Rubina Raja's work follows the path of the unpublished thesis written by S. Patronos, Public Architecture and Civic Identity in Classical and Hellenistic Ionia: the Cases of Miletus and Priene (University of Oxford, 2002). The theoretical background of R.'s study is explained in the introduction (ch. 1, p. 1): ‘The process of urbanization and urban development was and is reliant on the existence and persistence of communities that require public spaces — which are the centre of the development of most urban societies and vice versa. Not all social sectors and classes had access to expressing and defining themselves through the public urban space, and the decisions about the layout and design were made by specific and exclusive groups. In general, however, public spaces were to a great extent a communal — although selective — expression of a local society's ideas about itself.’ More specifically, R.'s work is an archaeological study of the development of four cities in the eastern Roman provinces: Aphrodisias, Ephesos, Athens and Gerasa in Jordan, in the period ranging from 50 b.c. to a.d. 250.
The work comprises six chapters: an introduction, four case-study chapters (one for each city) based on empirical studies of the sites, and a final short comparative chapter (the most suggestive in my view) with a synthesis of the information regarding monuments (agoras, basilicas, stoas, porticoes, colonnaded streets, streets, city walls, main urban sanctuaries, theatres, bouleuteria and odeia, stadia, hippodromes and circuses, arches and gates). In the introduction (1–7), R. does not convincingly explain her choice of these four very dissimilar cities, except that they are well-preserved and thus provide a large choice of archaeological publications. The numismatic and epigraphic sources are not neglected, even if a greater use of epigraphy would have provided additional details on local identities. For example, the manner of funding theatres is different in Aphrodisias and Ephesus. In Aphrodisias, the steps involved in building and adorning the theatre successively include the logeion, the proskenion (in 28 b.c. by C. Iulius Zoilus, IAph2007 8.1 and 5), the support walls, the stairs, the pavings, the vault passages under the seats, the cunei (c. a.d. 40–60 by Aristocles Molossus, IAph2007 8.14, 82, 108, 111–13), the columns (in a.d. 138–161 by Ti. Claudius Zelus, IAph2007, 8, 85–1), the provision of 10,000 denarii for the seats (c. a.d. 150 by M. Ulpius Carminius Claudianus, CIG 2782), the alterations to the podium (in a.d. 211–217 by Aurelius Menestheus Skopas, IAph2007, 8.115). All of these steps share a common denominator: only private individuals paid, with the objective being to gradually increase the capacity of the theatre. However, in Ephesus it was usual for the city to pay for expensive works (IK, 16-Ephesos, 2034–2035; 2039–2040). The theatre construction and adornment in Aphrodisias is a prerogative of private euergetai. Benefactors also paid for the theatre at Ephesus, but the largest amounts of money were spent by the polis. As a consequence, the perception of the theatre by the inhabitants of the two cities was probably slightly different (in Aphrodisias the monument was built and adorned by a pure and continuous euergetic practice).
Furthermore, the regional context should be taken into account more precisely. For example, we know how powerful the rivalries between neighbouring cities were in the Greek East. Perhaps, certain monuments of Gerasa, such as the freestanding monumental arch and the hippodromos, ought to be examined in this particular context. According to R., the location of this arch (dating to a.d. 129–130 and commemorating Hadrian's visit to the city) is interesting because the arch was never intended to be incorporated into the city walls (155, fig. 70; 215). (Perhaps Hadrian's arch was intended to fix a limit of a planned but eventually aborted urban expansion?) This would be a striking and unusual location in the eastern Roman provinces. But the people of Gadara built a great arch 350 m outside the city wall, on the west, on the road to Tiberias (T. M. Weber, Gadara-Umm Qes: Untersuchungen zur Topographie. Geschichte, Architektur und der bildenden Kunst einer ‘Polis Hellenis’ im Ostjordanland 1 Gadara Decapolitana (2002), 23, fig. 5). Similarly, Gerasa's hippodromos (c. 250 m long) was comparable in size to Gadara's (c. 290 m long). These similarities suggest a rivalry between the two cities which is expressed in an agonistic manner.
Nonetheless, R.'s monograph is a valuable contribution to our field: a synthesis that is robustly documented with archaeological sources, well illustrated with photos and figures (93 figs), and includes useful discussions of urban development at the end of each case-study (chs 2–4). The concluding chapter is particularly interesting. R. convincingly demonstrates (ch. 6) that the cities used a disciplined and organized architectural language that had spread across the entire Roman world, but which was interpreted differently from city to city and from region to region. The shaping of public spaces is the result of a mix of Greek, Hellenistic, Roman and local traditions. The detailed synthesis and the comparisons of various groups of monuments show both the importance of these monuments for the regional identity of the cities, and the strictness of the architectural language. This book will be useful for any scholar of archaeology and for any student interested in the cities of the Roman East under the Empire.
