The subject of this fine collection of articles is guilds and craftsmen in various parts of the Ottoman Empire. Its primary contribution is to fill some of the considerable gaps in our knowledge of Ottoman guilds. The editors' claim that “the dissolution of Ottoman guilds forms the centre-piece of our volume” (p. vii) is a bit misleading because the articles in fact focus on a wide variety of subjects with little in the way of a unifying theme other than the obvious claim that guild development and functions differed from time to time and place to place. There are twelve articles dealing with subjects such as the fluidity of guild organizations, the role of the state, inter- and intra-guild competition, local and foreign representations of guilds, and the causes of their ultimate demise. Due to this variety, I look at several of the articles individually rather than the book as a whole.
Suraiya Faroqhi's introductory article is one of the best in that it summarizes the relevant historiography and raises some questions for future investigation. Beginning with the early contributions of Osman Nuri Ergin and Abdulbaki Golpinarli, who focus on the spiritual, moral, and ceremonial concerns of the guildsmen, Faroqhi goes on to deal with Sabri Ulgener, who was one of the earliest historians to question “why Ottoman craft producers failed to make the transition to capitalism” (p. 5). He argues that the 17th-century commercial crisis gave rise to an ideology that emphasized the nobility of modesty, thereby curtailing the sense of ambition and materialism necessary for the rise of capitalism. Other historians, notably, Lutfi Barkan and Gabriel Baer, argue that the failure to undergo the transition to capitalism was structural in that the guilds were seen as a mere extension of the Ottoman state. Faroqhi concludes this review by noting that historians have more recently come to see Ottoman guilds in a much more positive light as dynamic institutions that did not necessarily impede economic or political progress.
In a later article, Faroqhi weighs in with her own contribution on the 18th-century guilds of Istanbul. Here she presents the differing views on the appearance of the gedik (a license to operate a business) and whether it developed as a response to adversity or as a result of prosperity (p. 89). However, the most significant contribution here is her investigation of the various social tensions that affected the guilds. These included the competition among the craftsmen, tensions arising between craftsmen and merchants, and, most important, between craftsmen and tax farmers.
Another excellent contribution is that of Eunjeong Yi on the question of guild structure and management. Yi argues that in 17th-century Istanbul “one observes an unexpected degree of fluidity” in the structure and membership of the guilds (p. 55) as opposed to the established notions of guilds with strict and ossified membership practices. She also observes little state involvement and numerous examples of outsiders subletting shops or entering into partnerships with guild members on a relatively regular basis. Yet as competition increased toward the end of the 17th century, “membership control seems to have gradually strengthened over the next century with the spread of the gedik” and the eventual appearance of guilds with highly inflexible structures (p. 72).
Eleni Gara's article takes a look at the intricate ties and conflicts among craftsmen and between craftsmen and the state. She examines the competition between two groups of Jewish weavers in 17th-century Salonica and Veria over the supply of wool. This article is especially interesting because the Salonica woolens serviced the Janissaries, meaning that the state held a significant interest in the conflict. It also demonstrates an impressive amount of research as Gara follows this case through fifty years of court suits and countersuits. Her work sheds light on the limits of state power and the strength of Ottoman law. This article, along with Minna Rozen's on the Jewish butchers of Istanbul, also helps to uncover the complex, often contentious, nature of relations within the Ottoman Jewish community.
The role of the millers and bakers of Istanbul in 1750–1840 is explored by Salih Aynural. The author skillfully presents a wealth of statistical information from differing sources. We are informed, for example, that “in 1739, a total of 991 millstones was recorded. In 1753 there were 1,118, whereas a document dated 1756 gives a total of 1,474” (p. 159). By patiently piecing together such information, Aynural concludes that due to their strategic importance in maintaining social peace in the capital, the Ottoman state established firmer controls over the millers' and bakers' guilds, thereby limiting members' opportunities for making large profits. In addition to state controls, the millers and bakers often suffered from heavy debts to the grain merchants. “In a sense,” Aynural concludes, “they paid the price for the successful functioning of the system, for it is indeed remarkable that during those years of Janissary uprisings, unremitting wars with Russia and the Napoleonic occupation of Egypt, the Ottoman government was still able to continue supplying bread to the inhabitants of its capital” (p. 184).
There are also several articles dealing with provinces such as Cairo and Damascus. Randi Deguilhem's work on mid-19th-century Damascus successfully challenges older notions by demonstrating that the builders' guilds were religiously mixed but that European penetration tended to increase religious tensions. Pascal Ghazaleh's article on late 18th-century Cairo is particularly interesting because of the manner in which she uses a comparative approach in utilizing four sources: French illustrations, an indigenous contemporary account of a guild parade, court records, and an income tax list (the firda). These sources “give four very different pictures” and allow for a multiangled investigation. The court records, for example, show that “leadership was not necessarily hereditary” nor were the guilds' “structures imposed from above by the state” (p. 252). In contrast, “the engravings, the procession, and the firda suggest in different ways that the guilds did not reflect the fragmentation of the production process; they were not organized along ethnic, religious, or geographic lines alone” (p. 252). Ghazaleh ends by emphasizing the need to go beyond the organizational study of 19th-century labor and to focus instead on “what prompted people to form, join and attempt to shape specific associations” (p. 254).
The book as a whole can be a bit challenging for one not familiar with some Ottoman terms or guild history. Nevertheless, there are a number of articles that could be useful for both undergraduate and graduate classes on premodern labor associations or Ottoman social history. For the specialist, the collection certainly adds to our knowledge and points to directions for further inquiry.
