“Meet those amazing kids from ‘America's Music Town’—Interlochen!—in the screen's joy-filled, song-filled entertainment treat! Your new singing-starlet, Susanna Foster, leads the parade of youth!”Footnote 1 Such advertisements heralded the opening of Paramount Pictures’ There's Magic in Music (also known as The Hard-Boiled Canary, 1941), a film starring the studio's first operatic ingénue, the sixteen-year-old Susanna Foster, and a host of talented teenagers representing the students of what was then known as the National Music Camp.Footnote 2 Incorporating ideas of intellectual, cultural, and moral uplift proselytized by proponents of the music appreciation movement, There's Magic celebrated the then widespread belief that so-called “good music” could transform ne'er-do-wells into model citizens.Footnote 3
The movie opens with a sequence in which Michael Maddy, the director of the Interlochen Music Camp, conducts a radio interview with the acclaimed music critic Deems Taylor—and causes quite a stir. During his interview, Maddy enthusiastically espouses the universal appeal of art music, claiming that he overheard the audience of a cheap burlesque theater in New York going “wild over a young girl singing grand opera.” His idealistic remark prompts the radio's horrified directors to terminate the interview immediately. Maddy then persuades the publicity director of the Manhattan Opera Company to accompany him to the burlesque. There they discover the film's protagonist, a teenaged soprano named Toodles LaVerne, singing the “Shadow Song” (“Ombre légère”) from Giacomo Meyerbeer's Dinorah.Footnote 4 To Maddy's chagrin, Toodles is “shadowed” by a striptease artist whilst singing her aria for the highly appreciative and chiefly working-class, male audience. A police raid subsequently drives everyone out of the theater, and Maddy finds Toodles taking refuge in his car. He whisks the girl away to safety and awards her a scholarship to attend Interlochen. Surrounded by the camp's upright management and middle-class prodigies, Toodles eventually renounces her morally dubious past as a reform-school refugee for a future full of magical music making.
There's Magic in Music seemed to contain all the ingredients necessary for box office appeal. It offered romance, a hint of sex, drama, and comedy as well as a variety of musical styles. The film's popular numbers featured “Fireflies on Parade,” a dance band tune written especially for There's Magic by composer Ann Ronell; a “celebrity imitation song” performed by Toodles; and a rendition of John Philip Sousa's “The Stars and Stripes Forever.”Footnote 5 The movie's more prominent musical selections comprised of opera excerpts, chamber pieces, and symphonic works, including, among others, Georges Bizet's Carmen, Johannes Brahms's Hungarian Dance No. 5, Charles Gounod's Faust, Edvard Grieg's Piano Concerto in A minor, Johann Strauss II's “Voices of Spring,” and Richard Wagner's Rienzi and Tannhäuser.
Despite this nod to a broad spectrum of tastes ranging all the way from “highbrow” to “lowbrow,” Paramount's sales department decided shortly before the film's release that the movie needed special advertising to reach the masses, Hollywood's catchall term for the working and middle classes who were believed to make up the cinema's main audience.Footnote 6 Imagining that these individuals were disinclined to like “good music” and therefore wary of the film's extensive display of orchestral and operatic performances, the sales department changed the movie's title from the sanguine There's Magic in Music to the seedier The Hard-Boiled Canary, effectively rebranding the film as more suggestive of a crime drama than a musical about the divine power of the Western European canon.Footnote 7 With its new—and arguably incongruous—title, the film flopped when it hit theaters in March 1941, causing Paramount to pull the motion picture and re-release it three months later in June under its former title, There's Magic in Music. Footnote 8
An abundance of archival materials positions There's Magic in Music as a valuable case study for investigating the transitional period of musical film production between the waning of the Great Depression and the onset of World War II. Whereas present scholarship offers rich insight into the production and reception of Broadway adaptations and musicals featuring popular songs, this study uses unpublished sources to contribute a new perspective on the complexities of producing and promoting films showcasing Western art music. Censorship records, studio correspondence, comment cards, promotional materials, scripts, and other such primary documents reveal how Paramount's internal debate over what to call There's Magic in Music indexed broader cultural and global developments affecting film content, genre conventions, and the studio system's “assembly line” approach to film production.
Indeed, the film industry's divided attitudes toward presenting “elite” music in the movies critically shaped the musical film's development, marketing, and reception. Pierre Bourdieu's theorization of cultural taste as informed by one's social standing offers a framework for understanding Hollywood's assumptions about musical preference as bounded by class and defined by economic strata.Footnote 9 Bourdieu asserts that taste is the “practical affirmation of an inevitable difference . . . the refusal of other tastes.”Footnote 10 The film industry—with a few exceptions of personnel who believed that “good music” could be appreciated by anyone—typically correlated musical taste with socioeconomic status. It identified upper-class individuals as the devotees of art music and presumed that the middle and lower classes patronized more “accessible” or popular musics. Hollywood, however, did not always differentiate between the middle and lower classes, either in regard to advertising strategies or in pinpointing a specific audience demographic. Studio documents, for example, frequently refer to the industry's perceived core audience in such vaguely classed terms as “the masses” or “the average viewer.” Still, some studio employees went so far as to label movie patrons “groundlings,” a term used in Elizabethan times to refer to those who could not afford seats at a public theater but who could pay a small fee to stand in front of the stage. The term later came to denote those individuals with unsophisticated or uncultivated tastes.
Yet broader cultural shifts complicated Hollywood's assumptions regarding the connection between one's musical preference and socioeconomic status. During the 1920s and 1930s, musical preference, or taste, had become increasingly politicized in the United States as the music appreciation movement gained momentum and as a middlebrow culture developed.Footnote 11 In the mid-1930s, movies showcasing excerpts of art music were discovered to be successful at the box office, generating the production of a new kind of musical film that spoke to a burgeoning middlebrow taste culture. Hollywood's investment in “good music” thus fell in line with broader cultural phenomena that helped heighten art music's cultural visibility. At the same time, tensions produced by debates over “good music's” accessibility versus its vaunted status as high art perhaps explains why the film industry had reservations about its viability as a form of popular entertainment.
