Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T01:04:42.405Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Unsteady turbulent buoyant plumes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 April 2016

M. J. Woodhouse*
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, University of Bristol, University Walk, Bristol BS8 1TW, UKSchool of Earth Science, University of Bristol, Wills Memorial Building, Queen’s Road, Bristol BS8 1RJ, UK
J. C. Phillips
Affiliation:
School of Earth Science, University of Bristol, Wills Memorial Building, Queen’s Road, Bristol BS8 1RJ, UK
A. J. Hogg
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, University of Bristol, University Walk, Bristol BS8 1TW, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: mark.woodhouse@bristol.ac.uk

Abstract

We model the unsteady evolution of turbulent buoyant plumes following temporal changes to the source conditions. The integral model is derived from radial integration of the governing equations expressing the evolution of mass, axial momentum and buoyancy in the plume. The non-uniform radial profiles of the axial velocity and density deficit in the plume are explicitly captured by shape factors in the integral equations; the commonly assumed top-hat profiles lead to shape factors equal to unity. The resultant model for unsteady plumes is hyperbolic when the momentum shape factor, determined from the radial profile of the mean axial velocity in the plume, differs from unity. The solutions of the model when source conditions are maintained at constant values are shown to retain the form of the well-established steady plume solutions. We demonstrate through a linear stability analysis of these steady solutions that the inclusion of a momentum shape factor in the governing equations that differs from unity leads to a well-posed integral model. Therefore, our model does not exhibit the mathematical pathologies that appear in previously proposed unsteady integral models of turbulent plumes. A stability threshold for the value of the shape factor is also identified, resulting in a range of its values where the amplitudes of small perturbations to the steady solutions decay with distance from the source. The hyperbolic character of the system of equations allows the formation of discontinuities in the fields describing the plume properties during the unsteady evolution, and we compute numerical solutions to illustrate the transient development of a plume following an abrupt change in the source conditions. The adjustment of the plume to the new source conditions occurs through the propagation of a pulse of fluid through the plume. The dynamics of this pulse is described by a similarity solution and, through the construction of this new similarity solution, we identify three regimes in which the evolution of the transient pulse following adjustment of the source qualitatively differs.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2016 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Spatial growth rates $\text{Re}({\it\sigma})$ as a function of the diffusion coefficient for (a) the Scase & Hewitt (2012) system with momentum diffusion (3.2), (b) the alternative form of the momentum diffusion equation (3.8) and (c) diffusion of buoyancy (3.11). In (a,b) different values of the momentum shape factor are shown, with $S=1$ (solid line), $S=1.5$ (dashed line) and $S=2$ (dash-dot line). In (c) the three branches of the growth rates are distinguished, with one branch corresponding to a real mode (solid line) and two branches that form a complex conjugate pair (dashed and dash-dot lines).

Figure 1

Figure 2.The exponents of the far-field algebraic growth rates of the amplitude of the volume flux perturbation, ${\it\mu}_{+}$ (dashed line) and ${\it\mu}_{-}$ (solid line), as functions of the shape factor $S$. The perturbation to the volume flux grows with increasing distance from the source when ${\it\mu}_{-}>0$, which occurs for $S<25/24$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The perturbations to the fluxes of volume, $Q/Q_{0}-1$ (a), momentum, $M/M_{0}-1$ (b), and buoyancy, $F/F_{0}-1$ (c), and to the plume radius, $b/b_{0}-1$ (d), the plume velocity, $W/W_{0}-1$ (e), and the reduced gravity, $G^{\prime }/G_{0}^{\prime }-1$ (f), as functions of the scaled distance from the source, $x$, for dimensionless times $t=0$ (orange), $t=10$ (red), $t=20$ (green), $t=30$ (blue), and $t=40$ (black). The momentum shape factor is fixed at a value $S=1.1>25/24$. The numerical solution scheme adopts a moving and expanding spatial grid with a fixed grid spacing of ${\rm\Delta}x=0.01$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Integral measures of the size of perturbations from the steady solutions for the volume flux, $\mathscr{I}(Q)$ (solid line), momentum flux, $\mathscr{I}(M)$ (dashed line), and buoyancy flux, $\mathscr{I}(F)$ (dotted line), as functions of the dimensionless time $t$, for a shape factor (a) $S=1.1>25/24$ and (b) $S=1.02<25/24$. The thick grey line illustrates the predicted growth rate of perturbations of $t^{2{\it\mu}_{+}}$ with (a) ${\it\mu}_{+}\approx -0.49$ for $S=1.1$ and (b) ${\it\mu}_{+}\approx 0.65$ for $S=1.02$ obtained from the far-field asymptotic analysis (4.12b).

