Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T15:59:19.673Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Direct numerical simulation of roughness-induced transition controlled by two-dimensional wall blowing

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 June 2021

Yuhan Lu
Affiliation:
National Key Laboratory of Computational Fluid Dynamics, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Fanzhi Zeng
Affiliation:
National Key Laboratory of Computational Fluid Dynamics, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Hongkang Liu
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory of Traffic Safety on Track, Ministry of Education, School of Traffic and Transportation Engineering, Central South University, Changsha 410075, PR China
Zaijie Liu
Affiliation:
National Key Laboratory of Computational Fluid Dynamics, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Chao Yan*
Affiliation:
National Key Laboratory of Computational Fluid Dynamics, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: yanchao@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

Discrete roughness-induced transition in Mach $2.25$ flow controlled by two-dimensional wall blowing is studied using direct numerical simulation. Spectral analysis and flow freezing operations reveal that the main source of unsteadiness in the case without blowing is the separated shear layer/counter-rotating vortex system: the shear layer is bent by the vortex pair, and this interaction induces disturbance growth at the shear layer. With the existence of weak wall blowing, the transition is delayed. Flow visualization demonstrates that upstream-positioned blowing achieves this by lifting the inflow boundary layer and decreasing the roughness Reynolds number. In contrast, downstream-positioned blowing takes effect by weakening the counter-rotating vortex pair and inhibiting the interaction. Vorticity transportation analysis suggests that this result is accomplished by increasing dissipation for streamwise vorticity and converting some of it into spanwise vorticity. In cases with strong wall blowing, the control effect is reversed, as wall blowing with enough strength can induce unsteadiness and promote transition. In upstream-positioned strong blowing cases, a new unstable mode is observed in spectral results throughout the near-roughness region, and further analysis indicates that this mode originating from the separation zone upstream of the blowing is the key factor for transition. With regard to downstream-positioned strong blowing cases, a very low-frequency mode is generated from the separation bubble between the roughness element and the blowing, but it only provides an initial disturbance for the transition process. The transition that occurs downstream is due to the distortion of the boundary layer in the wake.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Free-stream flow conditions.

Figure 1

Table 2.Shape parameters for smooth-edged roughness element.

Figure 2

Table 3.Details of all cases in this paper.

Figure 3

Figure 1.Computational domain configuration.

Figure 4

Figure 2.Spanwise correlation coefficients at $x-x_r=95\delta _r$ and (a) $y=k_r$ or (b) $y=\delta _r$.

Figure 5

Figure 3.Validation of similarity solution used as the inlet boundary profile: (a) streamwise velocity $u$ and (b) temperature $T$.

Figure 6

Figure 4.Grid point distributions on (a) wall boundary and (b) axial plane (displaying every second grid point in each direction).

Figure 7

Table 4.Grid resolution and sensitivity study.

Figure 8

Figure 5.Grid sensitivity study and result validation: skin friction distributions of (a) case $V_0$, (c) case $X_{-4}V_2$ and (d) case $X_4V_2$, and (b) van Driest velocity profiles at $x-x_r=95\delta _r$ of case $V_0$.

Figure 9

Table 5.Relative friction drag (the result of case $V_0$ is set to $1.00$).

Figure 10

Figure 6.Spanwise-averaged $C_{f,x}$ and $C_{f,L}$ distributions of case $V_0$ and cases with blowing in (a) upstream position and (b) downstream position.

Figure 11

Figure 7.The $C_{f,T}$ distributions of (a) case $V_0$, (b) case $X_{-4}V_2$, (c) case $X_{-4}V_4$, (d) case $X_4V_2$ and (e) case $X_4V_4$. (The dashed line indicates the roughness shape at the height of $k_r/2$.)

Figure 12

Figure 8.Visualization of the flow field, consisting of streamlines passing through the line $(x-x_r=-50\delta _r,\ y=0.1\delta _r)$ (dark grey) or the line $(x-x_r=-50\delta _r,\ y=0.2\delta _r)$ (light grey), streamlines on the symmetry plane and a slice $x-x_r=10\delta _r$ (black), streamwise skin friction coefficient contour on the wall, non-dimensional pressure contour on the symmetry plane and non-dimensional $Q$ criterion contours on slices $x-x_r=7\delta _r$ and $x-x_r=10\delta _r$ (here $p_{ref}=\gamma {Ma}_\infty ^2$ and $Q_{ref}=u_\infty ^2/\delta _r^2$).