There's Magic in Music therefore serves as a lens through which we might explore changes in musical film production and fluid notions of “good music” at the eve of World War II, both as the film industry adapted to, and as cultural taste and political frameworks shifted in response to, a Europe already embroiled in war. This article first interrogates Hollywood's mixed attitudes toward the classics, showing how the film industry harbored competing, and often contradictory, ideas about how best to market the classics to an American public recently given increased access to such music via the phonograph and the radio. I then outline the transition of musical film production from the Great Depression to the immediate prewar years. Shaping how films featuring “good music” were made, the studios began experimenting with the musical film's staple “backstage” formula—wherein narratives are set in theatrical contexts and musical numbers can be framed as the natural consequence of putting on a show—to combat dwindling sales. Next, I investigate how these shifts in filmmaking and the tension between “good music” as elite art and “good music” as mass entertainment manifested in Paramount's yearlong deliberation over what to call There's Magic in Music, as the studio sought an inclusive title that would appeal to all audiences. I then analyze two sets of documents to show how the public responded differently to the same film depending on its title. An examination of Paramount's promotional campaign further illustrates how the sales department's late decision to change the movie's title and attract the “groundlings” ran counter to the studio's promotional strategies, which targeted music lovers and the middle to upper classes.
Hollywood and the “Classics”
“Interest in good music is more widespread today than ever before. Radio programs featuring classical numbers are among the most popular on the air while phonograph records of great singers and symphony orchestras outsell even those of popular dance bands.”Footnote 12 Thus claimed Michael Maddy in a speech addressed to radio listeners during the opening scene of There's Magic in Music. The camp director's sound bite neatly encapsulated the position of art music in the United States at the dawn of the 1940s. A number of radio programs—including the Metropolitan Opera's Saturday afternoon broadcasts, conductor Walter Damrosch's Music Appreciation Hour, and the NBC Symphony Orchestra broadcasts—had cultivated a substantial audience for art music while the records of such famous artists as Lily Pons and Risë Stevens sold well nationwide.Footnote 13 The Federal Music Project, too, brought employment to various musicians during the Great Depression, supporting new orchestras, opera companies, music festivals, and music appreciation courses across the country.Footnote 14 “Good music” could be heard anywhere by virtue of such modern technologies as the phonograph and radio that granted audiences easy and affordable access to classical performances.Footnote 15
Even so, the businessmen controlling motion pictures, one of the most influential media in the United States, treated “good music” with caution. Hollywood gravitated toward popular styles from the early days of sound film, when such movies as The Jazz Singer (1927) sparked an interest in “talkies” featuring musical numbers. Music from Tin Pan Alley to jazz flourished in these films due to the initial limitations of early recording and camera technologies, the attraction of novelty, copyright laws, and studio biases against “elite” music.Footnote 16 A few early movie experiments, too, most likely bolstered industry skepticism over so-called highbrow music's potential for widespread appeal.Footnote 17 MGM, for example, produced two musical film duds starring Metropolitan Opera singers Grace Moore and Lawrence Tibbett: A Lady's Morals (1930) and New Moon (1930).Footnote 18
Yet once Hollywood ironed out the initial kinks of marrying sound to image, Columbia Pictures proved, much to the studio's own surprise, that there was a market for movies presenting the classics. Its smash hit One Night of Love (1934), Grace Moore's comeback film, received rave reviews and multiple Academy Awards.Footnote 19 One Night also sparked a wave of musical films cashing in on the popularity of “good music,” a label that Hollywood indiscriminately used in its fan magazines and other such publications to refer to both operatic and symphonic repertoires. Indeed, Hollywood released nineteen musical films between 1934 and 1939 that starred a number of well-known performers from the Met, including Jan Kiepura, Nino Martini, Grace Moore, Lily Pons, Gladys Swarthout, Marion Talley, and Lawrence Tibbett. Various studios further developed romanticized biopics of such figures as Frederic Chopin and Robert Schumann as well as stories about classical musicians.Footnote 20
Meanwhile, Universal Studios’ Three Smart Girls (1936), the debut vehicle for fourteen-year-old singing sensation Deanna Durbin, offered a new take on the opera diva-hopeful narrative, inspiring a new trend for family-friendly motion pictures featuring adolescent operatic ingénues.Footnote 21 In 100 Men and a Girl (1937), for example, Durbin played a precocious youngster who charms a wealthy patron into sponsoring a civic orchestra comprised of unemployed musicians. It starred renowned conductor Leopold Stokowski in his first of three film roles and included numerous sequences with music by Berlioz, Liszt, Mozart, Tchaikovsky, Verdi, and Wagner.Footnote 22 Even movies showcasing the talents of such popular artists as Judy Garland occasionally highlighted an operatic episode. In Babes in Arms (1939), for instance, MGM actress Betty Jaynes's operatic singing was juxtaposed equally to Garland's swinging style in the musical number “I Like Opera, I Like Swing.”Footnote 23
Movie publicity, however, operated as a double-edged sword. Columnists frequently reinforced the perception that art music was dull or old-fashioned when plugging Hollywood's new products. One representative example from Screen Album in 1936 addressed the recent influx of musicals featuring operatic episodes:
Until lately, the mere mention of grand opera was a signal for people to roll their eyes heavenward, which gesture was supposed to indicate acute boredom. The movie-going public has lived to break down and confess that all the good tunes do not come from Tin Pan Alley; that an aria can be as popular as a torch song; that prima donnas are not all fat; and that it is a pretty thrilling experience to hear a full, gorgeous voice weaving in and out of the accompanying mazes of a big symphony orchestra.Footnote 24
A multitude of journalistic narratives similar to this one created the impression that the public universally considered the classics to be tedious. Within these texts, “good music” by itself served as a negative foil for Hollywood's releases, which overcame the public's tedium by rendering performances as accessible, entertaining, and visually appealing.
Still, the preconception that the masses found art music to be boring was so strong that a few studios adopted multiple strategies for their promotional campaigns, hoping not to deter individuals with simpler musical tastes. One of these, RKO, hedged its bets when coloratura soprano Lily Pons joined the studio's roster in 1935. The studio advance for Pons's debut film, I Dream Too Much (1935), called it “entertainment for all classes of the American public.”Footnote 25 Even so, RKO informed theater managers that there was “no blanket campaign that will reach everyone. It will be necessary to direct a separate appeal to each class.” The studio therefore recommended that the theater manager exploit the film by selling the “opera angle to the highbrows” and the film's romance angle, popular music, and “glamorous girls” to the “mass public . . . whose entertainment ideas are purely sensory. Sell the clothes.”Footnote 26 Yet in proposing these directed marketing strategies, the studio revealed the complex nature of class-based campaigns by admitting that music lovers could, however, “be found among all classes.”
