In the summer of 2013, Shakespeare's Globe, the company based at the Globe reconstruction in London, mounted productions of the three parts of Shakespeare's Henry VI at Wars of the Roses battlefield sites. The battlefield as performance space, with its rolling hills and buried corpses, mediated the temporal overlap of past and present, as contemporary bodies engaged with the construction of a historical narrative in the fictional play and the actual historical moments of the Wars of the Roses. The associations entrenched in the soil of these sites, the physical remains and histories of the past, encode a connective experience for the contemporary participants interacting with it. The battlefield site, then, is not just a site of historical significance—it is also a site of historical reenactment, where present bodies meet absent ones in the Globe's attempt to converge separated temporalities. The Globe framed the battlefield performances as a way of enlivening history by grounding well-worn Shakespearean texts in the places they represent. But the Globe, in collaboration with The Space, an online arts collective, also filmed the ten-hour marathon event at the Barnet battlefield, live-streamed, and then saved the performance to a digital archive.Footnote 1 So the Globe displaced the site of their site-specific experience. Virtual spectatorship, a result of the Globe's efforts to increase access to their battlefield performances by making them available online, adds another layer of absence to the battlefield. The virtual spectator as absent spectator challenges the privileging of a physical viewing experience that the Globe's “open-air” project promotes. The displacement of site disrupts the relationships grounded in the material performance space and its geographical connections, and expands the understanding of site-specific by demonstrating how a specific relationship to place might be produced and maintained without physical access to a geographical location. Together with their placement at the historical sites and transmission into virtual spaces, the battlefield Henry VIs generate a multiplicity of shared viewing experiences. These shared experiences mediate the continuation of a (re)constructed historical and collective memory and highlight the role of spectatorship, both physical and virtual, in the formation of communal and national identity.
Performing History Plays at Historical Sites
The three parts of Henry VI were played at the battlefields at Towton, Tewkesbury, St. Albans Cathedral Grounds, and Monken Hadley Common in Barnet. For Dominic Dromgoole, the Globe's artistic director, and Nick Bagnall, the director of the series, the meaning of the battlefield performance site is embedded in its history, and their “open-air series” reflects the intentional desire to draw upon the historical and elemental particularities of the space. The three plays toured the UK from June to September, beginning at the York Theatre Royal before moving on to the battlefield at Towton. The show then moved between purpose-built theatres, including three stints at the Globe Theatre, and three more battlefield sites. By transporting the Henry VI plays into the “open-air” (although the viewing experience at the Globe Theatre is also in the open air), Dromgoole and Bagnall hoped to enrich them through movement to an unconventional space. Both believed this move to be unprecedented, the first time one of Shakespeare's plays had been performed on a British battlefield. This sense of novelty infused the performances with a spontaneity attached to its staging space, while the history of the space itself provided the “authenticity” on which the Globe production team hoped to capitalize by creating an educational venture that might be able to illuminate some of Britain's foggier historical moments that may have faded from public knowledge.
The Globe's use of a battlefield, a site of historical trauma, for the purposes of (re)education and entertainment aligns with what has been recently dubbed as “dark tourism,” where death, disaster, and atrocity are commodified for tourist consumption. Battlefields, grave sites, and memorials become complicated attractions that offer the opportunity to grieve or gawk at the violence of the past.Footnote 2 Frank Baldwin and Richard Sharpley question the appropriateness of battlefield tourism: “How should battlefield landscapes be interpreted: the glorification of war or the promotion of peace? How should battlefields be managed—sanitised and ‘cleansed’ or maintained with the detritus of war? … Can or should battlefields be promoted as symbols of national identity?”Footnote 3 The rhetoric surrounding the project was that the Wars of the Roses were fading away from contemporary British memory and these performances might serve to recapture what had been lost. This effort falls into Svetlana Boym's category of “restorative nostalgia,” or the attempted “transhistorical reconstruction of the lost home,” in direct contrast with “reflective nostalgia,” which privileges the ambivalence and multiplicity of remembering. Boym argues that restorative nostalgia aims to fill in the gaps of history for the sake of “truth and tradition.”Footnote 4 In this vein, Bagnall imagined the performances at their historical sites as a chance to remember: “I don't know of any better way of acknowledging and honouring our history than playing these beautiful plays on battlefield sites.”Footnote 5 Bagnall plays on a collective nostalgia—“our history”—that might serve to connect spectators to a shared sense of national identity through the (re)discovery of common origins. This connection, as Bagnall would hope, forms through the performance's proximate relationship to the historically charged space. Bagnall seems to suggest that the site serves as an agent of historical continuity, a backdrop against which bodies connect across times. Bagnall assumes, however, that a holistic sense of contemporary British identity can be constituted out of an imagined connection to the Wars of the Roses. The Globe's mission begs the question of whether or not this past trauma should begin or continue to serve as an active claim to “Britishness.” Predicated on the presumption of shared ancestry, the Globe's project perhaps limits national identity to a linear, homogenous narrative. Dromgoole and Bagnall's historical restoration project might glamorize a singular Britain that has never existed.