Figure 13

Figure 9.PSD results of pressure fluctuations at (a) probes 1–3 and (b) probes 4–5 (here $S_{ref}=p_{ref}^2\delta _r/u_\infty$).

Figure 14

Figure 10.Comparison of non-dimensional velocity fluctuation distributions on the plane $y=k_r$ between (a) case $V_0$ and (b) case $V_0$ with a flow freezing operation. (The dashed line indicates the roughness shape at the height of $k_r/2$.)

Figure 15

Figure 11.SPOD results of (a) the upstream region ($-2.75\delta _r\le {x}-x_r\le -0.85\delta _r$, $y\le 1.25\delta _r$ and $-2.5\delta _r\le {z}\le 2.5\delta _r$) and (b) the whole near-roughness region ($-2.75\delta _r\le {x}-x_r\le 12.75\delta _r$, $y\le 1.25\delta _r$ and $-2.5\delta _r\le {z}\le 2.5\delta _r$) of case $V_0$. (The grey areas are the $99\,\%$ confidence interval.)

Figure 16

Figure 12.DMD results of case $V_0$: (a) eigenvalues from standard DMD and DMDSP with $N_z$ DMD modes; (b) reconstruction of mode 1 extracted by DMD; (c) the distribution of streamwise shear on the symmetry plane ($u_{s,ref}=u_\infty /\delta _r$); and reconstruction of mode 1 at (d) $x-x_r=11.5\delta _r$ and (e) $x-x_r=12.5\delta _r$. (The grey solid lines in panels (d,e) are isolines of $u$ with the same value set, and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)

Figure 17

Figure 13.Slices of case $V_0$ at (a,b) $x-x_r=6\delta _r$, (c,d) $x-x_r=10\delta _r$ and (e, f) $x-x_r=14\delta _r$ coloured with (a,c,e) non-dimensional $Q$ criterion and (b,d, f) streamwise velocity fluctuation. (The dark grey solid lines on the left half of (a,c,e) are isolines of $u_s$ with the same value set; the light grey lines on the right are in-plane vortex lines; and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)

Figure 18

Figure 14.Slices of (a,c,e) case $X_{-4}V_2$ and (b,d, f) case $X_{-4}V_4$ at (a,b) $x-x_r=6\delta _r$, (c, d) $x-x_r=10\delta _r$ and (e, f) $x-x_r=14\delta _r$ coloured with the non-dimensional $Q$ criterion. (The dark grey solid lines on the left half are isolines of $u_s$ with the same value set; the light grey lines on the right are in-plane vortex lines; and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)

Figure 19

Figure 15.Profiles of non-dimensional streamwise velocity on the symmetry plane of (a,c) case $V_0$ and (b,d) case $X_{-4}V_4$. Panels (c,d) are zoomed-in views of the grey dashed rectangular regions in panels (a,b); black solid lines are in-plane streamlines.

Figure 20

Table 6.Effective roughness Reynolds number and inflow boundary layer parameters (here $\delta _r^*$ is the actual boundary layer thickness at the centre point of roughness).

Figure 21

Figure 16.PSD results of (a,c) case $X_{-4}V_2$ and (b,d) case $X_{-4}V_4$ at the (a,b) upstream region and (c,d) downstream region.

Figure 22

Figure 17.Profiles of the non-dimensional streamwise velocity on the symmetry plane of (a) case $X_4V_2$ and (b) case $X_4V_4$. (Black solid lines are in-plane streamlines.)

Figure 23

Figure 18.Comparison of wake structures between (a,c) case $V_0$ and (b,d) case $X_4V_2$: (a,b) slices of the non-dimensional $Q$ criterion at $x-x_r=5\delta _r$ and (c,d) non-dimensional streamwise angular velocity profiles at $z=0.3\delta _r$. (The grey solid lines are in-plane streamlines, and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness, $\omega _{ref}=u_\infty /\delta _r$.)

Figure 24

Figure 19.Slices of (a,c,e) case $X_4V_2$ and (b,d, f) case $X_4V_4$ at (a,b) $x-x_r=6\delta _r$, (c,d) $x-x_r=10\delta _r$ and (e, f) $x-x_r=14\delta _r$ coloured with the non-dimensional $Q$ criterion. (The dark grey solid lines on the left half are isolines of $u_s$ with the same value set; the light grey lines on the right are in-plane vortex lines; and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)

Figure 25

Figure 20.Profiles of (a,c,e) case $V_0$ and (b,d, f) case $X_4V_4$ at $z=0.5\delta _r$ coloured with (a,b) the non-dimensional streamwise angular velocity, (c,d) vorticity transportation term $S_{xx}$ and (e, f) $D_x$.

