This is a truly monumental book. In an age of companions and handbooks of mixed quality, it comes as a timely reminder that the days of the specialised monograph are not yet over. It seems therefore fair to begin this review by simply stating that Fikret Yegül and Diane Favro have written the most comprehensive Anglophone work on Roman architecture in over a generation. The last comparable books on the subject in English, apart from the 2014 Companion to Roman Architecture edited by Roger Ulrich and Caroline Quenemoen, were published by Bryan Ward-Perkins in 1981 and Frank Sear in 1982. They are matched in French by Pierre Gros’ two extensive volumes dedicated to L'architecture romaine (1996 and 2002, structured along the lines of typology and function) and, albeit to a lesser extent, in German by Henner von Hesberg's Römische Baukunst (2005, organised around key themes of socio-political and cultural importance). To this one could add important books by William MacDonald (1982; 1988) and Mark Wilson Jones (2000), which, although excellent in their own right, cover more specific aspects such as design, layout and the urban contexts of Roman architecture.
By contrast, Y. and F. aim at painting a much more comprehensive picture by moving through a linear chronological sequence, from the Republic to the reign of Constantine. Geographically, their narrative for each time period always starts with key chapters on Rome and Italy and then expands into the provinces. This structure tackles one of the main challenges for any university tutor faced with the task of teaching Roman architecture: how to develop specific themes which might not fit into neat temporal brackets (such as the architectural genesis of ‘the’ Roman bathhouse, ‘the’ Roman theatre, or ‘the’ Roman house), whilst at the same time progressing through the key time periods of Roman history and their respective architectural characteristics.
Overall, the book presents a successful formula for squaring this circle. Most notably, its chapters establish a balance between chronology, geography and typology. The result becomes manifest in two large clusters of chapters. The first deals with Rome and Italy and combines chronological and thematic organisation: ‘Urban Design and Architecture in Rome and Italy during the Republic and Early Empire‘ (ch. 1); ‘Temple Architecture of Republican Rome and Italy’ (ch. 2); ‘Julio-Claudian Architecture in Rome’ (ch. 4); ‘Imperial Architecture in Rome from the Flavians through the Antonines’ (ch. 6). The second cluster could be called ‘geographical’, as it shifts the focus from the imperial centre to the provinces and thus follows several individual trajectories within the orbit of Roman rule: ‘Architecture and Planning in Italy and the Western Provinces: From the Republic to the Empire’ (ch. 7); ‘Architecture and Planning in North Africa’ (ch. 8); ‘Greece under Roman Rule’ (ch. 9); ‘Architecture and Planning in Asia Minor’ (ch. 10); ‘The Roman Near East’ (ch. 11). In addition, there is one chapter which compresses time and space (‘The Late Empire in Rome and Provinces: From the Severans to Constantine’; ch. 12), alongside two thematic interjections (ch. 3 ‘Technology of Building’ and ch. 5 ‘Residential Architecture’).
In a short review, I cannot enter into a detailed discussion of any of these chapters; thus, it must suffice to state that each of them provides a stringent and clearly structured narrative, built around a series of well-chosen case studies. Surely, scholars will disagree on specific points and details raised in the discussion: for example, in the context of the beginnings of concrete architecture in Rome it is unfortunate that the authors still opt to date the so-called Testaccio building to the 170s b.c.e., based on its identification as the Porticus Aemilia which they take for granted, despite compelling recent counter-arguments by Cozza, Tucci and Mogetta. In the section on Republican temples, both the proposed identification (Hercules Victor) and the date (80 b.c.e.) for the Round Temple by the Tiber are merely based on conjectures, and the idea of a linear ‘Hellenization of Roman temples’ (91) seems to constitute an unfortunate step backwards when compared with most recent scholarship, such as the multi-faceted analysis provided by Penelope Davies (Architecture and Politics in Republican Rome, 2017). In the case of the Forum of Augustus, the authors duly mention the third possible exedra, but then state that this discovery has given ‘rise to pure speculation that with its hypothetical twin, the forum might have been articulated by two pairs of exedrae rather than one’ (203). However, their own reconstruction (204) equally presents speculation as fact, as it includes the architectural remains of the alleged exedra and adds a faint outline of its hypothetical reconstruction, while creating the impression that the forum's eastern colonnade — in solid outlines — could securely be reconstructed without the mirroring counter-piece, although this part of the forum has never been fully explored.
On a more fundamental level, it must be noted that the quality of the text is not always matched by the illustrations. Several of the numerous plans and photographs are blurred, occasionally even pixellated, which seems to be due to layout and formatting issues. In the print copy, these glitches are even more obvious than in the e-book version provided by Cambridge University Press. This is a shame, given the volume's pricing and its important role as a landmark publication in the field of Roman architecture, which, as any strand of architectural history, relies on visuals as a crucial tool of teaching and research.
When it comes to a final assessment, the great merit of this book is beyond any doubt, and its authors deserve the highest praise for their achievement. However, their view of Roman architecture also sheds valuable light on both the traditional strands and future perspectives of the field: throughout the 900 pages, Italy, North Africa, Greece and Asia Minor receive the lion's share of attention; case studies from the Rhine and Danube provinces, the Balkans and Egypt are few and far between; apart from some German and British villas, the architecture of the north-western provinces plays virtually no role in the narrative; and the focus on urban monumental buildings is so dominant that there are no dedicated sections on rural and military architecture or on architecture in ephemeral materials. Moving into the third decade of the twenty-first century, scholars and students may find it worthwhile to consider how this conventional view of Roman architecture as essentially Mediterranean, urban, and built of stone, brick, and concrete could be fruitfully widened to encompass a much broader spectrum of ancient realities.
