In an 1867 treatise on diamonds and precious stones, Harry EmanuelFootnote 1 writes the following:
[I]n the process of cutting, flaws and imperfections are often laid bare, which go much deeper than the appearance of the rough diamond would predict; and, on the other hand, the colour, apparent in the rough stone, is sometimes found to arise from the presence of flaws or specks, which are removed in cutting, thus leaving the stone white. (70)
From such a description, it is easy to see the parallel to the female condition, and particularly the female condition, as it is popularly portrayed in the mid-nineteenth century. With the emphasis on purity and hidden flaws, it is not difficult to understand why the diamond could hold such symbolic significance for the female wearer, by functioning as an indicator not only of personal wealth, but of moral worth. Trollope's The Eustace Diamonds (1871), a novel which can be said to revolve around this metaphor, is essentially a novel about worth: absolute vs. transitory worth, actual vs. symbolic worth, and especially monetary vs. moral worth. Lizzie's character, the legal issues surrounding the diamonds, and the convoluted marriage arrangements which are perpetuated by or affected by the presence of the diamonds are all, in one way or another, concerned with the different types of value – moral, symbolic, monetary, etc. – placed upon commodity objects: objects which, by their very nature, can never be permanently owned, as their value lies in their exchangeability. I will return later to a discussion of the diamonds themselves. There has been considerable recent commentary on the role of commodities – whatever their worth – and of commodity culture within Trollope's novel;Footnote 2 such readings, however, concentrate on the purely symbolic role played by commodity objects – and primarily the diamonds – in the novel; it is worth, by contrast, examining how Trollope utilizes the discourses and associations of actual commodity objects as he deploys them within his fictional world. This paper will examine the ways in which Trollope uses four commodity objects in particular – books of poetry, hunting horses, the safe box, and finally, the Eustace diamonds themselves – and the contemporary discourses surrounding them to defend the essentially mercenary character of Lizzie as a woman shaped by the demands that a commodity-driven society places upon her.
In 1865, Ruskin placed the acquisition of a library of books high on the list of priorities for the home-building man:
[E]very man who honestly exerts himself may, I think, still provide, for himself and his family, good shoes, good gloves, strong harness for his cart or carriage horses, and stout leather binding for his books. And I would urge upon every young man, as the beginning of his due and wise provision for his household, to obtain as soon as he can, by the severest economy, a restricted, servicable, and steadily – however slowly – increasing, series of books for uses through life; making his little library, of all the furniture in his room, the most studied and decorative piece. (7)
In addition to gendering the reading habit, Ruskin very obviously attributes a moral value to the acquisition of books; his emphasis in the first place on the bindings and in the second place on selectivity equates the well-chosen book with economy, domestic stability, good breeding, and, most importantly, aesthetic sensibility and good taste. It is curious that for Ruskin the physical quality of the book is important, more so even than the literary content which it contains. There is an implication that, as with diamonds, worth is not only internal but, more importantly, an externally visible factor, which can be lost through sloppy or careless presentation. In The Eustace Diamonds, Trollope's ironic application of these associations to Lizzie not only reflects on her character, but also draws into question the validity of such attributions of value. For Lizzie, books, and especially poetry, are an important part of her life; it is often unclear, however, how their worth to her can be broken down. Poetry is treated within this novel as a commodity item, directly parallel to diamonds themselves in the ways in which it is used to capture the attention and display inner worth: poetry is not so much a work of art in The Eustace Diamonds as it is a product to be bought, handled, and utilized in the marketing of oneself. Poetry is clearly a luxury commodity, in that it is frequently used as an indicator of wealth, leisure, and polished education. It is also a commodity which, when invested in, pays back its purchaser with the reflected aura of the poet, conveying an impression of sensitivity, intelligence, and moral fortitude (in a way, Trollope implies, that French novels very definitely do not).
