At least twenty Indian states have larger populations than the majority of UN member-states. But such is the fetishism of the nation-state in modern academic life that Indian regional history and culture is a neglected field. It is refreshing, therefore, to read a collection of essays that delves deeply into one region, the modern state of Himachal Pradesh, and that the work is by a domiciled scholar with deep roots in the region itself.
Chetan Singh's Himalayan Histories: Economy, Polity, Religious Traditions comprises thirteen chapters and an introduction. All the chapters have been previously presented or published in various fora, so that they inevitably overlap. The subtitle, however, captures the two major chapter clusters: one is political economy (especially the pastoralist), the other is ritual life and ritual conflict. Beyond these, chapter 7 analyzes collective peasant protests, largely agreeing with James Scott's modification of E. P. Thompson's “moral economy.” Chapter 12 considers possible explanations for the well-known practice of fraternal polyandry in parts of the upper Himalaya. It suggests that a combination of ecology and economics explains a practice deemed unorthodox by most South Asians. Chapter 14 is also an outlier: it energetically describes the creation of the great colonial “hill station” of Simla as a project built on the backs of the hill peoples, plundering their timber forests and financed by the taxes of the whole British Empire in India.
The major arguments (excepting chapter 14) are for continuity rather than drastic change. Mughal suzerainty, Sikh overlordship, the short-lived Gorkha conquest in the early nineteenth century, British colonial rule itself, and finally Indian independence were, Singh suggests, all overlaid upon deep and enduring structures molded by physiography and religious culture.
The Republican regime (1947 to present) saw the introduction of universal franchise accompanied by energetic yet orderly political competition. Starting in the 1960s, Himachal had an actively developmental state, and one that was highly successful in education and infrastructure. But the political culture of the region, Singh argues, has endured through all this. Conflicts and the absorption of small territories by greater ones frequently occurred without changing the structure of village community life. Political conflict (chapters 5 and 6) is still symbolically enacted in the religious domain as struggles between powerful deities—which, Singh notes, are ultimately conflicts between their respective devotees. When a stable ruling authority emerged, it did not extirpate, but rather exacted homage from local gods, as at the annual autumn festival in the Kulu kingdom. This was when the supreme deity, patron of the ruling house, mounted a chariot escorted by the Raja and proceeded in procession to a field where “all the deotas [deities] of the realm were assembled … in a manner quite similar to courtiers.” Homage to the king and to his patron deity were thus enfolded in one ceremony (pp. 65–66).
But the small deities of the field and village and higher deities—sometimes symbolically assimilated to “high” gods of Hinduism—all coexisted and shared in devotion and offerings from the peasant population. Singh also proposes that local deities had preceded the Brahmanical high gods of mainstream Hinduism. The latter came sponsored by regional kings rather than village lords. The possibility that remoter villages were founded under the protection of regional kings out of wasteland grants to priests and gods is not considered. Allegiance to the small divinities of place remains strong. An interesting vignette recounts how disputes over the ritual placing of different gods in 2004 reflected political conflicts between the BJP and the Congress Party, as represented by rival members of the state legislature (p. 113).
Chapters 8–11 consider pastoralism in relation to the market and the ecosystem. Singh points to pastoral semi-nomadism as an adaptation to the seasonal variation in available biotic resources. He observes how it was adapted to draw nutrients from lands unusable for arable farming and transport them as animal excreta to fertilize pockets of arable land carved out of the mountains. Singh emphasizes that seasonally adjusted pastoralism across political boundaries was functionally necessary for a farming population placed in the hard environment of the Himalaya. Sheep even served as pack animals to link the very different economies of the Tibetan plateau and the Indian lowlands. Political boundaries were deliberately porous in order to permit these practices.
Overall, Himalayan Histories offers a valuable window into unique mountain worlds. It does, however, tend to assume that the world has changed little over time, that its practices are “age-old” (p. 8). Much information is taken from British district gazetteers and other works written around one hundred years ago, which are assumed to hold true before and after their own time. Considering his sources, Singh's “chronological window” is effectively the period between about 1800 and 1950. Yet, the mountains have surely changed through recent history. Pastoralism and farming across the world have a history of expansion and adaptation—and of failure and retreat. Mixed farming villages, Singh notes, carried their gods with them “as they settled in distant places” (p. 41).
Archaeologists and paleo-climatologists have identified long swings in monsoon precipitation through the centuries: periods of cooling and warming have alternated until the present warming. Even if written sources are few, the earth sciences have discovered much about the thousands of years since the end of the last Ice Age. It is ultimately a paradox that a historian should draw such an ahistorical picture of his subject.
