Since the defeat of the 2009 Green Movement and subsequent election of the moderate Hasan Ruhani in 2013, many observers of Iran have turned to analyses of Iran's political factionalism in order to better explicate the intricacies of Iran's complex sociopolitical atmosphere. In Iran Divided, Shireen T. Hunter adopts this approach, purporting “to [go] beyond the binary visions of the debate” that portray current social and political conflicts in Iran as the direct result of a clash between liberalism and conservatism (p. 8). In order to do so, Hunter covers a broad swath of history—from early 19th-century Iran to the aftermath of the 2013 elections in two sections covering pre- and postrevolutionary history. The major claim of Hunter's book is that Iran's current fragmented condition stems from an ongoing left–right split among both the politicians and denizens of the Islamic Republic. In Hunter's analysis, this split is the continuation of a left–right split within the anti-Shah coalition.
The main tenet of Hunter's argument—that Iran's major reformists are not merely similar to, but rather, the continuation of prerevolutionary leftist movements such as the Tudeh and Mujahedin-e Khalgh—is historically tenuous and rhetorically unclear. Hunter argues that “the secular left” suffered a defeat at the hands of the “Islamists” after the 1979 Revolution (p. 118). However, in writing about postrevolutionary Iran, she claims that, “the former leftists are now liberal reformists” (p. 133). Under a long list entitled, “Major Leftist Figures and Organizations,” she lists the names of individuals such as Saʿid Hajarian, Muhammad Reza Khatami, and Mir Hussein Musavi, but offers scant explanations for their inclusion. The evidence she does offer relies on speculation and a troubling collapse between various left-leaning prerevolutionary groups, which she has taken the care to differentiate. For instance, as evidence that Mir Hussein Musavi is a “prominent leftist,” she writes: “His wife, Zahra Rahnavard . . . is identified as ‘a star pupil of Ali Shariati.’ This characterization places her firmly on the leftist front in Iran. Moreover, some recent articles by her detractors have claimed that she was close to the Mojahedin e Khalgh” (p. 134). The assumed linear trajectory from association with Shariati to the “leftist camp” is troubling, as is Hunter's reliance on Rahnavard's detractors as evidence for her argument.
In numerous instances throughout the book, Hunter collapses the prerevolutionary and postrevolutionary “left” into a single vague, mass conglomerate. Rather than treat terms such as “left” and “right” as ways to refer to relative positions in an ever-shifting sociopolitical context, Hunter uses them as blanket terms that themselves are the agents of change. Thus, in Hunter's work, “the left” popularizes the idea of revolution, the left ensures its success, and the resentment of the the left post-1979 brings about the discordant 2009 elections (p. 262). Even though Hunter sets out to complicate Iran's “many fault lines and divisions,” by arguing that contemporary Iranian politics is merely a manifestation of a longstanding and diametrically opposed left–right split, she instead reduces Iranian politics to another static binary. Similarly, in her introduction, Hunter states that one of the main theses of her book is that Iran's present condition results from its long history of foreign invasion, as well as Iran's “encounter with the West and modernity” (p. 9). Yet, after the first two chapters of the book, there is little mention of either topic. Nor does Hunter define the theoretical stakes of concepts such as “the West” or “modernity” in her work. As such, there is a marked disconnect between the book's theoretical aims, as outlined in the introduction and conclusion, and the bulk of its content.
The actual content of Hunter's book is devoted to a condensed history of modern Iran. Hunter's chapters follow chronological order, with a few exceptions, and cover the major political trajectories and events of the past century. Hunter writes clearly, offering effective historical descriptions of political conflicts, rendering them accessible to the general reader. Despite her problematic characterization of Iranian politics into two major groups of left and right, Hunter is particularly adept at distinguishing various factions within each of these groups. This clarity is enhanced by her writing style—Hunter's chapters are clearly delineated into short sections, and she commonly employs numbered lists and bullets to posit various theories of causality or describe the characteristic of a certain movement. She is thereby able to lay out stakes of fairly complex debate in an organized manner. However, the drawback of Hunter's list and summary-heavy style is that it often veers toward generalization, and Hunter does not make wide use of footnotes to explicate or elaborate the historical phenomena she describes. Iran Divided offers relatively little original historical information for English-language readers, as the major sources for this work are English-language news articles.
The strongest sections of Iran Divided are its latter chapters (Chaps. 9–11). Here, Hunter effectively conveys the nuances of the infighting of the group that she broadly identifies as “the right” in the Islamic Republic under the Ahmadinejad presidency. Hunter's assessment of the implications of Ruhani's election is also timely and valuable, and all three chapters are appropriate for the general reader or student of Iran. Finally, Iran Divided unfortunately suffers from weak editing, as evidenced by a general lack of standardization of Persian names throughout the book. For example, in discussing the Mojahedin e Khalgh, Hunter uses three disparate terms, “Mojahedin,” “Mojahedin e Khalgh,” and “Mujahedin-e Khalgh,” within the span of a single page, making it potentially difficult for a newcomer to literature on Iran to follow (p. 134). As the content of the book is too general for the specialist, the intended audience of Hunter's book is unclear. However, given that Hunter offers succinct précis of key moments in Iran's recent political history, Iran Divided may serve as a useful reference for students already familiar with Iran's history.