Trollope somewhat contemptuously notes that Lizzie's understanding of the poetry she reads is superficial, and that her preference is for sordid novels; nevertheless it is also clear that Lizzie recognizes the symbolic worth of “high” poetry, enough to wish to deceive not only her admirers, but also herself. We are aware from very early in the novel that Lizzie utilizes the respectability and prestige associated with books of poetry to seduce her first husband, Sir Florian: “Lizzie read poetry well, and she read verses to him, – sitting very near to him, almost in the dark, with a shaded lamp throwing its light on her book” (7; vol. 1, ch. 1). Trollope has made it clear that the poetry in this situation is not what is important, but the idea of poetry is enough to capture Sir Florian's imagination, and in addition the physical act of reading provides an excuse for intimacy. Sir Florian is himself interested more in Lizzie than in the poetry, and it is the physicality of Lizzie's reading – her lips moving, her close proximity, the sweetness of her voice – which charms him: “He was astonished to find how sweet a thing was poetry. By himself he could never read a line, but as it came from her lips it seemed to charm him” (7; vol. 1, ch. 1). Trollope also makes it clear that for Sir Florian, aristocrat and hedonist though he is, the prestigious status of intellectual or spiritualist, of respectability and good-breeding, associated with the reading of poetry is desirable: “It was a new pleasure, and one which, though he had ridiculed it, he had so often coveted!” (7; vol. 1, ch. 1).
In Lizzie, however, the ability to read and apply poetry does not quite indicate that she is the possessor of such qualities. Trollope describes her learning as one of her marketable qualities when Lizzie is first widowed: “We have said that she is clever. We must add that she had in truth studied much. She spoke French, understood Italian, and read German. . . . Of things to be learned by reading she knew much, having really taken diligent trouble with herself. She had learned much poetry by heart, and could apply it” (18; vol. 1, ch. 2). In the scene just described, we see Lizzie “applying” her poetry to the task of acquiring a husband; like her beauty and her reputation for wealth, her way with poetry is a tradable commodity which can be used to advantage in the marriage market. Thus, the application to which Lizzie puts reading and poetry is made very clear when she comes to search for a second husband. The scene between Lizzie and her prospective mother-in-law, Lady Fawn, is a telling one:
“There,” she said, stretching out her hand backwards and clasping the book which lay upon the small table, – “there; that shall be my guide. That will teach me how to do my duty by my noble husband.”
Lady Fawn in some surprise took the book from Lizzie's hand, and found that it was the Bible. “You certainly can't do better, my dear, than read your Bible,” said Lady Fawn, – but there was more of censure than of eulogy in the tone of her voice. (85; vol. 1, ch. 9)
There is a tension in this scene between the object – the Bible –, the associations of the object, and their application: we are aware that, had Lady Fawn not been warned previously of Lizzie's bad reputation, her gesture might have been warmly applauded. Lizzie's sentiment is entirely correct, and Trollope furthermore makes it clear that her worst condemners – Mrs Hittaway and Mr. Camperdown – are unlikely to be any better acquainted with their bibles than she is, as both are apt to use moral discourses in support of their own positions – precisely what Lizzie herself is doing. In respect to her later choices of husband, we see Lizzie employing the same tactics she used on Sir Florian: “She did not rise, or even give him her hand, but there was a spot close beside her on which it was presumed that he would seat himself. She had a volume of Byron in her hand” (237; vol. 1, ch. 26). Once Lizzie has no one around to seduce however, she loses interest in poetry and Trollope invites us to equate her “real” character with coarseness – novel reading: “Those first ten days of August went very slowly with Lady Eustace. ‘Queen Mab’ got itself poked away, and was heard of no more. But there were other books. A huge box full of novels had come down . . . and the studies of Portray castle were confined to novels” (201; vol. 1, ch. 22). This loss of interest, however, is clearly in part because, without an audience, Lizzie cannot enjoy the reaction her poetry has on others. Once again, Lizzie uses the associations of poetry with romantic sensibility and the physicality necessitated by the act of reading, to seduce her admirer. Nevertheless, there is nothing inherently deceptive about Lizzie's tactic, except that it is a tactic – Lizzie really does enjoy her poetry, but she enjoys it not for its own sake but for how it makes her view herself and how others view her, and it is her enjoyment and not the actual poetry which is being used to seduce.