Jamie Parker, who had played Henry V for the Globe in 2012, served as host for the filmed event and helped enact the Globe's restorative mission by interviewing audience members during the multiple intermissions and gaps between performances. He often asked individuals whether or not they were familiar with the Wars of the Roses’ history, and many were locals acquainted with the battlefield sites, while some cited Shakespeare's plays as the source of most of their knowledge concerning the events.Footnote 6 At the Towton performance, this knowledge was supplemented by the presence of the Towton Battlefield Society. According to Helen Cox, a Towton Battlefield Society member who also viewed the performances, the performances took place on the grounds of Towton Hall—an area believed to have been the site of the Lancastrian camp, now part of a landowner's garden and not a publicly accessible area of the battlefield. No placards, markers, or information signs marked the sectioned performance area (although such guideposts do exist along the Battlefield Trail), but a historical reenactment group, dressed in period costumes, framed the historical experience of the space for the audience. Upon entering the field, the audience encountered a period tent containing information about the Battle of Towton, including maps and publications.Footnote 7 The audience might then encounter food stands, portable toilets, and the lawn chairs of their neighbors, adding a festivallike feel to the educational efforts of the historical society.
These dissonant constructs of comfort and modernity demonstrate how, in pursuing a sense of “authenticity,” the performances meant to be part innovation and part commemoration also rely on artifice to construct the experience of the event. Dromgoole refers to it as a “funny kind of realism,” an acknowledgment of the extrarepresentational accessories of a theatrical production but also of the historical resonance of the space.Footnote 8 The Globe's staging of the Henry VIs, for instance, employs the natural battlefield as a backdrop only, opting to maintain a relationship among actor, audience, and environment that is similar to the arrangement of its theatre in London. The departure from the physical site of the Globe, then, was not accompanied by a departure from the Globe's staging practices. In utilizing open-air staging, amply doubled small companies, and stylized tactics, the Globe maintains their brand that claims to re-create the “authenticity” of Elizabethan touring practices. This produces a tension between the “authenticity” summoned through the physical elements of the battlefield, its earth and hills, and the quality of site-specificity as a staged framing of a natural environment. David Belcher titles his review “When a Battlefield Becomes a Stage,” but in actuality, the Globe brought the stage to the battlefield.Footnote 9 At each battlefield location, the same portable stage was constructed, similar in design and function to the scaffold sets with which the Globe travel when they tour other productions. The raised, theatrical construct stands out against the rolling hills in the background. Audience members sit on the grass on blankets or in lawn chairs (perhaps a more comfortable alternative to the experience of standing at the Globe, and certainly more comfortable than the experience of the battlefield in 1461). Henry V's coffin exists in the space, in preparation for his funeral, on the grass in front of the stage as the audience enters. To begin Henry VI, Part One actors make their entrances from behind the audience, using the hill as a vomitorium, sharing space but not interaction. The audience is used as playing space several more times, including during Gloucester's revelation of his desires and plans for the crown in Part Three, but the majority of the action remains framed within the stage's scaffolding.
In addition to performing on a constructed set, the actors are also performing historical fiction. Bagnall, in conversation about the historical (in)accuracy of the Henry VI plays, expresses his intentions: “I tried to get to the muscle of these plays. Shakespeare is historically incorrect and all over the place in these plays, but the emotional vitality of these characters is absolutely correct.”Footnote 10 Bagnall cites a bodily authenticity, a muscular vitality, which, for him, transcends the factual and historical inaccuracies of the dramatic text. The battlefield performance site animates this vitality. While Bagnall lauds the strength of the dramatic text and performance, he relies on the site to do the work of providing the historical aura.Footnote 11 The performances are placed on the battlefields—not integrated with them—so the staging does not alter the interpretation of the text in ways that other more fully site-specific performances might be able to do. The space risks becoming passive, as if the performance activates the site and then runs off of the charge it provides. The contemporary performance mediates the continuation of a painful historical moment, but the performance does not activate the space—the battlefield existed before the Globe's field trip and has continued after it. The performers and spectators continue after the performance as well, only now they carry with them the memory of the (re)performed history experienced at the site. The marketing tactics for the battlefield Henry VI plays emphasize how the performance space enhances the participants’ connection to history, but the Globe's movement outdoors might also suggest more of an effort to capitalize commercially on the historical associations of the site. The productions were created to fit in both the battlefield sites and purpose-built theatres. The versatility of the Henry VIs runs counter to Mike Pearson's prominent definition of site-specific performances as “inseparable from their sites, the only contexts within which they are intelligible.”Footnote 12 The Globe's site-specific claims of the battlefield performances’ connection to history might be more apparent in their marketing than in their actual approach to the performances. Regardless of artistic or commercial intention, I investigate the impulse behind site-specificity and examine how a battlefield site does inform performance, how the space itself (re)performs its history as an active participant in performance, almost in spite of the presence of scaffolding, food trucks, and lawn chairs.
