“The truth is the whole!” wrote Hegel. The reprint of V. N. Dadrian's article on the so-called Andonian “documents” steers clear of many pertinent facts related to Armenian-Turkish relations and falls short of Hegel's maxim. Dadrian reduces the topic to a one-sided indoctrination, limiting his references to selected narratives and omitting all evidence that contradicts mainstream Armenian views. His article bypasses the initial Armenian massacre of Muslim Anatolians, the Armenian-led revolt in the Ottoman province of Van, and Armenian shedding of blood in about a dozen wars or armed clashes. He attacks the Turks presented with the posture of a prosecuting attorney in tones so biased that today's social scientists would define them as racist.
Dadrian once more presents the theory that the “savage” Turks designed and accomplished the near total extermination of unarmed, unprotected Armenian civilians and that the Andonian “documents” substantiate that argument. Every reasoning, interpretation, judgment, and hint in such a train of thought is objectionable.
Many scholarly works confirm that the Ottoman millet system recognized a kind of minority self-government among all Armenian, Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant (as well as Jewish and Muslim) citizens. It gave these semi-independent communities basic freedoms: choice of administrators, worship in their own churches, use of national language, and the right to work and to hold office. It was the Ottoman Turkish sultan who recognized the Armenians in 1461, at a time when Europe was up to its neck in long religious wars. In contrast, about 11 million Muslims (mainly Turks) of the Balkans, the Crimea, and Caucasia were killed or forced to migrate between 1821 and 1922.
Dadrian entirely bypasses the scholarly works of outstanding writers of the older generation (like Langer, Whitman, Beaman, and others, including his compatriots Nalbantian and K. S. Papazian), as well as contemporary ones (Shaw, McCarthy, Lewis, etc.), all of whom underlined Armenian agitation, their resort to terror, and their search for an opportunity to kill Turks during wartime. It is impossible to overlook the threads of continuity in Armenian political violence from the 19th century through World War I, as well as in the bloody Armenian attacks on Turkish targets during the 1970s and 1980s.
Even British sources state that between 1 and 1.5 million Armenians were living in Turkey in 1914 and that armed Armenian volunteers and battalions “slaughtered an estimated 120,000 non-Armenians while the Turkish Army was preoccupied with mobilization.”Footnote 1 Armed Armenian rebels attacked the Muslim quarters in the Ottoman city of Van, proclaimed their provisional government there, joined forces with Turkey's enemies in all fronts, and controlled eastern Anatolia after 1917, engaging in mass killings once more. There exists ample evidence in the archives of many states that Armenians, who constituted only a minority even in the provinces that they called “Western Armenia,” rose up in arms in several towns, attacked unguarded Muslim quarters, massacred Muslims, cut Ottoman-army communication lines, blocked strategic roads, and threatened the security and logistics of the Turkish fighting forces. That the Armenians formed armies of “more than 200,000” fighting men in support of tsarist Russian, British, and French forces is in the war memoirs of their own commanders.Footnote 2
Hence came the Ottoman orders to resettle most, not all, of the remaining Armenians away from war zones. Undeniable Armenian armed violence left the Ottomans with no alternative. Not a single Jew in Germany and no Japanese American had resorted to armed violence before the notorious Holocaust and the U.S. decision to intern that minority. Not a single Ottoman document orders or hints at the murder of a single Armenian. When the British arrested 144 leading Ottoman functionaries and took them to Malta to try them there, the so-called Andonian “documents,” printed separately in 1920 in Boston, London, and Paris, were in the victors' hands. Yet because of their unreliability, all of the Turks under detention were set free in 1921 without trial or a charge. Years of research in the Ottoman archives and further consultation with the U.S. government failed to produce evidence that could be used against the Turks in a court of law.
However, there was bloodshed. As noted, third parties acknowledged Armenian mass murder of Muslims, the number of the victims running into six digits. Despite strict Ottoman-government orders to the contrary, there were also occasional civilian attacks on some Armenian groups as they moved southward. In 1915 and 1916, the Turkish courts passed severe penalties, including capital punishment, for such acts.
Dadrian shares the mainstream Armenian view that Turks can only be “victimizers” and Armenians “victims.” Psychoanalysis describes such disposition as “the egoism of victimization,” which recognizes no room for the sufferings of the “other group.” Its by-product can only be mythologizing the events in favor of one group. As a consequence, the number of Armenians killed is sometimes stated as twice as many as their total population.Footnote 3
Dadrian also overlooks that the Armenians often fought in conjunction with the Russians, British, French, and Greeks against the Turks, Azeris, and Georgians. They killed and got killed in return. They even shed blood in class wars in their native Armenia. Some survivors became refugees in Syria, Lebanon, France, and the United States. None of these losses may be described as “genocide.”
War conditions and epidemics have been the common enemy in armed conflicts throughout history. Turkish losses were especially high. Armenians lived and fought under similar circumstances. The disease losses in the other armies were also high. None of these losses may be categorized as “genocide.”
Dadrian's article–which omits crucial facts, indulges in exaggerations, and is sprinkled with prejudicial remarks–reflects his personal attributions that he expects the reader to accept as the whole truth. The Turkish arguments, reflecting the sufferings of the “other group” and based on valid documentation, constitute the indivisible parts of that whole.