By the late 1930s and early 1940s, “good music” had become an indelible part of Hollywood's soundtrack. It coexisted alongside the torch songs and increasingly popular swing music that marked the soundscape of World War II in the United States. Many of the studios held contracts with opera singers and occasionally welcomed other figures from the art music world such as conductor and pianist José Iturbi as novelties.Footnote 27 Hollywood even began developing its own stable of operatic stars, including teen singers Deanna Durbin, Gloria Jean, Susanna Foster, Kathryn Grayson, and Jane Powell.
Yet there was more at stake for “good music” in Hollywood than for popular music, due, in part, to the widely held bias in the studios that the public found the classics dull. If a particular popular song did not thrill audiences, popular music's raison d’être was not called into question. If moviegoers disliked a classical performance, however, it contributed to the sentiment that art music was a “yawn,” an artifact that one's grandparents appreciated or a sophisticated cultural pastime dutifully revered by high society. Producers, directors, and screenwriters therefore were considered essential to shaping “good music's” filmic presentation via screenplays, framing within the plot, and cinematography so as to make it attractive to the audience. Publicity and sales departments, too, played an equally critical role—although sometimes at cross-purposes—in cultivating advance interest in these musicals.
Musical Film Production: Transitioning from the Great Depression to the Prewar Years
The American public's interest in musical films began to wane at the end of the 1930s, and attendance for these films dropped.Footnote 28 In response to diminishing revenue, studios such as MGM and Paramount sought to revive the genre, in part, by modifying the aging backstage musical formula to focus instead on timely, dramatic narratives and star power.Footnote 29 Broader cultural concerns and changes to industry infrastructure helped shape the musical film's development as the United States began adapting to the ramifications of a second world war.
Earlier in the decade, Hollywood musicals typically featured a romance between the male and female leads and/or followed a backstage “show within a show” narrative.Footnote 30 The latter became a particularly useful formula for imparting a sense of realism to an otherwise unrealistic genre. By constructing plots centered on the subject of show business, the studios could cast a protagonist's frequent bursts into song or dance as a natural side effect of their profession. In Swing Time (1936), for example, Ginger Rogers's characterization as a dance instructor adds a touch of realism to a scene featuring the song-and-tap routine, “Pick Yourself Up,” during which she “instructs” entertainer Fred Astaire in the art of partnered dancing. Yet despite such attention to verisimilitude, the backstage musical of the 1930s did not present the grim realities of the Great Depression either often or directly, establishing what film scholar Rick Altman refers to as “the illusionist and happy-go-lucky syntax of the genre.”Footnote 31 Historian Allen L. Woll similarly observes that “while the majority of film musicals of the 1930s accepted the real world in terms of form, they generally ignored it in terms of content.”Footnote 32
By the end of the decade, the backstage formula and its various permutations began to take a toll on audiences as a well-worn plot device. According to Variety’s Denis Morrison, studios such as Universal, Fox, and MGM sought to recoup public interest by pointing the musical in a new direction, one in which an overarching plot served as a vital cinematic component rather than a means by which to tie a film's musical numbers loosely together.Footnote 33 For Fox Studios executive Darryl Zanuck, musicals now needed to be “stoutly equipped with plot,” while MGM mogul Louis B. Mayer proposed that they required “quality music played and sung by the best artists obtainable, production value and spectacle, plus a dramatic believable story.”Footnote 34 What's more, the studios looked to fresh personalities to add pizzazz to their new musical releases, including the teenaged Deanna Durbin, Susanna Foster, and Judy Garland.
Even with revised formulas and fresh-faced stars, however, musical-film production dwindled to a new low in 1938. MGM announced that it would produce only one musical per every six motion pictures, whereas Columbia completely abandoned the genre.Footnote 35 Warner Bros. and Fox Studios, on the other hand, progressively focused on narrative realism to draw audiences back to the movie theater. As Fox's Zanuck argued in the New York Times, musicals needed a “timely or news interest.”Footnote 36 Both Warner and Fox therefore looked to current events when devising plots for their films, releasing a series of productions addressing contemporary topics ranging from sports to politics.Footnote 37
Over the course of the next three years and as news reports from Europe relayed woeful tidings of escalating military conflict, darker realities began to underpin the musical's narratives.Footnote 38 According to film scholar Sheri Chinen Biesen, Hollywood began experimenting with hybrid genre movies, which “deviated from the upbeat song and dance conventions of musical comedies. They portrayed a grittier undercurrent of performers struggling behind the scenes in shady entanglements as dramatic musical and dance sequences invoked topical working-class themes.”Footnote 39 Pictures such as Blues in the Night (1941) served as the antecedents to the film noir musical of the 1940s and 1950s, providing an “economical alternative to the big-budget musical productions during the rationing, blackouts, and other constraints imposed by World War II.”Footnote 40 Such films spun stories about the underbelly of American urban society and told tales of antiheroes and “tough” women.Footnote 41
By 1941, the year in which There's Magic in Music was released, musicals openly embraced elements of melodrama, crime drama, and film noir. Sandwiched between the Great Depression and the United States’ involvement in World War II, these movies offered new twists on the previous decade's signature backstage formula, experimenting with plots inspired by current events, an increased sense of realism, hardened protagonists, and subtle (or sometimes not-so-subtle) inflections of patriotism. Still, the studios encountered a set of new challenges related to production and promotion when fusing these various generic elements together. Paramount Studios’ There's Magic in Music—which is at once realistic and optimistic, hardened and sentimental, highbrow and populist, patriotic and globally sensitive—encapsulates some of the intricacies involved in making and marketing the hybridized musical, intricacies that, in this particular case, ultimately manifested in an internal debate over an appropriate movie title.
There's Magic in Music or The Hard-Boiled Canary?
In early Fall 1939, composer Ann Ronell began brainstorming ideas for possible movie scenarios based on the National Music Camp (Interlochen). She secured the approval of the camp's founder and director, Joseph E. Maddy, and visited Interlochen in September to collect material that could be used for potential movie scenarios. Working in association with independent producer Lester Cowan and Universal Studios, Ronell then sketched out various plots inspired by the screen personalities of teenaged actors with box office appeal. Ronell first envisioned the lead role for Universal's Deanna Durbin, but, when the actress proved unavailable, Ronell revised the story to suit MGM's popular duo, Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland. Her initial storyline revolved around a romance between two camp kids who compete for the place of first chair, violin, in the Interlochen orchestra.Footnote 42 Maddy, however, rejected Ronell's idea, believing that the adolescent romance and various “animal scares” might convince parents not to send their children to Interlochen.Footnote 43 When Rooney and Garland also proved impossible to “land,” Ronell wrote to Maddy that she had to “switch the story to feature Linda Ware—then Jackie Cooper—and so on through the list of all available young talent. The casting difficulties were and are rampant, as most box office names are signed with various studios who do not wish to lend them to another studio. I wrote many numbers to show the possibilities inherent in the camp's entertainment values.”Footnote 44 Indeed, Ronell had worked out a complete musical score for the movie that she felt would be “important to the camp.”Footnote 45
By mid-December and after writing “umpteen” movie scenarios for various adolescent stars, Ronell sold her contract with Maddy to Paramount Pictures, who purchased the exclusive rights to make a motion picture based on Interlochen. According to the composer's agent, Ronell's story possessed “terrific national exploitation possibilities” due to the camp's name recognition and connection to various public schools across the country.Footnote 46 Paramount wasted little time green-lighting production. In January 1940, the studio tasked a screenwriting team with transforming Ronell's project into a full-fledged screenplay, temporarily titled Interlochen.