Sharing Space across Time
Although the staging does not engage directly with the performance space, the placement of these plays at battlefields affects the experience of the text as moments of resonance spark up among history, fiction, and the present moment. Henry VI, Part Three has more battle scenes than any other of Shakespeare's plays and represents the battles from all four performance sites. Towton was the most horrific, where, on 29 March 1461, Palm Sunday, twenty-eight thousand Englishmen died, making it the bloodiest battle ever fought on English soil. Shakespeare represents the battle with meditations on the horrors of war, found in Henry's famous molehill speech and the double-recognition scene of a father–son killing (2.5.1–124). While the Globe's staging does nothing to integrate the text directly with the performance site at Towton, the historical resonances are there. The performance utilizes the battlefield as a backdrop rather than as a staging area, but during Henry's soliloquy the constructed lines between stage and battlefield and the perceived lines between past and present, fiction and history, overlap. As King Henry sits on the molehill—a pile of sand Margaret earlier poured out on the stage, upon which she humiliates and executes York—he avoids the mayhem of the battle and muses on the carefree life of a shepherd: “O God! Methinks it were a happy life / To be no better than a homely swain. / To sit upon a hill, as I do now / To carve out dials quaintly, point by point / Thereby to see the minutes how they run” (2.5.21–5). As Graham Butler, who plays the inactive king, speaks the line “to sit upon a hill, as I do now,” he gestures with a smirk that seems to change the line reading to “as we do now,” inviting the audience to share his vantage point. And they do. The audience sits on their own hill with Henry, surveying the same battlefield, the same site of trauma. Audience members reported hearing sheep bleat as Henry imagined living out his days shearing fleece rather than enduring his kingly responsibilities during a civil war.Footnote 13 As Henry meditates on the advantage of a pastoral life, the pastoral backdrop comes to the foreground: “Ah, what a life were this! How sweet! How lovely! / Gives not the hawthorn-bush a sweeter shade / To shepherds looking on their silly sheep / Than doth a rich embroider'd canopy / To kings that fear their subjects’ treachery? O, yes, it doth; a thousand-fold it doth” (2.5.41–6). Butler charges the audience to notice their surroundings, to evaluate the shade of their own hawthorn-bushes. Just as Henry decides that the view must be sweeter for the shepherd, the audience might conclude that it is their view that is the privileged one. The sun is shining and the sheep are bleating as audience members share in the “happy life” of spending the day at the theatre, not engaging in brutal hand-to-hand combat. The most intense moment of resonance between past and present as mediated by the performance, then, is in fact a moment of dissonance. As the audience might become aware of how unsuited Henry's yearnings are for a king, they also might recognize the disconnect between the tranquil scene before them and the gruesome scene of history. And this is when the “feeling” of the space becomes the most heightened—at the confused intersection of perception, experience, and memory.
The production team refers to this feeling of performing these history plays at the battlefields by a variety of terms. For Dromgoole, it was a “shiver of resonance.” For Bagnall, it was an “energy,” for Peter Manjura, the curator of the online digital archive, it was a “visceral sensation.”Footnote 14 The production team struggles to explain the experience of “being there,” grasping at a vocabulary to describe not just the charge of live performance, but the coexistence of present, living bodies with the ghosts of the past. The presence of the performance in the “actual” space of a historical event connects the two temporalities, past with present, by evoking the remembered (or more often, forgotten) physical presences of the past and produces “shivers of resonance” for the spectators. But it is the glaring absence of the historical bodies in stark contrast with the imposing physical presence of the theatrical event that remains literally grounded in the battlefield site itself. The site contains the absence of the past bodies—literally in the graves of the fallen soldiers, but also immaterially in the memory of the past body, once present, now absent.
The performers stand in for those that participated in the battle, as do Shakespeare's characters, and although they are not reenactors, they (re)perform the history of the space. After Henry concludes his molehill soliloquy and resigns himself to his fate as monarch, he witnesses the heartbreaking scene meant to be representative of the Battle of Towton. He watches in horror as a son realizes he has killed his father in combat, and in an immediate parallel, as a father realizes he has killed his son. Bagnall simplifies the staging, using only two actors who switch between life and death. After the double recognition, the son and father face each other, with Henry observing from in between, each inches from the others’ faces. When the son asks, “Was ever son so rued a father's death?” and the father responds, “Was ever father so bemoaned his son?” it is as if they are speaking to an apparition still visible to them, rather than to an inanimate corpse (2.5.109–10). The stylized staging distances the moment from realism, but the stage moment might still vibrate with an uncomfortable energy of identification for the audience: the evidence of clashing familial loyalties and the tragic conflicts of conscripted services can be found beneath the nearby ground. How is it that a representation of the pathos of war—a theatrical construct on the themes of misery and familial strife—can resonate so strongly with the “actual” event?
The joint inhabitation of space by the contemporary actors and spectators with the memory and remains of past fallen soldiers—a cohabitation that suggests the material continuation of history in the present body mediated by space—reflects the body's ability to serve as a site of stored (or restored) memory. The difficulty the production team faced in finding words to describe the experience of being at the battlefields might be because the vocabulary in action, as Joseph Roach understands it, is a kinesthetic one. In Cities of the Dead, Roach describes a “kinesthetic imagination,” an act that involves “a way of thinking through movements—at once remembered and reinvented.”Footnote 15 The motions and actions of a performer can reproduce collective memory and restore lost or forgotten behaviors. Similarly, Rebecca Schneider sees the body as a repository of historical knowledge and memory. In Performing Remains, an exploration of temporality and performance's sustainability through perpetual reenactment, she argues for the body as a site of historical repetition and the consequent convergence of past and present:
the resiliently irruptive rub and call of live bodies (like biological machines of affective transmission) insist that physical acts are a means for knowing, bodies are sites for transmission even if, simultaneously, they are also manipulants of error and forgetting. Bodies engaged in repetition are boisterous articulants of a liveness that just won't quit. … [T]heir live bodies are the means by which the past and the present negotiate disappearance (again).Footnote 16
Both Schneider and Roach place emphasis on the body as the material that mediates the temporal overlap and charges “live” performance with historical resonances. Through the constant repetition of physical actions—whether gestures in performance or the physical act of spectating—live bodies as “boisterous articulants of a liveness” are (re)performing the past body, once live and boisterous itself, now present and rearticulated.
