Michael Hanchard is best known for his seminal book Orpheus and Power: The Movimento Negro of Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paulo, Brazil, 1945–1988 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1994). The brilliance of this work hinges on Hanchard's ability to excavate and bring analytical clarity to a dynamic that scholars had long ignored—the connection between ascriptive racial hierarchy and power politics in Brazil. Hanchard displays this same penchant for charting new scholarly terrain in his latest book Party/Politics: Horizons in Black Political Thought.
Whereas the struggles of Brazil's (self-identified) Afro-descendant population for recognition and a voice in that nation's politics animates his early work, Hanchard nimbly treats the politics of race, culture, and class across the entire African diaspora in Party/Politics. Indeed, the book is more an extended meditation on several important ontological and epistemological questions in the social sciences as they relate to politics in the African diaspora than a treatment of one coherent subject. Although some readers may yearn for greater integration between the book's six substantive chapters, the intellectual and analytical breadth that Hanchard displays in Party/Politics is extraordinary.
In chapter 2, Hanchard takes up the question, what is the dividing line between political behavior that is easily identifiable as part of the formalized politics that take place at the state level and what he calls “informal modes of political articulation” in the black diaspora? His main contention in this essay is that social scientists fundamentally misunderstand the politics of the black diaspora (and subaltern groups in general) because they have failed to pay enough attention to “every day” forms of political expression. Indeed, Hanchard argues that a theory of “quotidian politics” is essential to understanding the modalities of black struggles against white supremacy in the Western Hemisphere. Although the literature on peasant revolts in the developing world (i.e., James Scott's work) has clearly shaped Hanchard's ideas about politics in the black diaspora, his work is by no means a derivative of these earlier studies. Hanchard's concept of “coagulation”—which provides a theoretical basis for understanding individuated acts of resistance in systems of racial oppression—is an innovate contribution to this literature.
Chapter 3, written with Michael Dawson, a leading scholar of public opinion in the U.S. context, explores the connection between quotidian politics and the formation and dissemination of ideologies in the black public sphere. This superbly written chapter achieves two important ends. First, by demonstrating that many ideologies of resistance in the black world emerged from among the masses before they took hold of the black elite, Hanchard and Dawson provide a direct challenge to the dominant paradigm within public opinion research. Second, the qualitative and historic turn that Hanchard and Dawson take in this chapter demonstrates persuasively that “much of the survey-based literature on black public opinion provides only a glimpse of the ideas, norms, and outlooks of black political culture” (69).
Hanchard returns by himself in chapter 4. This brief essay explores what he calls the “ethnics of aversion.” In short, the chapter builds on his work with Dawson by asking the question, what happens to black political ideologies when blacks on the ground simply avoid contacts with whites in the post-Civil Rights era? Hanchard answers this question in chapter 5 with a treatment of the role of the “black public intellectual” in modern politics. He argues that these figures often play an important role in mediating relations between marginalized black communities and the “national political cultures” controlled by “dominant groups.” Given his perspective on the diffusion of political ideologies, Hanchard's use of this chapter to call on scholars of black politics to “broaden” their conception of the public intellectual to include “grassroots activists” is not at all surprising.
Hanchard examines literary and historical texts in chapters 6 and 7. In chapter 6, he presents a brilliant comparative analysis of Heinrich von Kleist's novella Kohlhaas: From an Old Chronicle and E.L. Doctorow's Ragtime with an eye toward illuminating the construction of outsiders in democratic societies. Although he succeeds at this task, the chapter does seem a bit out of place in the context of the broader work. Still, Hanchard's willingness to bring literature into the discussion is a bold move that future works on politics in the black diaspora should emulate.
Hanchard opens the final substantive chapter of Party/Politics with an examination of a speech that Henry Highland Garnet delivered in Rochester, New York, in 1848. Garnet, a renowned black abolitionist in the nineteenth century, is best known for his advocacy of black emigration to Africa as the ultimate solution to the problem of racial inequality in America. Hanchard argues that Garnet, who had not yet turned to emigrationism, foreshadows one of the central drives of both the postmodernist and cultural studies movements by creating “a diachronic relationship between hybridity and antiracist practice” (185). In Hanchard's view, Garnet's early emphasis on hybridity places him in dialogue with important grassroots activists and intellectuals in other parts of the black diaspora (but especially Latin America). Hanchard deserves praise both for making this important connection and for having the discipline to stop short of making hybridity a fetish in the way that some recent works advocating an antiracist ethics have done.
Michael Hanchard's Party/Politics is a theoretically rich yet superbly written book. It makes contributions to both political science and black diaspora studies. Moreover, it is one of those rare books with the potential to appeal to scholars of racial and ethnic politics in all four subfields of political science.
