Late medieval divergence between Western Europe and the Arab heartlands called for theories that ascribed the economic and technological stasis in the Muslim lands to Islam. Michael Dols, in his book The Black Death in the Middle East (1977), draws sweeping conclusions regarding the conceptual differences between Christianity and Islam from the contrasting reactions of Western Europe and the Middle East to the Black Death (1348). Stuart J. Borsch contests such generalizing theories, which have long since been labeled “Orientalist,” and offers a more reliable methodology based on established techniques of economic history. He uses quantitative data for the comparison he conducts between the pre- and post-Black Death economies in Western Europe and Islamic lands. Furthermore, he discusses the Black Death in a smaller and more manageable sphere of inquiry, limiting his study to the specific cases of postplague England and Egypt, or, more precisely, to the domestic economies of these two regions—their agrarian systems, rural industry, and international trade.
England and Egypt were chosen as the focus of this study in the first place because of their opposing reactions to the plague. Among Western European countries, the former recovered most impressively from the plague's depopulation and reacted with a technological and social revival, whereas the latter regressed to long-term economic deterioration. Despite their apparent differences, these two countries were chosen as a model for the comparison because they had much in common. They were both centralized and ruled by monarchs whose authority was limited by a landed aristocracy. Both had more or less the same population level prior to the plague, their agriculture was the mainstay of their economies, and their total agrarian gross domestic product (GDP) was roughly equal.
A key methodology for this research is the comparison of total agrarian output, or agrarian wealth, in Egypt and England before and after the onset of the plague. For this purpose Borsch used the land surveys of 1315, 1522, and the late 16th century as his basic data for Egypt's GDP. In order to achieve an accurate comparison, Borsch also had need of a secondary study on the value of the dinār jayshī, which served as a unit of account for those surveys. The landholding systems in England and Egypt served the author as another source of data to evaluate the GDP agrarian output of both countries. Borsch develops his central thesis in six chapters in a consistent presentation with tables and diagrams.
Borsch argues that the landholding systems in Egypt and England were the main factors that dictated the direction of their economies. The landholders' position in England was challenged by the plague depopulation. The relative shortage of rural labor and the abundance of arable land forced landholders to come to terms with peasants. The peasants demanded reduced land rents and higher wages for their work. The landlords' landed revenues were further reduced because of the drop in grain prices. To secure labor for themselves, the landlords were soon pushed into rivalry and made concessions to the peasants.
In Egypt the reaction to the plague depopulation was the opposite of that encountered in England in spite of the similarity in their plague-depopulation measures. Subsequent outbreaks during the 14th and 15th centuries brought about the death of half of Egypt's population. Not only was economic recovery not in the cards in the 15th century, but also the agrarian system in Egypt, which was the country's main source of income, lay in ruins. As landlords, the Mamluks were protected from the peasants' demands by the landholding system of the iqṭāʿ. The lack of inheritance of the iqṭāʿ, which resulted in its frequent transfer between different muqṭaʿs, the scattering of iqṭāʿs in various locations, and the filtering role played by officeholders in the fiscal administration all obviated the peasants' demands for a better distribution of wealth between the landlords and themselves. As a result, wages in Egypt dropped dramatically, unemployment increased, and the agricultural and total output decreased far beyond the percentage of the plague depopulation. Another reason for the suffering of the peasantry in Egypt was neglect of the irrigation system as a result of corrupt and oppressive measures imposed by the government. The impoverished farmers deserted their villages for the city only to swell the numbers of the penniless unemployed there. Some compensation for agrarian-output losses for the elite was offered by the spice trade. The author concludes his study with some suggestive remarks for similar cross-regional microcomparisons that might explain more unsolved questions concerning the divergence between the medieval Muslim Middle East and Western Europe.
In this study Borsch has undoubtedly presented an innovative perspective for the old central issue of the contrasts between Western Europe and the eastern Muslim lands. He offers a sound thesis based on comparative history and techniques of economic methodology that leave no room for traditionally held speculations regarding the differences between Islam and Christianity and their impact on the “Orient” and the “West.” This new interdisciplinary research is a welcome contribution to the existing corpus of studies dealing with the effects of the Black Death in the Old World. It will certainly be one of the studies consulted by anyone seeking to investigate the economic history of the medieval Middle East.
However, in his attempt to specify his argument from earlier interpretations of the drastic decline in the agricultural output of postplague Egypt, the author has overemphasized the role of the landholding system while other factors have been ignored or dealt with only briefly. Most critically, Egypt's landholding system that was in force during the 14th and 15th centuries, the iqṭāʿ, is portrayed as one that “stayed more or less intact,” although in fact it underwent significant changes that dramatically affected the country's agricultural output (p. 113). Privatization and bedouinization of rural areas in Egypt had far-reaching ramifications on the Egyptian village. ʿImad Badr al-Din Abu Ghazi has already shown the transition of iqṭāʿ lands into private hands during the 15th century (Tatawwur al-Haya al-Ziraʿiyya fi Misr Zaman al-Mamalik al-Jarakisa, 2000). Similarly, Jean-Claude Garcin has indicated that large tracts of arable land and villages in Upper and Lower Egypt in the 15th century were, in fact, dominated and inhabited by bedouins (Un centre musulman de la Haute Egypte medieval: Qûş, 1976, and “Note sur la rapports entre bedouins et fellahs a l'epoque mamluk,” Annales Islamologiques, 14 [1978], 147–63).
The transition of land from the government into private and bedouin hands meant that responsibility for the irrigation system, which was decisive for sustaining agriculture in Egypt, was left to sectors that did not possess the facilities to deal with it. Egypt and England had totally different water regimes. England depended on rain, but the Nile was Egypt's almost sole source of water. The government's role in maintaining the irrigation and agriculture systems in Egypt was far more decisive than in England. Familiarity with Garcin's and Abu Ghazi's works would have balanced the overstated centrality the author attributes to the landholding system for the decline in Egypt's agricultural output. It should be emphasized that this does not diminish the impressive value of the quantitative and comparative data that the author presents in this study.
A few spelling slips in Arabic were also noted in passing. In the quotation from al-Maqrizi's account of the outbreak of the plague (p. 2) mārkab should be markab, kuluhûm should be kulluhum, mina al-tājir should be mina al-tujjār, and jāmīʿan jamīʿan. Also, it should be kushshāf instead of kushaf and arbāb al-qurā not arabab al-qurya (p. 37).
This book is an important contribution to the study of Egypt and late medieval Islam. It introduces a challenging evaluation of central issues concerning the different paths taken by medieval postplague Western Europe and the Arab heartland. It will no doubt call for more microregional comparisons and further scholarly discussions on Old World economies. This book is a useful acquisition for scholars of Mamluk history in particular and of Islamic history in general.
