Naturalism in Theatre: Its Development and Legacy is a thorough introduction to one of the most dominant genres of twentieth-century drama. With remarkable scope, the text surveys the major European directors and playwrights, from Émile Zola and André Antoine through Henrik Ibsen, August Strindberg, and Bernard Shaw to the contemporary verbatim theatre of Peter Cheeseman and Alecky Blythe. More than a survey of major works though, the text situates the rise of naturalism in a broader historical context. By examining the development of naturalist theatre in a wide variety of national contexts and chronicling the rise of Darwinism, psychology, classism, and technological innovation, the authors illuminate how drama responded to Europe's changing sociopolitical landscape.
The volume is divided into four parts. In Part I, “Introducing Naturalism,” Pickering and Thompson concede that “‘Naturalism’ is a problematic term” (3) and draw on Raymond Williams's definition to overturn a long-held belief that naturalism is simply a reproduction of the natural world. Primarily, the authors aim to prove that naturalism's emphasis on accuracy stems from a growing social interest in Darwinian observation. Thus, the first chapter establishes the basic tenets of the genre in relation to the natural sciences; namely, an interest in the effects of biology, heredity, environment, and moment. The second chapter develops these definitions through a study of key manifestos. The reading of Zola's preface to Thérèse Raquin effectively proves that Zola's naturalism developed out of a desire to observe human behavior, but the authors' exploration of Strindberg's preface to Miss Julie is somewhat less successful. Pickering and Thompson acknowledge that “Strindberg's claims are a little confusing, if not somewhat misleading” (26). Although they choose to focus on class conflict (28) in Miss Julie, they largely overlook Strindberg's concern with “natural forces” such as “love and hatred” (27). Similarly, the possibility that Strindberg's preface is deliberately “misleading” seems significant, as it may upset readings of the preface as a sincere manifesto for naturalism. An inquiry into its potentially ironic tone and Strindberg's focus on “natural forces” may shed light on his increasing use of dreamlike narrative and representation.
Part II, “Naturalism in Its Context,” provides a concise summary of the sociohistoric context of naturalism. Chapter 3 outlines how the industrialization of Europe altered labor, transportation, and urban development. As train stations, in particular, became “chaotic meeting places of all sections of society,” class struggle became impossible to ignore (40). This historical context influences the secularism of modern drama and its shift from formal language and courtly locales to colloquial dialogue and middle-class drawing rooms. Darwin's theory of evolution had a similarly profound effect on the cultural imaginary, since it upset the biblical narrative that humans were inherently wicked. Pickering and Thompson suggest that this development freed women from traditional gender roles, and they trace this influence through a number of plays, including Hedda Gabler and A Doll's House. Chapter 4 explores how technological innovation reshaped staging and acting techniques. The authors argue that the use of gas and electrical lighting, as well as François Delsarte's and Henry Neville's scientific acting methods ultimately make the naturalist box set and Stanislavsky's “Method” possible.
Part III, perhaps the strongest section of the book, is an invaluable survey of the major European theatres of the period. Chapter 5 provides a thorough overview of the Meiningen Company, with a focus on its innovation of the director's role, its realistic approach to acting, its passion for historical accuracy, and its construction of three-dimensional sets. As the company toured Europe, its productions inspired Antoine in France, Stanislavsky in Moscow, and Irving in London, and thus led to the establishment of many small art theatres. Chapter 6, on Antoine and the Théâtre Libre, explores how the small theatre allowed audiences to close-read sets and actors' faces and body language. This intimacy led to a more symbolic stage space, where the paintings, books, and lighting provide clues about characters' relationships and emotional states. It also allowed actors to show internal turmoil through subtle acting techniques rather than through declamation. Chapter 7 traces Ibsen's influence on the development of naturalism in Germany, and Chapter 8 illuminates the close relationship between the Moscow Art Theatre and Chekhov's psychological drama.
The fourth and final part, “The Legacy,” charts the rise of naturalism in Britain and North America. In Chapter 9 Pickering and Thompson explore how Ibsenism led to the Little Theatre movement by examining the development of the Court Theatre in London, the Gaiety Theatre in Manchester, the Abbey Theatre in Dublin, and the Provincetown Players in the United States. Chapter 10 examines the role of the Royal Court Theatre as the center of 1950s new-wave drama, such as John Osbourne's explicitly political Look Back in Anger. The inclusion of Bertolt Brecht in this section is somewhat problematic. Brecht certainly fits within the larger historical framework of the 1940s–1950s and is similarly concerned with social inequalities, but he and his groundbreaking Berliner Ensemble theatre get rather short shrift. Chapter 11 turns to the contemporary verbatim theatre devised by Peter Cheeseman, which is treated as a direct consequence of naturalism's obsessive desire to record truth.
Overall, Naturalism in Theatre: Its Development and Legacy is an indispensable teaching tool. Occasionally, though, the text's breadth forces the authors to skim subjects that deserve more attention: for instance, a longer discussion of realism might have helped distinguish naturalism from realism, as the authors note that even key thinkers, including Zola, use the terms “interchangeably” (3). Similarly, a closer engagement with how Strindberg and Brecht diverge from naturalist aims would help put the genre into relief and thus achieve a more precise definition. However, the comprehensive nature of the book and its formidable structure makes this work a perfect course companion. Pickering and Thompson achieve that rare feat of providing a wealth of material in an easily accessible format.