Two months later, the studio entered into what would become a yearlong debate over an appropriate title for the motion picture. Paramount's executives decided that the working title, Interlochen, lacked box office appeal and was too difficult for the average American to pronounce.Footnote 47 They therefore requested a different one from the film's production unit. Besides potential pronunciation problems, the executives most likely did not consider the music camp famous enough to warrant its own eponymous movie and wanted a title that would recall other recently celebrated musical films such as Samuel Goldwyn's They Shall Have Music (1939), a story about a boy who, with violinist Jascha Heifetz's assistance, saves a music school from financial ruin.
The movie's writer and director, Andrew Stone, on the other hand, disagreed with the executives, advising that the studio retain the camp's name within the title. A lifelong devotee of the classics, Stone argued that Interlochen was illustrious enough to spark public interest, estimating generously that “at least ten million people in this country know about Interlochen intimately, namely the high school students who enter the National Music School contests and their families.”Footnote 48 Stone's studio communiqué indicates that, so far as he was concerned, Interlochen would garner the attention of both musicians and music lovers, a niche market that had been growing for the past decade. He was supported by executive Sam Frey, who believed that, from both marketing and cost perspectives, it would be advantageous to maintain some connection to the working title. Frey wrote to the film's producer that Stone's “point may be well taken. . . . All the publicity to date naturally has used Interlochen and will most likely continue to do so until we find a definite title, so that by retaining what we have now, we will be salvaging all the accumulated publicity.”Footnote 49
Despite potential name recognition and an ongoing publicity campaign promoting the movie's contracted musical prodigies and connections to the camp's musical community, Interlochen became There's Magic in Music, a title that pointed to the film's uplifting message rather than a specific musical institution. This new title, however, caused even more apprehension than its predecessor. Producer A. M. Botsford considered the replacement “bad” for two reasons: first, because the title “had the same sort of lilt” as that of the Heifetz film They Shall Have Music, and second, because the word “music” was “probably overdone as a word in former musical titles.”Footnote 50 According to custom, Paramount therefore put out a call to studio personnel to see who could formulate the best title for the film, promising a cash award for the winning selection.Footnote 51 Lists upon lists of suggestions reveal that eager employees played on every conceivable title with the words “melody,” “singing,” “song,” and “music” in it. One in particular, A Singing Cinderella, received positive attention by the executives but was soon discarded because, as Botsford put it, A Singing Cinderella:
definitely makes it a Susanna Foster starring picture—it puts all the emphasis on her, and even if this is true in the picture itself, I am wondering whether it does not bring the selling of the picture down in importance. If Foster had the reputation of [Deanna] Durbin, it would be all right, but I think we should have a title fairly resounding and important in itself. Moreover, I do not think Toodles is a Cinderella, by any means.Footnote 52
At the time the producer wrote this letter, Durbin dominated the operatic corner of Hollywood alongside Jeanette MacDonald. Durbin had starred in six highly popular films with her seventh—her own Cinderella story, It's a Date (1940)—just about to be released a few days later. The actress's name alone was enough to draw audiences to see the “latest Deanna Durbin picture” playing at their local theater. Foster, on the other hand, was still essentially an unknown with only a minor role in the biopic The Great Victor Herbert (1939) to her credit, a film also produced and directed by Stone.
Botsford's remark comparing Toodles to Cinderella encapsulated a few of the complications surrounding Toodles's characterization. Certainly, Toodles was not the typical good girl portrayed by the Durbins or Garlands in contemporary film offerings. According to There's Magic’s censorship records, the screenwriters conceived of Toodles as a rather worldly wise and grownup figure who resonated more with the hardened characters of World War II film noir—perhaps too much so. In a letter addressed to executive producer William LeBaron on March 18, 1940 regarding an early version of the screenplay, Botsford emphasized that the writers should not overdo the protagonist's hard-boiledness. Assessing the movie's opening burlesque scene, Botsford mused: “Of course, we need the strip-tease in order to have the raid and the flight of Toodles, but this will have to be handled in pretty good taste since even though Toodles is a ‘tuffy,’ the kind of people who want to see her and this fine musical picture may be affronted by the use of a child in these surroundings. Can you strip-tease to the aria from Traviata?”Footnote 53 Botsford stressed the importance of balancing Toodles’s characterization with the demands of the drama. Although necessary to underscore “good music's” power to enrich lives, the young lead's morals could not be so questionable as to upset the film's target audience: music lovers from the middle and upper classes.
Joseph Breen, the head of the Los Angeles censorship office, also critiqued multiple scenes in which Toodles's actions might be considered distasteful. Writing to Paramount's head of censorship, Luigi Luraschi, on April 13, 1940 regarding the film's initial script, Breen urged:
that you do not show your 14-year-old star, Susanna Foster, connected in any way with a burlesque theater. We are sure that this business will cause widespread offense to audiences generally. We think you should eliminate making Susanna too hard-boiled and showing her smoking cigarettes at several points in this story. In this connection, note also . . . the business of Susanna winking at the hotel clerk in Scene A-35; Scene A-38, this business of Susanna coming in to have her dress zipped up; Scene B-31, as to cigarettes and also as to her “hula” dance; . . . Scene A-38: the nude painting is entirely unacceptable. Also, Toodles’ remark “a sailor showed it to me on a post card” must be deleted.Footnote 54
From this communiqué as well as various script drafts, it is clear that Toodles underwent a fairly extensive character makeover before the final product's release. The actions Breen repeatedly opposed in his letters to Paramount were excised from the final script.