Figure 4

Figure 5.The perturbation to the steady volume flux due to harmonic oscillation of the source buoyancy flux with period $2{\rm\pi}$ as a function of the scaled spatial coordinate $x$ at dimensionless time $t=99$ for a shape factor of (a) $S=1.05>25/24$ and (b) $S=1.03<25/24$. The red dashed line illustrates an algebraic growth of perturbations of the form $cx^{{\it\mu}}$, where (a) ${\it\mu}=-0.12$ for $S=1.05$ and (b) ${\it\mu}=0.26$ for $S=1.03$. The prefactor $c$ is selected to provide an envelope of the numerical solution.

Figure 5

Figure 6.The scaled width, $B(z)=z\widehat{Q}/\widehat{M}^{1/2}$, the scaled velocity, $W(z)=z^{-1/3}\widehat{M}/\widehat{Q}$, and the buoyancy flux, $\widehat{F}$, as functions of the distance from source, $z$ at dimensionless times $t=2.4$ (orange), $t=4.9$ (red), $t=7.4$ (green) and $t=9.9$ (blue) for an increase in buoyancy flux $(\mathscr{F}=0.05)$ at $t=0$ and with shape factor $S=1.1$. In (b) the scaled velocity $W=z^{-1/3}$, corresponding to the steady velocity field of the original buoyancy flux at the source, and the scaled velocity $W=z^{-1/3}20^{1/3}$, corresponding to the steady velocity field associated with the new buoyancy flux, are plotted with dashed lines. In (c) the original buoyancy flux, $F=F_{0}=0.05$, and the new steady-state buoyancy flux, $F=F_{1}=1$, are plotted with dashed lines.

Figure 6

Figure 7.The similarity solution for the volume flux, $\widehat{q}({\it\eta})$, the momentum flux, $\widehat{m}({\it\eta})$, and the buoyancy flux, $\widehat{f}({\it\eta})$, as functions of the similarity variable ${\it\eta}$ for shape factor $S=1.1$ and an increase in the source buoyancy flux $\mathscr{F}=0.05$ (plotted with solid lines). Also plotted are results from the direct numerical integration of the governing equations (dashed lines), although the two sets of curves are so close in values that they are virtually indistinguishable. The values ${\it\eta}_{c1}$, ${\it\eta}_{m}$ and ${\it\eta}_{s}$ are also marked. These correspond respectively to the boundary between the time-dependent part of the solution and the steady state associated with the new buoyancy flux at the source, the location of a contact discontinuity and the location of a shock that marks the interface between the unsteady evolution and the steady state associated with the original buoyancy flux at the source.

Figure 7

Figure 8.The scaled width, $B(z)=z\widehat{Q}/\sqrt{\widehat{M}}$, the scaled velocity, $W(z)=z^{-1/3}\widehat{M}/\widehat{Q}$, and the buoyancy flux, $F$, as functions of the distance from source, $z$, at dimensionless times $t=4.5$ (orange), $t=9.5$ (red), $t=14.5$ (green) and $t=19.5$ (blue) for a decrease in buoyancy flux $(\mathscr{F}=2)$ at $t=0$ and with shape factor $S=1.1$. In (b) the scaled velocity $W=z^{-1/3}$, corresponding to the steady velocity field of the original buoyancy flux at the source, and the scaled velocity $W=z^{-1/3}2^{-1/3}$, corresponding to the steady velocity field associated with the new buoyancy flux, are plotted with dashed lines.

Figure 8

Figure 9.The similarity solution for the volume flux, $\widehat{q}({\it\eta})$, the momentum flux, $\widehat{m}({\it\eta})$, and the buoyancy flux, $\widehat{f}({\it\eta})$, as functions of the similarity variable ${\it\eta}$ for shape factor $S=1.1$ and a decrease in the source buoyancy flux $\mathscr{F}=2$ (plotted with solid lines). Also plotted are results from the direct numerical integration of the governing equations (dashed lines), although the two sets of curves are so close in values that they are virtually indistinguishable. The values ${\it\eta}_{c1}$, ${\it\eta}_{m}$ and ${\it\eta}_{c2}$ are also marked. These correspond respectively to the boundary between the time-dependent part of the solution and the steady state associated with the new buoyancy flux at the source, the location of a contact discontinuity and the location of the interface between the unsteady evolution and the steady steady associated with the original buoyancy flux at the source.