Furthermore, it is clear that for Lizzie poetry has more than a simply functional purpose; as mentioned earlier, the associations of poetry and poetry reading are attractive enough to make Lizzie wish to deceive not only other people but also herself. Lizzie wishes to actually be a poetry reader, and all that that implies, although she is not entirely successful at applying herself to being genuine: “Her darling ‘Queen Mab’ must be read without the coarse, inappropriate, every-day surroundings of a drawing-room; and it was now manifest to her that, unless she could get up much earlier in the morning, or come out to her reading after sunset, the knob of rock would not avail her” (196–97; vol. 1, ch. 21). Nevertheless, however base her genuine concerns and feelings might be, poetry does strike a chord with her, and we are invited to sympathize as well as laugh at her soulful musings:
“‘Each stain of earthliness had passed away.’ Ha; – yes. They will pass away, and become instinct with beauty and grace.” A dim idea came upon her that when this happy time should arrive, no one would claim her necklace from her, and that the man at the stables would not be so disagreeably punctual in sending in his bill. . . . What a tawdry world was this, in which clothes and food and houses are necessary! (197; vol. 1, ch. 21)
Lizzie's musings on the word “stain” again bring to mind Emanuel's comments on the connotations of “purity” surrounding diamonds. Trollope's emphasis is frequently on the materiality of Lizzie's books: she may not be able to engage on a completely disinterested level with these poems, but their physical presence lends her a feeling of superiority which is clearly important to her. Indeed, these poems act, through their physical presence, as a stimulus for her imagination – even if they do not do so in the way that poems are conventionally supposed to – adding yet another level to their emblematic worth as commodities. Although the picture this gives us of Lizzie is somewhat ambivalent, it is nevertheless the case that Trollope is in some ways defending Lizzie's character against the charges of ignorance, silliness, superficiality, shallowness, and so forth, which reader and society might be tempted to bring against her. As the various attitudes to poetry reveal, Lizzie is not alone in her manipulation of poetry as a commodity: she genuinely enjoys it, if not in the expected way, and that she can so easily fool her contemporaries into thinking her an accomplished reader and enthusiast indicates clearly that they are as unversed in its actual artistic value as she herself is. Trollope implies that it is the hypocritical value placed upon poetry as a commodity item by Lizzie's society – which is guilty of commodifying poetry in this way – that has prompted Lizzie into using it in the way she does: she may be a scheming young woman, but she is also an intelligent young woman playing the game of courtship and marriage by the rules which have been laid down by society for her. If Trollope had meant to expose Lizzie as an unscrupulous or hypocritical manipulator who uses a pretended love of poetry as a weapon, a different narrative strategy, such as the juxtaposition of Lizzie with a true lover of poetry, would have been more effective. This brings us, then, to another of the status indicators present in the novel: the hunt and hunting horses.
