The practice of infanticide can be found throughout Western history from ancient Greece and Rome to early modern Europe, yet in modern times it has come to be seen as a predominantly Chinese problem. What accounts for the engendering of this perception? In Between Birth and Death, Michelle King takes us to the nineteenth century, at the height of Western intrusion in China, to locate the inception of this idea, and she argues that “female infanticide became Chinese in the imperialist context of the late nineteenth century, when it was immutably transformed from a local, moral, philanthropic issue into a cross-cultural, political, scientific issue of international concern” (pp. 7–8).
This finding is established through a combined textual and visual analysis of Chinese and Western records, a great many of which were produced by Western travelers, missionaries, and diplomats (among them renowned sinologists). The Westerners' fascination with Chinese infanticide was exemplified by an academic undertaking sponsored by the North China branch of the Royal Asiatic Society. In 1885, the organization devoted an entire symposium to the question, “To what extent does it [infanticide] prevail here in comparison with other countries of the world?” (p. 77). Although few participants had direct knowledge about Chinese infanticide, devoted members managed to garner all kinds of “evidence” and to use methods such as statistical enumeration to prove the “prevalence” of the practice in China. King convincingly shows that the obsession with “evidence” and the outright denunciation of Chinese “cruelty” in Western accounts bespoke a deep sense of Western cultural supremacy, one rooted in the sentiment that “China could not compete in civility with either the European past or present” (p. 93). Infanticide was explicitly held as an indicator of China's inferiority.
A major force that perpetuated the association of China with the practice of infanticide was the Oeuvre de la Sainte-Enfance (Holy Childhood Association), a France-based Catholic charitable organization. King details how it aggressively enlisted Catholic children worldwide to fund its operation to “save” unwanted infidel Chinese children through baptism. It used catechism, often vividly illustrated, and stage performances by children themselves to appeal to its young members' empathy and to incite their religious passion. The infidel children in China were depicted as being destroyed “by the thousands and hundreds of thousands, either in the waters of rivers and the abysses of the sea, or by the teeth of dogs and pigs” (p. 118). It was up to the Sainte-Enfance to take up the role of savior.
Drawing heavily on publications in Shenbao, the first Chinese-language newspaper, King further narrates how cross-cultural interactions spurred shifting attitudes toward, and perceptions of, female infanticide in China at the turn of the twentieth century. Indigenous Chinese rhetoric about the immorality of infanticide did not lose its appeal entirely, to be sure, but female infanticide was now primarily discussed through the lens of “scientific objectivity, anatomical concepts of human reproduction, and equality between the sexes” (p. 159) and was regarded as a serious issue in terms of national survival and strength.
While primarily concerned with the questions of perception, Between Birth and Death also examines the endeavors of Chinese local elites to curtail female infanticide. King's chief example is that of Yu Zhi, a philanthropist and author of morality books. She provides an innovative read of these morality books by seeking to “reinsert women into the history of infanticide in late imperial China as more than just the simple victims of a patriarchal system” (p. 17). Here, King analyzes the morality tales for insights into the roles that various women (the mother, the midwife, and the mother-in-law, for example) played at the very moment when the fate of the newborn was being decided. However, given the didactic nature of such texts and their inherent gender bias (women were regularly made responsible for the fatal decision), it comes as no surprise, as King notes, that they have little to reveal from a female perspective. It is here that readers will appreciate the only known story that does give late imperial women some voice. Told by Woman Ye and written down by her son Chen Que, a noted seventeenth-century thinker, it described how she had drowned her infant daughter when she was a young wife under dire financial, emotional, and psychological circumstances. It is no doubt the most gripping account of the entire book.
Conceptually refreshing and informative, Between Birth and Death is an illuminating study on the history of female infanticide in China. It is not the first major research on infanticide that makes use of morality books or of Westerners' writings. However, by shifting the focus from practice to perception, the book highlights the different set of historical conditions that informed the understanding of infanticide in modern China while effectively dismantling the century-old, powerful misconception that this is a uniquely Chinese problem. Given its inclusion of discussions of modern-day implications, including the one-child policy and international adoption, the book will be welcomed not only by scholars, but also by nonspecialists who wish to expand their knowledge on the subject.
