In The Rise of Gridiron University, Brian M. Ingrassia attacks an obvious yet often ignored mystery unique to American higher education. Why did American colleges and universities, seats of higher learning and culture, come to intimately sponsor the pop-culture spectacle of big-time college football? Scholars have explored the rise of the American university and the growth of college football separately, but few have endeavored to attack this intriguing paradox directly. In focusing on football, Ingrassia believes the answer to this baffling incongruity comes through understanding the growth of the modern university and football as part of the same process. Football was present at the creation of the modern university, as he adeptly points out, so the book attempts to place “intellectual history and sports history side by side” (5). The embrace of football by leading universities as a “cultural cornerstone of the ivory tower,” argues Ingrassia, “allowed America's institutions of higher education to maintain public visibility at the same time they invented an esoteric modern intellectual culture not easily consumed by the American public” (13). Academics championed and then reformed football not just because it seemed suited to training young men on campus to cope with the strains of modern life, but also owing to football's ability to make the academy “culturally legible” at the very moment that modern scholarly disciplines grew more narrowly focused and, he argues, detached from public engagement.
In the first two chapters, Ingrassia sets the stage by laying out the concurrent growth histories of American higher education and sports in the nineteenth century, and Progressive Era fights over football's increasing brutality and resultant reform efforts. The next two chapters form the intellectual heart of the book, as Ingrassia explores the academics who ardently championed football at the same time they spearheaded the formation of their modern disciplines. He performs highly original research in tracing the academic pedigrees and careers of several psychologists and social scientists. The webs of intellectual connections proved illuminating. The psychologists promoted football in academic journals and popular magazines, praising the sport's ability to cultivate “nerves” and release energy, both increasingly vital phenomena in the competitive stresses of the modern world. Social scientists (economists, sociologists, and some historians) added that football could also develop social ethics, and academics of both groups touted the possible salutary effects of simply watching football, inspiring spectators to grasp the competitive and yet cooperative lessons, as well as forming an outlet for their own savage energies. Nevertheless, they all conceded that to fill its proper role, football (pre-1910) demanded reform and guidance, firmly under university if not faculty control. I appreciated Ingrassia's careful survey of these academic fields rather than simply using a quote from this or that academic. He succeeds in connecting the discourse on football's social utility to these budding disciplines, all shaped by the social Darwinistic assumptions then swirling through the culture.
In perhaps his two most innovative chapters, Ingrassia examines the professionalization of football coaches and the meanings behind the penchant for stadium building, particularly during the 1920s. Ingrassia is one of the first to broadly examine how coaches and athletic directors crafted novel split identities, as both quasi academics and purveyors of popular spectacle. Borrowing from the arguments first created by football's academic champions, they cast themselves as teachers of young men (cultivating discipline, courage, etc.), through lessons broadly applicable to other students and the general public alike. The new genre of coach-authored and highly popular “how to” books on football form Ingrassia's central source base. Ingrassia then delves into the building of massive new stadiums at Yale, Berkeley, Ohio State, and Illinois, the latter three serving as prime examples of how college football fused with the spirit of martial patriotism coming out of World War I. Of course these memorial stadiums were also geared to sell seats and raise revenue and publicity, highlighting the Faustian bargain academics had made (and lost). They failed to control the meanings attached to the sport when they sanctioned sponsorship of what essentially remained a pop-culture spectacle. Ingrassia brings his analysis full-circle in an insightful final chapter on the largely impotent academic backlash to the sport.
In his endeavor to chart the academic, intellectual history of football within higher education, Ingrassia supplies a unique, valuable, and enjoyable study. Nevertheless one central theme of his argument proves stubbornly problematic. “Big-time athletics represented universities’ flawed attempts to maintain a connection to the public in an era of intellectual fragmentation and isolation,” writes Ingrassia, enabling institutions “to appear culturally relevant to non-academic constituencies at the same time academic life became sealed off within departments and disciplines” (10, 13). The author expends a great deal of effort in his chapters on academics, describing his subjects’ part both in promoting football and their seemingly unrelated parallel efforts in creating distinct academic disciplines, housed in separate departments and connected more to other professionals than to their surrounding university. Is what he presents accurate? Yes, academics did erect an ivory tower during this period. Was big-time athletics a way that universities stayed connected to a non-academic public? Absolutely, and publicity-conscious captains of erudition back in the day knew that. What Ingrassia continually asserts, though, is that academics promoting football felt some pangs of public marginalization due to their increasingly esoteric professional pursuits and saw football as a remedy. I do not think it accurate that Progressive Era academics felt themselves marginalized. The period is defined by academics’ new active engagement with the public at practically every level. Ingrassia never presents direct evidence of any supposed disconnect as a factor in promoting football. Rather it seems far more plausible to see the championing of football as a logical extension of Progressive Era academics’ own vision of themselves as engaged in guiding America, rather than some attempt to assuage supposed feelings of disconnection. Pointing out the fascinating juxtaposition of maturing and narrowing disciplines certainly deserved attention, but to assert it as a trigger for the embrace of football seems a causal blind alley.
Despite this difference of interpretation, Ingrassia has produced a superbly researched and valuable piece of scholarship unprecedented in its tight weaving of the history of higher education and college football.