The physical actions of performers placed at a battlefield site imbue the accidental kin-slaying scene in Part Three as an event with a direct connection to the events of 1461. The scene itself, a nonliteral representation of the actual events, functions as a kind of memorial. The double recognition, symmetrical both in Bagnall's staging and Shakespeare's text, ritualizes the moment. The memorialization of the text parallels the reverence granted to the battlefield site—a site memorialized by period tents, informational brochures, and a historical society that frame the narrative encompassing the performance. While I am not specifically arguing for the battlefield performances as rituals, the production aims to function like the kind of historical rite Paul Connerton describes in How Societies Remember: “It was at this [ritual] site that temporal difference was denied and the existence of the same, the ‘true’ and ‘authentic’ reality, was annually disclosed.”Footnote 17 The battlefield Henry VIs have not been performed cyclically like the religious ceremonies Connerton examines, but in their (re)performance of history at the historical site—a (re)performance Schneider would argue is mediated by the bodies in that space—there might be a “denial” of temporal difference that gives participants a sense of feeling closer to a past historical moment in the “metaphysical present.”Footnote 18 Schneider calls this conflation of temporalities a “touch,” as “interaction with (and as) traces exercises a cross—or multi-temporal engagement with im/material understood to belong to the past in the present. Said more simply; inside the archive or out, times touch.”Footnote 19 This simultaneity of past and present can elicit a visceral response from the present-day participants. In his review of the battlefield Henry VIs, Belcher describes how, on the battlefield, “even on a blistering summer day in this tiny village near York, George Goodwin, a British historian and writer, sees the snow and fog of a Palm Sunday more than 500 years ago.”Footnote 20 There is the sense that the present becomes the past—or perhaps the other way around—in a rupture of linear time that Schneider refers to as “part of the nervousness or queasiness of theatricality, contributing to the uncertainty of where and how time takes place.”Footnote 21
The transmission of the live performance into virtual space magnifies this uncertainty. The virtual spectator, absent to the performance site itself, is the present body in the virtual viewing experience. Amid the circuitous layering of temporalities and geographies—virtual audience members watching the now past spectators watching performers reenacting past bodies in a space haunted by these past bodies—the question of where and when the performance can be said to take place becomes more complicated. The online viewer inhabits multiple spaces at once—the actual viewing location and the distant one the screen mediates. The navigation of this unique topography is one that combines the experience of being both “here” and “there”—an analogue to Schneider's queasiness of being both past and present.
A moment at the Towton performance demonstrates how time also “takes place.” By act 2 of Henry VI, Part Three the sun was setting behind the audience. Before the Battle at Mortimer's Cross, Edward and Richard see a vision of three suns rising over the horizon. As the characters shield their eyes against the “blazing” and “fair-shining suns” (2.1.36, 40), Graham Butler and Patrick Myles (Edward) raise their hands to block out the setting sun, at eye level in this moment of the performance. The symmetrical incongruity between the text and performance, the discussion of a sunrise during a sunset (and the obvious lack of a supernatural meteorological phenomenon), might actually serve to incite in the spectator a visceral feeling of past become present. Time becomes specific to place, with the sun setting around 8 p.m. in Towton, and the connection between the place and the text manifests in bodily reactions to the environment, seen onstage by the spectators and felt by the squinting performers. And then those watching online in the middle of the night might be watching those performers react to a sunset as they talk about a sunrise. Just as they inhabit multiple spaces, the online viewer navigates multiple temporalities at once. Those watching the live stream may share a contemporaneous sense of presence with the “present” audience, while those watching the archived performance at a later time might experience a sense of timelessness without the visual markers of dwindling sunlight and with the ability to pause, rewind, or otherwise manipulate the performance. Whether resonant or dissonant, the layers of time overlap for each spectator and contribute to a theatrical “queasiness,” a “shiver of resonance” from a perceived or imagined connection between past audiences and a past battle that allows separated parties to share experiences. Each viewing experience, specific to its contemporary moment, invites history to reappear. The Wars of the Roses may have ended over five hundred years ago, but they have yet to disappear completely.
Absent/Present Bodies: The (Re)Performance of the Past
The historical soldier reappears in staged representations of combat. The stylized, physical actions of battle scenes evoke the most obvious comparisons to the actions—and their consequences—of history. At Towton, the Globe faced the overwhelming challenge of representing twenty-eight thousand casualties with a playing company of fourteen. Bagnall staged the battles with the persistent beating of onstage drums to signal the presence of conflict, with the clanging of swords against the metal scaffolding, and with groups of actors facing the audience swinging their weapons in slow motion. For Schneider, the elision of the past and present exists in the labor of the performers: “the literalness and hard labor of the reenactment provoke[ ] something that flicker[s] in the space between ‘original’ and ‘copy’”Footnote 22 The cross-temporal overlap occurs in the gestic work of the body. The stage combat, slow and stylized as it is, contains the traces of the historical body in combat. The performers in (simulated) battle attempt to repeat the actions of a battle centuries old, continuing history through their sweat and labored breath. The performing bodies also unconsciously participate in the (re)enactment of a socially and collectively formed history inscribed on the body itself. Connerton examines how the body's conditioned responses, whether trained through repetition or inscribed by cultural forces, are the ones performed without conscious thought. Habit, then, involves the body actively remembering while the mind forgets. Just as Roach believes performance can restore or produce collective memory, Connerton argues that habitual memory, through a process of repetition and sedimentation, also constructs a form of social memory, a communal and unconscious remembering maintained and preserved through bodies across history.Footnote 23 The Battle of Towton, then, is memorialized not only through the structure of the text, but also through the physical (re)production of a shared history.