The incident at Portray in which Lizzie is convinced that she must purchase horses and join in the season's hunting is another instance of Trollope's emphasis on the social tension between actual and symbolic value. In 1865, Trollope published a series of “Hunting Sketches” in the Pall Mall Gazette, one of which concerned women who hunt. He wrote:
It is a pernicious vice, that of succumbing to the beast that carries you, and making yourself, as it were, his servant, instead of keeping him ever as yours. I will not deny that I have known a lady to fall into this vice from hunting; but so also have I known ladies to marry their music-masters and to fall in love with their footmen. But not on that account are we to have no music-masters and no footmen. (76)
By this, Trollope seems to be highlighting the very real, but perhaps unspeakable burdens, which are a part of the ownership of horses as commodities. Although this is a vice which he describes as equally distasteful in a man as a women, it is interesting that, in this passage, he uses the analogy of inappropriate marriage or love affairs to emphasize its “perniciousness.” It is not, he implies elsewhere, at all becoming to be too focused on the physicality of one's horse – that is to say, the need to choose, purchase, transport, stable, feed, and so forth, one's property. This is precisely the dilemma he uses to indicate Lizzie's insecurity in her new independent social position. At this point in her career, Lizzie is conscious both of her precarious social position – she has failed to entice either Frank Greystock or Lord Fawn into marriage – and her dwindling resources, as her supply of ready cash is sacrificed to her own societal ambition and to exploitative associates. We are given a sympathetic description of Lizzie's dismay at just how much it will cost her to own the two horses necessary to take part in the hunting party:
[H]er feeling of cautious fear in regard to money had received a shock. Mrs. Carbuncle had told her that a couple of horses fit to carry her might perhaps cost her about £180. Lord George had received the commission, and the cheque required from her had been for £320. Of course she had written the cheque without a word, but it did begin to occur to her that hunting was an expensive amusement. (337; vol. 1, ch. 37)
Furthermore, the expense leads her to question and doubt her new friendships, indicating both the superficiality of those friendships, and her at least partial awareness of that superficiality: “Was the game worth the candle? She was by no means sure that she liked Mrs. Carbuncle very much. And though she liked Lord George very well, could it be possible that he bought the horses for £90 each and had charged her £160?” (338; vol. 1, ch. 37). Nevertheless they are a necessity for Lizzie as they serve a variety of functions unconnected to the actual act of hunting: as luxury items they confirm her wealth both to those who would doubt her because of the controversy relating to the diamonds, and those who would doubt the extent or reality of her income – which is the factor which makes her most eligible in the marriage market. As Frank asks her somewhat incredulously: “You don't mean to put up all their horses, Lizzie?” (281; vol. 1, ch. 31). Frank, as the reader is aware, is as adept as Lizzie at managing the social-financial game being played throughout the novel; he is however, less given than she to flights of fancy and self-indulgence. Lizzie is both worried by and somewhat ignorant about the actual cost of hunting, but she is determined to show that she can hold her own in this status situation. She explains her economic arrangements:
“Well, not all. Lord George and Sir Griffin are to keep theirs at Troon, or Kilmarnock, or somewhere. The ladies will bring two apiece, and I shall have two of my own.”
“And carriage-horses and hacks?”
“The carriage-horses are here, – of course.” (281; vol. 1, ch. 31)
Both Frank and the pragmatic Mrs. Macnulty are quick to point out that her attempts at economy will not do much to dent the expense of this extravagance: “It will cost you a great deal of money, Lizzie,” says Frank, and: “‘That's just what I tell her,’ said Mrs. Macnulty” (281; vol. 1, ch. 31). Although Lizzie is aware of the truth in their warnings, however, the implied criticism of her spending urges her not to caution but to a defensive outburst: “I've been living here, not spending one shilling for the last two months, and all for the sake of economy; yet people think that no woman was ever left so rich. Surely I can afford to see a few friends for one month in the year” (281; vol. 1, ch. 31). For Lizzie to have confidence in herself and to inspire confidence in others, it is necessary for her to show willingness when it comes to investing in the extravagances of aristocratic life.
