The relationship between climate change and aviation is a complicated one. On a factual level, there is a controversy regarding the degree to which aviation contributes to climate change. The responses vary. While the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) estimates that aviation is responsible for two percent of the total global carbon emission, some argue that aviation is apportioned six percent of the blame when other greenhouse gases are measured. Regardless, the undeniable fact is that aviation’s carbon emission continues to rise.
On the legal and regulatory side, there are two key dilemmas. The first is that the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) excluded the international aviation sector, and the Kyoto Protocol expressly assigned the task to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). But little has been done under the ICAO on the issue of climate change until recently. Frustrated with the slow progress at ICAO, the European Union (EU) announced its intention to subject all EU and foreign airlines flying to and from airports in the EU to its controversial Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS). Although the EU eventually suspended the plan, the EU ETS gave an impetus to the ICAO to seek a global solution at the 39th ICAO General Assembly in 2016. The second dilemma, and a more challenging question, is how the principle of common but differentiated responsibility (CBDR), the key principle of climate change discourse, can coexist with the non-discrimination principle under the Chicago Convention of 1944, which is the overarching treaty of international civil aviation with 191 Member States.
In this book, Alejandro Piera clearly identifies the complex issues and effectively suggests a possible legal framework. At the outset, skimming through some of chapter titles helps the reader to familiarize the topic, such as “Chapter Two—Aviation and Climate Change: A Case of Fragmentation of International Law”, “Chapter Four—The Inclusion of International Aviation in the EU ETS”, “Chapter Five—Legal Challenges against the EU ETS: Extraterritoriality”, and “Chapter Eight—The Way Ahead: Key Considerations in Addressing GHG Emissions from International Aviation in the Future”.
One of the author’s key messages is that “CBDR and non-discrimination could be reconciled through the adoption of a route-based/phase-in approach where routes from different countries to a specific destination could be integrated into the scheme at different stages in accordance with a specified set of criteria” (p. 359). The nine illustrations that were inserted in Chapter Eight convincingly explain how a route-based/phase-in approach could work (pp. 323–32). The author rightly points out that the global scheme will not have any meaningful effect in reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from international aviation without enforcement mechanisms, and suggests solutions. To make this book more complete, Piera also analyzes legal vehicles to adopt and implement the global scheme: namely, an annex to the Chicago Convention, a resolution of the General Assembly, and a new international treaty.
This book is relevant both for those who want to study the climate change discussion from an aviation law and policy perspective, and for those who want to be informed about aviation sector-specific discussion from a climate change law perspective. Alejandro Piera achieved this daunting task marvellously and has indeed satisfied the needs of both groups.