At the battlefield, live performers and spectators do not simply evoke a connection with the past by occupying a space that the historical bodies themselves once occupied; rather, the live bodies are the connection themselves. The imperfections and inaccuracies of theatrical representation become inconsequential. While the staging choices for battle scenes worked to give the audience a sense of the sights and sounds of combat, they could be only a pale reflection of the “actual” events. Regardless of the clarity of that reflection, however, the separated temporalities still converge through presence at a shared space. Even at the site of the battlefield, spectators must at some level work to imagine the connection through the stylization—the same work viewers watching online must do to fill in the sensory gaps of their distance. Roach's understanding of kinesthetic imagination is that it “inhabits the realm of the virtual. Its truth is the truth of simulation, of fantasy or of daydreams, but its effect on human action may have material consequences of the most tangible sort and of the widest scope. This faculty … flourishes in the space where imagination and memory converge.”Footnote 24 Roach draws on Susan Foster's idea of “kinesthetic empathy,” which is “an affiliation … between living and dead but imagined bodies.”Footnote 25 Kinesthetic connection, then, is not predicated on physical presence at the battlefield if it is partly achieved through imagination. Empathy may be developed by sight in addition to touch. The conflation of spaces achieved through telematics (telecommunication like Skype, Facetime, or a live-stream performance) mirrors and shares in the conflation of temporalities experienced at the battlefields. The Globe's impulse to broadcast their productions and increase access (and revenue) results not in the loss of connection but in the expansion of copresence and in new ways of sharing and (re)producing social memory that extend beyond the geographical space of performance.
Immaterial evocations produced by interaction with the space challenge physicality as the only form of presence at the site. The live bodies remember—both as an act of imagination and as the embodied encasement of history—as they specifically interact with the site. As the live bodies (re)enact the historical archive, they come into contact with the immaterial traces of bodies who previously inhabited the space. In an interview with critic Alfred Hickling, Bagnall touches upon this sensation of haunting produced by the cross-temporal meeting of present and absent bodies: “Coming here makes me feel that the ghosts will be watching.”Footnote 26 And in a way, Bagnall staged these witnesses. Throughout the three plays, when characters exited a scene, they continued to watch the action from upstage. Henry would remain on his throne, reading a book or cringing at battle noises, but the other Lancasters and Yorks would form a line of silent spectators, giving the sense of a solemn witnessing of trauma. The ghosts of the battlefield site that Bagnall feels are watching, however, are not merely passive spectators as his comment and staging suggest. They are active participants, presently haunting the space, immaterially touching the live bodies with which they come into contact. The ghost is a way the space remembers and performs. While the ghost cannot necessarily take up space, it can certainly infuse it—with the affective evocation of its memory, but more interestingly, with the glaring acknowledgment of its absence. As the Globe's production team would readily claim, these absent bodies are remembered because they were lost, violently and brutally. The performances of the Henry VI series on a battlefield that actively “remembers” this violence place material bodies in direct contact with the striking immateriality of loss. The past bodies are glaringly absent, and their ghosts, in their haunting of the site, reflect the struggle to contend with that absence. For the Globe, this absence is an evocation, a chance to remember. And yet, this misses the phenomenal queasiness of theatricality to which Schneider points when the material and immaterial, the past and present, connect in a way that somehow transcends imagination. The ghosts do not need to be summoned—the battlefield Henry VIs are not an invocation. Unlike the absent body of the virtual spectator, who might log on and remain unnoticed to the battlefield audience, the absent soldier's body is present, linked to the site, interacting across temporalities with those who share its space.
The material remains of the British battlefields, evoking their immaterial counterparts while interacting with those bodies physically present, participate in the (re)appearance of the historical event. Historian Julian Humphrys emphasizes the potential power inscribed in the presence (or, rather, absence) of physical bodies at the battlefield, urging Hickling, his interviewer, to “imagine if each sheep we can see now were a mutilated body.” Hickling responds, “There are a lot of sheep.”Footnote 27 Humphrys uses this imaginative exercise, an exercise that parallels Henry's own musings on sheep, and his emphasis on the physical trauma of the bodies that remain to frame the performance event as a more complete re-creation. If the sheep, a contemporary part of the space, were people—and if there were twenty-eight thousand sheep—the battlefield would look and feel more like it did five hundred years ago. But the sheep are not people. The imagined corpses are visibly, and perhaps for Humphrys, regrettably absent. The live bodies’ perception of the space and those who haunt it is necessarily incomplete and imperfect—as the historical event itself remains incomplete. To lose sight of the force of imagination required to transform sheep into a mutilated corpse is to underestimate the power of the actual buried corpses and their connection to the space and those who interact with it. Humphrys's desire to connect the performance to the physical “reality” of the historical moment reveals the contingent desire to have the performance participate in the traumatic event itself. His evocation of the mutilated bodies, while an effort to solidify a sense of authenticity for the production, ignores the artificiality of the Globe's project. The theatrical construct—while careful not to disturb the physical gravesites—risks forgetting that imagining is not living, that sheep are not people. While the experience of a cross-temporal “touch” may not be dependent on historical accuracy, what the Globe presented may have served only as their own substitution for history, as they valued the “authentic” while remaining oblivious to the contemporary limitations of reliving a past trauma and to their presumptions of an all-encompassing British identity that identifies with the Wars of the Roses.