The film shoot for There's Magic in Music wrapped in July, by which time hundreds of potential titles had been rejected as unsatisfactory. As Botsford elaborated in a Washington Post article, choosing titles was a “chore” that everyone in the studio took a “whack at, from the office boy on up to the president.”Footnote 55 The producer revealed that his job was to try to find movie titles that satisfied everybody at Paramount, an outcome that he described as “impossible.” In particular, Botsford singled out the sales department as especially choosy, demanding titles with “oomph” and “action.” The studio certainly seemed to be hard-pressed to find a suitable “action” title for their musical film. On July 29, Botsford informed the studio's upper echelons that it was “going to be next to impossible to get a really good box office title” for the movie.Footnote 56
Instead of the idealistic There's Magic in Music, Botsford recommended renaming the film The Hard-Boiled Canary, a suggestion that, in his opinion, was “getting too little thought and consideration”:
I notice here that it is the one title out of the scores that have been suggested for the picture that really gets a widespread favorable reaction. I admit that the title ignores [Allan] Jones and is a bit crass, but we are not going to create advance interest in this picture with a title that talks about charm and music, etc. The title must have some novelty and sock in it. [Publicity and advertising director, Robert H.] Gillham, for example, thinks he could do a lot of good stuff with the title The Hard-Boiled Canary.Footnote 57
Botsford might not have considered this title to be an irregular choice because he was a producer who worked mostly on B-grade crime dramas, including Murder with Pictures (1936), Hideaway Girl (1936), and The Accusing Finger (1936). Still, the term “hard boiled” was almost never used in film titles, although the studios regularly employed it when describing certain storylines or characters, particularly those associated with crime dramas and, later, film noir.Footnote 58 “Canary,” too, further raised questions of genre, as it typically referred to, at least in a musical sense, a female performer who primarily sang popular songs.
Perhaps responding to the implications of “hard boiled” as denoting a particular film category, Botsford's colleagues vetoed the grittier title. Once again, the producer requested more suggestions from Paramount's eastern production manager:
I don't get a very good reaction out here on the title The Hard-Boiled Canary. Mr. LeBaron is definitely against it and so is Andrew Stone. Mr. Freeman doesn't think it is right, either, although he is not definitely against it. . . .Very rarely are there titles that actually draw people in. In these cases I think one of the parts of the search should be for a title that is fairly appealing but whose main virtues are that it will not keep people out. I would judge there would be a certain number of people who would not care to see a picture called The Hard-Boiled Canary which features Susanna Foster, whom they don't know. Whatever recollection of Foster they have would be that she and Jones were in a beautiful musical called Victor Herbert, and whatever draw there would be on There's Magic in Music should be on the basis of the same kind of musical with, unfortunately, no kind of a name as Victor Herbert to put on it. . . . After all, this is a musical picture. Are we to deny it is a musical picture in our title? . . . The Hard-Boiled Canary, to me, is the title of something that could be for Ann Sothern or Lucille Ball and runs the danger of keeping people away from the picture rather than attracting them to it.Footnote 59
One reason Paramount's executives could not agree on an appropriate title was because Foster was not a famous actress. Known as the “star studio,” Paramount plugged its movies according to which of its major celebrities was the headliner. Botsford's reference to Ann Sothern and Lucille Ball presupposes that a movie called The Hard-Boiled Canary would only generate appeal if its leading lady were already known for playing hardened roles.
In addition to the turmoil over the title, Paramount Pictures itself was undergoing structural changes that might have affected the way the studio sought to handle the film. By the summer of 1940, the film industry's finances had been negatively affected by World War II. Germany and Italy cut ties to American “propaganda” by banning Hollywood films, seeking instead to focus on the production of their own motion pictures. In addition, the German occupation of France, Belgium, Holland, and Norway as well as the threat of an “imminent attack” on Great Britain—Paramount's largest source of financial revenue from abroad—curtailed much of the U.S. film industry's foreign sales.Footnote 60 According to a Wall Street Journal article from June 1940, Paramount had lost 22 percent of its foreign revenue.Footnote 61 To recover profits, studio president Barney Balaban announced that Paramount would therefore abandon “B pictures in an effort to bolster its domestic revenues to replace foreign revenue lost due to the European war.”Footnote 62 The president's goal was to entice “some of the 50% of the American population which never goes to the movies at all” by making “consistently better” movies than “the budget for B pictures usually allows.” Observing that Paramount's “difficulty in recent years has been in its studios and it has comparatively few notable film successes,” the Journal proposed that the studio's decision to operate on fewer film rentals (i.e., it would have fewer foreign losses than its competitors) would “quickly reflect any real improvement in the quality of its film productions.”Footnote 63 As an eighty-minute picture with a projected budget of $534,000 and a final production cost of $496,811.02—numbers on the top end of budgets for “B” pictures—There's Magic may have been a transitional film that denoted Balaban's anticipated era of “quality” films, in which case a superior title would prove vital for publicity purposes.Footnote 64
While the search for a compelling title continued, Paramount retained There's Magic in Music for three previews in September and October 1940 to great success. Members of the audience even expressed their admiration for the title, which, to them, perfectly captured the movie's message and content. As three individuals exclaimed: “There's Magic Music in ‘There's Magic in Music’”; “Marvelous! Simply Marvelous . . . There couldn't be a better title for this Great Picture”; and “Truly a great show. The name is grand and fits to a ‘T.’”Footnote 65 Meanwhile, the studio's home office production manager commented on Paramount's indecision over the current title when forwarding the preview comments to the film's director: “The title baffles me. I hope to God it is settled one way or another before any further time passes. I have a distinct theory that the title of a picture should be selected before it goes into production and come hell or high water, it ought to be stuck to. No doubt you will disagree with me, but our record in changing titles at the last minute has been extremely bad.”Footnote 66 Despite this grim track record with the title switches, Paramount continued to waver over the final selection for the next few months while maintaining a publicity campaign centered on the film's connections to Interlochen, its rich cast of musical prodigies, and presentation of “good music.” The studio, for reasons unknown, changed the title There's Magic in Music to Magic in Music in mid-October before finally settling on The Hard-Boiled Canary on November 23, 1940.