In addition to functioning as an emblem for the security of her actual wealth and social position, for Lizzie and her companions – particularly the other two women – the hunt is a courtship ritual in which Lizzie must prove that she can hold her own. R. S. Surtees,Footnote 3 whose popular novels and sketches about hunting tally well with Trollope's own portrayals, writes in Fox Hunting: “Hounds, we maintain, have always been great conducers to country society, conviviality, and consequently matrimony” (199), and he furthermore exclaims, in his collection of essays and sketches entitled The Analysis of the Field: “Let ladies come on horseback, especially if they are pretty, for then the gentlemen can make up to them through their horses” (294). Flirtation, and even serious husband hunting, was, it seems, a recognized aspect of the hunt. In his Hunting Sketches, Trollope writes of popular opinion:
There are two accusations which the more demure portion of the world is apt to advance against hunting ladies, – or, as I should better say, against hunting as an amusement for ladies. It leads to flirting, they say, – to flirting of a sort which mothers would not approve; and it leads to fast habits, – to ways and thoughts which are of the horse horsey, – and of the stable, strongly tinged with the rack and the manger. (74)
Again, Trollope seems to indicate that, for women at least, the hunt carried specific connotations of marriage and sexuality which, “tinged with the rack and the manger” associated a distasteful materiality (possibly financial) with flirtation and the “hunt” for a husband. Surtees goes even further, describing a scene which is very close to that in Trollope's novel:
When women do ride they generally ride like the very devil. There is no medium with them. They either “go” to beat the men, or they do not “go” at all. We have seen some uncommon performers among women, performers that would put nine-tenths of the men to the blush. We are puzzled whether to give the palm to the single or to the married women in this respect; but, as they single are most interesting, perhaps the preference will be yielded to them. (“Analysis of the Hunting Field” 295)
Surtees's language seems to deal with the woman in the same terms it would deal with a fine horse, as the word “performer” indicates, emphasizing the ulterior motives he credits to these women; that they put the men “to blush” seems to infer that they not only excel the men in hunting spirit, but also that their behaviour could be construed as shameful. And, as Surtees points out, it is the single women in which this trait is “most interesting.” The race between Lizzie and the haughty Lucinda clearly demonstrates that it is matrimony, and not the bedraggled fox, which is being hunted:
[S]he was not only happy but comfortable. The leaping was delightful, and her horse galloped with her as though his pleasure was as great as her own. She thought that she was getting nearer to Lucinda. For her, in her heart, Lucinda was the quarry. If she could only pass Lucinda! That there were any hounds she had altogether forgotten. She only knew that two or three men were leading the way, of whom her cousin Frank was one, that Lucinda Roanoke was following them closely, and that she was gaining upon Lucinda Roanoke. (352; vol. 1, ch. 38)
In this sense, the horses are a symbol not only of Lizzie's matrimonial desirability, but also of her freedom and independence – independence which is largely due to the size of her income. Here again, therefore, it seems that Trollope's portrayal of Lizzie is designed in part to defend her against a charge of superficiality, immorality, and stupidity. Although it is easy to see Lizzie as spending stupidly and recklessly in a vulgar attempt to impress, it is also clear that she is simply adhering to the expectation laid upon her by an unrelenting society: a society which expects wealth to play wealthy games, and which will be reluctant to grant a husband if these expectations are not met. The comparison to Lucinda is likewise favourable: although it throws into focus the scheming nature of Lizzie's husband-hunting, it also shows clearly why she must act in this way; Lucinda may be more “true” to her own nature, but by conforming to the idealized views of marriage which are hypocritically used by society to judge Lizzie, she makes herself unpleasant, gains the scorn and dislike of those around her, and ultimately destroys herself. The message is clear: women have no choice but to play this game of deception and manipulation, and Lizzie's crime is not so much that she does so, as that she does so badly, or perhaps on too grand a scale. As Mr. Camperdown later says, it is acceptable for a widow to pilfer the silver cutlery, but to do so with a priceless diamond necklace is another matter entirely. As we shall see in the discussion of the diamond necklace itself, Trollope seems to be implying that Lizzie is condemned unfairly: accused of immorality, her real crime is too much independence and success, which are anathema to the hypocritical society which formed her.
The third object this paper will examine, Lizzie's safe-box, is perhaps representative of the most ironic use to which Trollope puts a commodity object in the course of the novel. The box is, first and foremost, a product of and symbol for Lizzie's stubbornness, and the discourses which surrounded the development and manufacture of safes and strongboxes in this period is played upon to explore the issue of ownership and independence yet again. As Lizzie so frequently admits, the diamonds are of no monetary value to her, and they are both a burden and constant worry; the safe-box is the method by which they are made quite literally a weight upon her conscience: “The strong box, which was so heavy that she could barely lift it herself, was now in her London bedroom” (41; vol. 1, ch. 5).