The literal remains of the dead bodies buried beneath the soil of the battlefield do not have to be imagined and were also used to serve the project's pursuit of creating an “authentic” connection between past and present. In 1996, thirty-seven bodies were discovered in a mass grave near the Towton village church. As Belcher states, “The bodies belonged to soldiers, all killed around the time of the Battle of Towton.”Footnote 28 With his use of the past tense—“belonged”—Belcher unintentionally strips the nonliving physical remain from its attachment to its previously live body. If the dead body no longer belongs to the live soldier, to whom does it belong? Perhaps Belcher would suggest the remains belong to the public, as “the story of the grave has been the subject of television shows and books,” documenting the discovery as the most direct contemporary link to the Wars of the Roses up until the Globe's open-air series. Or perhaps, as Bagnall might imagine, the remains belong to the space, to serve as an addition to the battlefield site itself, a provision to heighten the authenticity of a theatrical production: “We planned it so that we're not treading on these people's graves. We're there to understand part of our history.”Footnote 29 Bagnall's consideration of the physical graves acknowledges the material presence of the past bodies and their ability to (re)enact history within the present, but also suggests that this materiality can be avoided, nimbly sidestepped somehow. Bagnall does not want to tread on the graves—but he still wants the performance close enough to benefit from the proximity. He privileges the physical graves as the sites that literally contain history: perform too close to this physical site and risk disrespecting that history; perform too far away and the phenomenal and cross-temporal touch might not “reach” you. What are the boundaries of the historical site, and what are the limits of its physical connection to participants?
In staging at the geographical location, performance defines these borders, marking the space and containing it within conventional staging relationships. Sharing the space of the battlefield, like sharing the space of a nation as mapped by its drawn borders, produces a symbolic perception of community. As Benedict Anderson has famously argued, the nation is socially constructed, “an imagined political community.”Footnote 30 The site-specific (re)construction of a presumptively shared past serves to create Anderson's concept of a “deep, horizontal comradeship.”Footnote 31 As with the mission of restorative nostalgia, the Globe's battlefield stagings can be seen as an effort to preserve a particular (and limited) version of national identity through remembrance of the past, authenticated by the physical connection to the historical site. Ironically, the displacement of performance into virtual spaces stretches the phenomenological reach of the site's history located at the battlefield. Even beyond the battlefield, the intersection of two different manifestations of the past body, the material remain and the immaterial trace, participates in the remembrance and consequent continuation of history. The mediated transmission makes visible the concentric spheres of community, collectivity, and the globalizing effect of linking two disparate spaces, allowing the virtual spectator to participate in the affective experience of (re)constructing history through an imagined connection to the physical audience, battlefield, and online spectating community.
The battlefield spectator's viewing experience involves an interaction with both the immaterial traces of the absent historical body and the physical remains of their corpses as negotiated through the spatial specificity of the battlefield. While the performers (re)perform remembering through gestic practices, spectators (re)perform spectating as they participate in the connective memory between past and present. Marvin Carlson, in his book The Haunted Stage, conceptualizes an experience he terms “ghosting,” the experience of a past memory or historical event haunting a present performance space or encounter. Carlson explains that ghosting occurs when “audience members encounter a new but distinctly different example of a type of artistic product they have encountered before,” and that in such an instance, ghosting presents the performance in a different context.Footnote 32 These ghostings occur in the minds of the audience, as a reencounter with something that has been seen or felt—either literally or abstractly—in a previous moment. At the battlefield, audience expectations of Globe staging—a specific relationship between audience and spectator—can influence their reception of the event. Ghosting is not necessarily the literal event of remembering a lived experience, but is rather the sensation of remembering, of returning. As spectators return (even if for the first time) to the battlefield, they return to the experience of the historical battle of the Wars of the Roses—a battle obviously not lived in their own bodily experiences, but one that returns through its associative haunting of the specific space. Carlson discusses particularized place (made specific by its im/material bodily haunts) as an active agent in ghosting: “in such [site-specific] productions already written texts are placed in locations outside conventional theatres that are expected to provide appropriate ghostings in the minds of the audience.”Footnote 33 Here, Carlson illuminates the Globe's desire to connect their performance to history through the associations the battlefield site evokes. Even in virtual performance spaces, the traditions of usage and the memory of previous performances form material traces that provide perceptual orientations for the spectators. In spite of the familiar physical orientation toward a stage constructed outdoors, or toward a screen, the spectator's perceptual orientation is instead informed by the material traces specific to the im/material remains contained in the site. The spectator, a repository for historical and social memory, serves as an agent of temporal continuity in the embodied reception of the historical traces simultaneously present with the viewer.
