This collection of short essays by a variety of experts with differing backgrounds and perspectives (i.e., national and global practitioners, policymakers, and academics) provides a very useful overview of the key issues related to sovereign wealth management. Throughout the book, a clear distinction is made between traditional reserve management, long the domain of central banks, and the very different challenges and issues related to sovereign wealth management, which several writers suggest may be outside the traditional organizational framework and expertise of central banks. Numerous essays also very effectively outline the key factors in deciding to establish sovereign wealth funds or other separately managed investment vehicles, such as the source of funds, the expected variability of the flow of funds, the intended future use of the funds or investment returns, the existing governmental and organizational framework, the importance of reaching a sustainable consensus among political and other stakeholders in the country or state, and other less quantifiable objectives (such as the development of new domestic markets and professional skills).
A very important issue touched upon in several essays relates to the need for governments to manage their entire balance sheets. In addition to considerations of how best to manage increased or excess reserves beyond those needed for liquidity or other short-term risk management considerations, national authorities need to understand and consider their explicit, implicit, and contingent liabilities more fully. This important point is made early and often throughout the book, and both developed and developing governments should seek to adopt a more complete asset-liability management or balance sheet approach to the consideration of longer-term reserve and fiscal management. Indeed, in a number of countries today, we are witnessing an increased appreciation of the desirability or need to manage public accounts like a risk manager seeking ways to better measure and better manage asset and liability exposures, including longer-term or distant exposures. In several countries, consideration is being given to the establishment of an “Office of Chief Country Risk Officer”. This would seem a very positive trend, and it will likely to lead to the better measurement and potentially more proactive management of national balance sheet exposures.
It would be very interesting for the authors and editors of this collection of essays to consider updating their work in light of financial market events since the Summer of 2007, and in particular, the extreme market volatility and disruptions experienced in 2008. How have sovereign wealth managers dealt with this turmoil, and what important lessons have been learned that may be implemented in risk and portfolio management principles going forward? This would be an interesting extension of the collected work, and possibly the subject of a second World Bank program similar to the one generating the original collection of essays. Interestingly, many of these essays draw comparisons to traditional portfolio risk management and pension fund portfolio practices in describing how sovereign wealth management investment philosophies have evolved. However, consistent with the need to consider the entire national balance sheet, it would be interesting to explore further how sovereign wealth managers may evaluate risks and returns in light of a country's longer-term liabilities and obligations, and how they compare to a consideration of the “hard or soft” liabilities of private and public sectors pensions and those of other long-term investors, such as endowments or foundations. These are interesting issues and questions introduced in general terms; follow-on work will need to consider these in more depth.
The volume is organized in three sections. Part 1 outlines many fundamental issues in considering the establishment of sovereign wealth funds relative to traditional reserve management. The essays by Larry Summers and Philipp Hildebrand raise important fundamental questions about the role of sovereign wealth management, while subsequent essays by Jennifer Johnson-Calari and by Fred Weinberger and Bennett Golub discuss numerous practical policy issues and move into the consideration of appropriate asset allocations. Part 2 expands upon the principles highlighted in Part 1 and considers how sovereign wealth may be managed in the context of the entire national balance sheet. This section provides philosophical and qualitative analysis by Mohammed El-Erian and Mike Williams, quantitative analysis of contingent balance sheet liabilities by Dale Gray, and an evaluation by Bernard Lee of how different asset classes influence portfolio construction and returns.
The final portion of the book includes a collection of case studies. This is a particularly interesting section as the case studies represent a diversified set of background factors and national or governmental situations. It therefore offers an attractive variety of approaches to the practical consideration and pursuit of sovereign wealth management. Both Mexico and Norway have taken relatively well-known and highly regarded steps to implement a more proactive risk management approach to the management of their sovereign balance sheets. Norway is frequently cited as a model for many newer sovereign wealth funds, and Mexico has utilized financial market tools to manage certain national exposures. Case studies on Alaska, Wyoming, Kazakhstan, Botswana, and Korea are also extremely useful and raise important issues (including mistakes made) that any national authority would likely need to consider with regard to the establishment of a sovereign investment fund. A final case study outlines how central bank reserve management has evolved in the context of the European Union and the European Central Bank system.
As a whole, the case studies provide a variety of very useful and practical perspectives on the management of sovereign wealth, of interest to governments and practitioners in both developed and developing countries. As noted earlier, it would be interesting to update these issues, particularly regarding the question of how to manage the entire sovereign balance sheet, and “lessons learned” by sovereign wealth managers from the recent financial crisis.