Mrs. Beeton, in her Hints to Housewives, writes that: “Burglary and Theft are two of the bugbears of the householder's life, and both may be deprived of most of their terrors by means of insurance” (43). It is interesting to note that it is in insurance – the ability to regain the monetary value of an item after theft – that Mrs. Beeton advises the homeowner to place trust, rather than in any means of keeping possession of the actual item itself. In this sense, it is easy to see why the idea of the diamonds as an heirloom, a continuing and immutable symbol for the possessing family, should be such a contentious one. That safe boxes were of dubious utility against thieves and burglars is clear from the newspapers of the time; a good example being the “lock controversy” which was spawned by the display of strong boxes in the Great Exhibition. Challenged by the presence of American safe and lock manufacturers, the British manufacturers were forced to reluctantly admit that their locks, previously believed to be impregnable, could in fact be picked by their opponents, as was stated in the Times in 1851:
The lock controversy continues a subject of great interest at the Crystal Palace, and, indeed, in now become of general importance. We believed before the exhibition opened that we had the best locks in the world, and among us Bramah and Chubb were reckoned quite as impregnable as Gibralter . . . it seems cruel at this time of day, when men have been taught to look at their bunches of keys and at their drawers and safes with something like confidence, to scatter that feeling to the winds. (“Great Exhibition” 5)
There were at least eleven pieces printed between August 1851 and September 1851 alone dealing with “the lock controversy,” appearing in Letters to the Editor, Classified Ads, and Reviews of the Great Exhibition, amongst other sections, all debating the impregnability of the British Chubb and Bramah safes, as various safe manufacturers challenged their opponents publicly to pick the locks of their safes – and many of those opponents succeeded. What is perhaps most significant about the controversy, however, when compared to Trollope's novel, is the association of security of possessions with attention-fixing publicity: there is little doubt that the ostentatious display of the safe box in part prompted the attempts at safe-cracking. That the strongbox was both a challenge and a temptation to thieves is clear from such contemporary discussion, and the safe-box, in Lizzie's case, raises a complicated question: was Lizzie in fact guilty of anything more than trying to protect her property in the face of both multiple threats and official disinterest in her rights? Like the safe boxes put so prominently and temptingly on display at the Great Exhibition, Lizzie with her famous and controversial diamonds is a conspicuous target. It is all very well for Mrs. Beeton to place her faith in insurance, but Lizzie unfortunately cannot: the very lawyers are against her, and she, knowing that public opinion is likely to be against her in this issue, cannot trust the diamonds to any creditable (or disreputable) trustee, for fear that they might hand them over to Mr. Camperdown against her wishes. Her paranoia is clear, and the safe seems to stand in her mind as a bulwark between herself and the lawyer, even if it cannot actually keep the jewels safely in her possession: “which box, for aught she knew, myrmidons from Mr. Camperdown might carry off during her absence from the house?” (43; vol. 1, ch. 5). Lizzie, aware of the negative implications of guilt or at least uncertainty that the safe imparts, is anxious to play down the associations of the strong box: “Well, – yes; only it isn't a safe. A safe is a great big thing. I had it made especially for the diamonds Sir. Florian gave me” (45; vol. 1, ch. 5). Much as with the “lock controversy,” Lizzie's usage of the strong box makes her attempts at keeping hold of what she believes to be her property a matter of public spectacle, and as comical as her discomfort is, we are made as aware as she is of the vulnerability such spectacle imposes on the jewels:
The iron box was again put into the carriage; and was used by Lizzie as a footstool. This might have been very well, had there been no necessity for them changing their train. At Troon the porter behaved well, and did not struggle much as he carried it from the carriage on to the platform. But at Kilmarnock, where they met the train from Glasgow, the big footman interfered again, and the scene was performed under the eyes of a crowd of people. (38; vol. 2, ch. 44)
If the safe represents Lizzie's claim to ownership of the jewels, it also represents the public scrutiny of that claim and implies that Lizzie “doth protest too much.” Andrew Miller, in his examination of symbolic commodity in the novel, suggests that: “this box becomes a visible emblem of the diamonds’ narrative invisibility” (163). It is more accurate, however, to say that the box is an emblem of Lizzie's desire for their invisibility: a desire which, because of the connotations surrounding the object of the safe, is thwarted. It is ironic that, by stealing the box without the diamonds, the thieves both remove the doubts concerning Lizzie's rights of ownership and render the diamonds more secure and invisible than could the safe itself:
The enterprising adventurers had, indeed, stolen the iron case, but they had stolen nothing else. The reader must not suppose that because Lizzie had preserved her jewels, she was therefore a consenting party to the abstraction of the box. The theft had been a genuine theft, planned with great skill, carried out with much ingenuity, one in the perpetuation of which money had been spent, – a theft which for a while baffled the police of England, and which was supposed to be very creditable to those who had been engaged in it. But the box, and nothing but the box, had fallen into the hands of the thieves. (45; vol. 2, ch. 44)
By stressing Lizzie's lack of premeditation, Trollope reminds us of one thing: although Lizzie has been proven guilty of greed, self-interest, and numerous counts of perjury, her crimes have all been attempts to retain possession of what is, arguably and perhaps lawfully (Trollope leaves us in some doubt about this point), her own property. As the police conclude at the end of the novel, it is doubtful whether or not she can be accused of theft. It is with this object in particular, then, and the controversy which surrounds it after the theft, that our understanding of Lizzie's character becomes more sympathetic: the unwieldy and inconvenient safe marks Lizzie clearly as a victim, as a woman who strives only to protect what is, for the moment at least, her property, in the face of unhelpful and even malicious officials. By leaving the question of the legal ownership open at the end of the novel, Trollope even implies that in some ways the necklace is Lizzie's by right of conquest: after all of her successful work on Sir Florian, what right have his relatives to deny his stupidity and their own failure to protect family interest, and reclaim her hard-won spoils? Lizzie's position may not be “right,” but nor is it any more wrong than that of the society which condemns her.
We return finally then, as promised, to the Eustace Diamonds themselves. The Eustace Diamonds themselves are both the most prominent and the most invisible of the commodity objects given importance in the novel, and Trollope uses them, and the contemporary discourses which surrounded women's jewellery, to comment both on legal ownership in relation to women, and the morality of female adornment. In 1867, Harry Emanuel wrote:
The diamond occupies the highest rank amongst precious stones, and possesses an intrinsic value in almost every part of the globe. . . . Diamonds follow the same laws which govern the value of every other commodity – those of supply and demand – and as the production of these gems has diminished, and the number of wearers greatly increased, the price has gone on augmenting, and no doubt will continue to augment, unless some unforeseen occurance, such as the discovery of a new diamond mine, or other source of large production, takes place. (86–88)
Diamonds, clearly, were an ultimate synecdoche of commodity wealth; but perhaps more importantly for a discussion of Trollope's novel, they were a symbol of commodity wealth which were associated predominantly with women and women's ownership. Emanuel indicates their “intrinsic” value, but for Lizzie this value is problematic to say the least. Madam de Barrera indicates a different sort of value in her Reference De Barrera1860 monograph, Gems and Jewels Footnote 4:
Precious Stones and Gems, may at first seem but a frivolous subject. The mention suggests a jeweller's show-rooms, or the toilet of a rich and elegant woman, whose magnificent diamonds evidence her taste and her wealth, satisfying at once the requirements of her station, and gratifiying the vanity of eclipsing rivals less favoured by the blind goddess. (vii)
Trollope applies all of these characteristics – wealth, elegance, vanity, and, as de Barrera implies, superficiality – to Lizzie and her diamonds; however, the negative connotations which de Barrara seeks to avoid in her treatise are also problematized (although in a different manner)Footnote 5 in The Eustace Diamonds. Again, Trollope seems to defend Lizzie, as one thing is made consistently clear throughout the novel: Lizzie's excesses of behaviour can be attributed to her desire for a husband, and her desire for a husband is itself attributable to nothing more than her need for fiscal security and her desire for a comfortable life. As Thad Logan points out in The Victorian Parlour: “Although women . . . were closely linked in the cultural field with consumption, the question of ownership on the part of women was problematic throughout the nineteenth century” (95). This is one of the questions with which Trollope seems to be particularly concerned, and through which he problematizes a complete condemnation of Lizzie's character and behaviour. Trollope, by contrasting the acknowledgement of Lizzie's right to Portray with the rabid denial of her right to the comparatively worthless diamonds, brings to a head the questions about the absolute value of ownership which his other portrayals of commodity objects in the novel have raised.