The battlefield Henry VIs demonstrate the body as archive, the body as repository for the collective and social memory of a space and a culture, and the Globe privilege the physical location of the battlefield as the site of this exchange. The spectators’ physical participation in the (re)performance of history occurs in the body's sensory reception of its environment. In his review of the performances, Belcher describes his multisensory experience at the first battlefield performance in Towton, Yorkshire:
The Towton performance, on a clear day with the smell of newly mowed grass in the air, took place on a makeshift elevated stage in the shadow of a church and a towering tree. The audience sat on a gentle slope, mostly in lawn chairs or on blankets, just yards from where the graves of dozens of fallen soldiers from that war were uncovered as recently as 17 years ago.Footnote 34
The ability to smell the surrounding environment highlights the sense of that “immersive” experience the artistic collaborators were hoping to create. Belcher also significantly underscores the necessity of physical and sensory cohabitation for the project—the graves were “just yards” away, close enough to touch, or smell even. The individual spectator's specific positionality—seated on the grass with an immediate tactile connection to the site, or within the shade of “a towering tree”—directly affects the viewing experience. The spectator reacts to the historical associations emanating from the battlefield performance site—physically perceiving the sensory immediacy of the site itself—while also responding to his or her own imaginative constructions of collective embodied experiences. Harvey Young, in his discussion of a lynching victim's corpse, demonstrates how the spectator's interaction with the bodily remain “creates the possibility of an imagined, personal interaction with the original body, even as a construct, that exists within the present as a series of parts. … [T]he value of the performance remain is in its seeming ability to reactivate the expired performance event.”Footnote 35 Direct physical contact with a historical object—in the case of the battlefield Henry VIs, the site itself participates as material object—seemingly possesses the ability to “reactivate” the historical experience, to allow the present to embody the experience of the past physically. This affective response as shared embodied experience can exist as an intense imaginative construction, as evidenced by Cavendish's account of his marathon viewing experience:
I have to confess that I won't be putting myself through such a sedentary marathon for quite a while—even with the benefit of a fold-up chair I felt like walking wounded by the end of the evening. But I'm heartily glad, nay feel thoroughly privileged, that I did and I'm full of admiration for a cast of just 14, directed by Nick Bagnall, that sweats its collective guts out in quasi-period costume to entertain, inform and inspire on such a grand scale.Footnote 36
His “sedentary marathon” demonstrates the actual physical labor of spectating and highlights the physiologically indexed nature of temporality for the physical spectator. Cavendish's marathon, and his reference to the labor to the acting body that “sweats its collective guts out,” also glibly echoes the historical events of the battle. Cavendish may have felt like the “walking wounded,” but his physical comparison to the absent wounded of the battlefield is ultimately psychical. He continues to describe his affective response: “And without getting falsely sentimental, it's quite a pole-axeing thing to realise that the field you're in and surrounding tranquil farmland, was, that snowy day 550-odd years ago, a landscape of barely describable horror.”Footnote 37 Cavendish's realization of the physical space he occupies is also a requisite imagination of the events that took place there, and this imagination, as Roach would suggest, has the material consequences of a physical reaction. Cavendish approaches the space, and the bodies present in the imagined “landscape of barely describable horror,” as an access point to an emotional connection between his physical body and the fighting and wounded bodies of the past. In feeling the stiffness in his legs and seeing the sweat on the actors’ brows, Cavendish imagines himself into the embodied experience of the historical moment—ignoring the discordant, yet equally present, contemporary intrusions of food trucks and picnics imposing their own specific sensory effects upon the environment.
Unpredictable weather conditions provided another sensory experience specific to the battlefield environment. On the Saturday performance at Barnet, the marathon performances of the Henry series were met with a torrential downpour, drenching both audience and performers alike. The weather, like Henry's molehill speech, could have served to bring the surrounding environment into the audience's awareness. When Edward celebrates his victory during “this bright-shining day,” the audience laughs from beneath their rain-soaked ponchos (5.3.3). His next line, though, “I spy a black, suspicious, threatening cloud,” forebodes the dark comings of Richard III and mixes metaphor with reality as the weather suggests that those dark times are already come. And despite Clarence's assurances that “a little gale will soon disperse that cloud” (5.3.10), the rain is still falling as Henry provokes Richard, claiming that a “hideous tempest shook down trees” at his birth (5.6.46). With environmental elements encoded in the dramaturgy of plays written intentionally for open-air performance, the weather highlighted the performance's resonance with the space, and in doing so, also created a shared viewing experience unique to the specific site. Audience members were applauded for their hardiness, performers for their courage—as if, together, they had braved a battle by braving the elements.
Jamie Parker, in an effort to encourage those sitting through the inclement weather between performances, once yelled out the British World War I battle cry: “Are we downhearted? No!”Footnote 38 In a fascinating moment that connects the Wars of the Roses to the Great War to a community of British theatregoers, Parker reflects that the rain acts as a unifying force, collecting the spectators into a single consciousness, another constructed moment of “deep, horizontal comradeship.” The physical experience of discomfort, of sitting in the rain for ten hours, may very well connect the live bodies to that snowstorm on Palm Sunday in 1461, but in a more grounded sense, the spectators’ sensory experience of precipitation connects them to one another in an experience of a performance that is specific to its site.
