Standard economic theory and intuition often posit that people act in a rational manner, for example when we expect consumers to optimize their outcomes and maximize value when making decisions. In this best-selling book, Dan Ariely, a professor of behavioral economics at MIT, enumerates the many ways in which our cognitive systems, emotions, and social norms lead us to less than optimal decisions and sometimes downright strange behavior. More importantly, Ariely illustrates how bad decision making is not random and capricious, but rather is predictable and systematic. Moreover, he does it in an interesting and accessible way, interweaving experiments with timely examples and personal anecdotes.
The book is clearly intended for a general audience as it presents very little data and explains most of the experiments in a narrative form using nontechnical language. While Ariely describes core concepts like anchoring, cognitive dissonance, and the endowment effect, he reinvents the effects in simple and sometimes cute ways using terms like self-herding and the “Ikea” effect. Additionally, a few concepts are extended to lend insights into a wide variety of behavioral peculiarities. For instance, Chapter 9 uses the concept of expectation and frame of reference to explain why football fans of different teams see the same play in two different ways; why bar patrons prefer beer with balsamic vinegar added but dislike it when they are aware of the foreign substance; and why Pepsi is preferred in blind taste tests while Coke is preferred in identified taste tests. He goes further to discuss how expectations are likewise a key factor in every major ethnic conflict around the globe. In this way, Ariely makes the case that understanding the underlying drivers of decisions can help us predict, and perhaps sometimes control, seemingly irrational behavior across multiple domains.
The book offers no new data or theories and both Ariely's past work and classic experiments are described in very simplistic terms. However, this does not mean the book is not worthwhile for researchers and academics. It could certainly serve as an easy primer for those looking to familiarize themselves with the field of behavioral economics and social psychological-based decision-making. For those who are already familiar with Ariely's impressive body of research, the book is a telling, behind-the-scenes look at how his ideas were born. The author describes how growing up in Israel and spending much of his youth in hospitals ignited his passion to understand people. Additionally, he offers many original anecdotes that served as the inspiration for specific studies. He also describes particular subjects in amusing detail that would not normally be permitted in a serious academic journal. In this way, the book has a broad appeal to speak to many real-life situations.
The only sections of the book that seem to veer off-course are Chapters 10 and 11, in which the author probes the context of our character. These chapters loosely apply some of the lessons from previous chapters to explore the basis of honesty. Here social commentary seems to trump scientific insight, as Ariely moralizes about the decline of professionalism, corporate scandals, unscrupulous lawyers, and generalized human greed. Yet this shortcoming is easily forgiven, because the author is exceedingly optimistic and positive about people throughout the book. Despite spending most of his time demonstrating our limitations as human decisionmakers, he offers hope throughout that we can overcome many of our weaknesses both as individuals and cultures. For example, he describes how a “self-control” credit card could be fashioned that would empower consumers to create self-accountability and bolster self control. With such a card, consumers could establish pre-set limits for various spending categories, impose waiting periods to combat impulse shopping, email reminders to themselves with spending alerts, and encourage themselves to save more by “taxing” themselves for discretionary spending. He also makes a compelling case that such a card would also be good for a credit card company willing to differentiate itself by being an advocate for consumers. Throughout the book, he offers multiple tips and suggestions for dampening biased decisions and avoiding negative outcomes.
Dan Ariely is unquestionably an authority on decision making and has been one of the most innovative researchers in the field. In his volume, he offers simple descriptions of some core behavioral economic concepts in an entertaining and accessible way. It is worth reading for those looking to learn about decision-making, as well as those looking for a fun and fresh take on some well-known behavioral effects.
