iran. Mahallati shows how these social institutions have provided ethical and symbolic bases for understanding both interpersonal relations, and broader power relations, including war, peace, justice, forgiveness, and so forth. The fourth and final chapter in this section presents a strong case for modern Iranian intellectuals, such as Abdol Karim Sorush, Mohsen Kadivar, and Seyyed Hossein Nasr, rethinking traditional Islamic ideals of war and peace. In particular, they explored new ways of thinking about nonviolence and proposed revised visions of moralizing religion.
There are, however, some methodological challenges in this section. The treatment is somewhat ahistorical and at times eclectic. As a result, causal links between these cultural trends and more recent trends in Iran are not fully explored. For example, while the Shahnameh is very effectively analyzed as a text, the chapter would benefit from more analysis of discourses in particular times and contexts, in which symbols and ideals from the Shahnameh have been used or referenced. The same is true for the chapter on chivalry. The section on philosophically oriented thinkers such as Farabi, Miskawayh, and Tusi consists of a thoughtful and effective analysis. However, it is not always clear why these, and only these thinkers, were included in the discussion, because they are insufficiently contextualized within the broader contemporary discursive milieu in which they lived and functioned. There was a vast literature on war and peace among premodern Muslim scholars and intellectuals. These could be more fully incorporated in this section. The selection criteria are also not always clear, unless one assumes an underlying modern national teleology. The chapter on modern thinkers does not raise these above-mentioned methodology concerns. However, it seems out of place here. It seems like it would fit much better in Part Two, which is discussed below.
Part Two, which is also the longest section, is where the author's argument is most thoroughly and effectively presented (especially if we treat the preceding chapter on modern Iranian intellectuals as being connected to this section). What makes this section work most effectively is that the analysis of each theme is contextualized within specific historical trends and events, such as the Islamic revolution, the Iran–Iraq War, the US-led wars in Iraq, and the violent chaos that has recently proliferated across the region, especially in Iraq and Syria. The author does an excellent job of showing how social, political, and economic trends have influenced trends in thought related to war and peace. Additionally, since this section is more narrowly focused on intellectual trends more closely associated with the official discourse of the state and of the ʿulamaʾ, the conceptual framework is more cohesive.
The section starts with a survey of primary sources related to the early formation of Shiʿism. These sources represent a period in which Shiʿi scholars were mostly concerned with intra-Muslim warfare from the perspective of a minority Muslim group. Therefore, the focus was largely on fighting for justice and dying a martyr, either for the principle of the matter or in pursuit of soteriological goals. This changed somewhat with the Islamic revolutionary movement in the decade leading up to the Islamic revolution, as well as the Iran–Iraq War that followed. The new doctrines associated with war provided an ethical justification for war that was much closer to modern humanistic just war theories, which then also became intertwined with postcolonial justifications for fighting against the oppression of imperialists and national dictatorships. This new way of thinking was then directed outwards in considering the increase in the sorts of violence that are loosely grouped under the rubric of “terrorism.” Mahallati demonstrates how traditional ideals associated with the minority position of Shiʿis, and which focused single-mindedly on justice, gradually gave way to new frames of reference, that were more in line with postrevolutionary government, culture, and trends in society. The Iran–Iraq War, and to some extent the revolution, tended to encourage the old siege mentality of the Shiʿa that focused on victimhood martyrdom. However, the trend otherwise has continued in a different direction, as several leading ʿulamaʾ criticized the war and, following the negotiated end to the war, a broad-based reevaluation of the ideals related to war picked up steam. The author argues convincingly that a new outlook has emerged that is more pragmatic, humanistic, and cosmopolitan in nature, and which serves as an alternative to the harsher and more utopian ideals that have often been expressed by the government and others in Iran.