Figure 26

Figure 21.Profiles of (a) case $V_0$ and (b) case $X_4V_4$ at $z=0.5\delta _r$ coloured with the non-dimensional vorticity transportation term $S_{zx}$.

Figure 27

Figure 22.PSD results of (a,c) case $X_4V_2$ and (b,d) case $X_4V_4$ at the (a,b) upstream region and (c,d) downstream region.

Figure 28

Table 7.Relative friction drag (the result of case $V_0$ is set to $1.00$).

Figure 29

Figure 23.The $C_{f,T}$ distributions of (a) case $X_{-4}V_{18}$, (b) case $X_{-4}V_{20}$, (c) case $X_4V_{23}$ and (d) case $X_4V_{25}$. (The dashed line indicates the roughness shape at the height of $k_r/2$.)

Figure 30

Figure 24.Slices of (a,c) case $X_{-4}V_{18}$ or (b,d) case $X_{-4}V_{20}$ at $x-x_r=6\delta _r$ coloured with (a,b) the non-dimensional $Q$ criterion and (c,d) the streamwise velocity fluctuation. (The dark grey solid lines on the left half of (a,b) are isolines of $u_s$ with the same value set; the light grey lines on the right are in-plane streamlines; and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)

Figure 31

Figure 25.PSD results of (a,c) case $X_{-4}V_{18}$ and (b,d) case $X_{-4}V_{20}$ at (a,b) the upstream region and (c,d) $x-x_r=6\delta _r$.

Figure 32

Figure 26.Separation zone at the upstream region of the blowing slot in (a,c) case $X_{-4}V_{18}$ and (b,d) $X_{-4}V_{20}$: (a,b) streamwise velocity profiles on the symmetry plane (black lines are in-plane streamlines), and (c,d) PSD results.

Figure 33

Figure 27.Flow freezing operation: (a,b) comparison of velocity fluctuation distributions at $y=k_r$ between (a) case $X_{-4}V_{20}$ and (b) case $X_{-4}V_{20}$ with the flow freezing operation (the dashed line indicates the roughness shape at the height of $k_r/2$); and PSD results for case $X_{-4}V_{20}$ with the flow freezing operation at (c) upstream region and (d) $x-x_r=6\delta _r$.

Figure 34

Figure 28.Reconstructions of (a) mode 1 at $x-x_r=7\delta _r$ and (b) mode 3 at $x-x_r=8\delta _r$. (The grey solid lines are isolines of u with the same value set, and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)

Figure 35

Figure 29.Flow visualization of (a,c,e,g,i) case $X_4V_{23}$ and (b,d, f,h,j) case $X_4V_{25}$: (a,b) streamwise velocity profiles at the symmetry plane (black lines are in-plane streamlines), (c,d) profiles of streamwise vorticity at $z=-0.9\delta _r$, (e, f) profiles of vorticity transportation $(S_x-D_x)/S_{ref}$ at $z=-0.9\delta _r$, (g,h) slices of the $Q$ criterion at $x-x_r=12\delta _r$ (the dark grey solid lines on the left half are isolines of $u_s$ with the same value set and the light grey lines on the right are in-plane streamlines), and (i,j) slices of the velocity fluctuation at $x-x_r=12\delta _r$ (the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness).

Figure 36

Figure 30.PSD results of pressure fluctuations for (a,c,e) case $X_4V_{23}$ and (b,d, f) case $X_4V_{25}$ at (a–d) the upstream region of the blowing slot and (e, f) $x-x_r=12\delta _r$.

Figure 37

Figure 31.Flow freezing operations: comparison of (a,b) velocity fluctuation distributions at $y=k_r$ and (c,d) $C_{f,T}$ distributions between (a,c) case $X_4V_{25}F_1$ and (b,d) $X_4V_{25}F_2$ (the dashed line indicates the roughness shape at the height of $k_r/2$); and PSD results for (e) $X_4V_{25}F_1$ and ( f) case $X_4V_{25}F_2$.

Figure 38

Figure 32.Slices of (a,c,e,g) case $X_4V_{23}$ and (b,d, f,h) case $X_4V_{25}F_2$ at (a–d) $x-x_r=24\delta _r$ and (e–h) $x-x_r=36\delta _r$ coloured with (a,b,e, f) the non-dimensional $Q$ criterion and (c,d,g,h) the streamwise velocity fluctuation. (The grey lines are in-plane streamlines, and the black dashed line indicates the projection of roughness.)