Mikael D. Wolfe masterfully rewrites the history of Mexico's arid north-central Laguna region from the early twentieth century through radical land reform and the Nazas River dam construction in the 1930s–40s and the dam's rehabilitation in the 1960s–70s. He interlaces an account of one of the most famous post-revolutionary agrarian reform projects from the perspective of water management (hence the title Watering the Revolution); an environmental history of the contentious modernisation of the Laguna's ecologically sound (but socially unequal) system of flood irrigation; and a technological study of changing ‘envirotech paradigms’ – how técnicos (federal engineers) and government officials understood the environment, specifically hydrological processes, in different time periods. Wolfe thus makes important contributions to the large, rapidly growing field of Latin American environmental studies and the historiography of technology in Latin America. Drawing on extensive archival research in Mexico and the United States, the author distils the essence of (and makes comprehensible) engineering techniques, measurements and reports. The book's underlying research question is why técnicos and government officials insisted on employing invasive and damaging technologies that were already proven to be ecologically unsustainable. The tragic result of the region's infrastructure modernisation was not only the depletion of aquifers and a rise in the arsenic content of the subterranean water supply (‘a geologically poisonous brew’, p. 216), but also the exacerbation of existing rural social inequalities.
The early chapters offer a historical ecology of the Laguna region and its largest river, the Nazas, from the colonial period to the development of irrigated cotton farming on large estates during the nineteenth century. Wolfe explains the development of the technically sophisticated aniego method of irrigation (flood irrigation), the water politics along the Nazas River during the Porfiriato (1876–1911), and how government engineers (as mediators between state, society and the environment) carefully adapted federal laws to the river's flow cycle. It is of historical interest that it was future revolutionary Francisco I. Madero who, a few years before the outbreak of 1910 Revolution, unsuccessfully attempted to organise fellow cotton growers to lobby the government to build a high dam on the Nazas River. In the 1920s and 1930s it was mobilised hacienda workers who adopted the idea that water in this arid region would be better managed with the construction of a high dam. During this period of massive unionisation of the agricultural labour force on cotton-producing estates, workers organised mostly for better working conditions but also for land and water. Thus, unlike other environmental histories that adopt a top-down perspective on massive infrastructure modernisation projects, Wolfe shows that hacienda workers in the Laguna region favoured the construction of a high river dam because they believed it would boost employment and lead to better working conditions and wages.
The middle chapters detail the history of two revolutionary social and environmental experiments in the Laguna region in the 1930s and 1940s. The first was President Lázaro Cárdenas's expropriation of 266 medium-sized and large estates and their replacement by collective ejidos and small landholdings. In what became ‘one of the most ambitious and far-reaching social experiments of its kind in Latin America, if not the world’ (p. 95), 38,000 land beneficiaries received 67 per cent (or 146,000 hectares) of the region's irrigable land. The second revolutionary experiment was the ten-year-long construction of a mega-engineering project at the El Palmito site (later renamed the Lázaro Cárdenas Dam) 120 miles west of Torreón that, at its completion in 1946, was the largest earthen embankment dam in the world. Wolfe provides a detailed account of life and work in the socially stratified company towns, where 13,000 workers and their dependants (of whom 40 per cent were regional ejidatarios and small landowners) spent a decade working on the dam's construction.
The problem with these two revolutionary experiments was that the water regulations that sought to promote greater social equality in the region did not correspond to the natural hydrological cycle of the Nazas. The dam was an environmental disaster because it obstructed the river's natural fertilising function through flood irrigation. At the same time, starting in the 1940s, Laguna farmers were hit by a decades-long crippling drought that increased the use of motorised water pumps by both private farmers and those ejidatarios who could afford them. Even when they knew the pumps were depleting aquifers, self-interested government officials profited from their sale, as they did from the drought relief programmes. Moreover, the 1950s government-sponsored modernisation projects (including lining earthen canals with concrete) to satisfy the burgeoning water-intensive dairy industry caused further ecological damage.
The last chapter shows how the 1960s and 1970s rehabilitation plan for the Laguna region was a short-term success. It consisted of another major social and environmental engineering project in which government officials transferred ejidatarios from their original collective ejidos to ‘compacted’ and radically reduced irrigated lands. In one fascinating sketch from the time, we see how, to raise water-use efficiency, engineers reduced 17 Tlahualilo collective ejidos covering 22,000 hectares to a compacted area of 5,700 hectares. This relocation scheme was temporarily successful in raising agricultural production and incomes on ejidos, but based as it was on ecologically unsustainable technology – including building a second dam and lining the canals with concrete – it ultimately depleted the aquifers. The collective ejido deteriorated not only because of diminishing water supplies, but also because of reduced credit, demographic growth, poor governance, and state policies favouring the La Laguna agro-industrial group that concentrated scarce groundwater supplies for cattle-raising.
The book ends with a short evaluation of Mexico's current water crisis, showing that government debates in the 2000s were not unlike those in the 1920s and 1930s in terms of their disregard for environmental sustainability. The result of this long history of environmental mismanagement has been greater frequency and duration of severe droughts in the region. This impressive work of scholarship is, therefore, also a most timely example of how exactly anthropogenic climate change occurs.