Reception: The Hard-Boiled Canary Lays an Egg
Under the title There's Magic in Music, the film received overwhelmingly high praise at its three previews, held respectively in Poughkeepsie, NY, Inglewood, CA, and Huntington Park, CA.Footnote 67 After the first showing in New York, the home office production manager informed the movie's director:
Let me tell you that I think your picture is swell. It is a grand piece of entertainment, and I have never attended a preview where the audience seemed any more appreciative than they did at the preview of your picture at Poughkeepsie. I don't believe there were more than two or three bad preview cards out of the entire lot—a percentage which I have never before seen equaled.Footnote 68
As one previewer from Poughkeepsie announced: “This is one picture to which all the Hollywood superlatives may be truthfully applied. For sheer beauty, for good entertainment, and for exquisite music it is tops.”Footnote 69 A few viewers even claimed that they wanted to see the movie a second time when it officially premiered in theaters, one of whom enthusiastically professed that he or she could watch the movie at least ten times.Footnote 70
The preview audiences singled out the music as the highlight of the motion picture. Even those amongst the minor contingent of viewers who openly admitted their aversion to either “good music” or musical films stated, for example: “Would not have gone under ordinary advance. However, really liked it. Music tonal qualities excellent;” and “I don't usually care for that type of picture, but this one was enjoyable.”Footnote 71 There's Magic’s comic elements proved to be its secondary draw, potentially making the musical numbers more accessible for some moviegoers. As one individual stated: “For one who dislikes the classics, such as I, the picture was very good because of the comedy.”Footnote 72 Only one viewer from Inglewood specifically differentiated between classed perceptions of musical taste, commenting that the movie was “too high class for the low class.”Footnote 73
There's Magic’s comment cards also reveal a consensus regarding the target audience for the movie. The previewers—who appear to have been fairly diverse in age, gender, and class—believed that the movie would go over especially well with two primary groups: music lovers and adolescents.Footnote 74 One moviegoer specified: “I thought the picture was very good as it is. The singing and music was [sic] excellent. The picture should appeal to music lovers.”Footnote 75 Another requested: “As one interested in good music I am very well pleased. More pictures like this for me. More—More—More.”Footnote 76 There's Magic likewise appealed to younger viewers, particularly because of its large cast of teenagers and its “clean” film content. One youthful attendee praised Paramount for offering a movie that differed from other contemporary releases: “I believe that this type of picture has a very bright future. At present many of the ‘movies’ are of the slapstick type or inspired from a literary masterpiece. I do hope that in behalf [sic] of many of my friends that this show and all its juvenile very talented characters will continue.”Footnote 77 Adults, too, agreed that There's Magic held value for adolescents. One claimed that: “This is an excellent picture, especially for children in their teens. It makes them realize how important music can be and anyone interested in music would never miss the opportunity of seeing such a picture.”Footnote 78 Even those who objected to the “mediocre” storyline professed appreciation for some element of the movie, whether it was the music, the talented cast, or the comedy.
Audiences reacted quite differently to its release as The Hard-Boiled Canary, however. The new title, aimed at attracting a broader audience, changed the film's promotional angle and cultural framing, shaping audience expectations accordingly. Various musical organizations that had promised to help promote the picture threatened to withdraw their support in protest against the new title, which, as the New York Times explained, was found to be “objectionable for a film dealing with the Interlochen music camp for children in Michigan.”Footnote 79 In a similar vein, a Mr. K. G. Campbell from Vancouver wrote to Botsford in January 1941 to express his own and others’ “horror” at the title switch, which seemed to devalue the film's merits.Footnote 80 In his reply, the producer explained that the studio chose the new title purely for business reasons:
We went over hundreds and hundreds of titles and they seemed static or too pretentious and with no particular mass appeal. Nowadays you have to get to the groundlings in order to get any business at all. Therefore, the Sales Department demanded that we change the title and they picked the title to which you and I both object. I am sorry this has to be so, but there seems to be no help for it.Footnote 81
The sales department's quest for titles with “oomph” as well as its perceptions of the masses’ taste seemingly guided this decision. Circulating ideas of “highbrow” music's limited appeal—clearly formed, in part, by Hollywood's own publicists—complicated a marketing strategy for a film focused on an uplifting message and featuring numerous sequences of classical performances, even though There's Magic received highly positive feedback from its preview audiences. The sales department's insistence on changing the title of the movie also seems puzzling, given that similar musical films ranked among some of the most popular movies of the previous seven years and that the music appreciation movement was in full swing at the time.
It is also possible, however, that the sales department favored promoting a more realistic, perhaps even borderline sensationalist, narrative to draw the masses. As Hitler gained more control over Europe, Hollywood progressively began making films that dealt with, in some way or another, World War II. Although some movies such as Confessions of a Nazi Spy (1939) operated as blatant calls for the United States to enter the war, many more films offered subtler propaganda, promoting what cultural historian David Welky refers to as “Americanism.”Footnote 82 These types of films plugged such “American” ideals as democracy, free enterprise, individualism, and a common national identity.Footnote 83 There's Magic in Music/The Hard-Boiled Canary might be considered one such film because it promoted the United States’ celebration of democracy, individuality, and equal opportunity for all classes. It also promoted a sense of national pride. In one scene, for example, the camera follows the Interlochen students marching into camp to John Philip Sousa's “Stars and Stripes Forever” before zooming out to include the American flag in the shot.
In fact, a few individuals from the previews interpreted this scene specifically in the context of the war, although in two particular ways. On the one hand, some viewers were upset by the marching scene, which they perceived as flagrant propaganda. One moviegoer remarked: “Patriotic march of Jones and kids ending in shot of flag was very, very crudely done and very jingoistic.”Footnote 84 Another argued: “I thought that the close up of the Flag was unnecessary and a little on the ‘cheap’ side. The American public will become tied up with such obvious attempts both in pictures and on the radio. A more distant shot of the cabin and flag would have seemed in better taste.”Footnote 85 A second group, however, interpreted the marching scene as fostering “Americanism” in more nationalist terms. One person stated, for example: “Thank God, that in this country the camps are devoted to a venture of this sort, rather than one of a military nature.”Footnote 86 Another praised the filmmakers’ patriotic flair: “A wonderful picture for everyone to see. The ‘Stars and Stripes Forever’ is an inspiring scene.” Still, a third moviegoer saw the entire film as less politically engaged than its contemporary releases: “An excellent picture. We should have more of this type and less propaganda.”Footnote 87
By switching the title, however, Paramount's sales department obfuscated what Rick Altman refers to as the “pragmatic dimension” of genre, or the ways in which moviegoers engage with, respond to, and understand genre.Footnote 88 Certainly according to box office statistics—presumably affected, in part, by certain “class” audience members boycotting the film—the “groundlings” whom the advertisers had targeted specifically with the new title did not see The Hard-Boiled Canary as delivering on its promises of thrills and grit, being presented instead with a movie about talented musical children and the uplifting power of “good music.” Variety reported that the film “did very poor” [sic] in Denver during its first week and brought in only $2,500 during its second week; Kansas City canceled the film's engagement at one of its theaters after only six days, while ticket sales for San Francisco remained “sub-par” at $10,000.Footnote 89 In comparison, the new Deanna Durbin picture Nice Girl? (1941) accrued at least double the numbers of Canary.
