Aduersus Iudaeos has been largely neglected in studies of Tertullian as well as in studies of Jewish-Christian relations in the Roman Empire. Geoffrey Dunn proposes to remedy this oversight by offering the first extensive study of the text in English. Adu. Iud. has been overlooked largely due to contention over its authorship. Numerous scholars have argued that the second half of Adu. Iud. is by another writer who re-used material from Tertullian's Aduersus Marcion. D. cites other scholars who view the entire work as Tertullian's and positions himself in their camp. An extensive rhetorical analysis of the work, he argues, will settle the matter once and for all. Furthermore, a detailed discussion of the text will reveal further information about the social context of Tertullian's arguments against the Jews and how these arguments are structured according to the conventions of classical rhetoric.
One of the starting points for D.'s book is Robert Sider's omission of Adu. Iud. in his Ancient Rhetoric and the Art of Tertullian (1971). D. repeatedly (and justifiably) refers to Sider in order to show how Tertullian used the structures of classical rhetoric in his other works. These frequent references, though, raise the question of why Adu. Iud. should deserve a significantly longer treatment (210 pages) than Sider's examination of twenty-nine works by Tertullian (142 pages).
The book is organized into five chapters. The first chapter focuses on the problem of discerning the authenticity of the text and the extent to which it reflects Jewish-Christian interaction in second-century Carthage. D. draws on an impressive range of scholarship on Tertullian as well as Jewish-Christian relations in antiquity. Here, he makes some of his most significant observations about Adu. Iud.: it should be considered a pamphlet rather than a treatise because the latter term would imply a more systematic approach. In response to scholarship proposing particular audiences (Christians, Jews and/or pagans) and functions (to attack or convert the Jews, convince the pagans, or promote Christian self-definition) of this text, D. makes the sound assertion that there can be multiple audiences and multiple purposes. Ch. 2 examines the readership of the pamphlet. Although intended primarily for Christian readers, it provided Christians with arguments to use in response to Jewish criticism. D. argues that there is no reason to suppose this was a fictional situation. Although a fictional scenario was the norm for Second Sophistic rhetoric, Christian rhetoric addressed real issues. In connection with questions of audience, D. examines how Tertullian used the first person for Christians, while referring to Jews in the third and second person. Here, quotations from the text would have been useful. Ch. 3 dissects the rhetorical structure of the work according to the standard parts of a speech described by Cicero and Quintilian. The fact that Tertullian did not follow these divisions (for instance, there is no narratio) demonstrates that he was an advanced rhetorician. The overall structure is summarized helpfully in a detailed outline (86–7). This chapter demonstrates the unity of the text as a whole, countering the argument that another author wrote the last chapters. Instead, problems of cohesion within the text resulted from a lack of revision. D. begins his fourth chapter, on argumentation, with an introduction to the relevant terms from classical rhetoric. This section is a bit confusing: although meant as an overview for readers unfamiliar with classical rhetoric, it assumes knowledge of Ad Herennium and Hermagoras’ theory of stasis. The rest of this chapter demonstrates how Tertullian used the standard approach to argumentation to build his case that the gentiles, not the Jews, were the proper recipients of God's grace. The final chapter focuses on the style of the pamphlet, offering further confirmation of Tertullian's rhetorical skill.
This book should be of interest to scholars studying Tertullian, the use of ancient rhetoric by Christian writers, and Jewish-Christian interactions. It strengthens the case for Tertullian's authorship of Adu. Iud. Most significantly, D. urges scholars to resist false dichotomies when interpreting rhetorical texts: evidence of one type of audience or social function for a text does not necessarily preclude all others.