Figure 9

Figure 10.The scaled width, $B(z)=z\widehat{Q}/\sqrt{\widehat{M}}$, the scaled velocity, $W(z)=z^{-1/3}\widehat{M}/\widehat{Q}$, and the buoyancy flux, $F$, as functions of the distance from source, $z$, at dimensionless times $t=4.5$ (orange), $t=9.5$ (red), $t=14.5$ (green) and $t=19.5$ (blue) for a decrease in buoyancy flux $\mathscr{F}=20$ at $t=0$ and with shape factor $S=1.1$. In (b) the scaled velocity $W=z^{-1/3}$, corresponding to the steady velocity field of the original buoyancy flux at the source, and the scaled velocity $W=z^{-1/3}20^{-1/3}$, corresponding to the steady velocity field associated with the new buoyancy flux, are plotted with dashed lines.

Figure 10

Figure 11.The similarity solution for the volume flux, $\widehat{q}({\it\eta})$, the momentum flux, $\widehat{m}({\it\eta})$, and the buoyancy flux, $\widehat{f}({\it\eta})$, as functions of the similarity variable ${\it\eta}$ for shape factor $S=1.1$ and a decrease in the source buoyancy flux $\mathscr{F}=20$ (plotted with solid lines). Also plotted are results from the direct numerical integration of the governing equations (dashed lines), although the two sets of curves are so close in values that they are virtually indistinguishable. The values ${\it\eta}_{c1}$, ${\it\eta}_{m}$, ${\it\eta}_{s}$, ${\it\eta}_{c3}$ and ${\it\eta}_{c2}$ are also marked. These correspond respectively to the boundary between the time-dependent part of the solution and the steady state associated with the new buoyancy flux at the source, the location of a contact discontinuity, the location of an internal shock between flow states, the location of a continuous transition and the location of the interface between the unsteady evolution and the steady state associated with the original buoyancy flux at the source.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Trajectories in the phase plane of solutions to the steady plume equations with the diffusive regularization of Scase & Hewitt (2012) with $F_{0}=1$, ${\it\alpha}=0.1$, ${\it\kappa}=0.1$ and $S=1$. The autonomous system has a single fixed point (denoted by the black point in the figure) that corresponds to the steady pure-plume solution of Morton et al. (1956) with a modification for the diffusive term (given by (3.3)). The fixed point is a saddle, with two stable directions and two unstable directions, shown as bold solid lines in the figure, with arrows denoting the stability of the trajectories. Additional trajectories, corresponding to solutions with non-pure-plume initial conditions, are shown as thin grey lines.

Figure 12

Figure 13.The stable and unstable trajectories through fixed points in the phase plane of solutions to the steady plume equations with the diffusive regularization of Scase & Hewitt (2012) with $F_{0}=1$, ${\it\alpha}=0.1$ and ${\it\kappa}=0.1$ for momentum shape factor $S=1$ (solid lines), $S=1.5$ (dashed line) and $S=2.0$ (dotted line).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Trajectories in the phase plane of solutions to the steady plume equations with the diffusive regularization (3.8) with $F_{0}=1$, ${\it\alpha}=0.1$, ${\it\kappa}=0.1$ and $S=1$. The autonomous system has a single fixed point (denoted by the black point in the figure) that corresponds to the steady pure-plume solution of Morton et al. (1956) with a modification for the diffusive term (given by (3.9)). The fixed point is a saddle, with two stable directions and two unstable directions, shown as bold solid lines in the figure, with arrows denoting the stability of the trajectories. Additional trajectories, corresponding to solutions with non-pure-plume initial conditions, are shown as thin grey lines.

Figure 14

Figure 15.The stable and unstable trajectories through fixed points in the phase plane of solutions to the steady plume equations with the diffusive regularization (3.8) with $F_{0}=1$, ${\it\alpha}=0.1$ and ${\it\kappa}=0.1$ for momentum shape factor $S=1$ (solid lines), $S=1.5$ (dashed line) and $S=2.0$ (dotted line).

Figure 15

Figure 16.The scaled width of the plume, $\widehat{q}/\sqrt{\widehat{m}}$, as a function of the similarity variable, ${\it\eta}$, for $\mathscr{F}=0.05$ (green line), $\mathscr{F}=2$ (red line) and $\mathscr{F}=20$ (blue line) and shape factor $S=1.1$.