In addition to the disappointing figures at the box office, the critics’ responses were mixed. The Hollywood Reporter praised the talents of Susanna Foster, claiming that the young lead was a proficient actress “on her way to becoming a star of real magnitude.”Footnote 90 Other trade journals reported on the film's extensive use of art music. Both Variety and Motion Picture Herald provided lists of Canary’s “wide range” of musical numbers, from its classical excerpts to the newly composed pieces by Ann Ronell.Footnote 91 Although some critics were impressed by Foster's vocal ability and the quality of the musical sequences, many journalists found fault with the movie's narrative. One such response appeared in the February 26, 1941 issue of Variety: “Addicts of the better type of music in the classical range will give this one a moderate play, but will have to sit through the tedious, mediocre story.”Footnote 92
Twelve days after the movie's release on March 7, Variety informed its readers that Paramount was withdrawing the film. According to the trade paper, the film's title contributed to the movie's poor performance at the box office:
It was originally called There's Magic In Music, [the] whole idea having been based on a kids’ music camp in Michigan. At first projected along serious lines, it was subsequently “hardened” a bit and the title of The Hard-Boiled Canary tacked on. Music societies and organizations protested, Paramount deciding a few days ago that it would be advisable to turn back to the original title and tie in with national music week in May. However, no changes will be made in the film except the title.Footnote 93
Joseph Maddy further suggested that Paramount changed the title back because the film's male lead, Allan Jones, had protested the studio giving Susanna Foster lead billing over himself.Footnote 94 Still, re-releasing the movie as There's Magic in Music did not improve the film's standing at the box office, despite a few favorable reviews that asserted, as Richard L. Coe did for the Washington Post, that “there's something in There's Magic in Music to please everyone, if not all of the time, some of the time.”Footnote 95 The trade journals and film magazines seldom mentioned the movie after March, and the few reports of the weekly box office numbers remained similar to the motion picture's original release. Evidently, the sales department's desire to make the film edgier for greater appeal backfired, alienating the originally targeted public to whom the studio had been advertising over the course of the previous year.
Promotional Campaign
According to the promotional materials for There's Magic in Music, Paramount had marketed their product to a particular demographic from the beginning of production. As early as February 6, 1940, the studio had closely connected their film with the Interlochen Music Camp and its director, Joseph Maddy, as well as the cast's impressive list of adolescent musical prodigies.Footnote 96 The studio's initial press release from March 1940 stated that Paramount was conducting a national campaign to “make America conscious of Interlochen.”Footnote 97 Their film, then advertised under the title Interlochen, was going to “get off to a sensational start” by bringing “hundreds of delegates” from the Music Educators’ National Conference to the studio to observe a “demonstration of music recording on a sound stage” with the film's two singing stars, Allan Jones and Susanna Foster. In Paramount's generous estimation, fifteen thousand visitors would travel to Los Angeles for the convention, many of whom, the studio alleged, had studied at Interlochen. The press release suggests that Paramount marketed There's Magic to the oft-used studio categorization of “music lovers” from the beginning of production, a group of individuals that might readily buy into the film's uplifting narrative. Indeed, contemporary articles printed in the Music Educator's Journal demonstrate that many teachers were excited about the prospect of Paramount's “Day in Hollywood” event as well as the potential press coverage for music camps similar to Interlochen. One such article proclaimed: “The importance of the promised feature film, from the standpoint of all music educators, is obvious. It will also serve to draw attention to the importance of an institution which probably more than a few in our field have been prone to take too much for granted.”Footnote 98
Paramount also sought to increase their film's prestige by establishing a publicity connection with the Metropolitan Opera in New York.Footnote 99 As Richard Halliday, the head of Paramount's story department, wrote to director Andrew Stone, a tie-in with the Met would be advantageous because the institution reached millions around the country via the radio and press: “At this time the Met is receiving important radio time every Saturday for three and four hours and every Sunday for its half-hour audition period, besides a good deal of free newspaper attention and national mail lists.”Footnote 100 Aware that the Met was currently attempting to raise a million dollars, Paramount proposed donating $25,000 in return for a few of the “big names” to provide their services for the grand finale of There's Magic, an operatic mash-up of Carmen and Faust.Footnote 101 Among the celebrities on the studio's list were conductors Leopold Stokowski and Walter Damrosch (neither one associated with the Met) as well as soprano Rosa Ponselle and baritone Lawrence Tibbett.Footnote 102 The Metropolitan agreed that Paramount could use the institution's name in exchange for the donation, but stated that it “would be impossible for the Met” to ask their contracted singers “to work gratis.”Footnote 103 The proposal apparently fell through.Footnote 104 In the end, Met singers Richard Bonelli and Irra Petina as well as music critic Deems Taylor appeared in the film.
Besides the publicity connections with these societies and musical institutions, Paramount's press book for the film's re-release as There's Magic in Music indicates that the studio remained consistent in its promotional campaign from the start of production, hoping to capitalize on the music appreciation angle throughout the film's production period.Footnote 105 The studio announced that the heads of three national music organizations—The National Music Council, the National Bureau for the Advancement of Music, and the National Music Camp (Interlochen)—all endorsed the film. Parents’ Magazine, too, awarded the film a medal for “Picture of the Month for Family Audiences” in their May 1941 issue.Footnote 106 As with similar musical films, the press book's suggestions for film distribution included targeting specific audience demographics. In particular, the publicists recommended advertising to music schools and teachers; music and radio stores; record shops; dancing schools; and, oddly enough, night clubs.
