This exciting tome examines the era that began with the formation of the Wafd, continued with the 1919 revolution, and ended with the coup turned revolution of July 1952. It binds together a plethora of historiographical approaches and moves from political history to sociocultural history and from legal history and gender relations to history of art. The lives of peasants, women, aspiring members of the middle class, military officers, and powerful pashas figure strongly in this volume. The diverse list of contributors consists of scholars from different professional generations and multiple scholarly traditions. Obviously, trying to fuse together such a wide range of scholarly approaches and thematic preferences into a coherent reevaluation of this period is an extremely ambitious goal. Although largely successful, the editors stop short of translating the richness of their collection into a reflective, critical, and focused statement on the overall nature of this era and its relation to adjacent periods.
For the most part, the inability to conceptualize, or reenvision, this era in new terms derives from two basic working assumptions. First, the editors argue that this era “continues to receive insufficient scholarly attention” (p. 2). Second, in contrast with existing scholarship, they propose that “this book invites the reader to reconsider the accepted wisdom on 1919–1952 Egypt. Rather than being a period of creeping decay, these years emerge as integral to modern nation-state formation and social transformation” (p. 6).
These two working assumptions are problematic, if not altogether mistaken. Although “sufficient attention” is a matter of degree and taste, this era has received—and continues to receive—unparalleled scholarly attention (it is the three decades that preceded 1919 that are relatively neglected), attention that the editors did not take seriously enough. Indeed, awareness of the academic literature on the period comes only as an afterthought when, in the last chapter, Arthur Goldschmidt uses his vast knowledge and provides a bibliographic inventory. As undeniably useful as this inventory is, it would perhaps have made better sense to examine the meaning and validity of previous scholarly achievements in a strong introductory chapter.
The “decay” assumption is a direct outcome of the editors' cursory attitude to a long pedigree of literature. Although at times critical, this literature did not sweepingly condemn this era as one of corruption and decay. In fact, more often than not, it was quite appreciative of the “liberal experiment” and even celebrated it as the culmination of the entire nahḍa project and the birth of a mature modern public sphere (perhaps it is time to rethink precisely this image). Unless one is a staunch Nasserite who reads only Egyptian historiography of a certain cut, “decay” is not likely to be the “accepted wisdom” that one would encounter and that the editors seem eager to destroy. In the end, the many achievements of this project are hidden in its various parts, away from such claims of a historiographical wasteland and the easy victories they seem to offer.
Unlike many edited volumes, this compilation is homogenous in its high quality of research and its intelligent integration through countless cross-references (although the lack of an index should be lamented). For the most part, common concerns revolve around questions of social justice and mobility, the meaning and scope of the elusive process of “Egyptianization,” the impact of mass media on the lives and preferences of ordinary people, and the nature and utilization of growing state power. Although not stated as such, a possible common denominator that clearly set this era apart from earlier times is the unprecedented creativity with which Egyptians tried to settle and resolve the many paradoxes and tensions of modernization that characterized this era. For instance, the schizophrenic dependency–fear approach of the elite vis-à-vis the lower classes figures strongly in this volume.
With this in mind, several contributions out of many good articles warrant special attention. James Whidden's original chapter on the sociopolitical generations in the 1920s illuminates an entire array of ideological preoccupations with social illnesses and, thus, contributes to a more sophisticated understanding of party politics. It relates to Amy Johnson and Scott David McIntosh's biography of social reformer Aziza Hussein in which they examine Hussein's integrated philosophy of development that emphasized public responsibility for the malaise of the nation, namely, “poverty, ignorance, and disease.” Misako Ikeda's study of parliamentary debates regarding free public education and the war against illiteracy illuminates the very notion of what “public” actually meant and who had the right to define it.
Connected to Tawfik Aclimandos's detailed study of political activism in the military, Anne-Claire Kerboeuf examines the complexities of mass political violence. In an argument that echoes Latifa al-Zayyat's al-Bab al-maftuh narration of the January 1952 burning of Cairo, Kerboeuf shows that the Egyptian historiographical obsession with the question who set the fire is a historiographical dead end. Instead, she examines in great detail how, over a long period of time, various political and social elements ambiguously contributed their share to the hidden hand of mass violence.
Related to political violence, Lucie Ryzova examines the so-called “trouble makers” of the era: the new effendīyya. Ryzova's history of this class is one of the most notable contributions in this volume. Ryzova examines the multiple lives of the effendi from the perspective of habitus and, thus, coherently promotes a new notion of class as “always in the process of becoming something else” (p. 125). Her effendis emerge as financially unstable, intellectually curious, politically volatile, and relentless careerists. This study goes beyond the current academic consensus, which views the effendi mostly in the context of the literary revival of the nahḍa and the Habermasian public sphere. Her insights fit nicely with Barak Salmoni's chapter on historical consciousness, which extensively explores the pedagogical usage of the past in the context of schooling and nationalization.
Turning the focus to the sociocultural structure of the family, an extremely important contribution by Hanan Kholussy deals with the way in which the state promoted the modern nuclear family by curtailing the marriage of minors, mainstreaming monogamy, and deterring divorce. Here, the nuclear family emerges as the core cell of economic activity, psychological comfort, moral upbringing, and general socialization into modern life. Methodologically, Kholussy's research continues an emerging tendency to break away from the strict tradition of Islamic law through which marriage is often studied.
In the field of mass media, Shaun Lopez's sensational urban tale of the two famous serial killer sisters Raya and Sakina illustrates how the mass media popularized the modern relation between body, mind, and morality at the expense of existing norms. Although Lopez is especially interested in the rise of mass media after World War I, the strength of his analysis lies in the examination of how modern categories of knowledge such as psychiatry and psychology marginalized well-rooted biomedical notions and promoted a new virtuous order. This approach, in fact, is also the direction that Nancy Gallagher follows in her interesting chapter on the role of female medical and public-health workers. In addition, Gallagher appears to be the only participant in this volume who is thinking of her work in more inclusive terms, as a research agenda for future inquiries.
This accurate panoramic view of work currently being conducted in the field makes this volume recommended reading for scholars. There is of course much room for future work, including methods and themes that are not represented in this volume, such as business history, history of science and technology, consumerism, social biographies of dominant households (the Abazas always come to mind), and, above all, innovative comparative work.
Finally, on a sad note, this was also the last work of the late Amy Johnson, a sensitive and gifted historian of Egyptian social history. Perhaps the best way to benefit from her perspective is articulated by her former adviser, Roger Owen, who in a reflective concluding chapter writes, “Let us hope that this book is translated as soon as possible into Arabic. Let us hope that its ideas and reassessments will be taken seriously enough in Egypt to provoke counter hypotheses…” (p. 501).