Beyond the Physical: The Im/Materiality of Virtual Spectatorship
The Globe privilege this physical experience of the live performance. The ability to touch the ground, to feel the rain, mediates the connection to history and creates the collective consciousness. For Schneider as well, the emphasis is in the body. Physical presence achieves the cross-temporal “touch.” But the experience of rain is not limited to only those who can feel it. Even with the experience mediated by a screen, an online viewer can hear the raindrops hit the stage and watch the actors lose their footing, their boots squeaking as they struggle to maintain traction. Just as Jamie Parker fabricated a sense of shared community by rallying the physically present audience members together around their specific experience of rain, the experience of being absent, of accessing the battlefield from a distance, creates its own specific collective. “This presencing, this re-presenting of a present occasion to an absent audience,” as Paddy Scannell describes of broadcast television, creates connected communicative and experiential spaces of spectating.Footnote 39
The Globe touted the “open-air” series as enlivening history by virtue of its placement at the battlefield location, but then the performances, so critically linked to their landscapes through the embodiment of historical traces, were stretched into virtual space(s). This displacement of the site-specific experience questions whether a live stream and virtual transmission of a “live” performance can communicate the hauntings of history and the attachment of associations that exist within a physical space as effectively as the physical space itself. The production of an alternative viewing experience suggests a multiplicity of (re)produced spatial specificities mediated through divergent, rather than collective, physical experiences. In its transmission from battlefield to home or coffee shop or bus stop, the continuation of history played across the bodies of the battlefield is not necessarily lost; rather, its possibilities for continuation are multiplied.
Physical presence at the battlefield site might be only one of multiple ways to experience the collective and resonant energy of the battlefield performances. Philip Auslander, in Liveness argues that the experience of “liveness” (the elusive synonym of “resonance” and “energy” when used to describe the experience of live performance) is not singularly contained: “live performance has indeed been pried from its shell and … all performance modes, live or mediatized, are now equal: none is perceived as auratic or authentic; the live performance is just one more production of a given text or one more reproducible text.”Footnote 40 Auslander argues that live and mediatized experiences are not technologically opposites, but rather are historically synchronous, with “liveness” being a term that could be understood only with the advent of recording. The divide between “live” and mediatized, then, becomes less clear and less relevant. Thinking beyond physical presence at the battlefield as the only way to experience the performance in that space, the transmission of the performances into virtual spaces demonstrates an overlap of both separated temporalities and geographies.
The constant (re)negotiation of the historical moment, (re)configured in its mediatized transmission, refracts the singular site-specific experience into a heterogeneous and continuous “presencing” of the past. The virtual, then, can be understood via Boym's concept of reflective nostalgia: “Reflective nostalgia does not follow a single plot but explores ways of inhabiting many places at once and imagining different time zones. … [It] cherishes shattered fragments of memory and demoralizes space.”Footnote 41 This virtual displacement stretches the realm of performance space to include multiple spaces and times, multiple perspectives, and multiple relationships between spectator and performer. Rather than losing the spatial specificity of the battlefield, then, this movement into virtual spaces creates multiple specific viewing experiences and embraces the contradictions of modernity, of overlapping experiences of digital presence and absence. The navigation of the multiplicity contained in the virtual represents a transference, or a continuation, of “liveness” from the physical location of performance. The online viewer participates in the performance in a way that the “live” and “present” audience member cannot—by pausing, rewinding, and restarting the video, accessing multiple viewpoints, and navigating hypertextual material offered in the digital program—and disrupts the relationship between performance and geographical site by challenging the privileging of physical connections to the battlefield. The result of the narrowed gap between “live” and mediatized performance is the increased possibility for connection. Archived video gives exponentially more potential viewers access to the battlefield performances, and the experience of the battlefield is shared, not only through physical coexistence in the same location, but through kinesthetic connection across time and space—an overlap similar to the imagined connection to the ghosts of the past achieved at the battlefield site. The history of the site—its specific charge and resonance—continues and transforms through the multiplicity of virtual spectatorship, contributing to the creation of a collective consciousness that extends beyond the limitations of a single geographical location.
In the (re)performance of the battlefield's history, site and performance together resist the disappearance of this history. The Wars of the Roses remain, not only in the physical remains of the battlefield's graves, but also in the collective memory restored in the participants both at the site and removed from it. The movement of the battlefield Henry VIs across geographies and temporalities, their placement at the battlefield and subsequent displacement into virtual spaces, creates multiple specific viewing experiences, each of which work to mediate the continuation of history. Through performance, a past event comes out of the past and into the present. Although a direct emotional connection might be achieved through physical contact with the place of the historical event, the performance's movement to other spaces challenges a static understanding of history. Just as the performers and physically present spectators mediated the continuation of history through their embodied participation in the performance event, virtual spectators can also carry the collective and social memory of the event itself. These battlefield plays challenge the relationship between physical presence and spatial connection, and with it, the attached implications of historical authenticity and a static understanding of history. Virtuality offers another example of how national identity need not rely on national boundaries, as well as a new multiplicity of possibilities for collective identity formation that still needs to be explored further. The question of whose identity is being constructed and who is doing the constructing also multiplies, however. The Globe's version of authentic history as singular truth might continue to eclipse other narratives as it stretches beyond the battlefield. In the return of performance to a remembered site, and in the expansion of that site beyond the geographical location, virtual spaces continue to be new battlegrounds for perpetuating or disrupting how collective identities relate to history.