At the same time, the press book reveals that the publicity department maintained a bias against promoting art music without appealing to the supposed predilections of the masses: popular music and love stories. For example, one of the press book's prepared articles—which were written by studio publicists for mass distribution in various print media—was titled “Famous Opera Stars Seen in Film Musical.”Footnote 107 However, the article itself focused on the ways in which There's Magic combined swing music with operatic classics in a popular style. Another prepared column similarly claimed: “Very cleverly, several popular operatic arias were given a popularization treatment, so that, although the music itself remains familiar, nevertheless, as performed, it sounds a good deal like modern swing. This is exactly in the spirit of the highly amusing story, which bounces along with verve and sparkle.”Footnote 108 In actuality, There's Magic did not blend “good music” with swing; only Ann Ronell's “Fireflies on Parade,” which featured a small dance orchestra and choir of voices, could be loosely considered as such. Humorously enough, the revamped press book recommended that theater owners promote the movie by way of the message underpinning the title, There's Magic in Music: “The Title opens the way for you to a number of unusual co-operations which can do a great job of getting the title over to your public.”Footnote 109 Unfortunately for Paramount, no amount of magic could salvage the film's standing at the box office after it had been disguised as a Hard-Boiled Canary. According to various trade journals, it garnered little profit and soon disappeared from movie theaters after its re-release.
Musical Films at the Crossroads
Although the multiple title changes surrounding There's Magic in Music/The Hard-Boiled Canary might have been unique to this particular film, the challenges associated with naming movies appropriately were the subject of a broader industry discourse. A. M. Botsford's interview with the Washington Post in 1939, for example, neatly encapsulated the importance of naming a film correctly:
A lot of people claim that a title means very little. They point out that there was a picture with a terrible name called Mr. Deeds Goes to Town. That title means absolutely nothing, yet the picture was a whale of a success. On the other side of the fence is an excellent picture we made a while back called Café Society. It was a good show. Everybody that went enjoyed it. Only not enough people saw it. Some of our executives are afraid they stayed away because they weren't interested in Café Society. That's probably true, though at the time we selected that title, we believed it to be a real inspiration. It just goes to show that we're always wracking our brains for names and if the picture is a fizzle we get blamed, while if it's a success everybody says the title doesn't matter.Footnote 110
Paramount's debate over what to call There's Magic in Music/The Hard-Boiled Canary highlights competing ideas held by studio personnel about how best to promote a film featuring a narrative about the uplifting power of classical music during a transitional period in Hollywood filmmaking. The film industry took its cue from widely circulating, and often contradictory, ideas about “good music's” cultural cachet, disseminated, in part, by proponents of the music appreciation movement, which included music educators, conductors, women's clubs, and arts organizations. Even as the classics were being heralded as accessible to all U.S. citizens, the discursive gap between musical forms coded as highbrow or as lowbrow began to widen (e.g., “sophisticated” and “complex” music versus “simple” and “entertaining” music).
This tension affected the production of musical films in two ways. First, studios sought to cash in on the popularity of “good music,” producing movies that showcased highlights of the Western art music canon. In presenting orchestral or opera excerpts within a cinematic setting—both in terms of narrative framing and venue—Hollywood effectively turned “elite” art into something deemed more accessible and entertaining, and, in turn, reframed the cinematic experience as one that could be culturally uplifting. Second, marketing and sales departments were influenced by classed perceptions of musical preference when promoting the studio's products, which could affect a film's outcome at the box office. In their eyes, the American masses went to the movie theater to be entertained at a price that did not break the bank, whereas patrons of such venues as the Metropolitan Opera went to witness great art—at a much greater cost. The film industry therefore attempted, not always successfully, to reconcile these divergent activities when promoting products that brought together “highbrow” and “lowbrow” cultures.
Furthermore, the film industry's infrastructure began to shift in response to World War II, affecting how the studios were run. For its part, Paramount focused on making quality pictures with higher budgets to entice more people to the movie theater, increasing domestic profits to offset lost European revenue. Only a few months after There's Magic’s release, too, a government ruling on the issue of “block booking” upset the major studios’—RKO, Loew's (MGM), Twentieth-Century Fox, Warner Bros., and Paramount—control over exhibition and distribution. As the Chicago Daily Tribune explained in 1940, “block booking” refers to a practice enforced by the larger studios that required independent theater owners to purchase the rights to show “all of the major pictures of a given studio” on a blind basis and “a year in advance”.Footnote 111 In September 1941, the Department of Justice decreed that the studios could only sell blocks of no more than five films and that they had to offer a trade showing of the films before being sold to exhibitors.Footnote 112
Moreover, the uncertainty of the United States’ involvement in World War II ushered Hollywood into a new era of filmmaking during a time of global crisis. The film industry, or at least a part of it, joined the so-called “phony war” with such films as Confessions of a Nazi Spy (1939), The Man I Married (1940), and Foreign Correspondent (1940). Indeed, the 1940s would see the rise of the propaganda film, comedy duos such as Bud Abbott and Lou Costello, film noir, and the show-stopping musical extravaganzas of the Canteen pictures. Even the typically lighthearted musical film responded to the war, favoring realism and drama over fantasy.
Understood within this context, There's Magic in Music marks the transition between musicals featuring “good music” that were produced during the Great Depression and those made during World War II. This transition can be seen most clearly by a shift in who was cast in the leading roles. By the end of the 1930s, the Metropolitan Opera singers who had ventured west from New York in pursuit of Hollywood fame returned to their careers on the stage, and a new generation of operatic actresses took their place.Footnote 113 Responding to the age and experience of these adolescent singers—including Deanna Durbin, Susanna Foster, and Gloria Jean—filmmakers devised new characters for their young protagonists as well as a variety of novel scenarios in which their stars might logically be expected to perform. In other words, fresh personalities helped shape film formulas. Whereas their predecessors from the Met had starred in musical films based on opera singer narratives with fully staged opera sequences, this trio of teen actresses played ingénues who performed either at home, school, camp, or in other community settings. Especially during wartime, these young women represented the ideal image of the girl-next-door.
Paramount's indecision over a film title further speaks to broader industry and national concerns during a period of uncertainty and change. What was the future of the musical film? And what role, if any, would “good music” serve in wartime musicals? As one of the new hybrid musicals, There's Magic in Music built on preexisting ideas while also hinting at changes to come. In one scene, for example, Finnish refugee Heimo Haitto explains to Toodles that he came to Interlochen for the opportunities he could not access in his homeland.Footnote 114 Indeed, the United States would curate its image as a cultural refuge wherein “good music” could flourish, untouched as it was by bombing raids or military occupation.Footnote 115 Situating There's Magic in Music within a transitional period of Hollywood filmmaking, at the crossroads of the Great Depression and World War II, therefore allows us to investigate how classed perceptions of musical taste informed the film industry's presentation and marketing of art music in the tumultuous prewar years. Although Depression-era notions of what constituted so-called high or low forms of musical preference guided Paramount's marketing strategies, There's Magic in Music’s narrative pointed to the more universalist, and simultaneously democratic, understanding of “good music” that would underpin the musical films of World War II.
