
Rewind more than 20 years to Professor Paul Mullen’s authoritative paper on lone mass killers of random victims in Behavioral Sciences and the Law: ‘The autogenic (self-generated) massacre’.Reference Mullen1 He described motivation for the killings as ‘autogenic’: essentially self-generated from within the killer’s mind and rarely ‘connected to wider social and group processes’. But in the last 20 years new ‘processes’ have emerged, namely instant access to a worldwide audience of the fellow-minded and easy availability of lethal weapons.
In this book, aimed at a general readership, Mullen takes us through the development of lone-actor killings, from 16th-century acts of ‘amok’ in the Far East to their much later emergence in the west from the early 20th century. Killers are not named but some victims are identified to remind us of the tragic loss of countless innocent lives. The emphasis throughout is not on shock and horror description but on the varied mindsets and multiple factors that lie behind each of these individual acts. The source material is partly the appropriately anonymised accounts of surviving lone killers examined by the author, but more extensively from publicly available documents and inquiry reports that have followed massacres, including, for example, those at Monash University, Utøya, Dunblane and Virginia Tech. To this material Mullen applies a cogent and balanced analysis of individual psychopathology, in effect discussing differential diagnoses.
Mullen claims that ‘there are solutions to reducing lone actor massacres’. He suggests three approaches. First, in the conduct of criminal trials he urges courts not to provide an opportunity for ‘surviving killers to strut and pontificate before a global audience’. Second, while psychiatrists must accept the link between psychotic disorders and increased violence in general, he emphasises that the great majority of lone mass killers do not have a diagnosable mental disorder. Thus, he calls for an increased focus on specific ‘sets of personality traits and states of mind’. For example, he lists pursuit of grievance, social withdrawal, grandiose pretensions, fantasies of a dramatic suicidal death, a fascination with weaponry and with previous lone mass killers.
These features should ring alarm bells but, third, he laments the lack of any agency that can assimilate information from a variety of sources and take effective action. This lack of a coordinated response was tragically exposed in the killings of Bebe King (aged 6), Elsie Dot Stancombe (7) and Alice da Silva Aguiar (9) at a Southport dancing class in 2024. The 17-year-old killer was known to a plethora of police, health and welfare agencies, including Prevent. But if warning signs are present and there is no crime committed and no diagnosable mental disorder, what then? Readers may or may not share Mullen’s cautious optimism that those identified as a potential threat would engage voluntarily in some form of beneficial talking therapy.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.