Madam de Barrera indicates one way in which diamonds were of a particular use to women in Victorian society:
No description of property offers as ready, as instantaneous, a resource, in moments of pecuniary difficulty, as jewels; and of all jewels, diamonds. No sacrifice of cherished souvenirs, of family heir-looms; no selling, for a mere song, articles of inestimable value, is imposed now by the stern necessity of the hour. . . . Could the brilliant parures that sparkle on heads and bosoms at the court balls relate their wanderings, very many of those least likely to be suspected would be found to have made a longer or shorter sojourn, on one or more occasions, at the residence of that convenient and universal, but unacknowledged, relative of the Rue des Blancs, Manteaux. (353–54)Footnote 6
Diamonds, it seems, were a recognized source of ready cash – as valuable but easily exchangeable commodity items – for those women who found their ample incomes somewhat stretched by the demands of fashionable society. Lizzie, however, is made aware very early on that, unlike the jewels she has previously “owned,” the Eustace Diamonds will bring her little by way of actual monetary value, and will even be problematical as visible symbols of wealth: “She had, indeed, already realised the fact that it might be very difficult to touch the money. When she had suggested to Mr. Benjamin that he should buy the jewels, that worthy tradesman had by no means jumped at the offer. Of what use to her would be a necklace always locked up in an iron box?” (43; vol. 1, ch. 5). The diamonds, however, despite being of absolutely no actual financial worth to Lizzie, are much more valuable to her in terms of emblematic worth. There is a certain amount of irony in the fact that Lizzie does not realize just how much trouble they will bring her, and so her initial response to Mr. Camperdown's request is in fact the accurate one in spite of her ignorance:
Mr. Camperdown's first attempt was made by a most courteous and even complimentary note, in which he suggested to Lady Eustace that it would be for the advantage of all parties that the family jewels should be kept together. Lizzie as she read this note smiled, and said to herself that she did not exactly see how her own interests would be best served by such an arrangement. (38; vol. 1, ch. 5)
In the first place, it is through the notoriety brought about by the debate over their ownership that gains for Lizzie the social recognition – at least in some spheres – which she so ardently desires; and this is especially the case after the diamonds are stolen. Sympathy with her cause, and the trouble she is put to after the theft, are in part to thank for the interest of both Frank Greystock and George Carruthers, not to mention Mr. Emilius, replacing her lost matrimonial prospect with a host of new opportunities. It is unclear whether Mr. Camperdown and his supporters revile Lizzie because of her appropriation of goods which in right belong to another, or because she seeks to keep for herself a measure of the power leant to her by her first husband's demise, but it is certainly the case that, while Lizzie's ownership of the Portray estate can never have the value of permanence for her, the diamonds, so long as she can retain ownership or the semblance of ownership over them, are a source of power and prestige unusual in the realms of nineteenth-century female possession.
It is clear, then, that the value of commodities as they are used within The Eustace Diamonds directly reflects on the user in both social and moral terms; in Lizzie's case her habits of consumption and modes of ownership are directly linked to the value of her femininity in the marriage market. As Logan points out in The Victorian Parlour, women's lack of involvement outside of the domestic sphere necessitated a dependence upon material objects for the expression of identity;Footnote 7 a Victorian writer commenting on female fashion agreed, saying:
With their habitual delicacy of mind, and reserve of manner, dress becomes a sort of symbolical language – a kind of personal glossary – a species of body phrenology, the study of which it would be madness to neglect. . . . We . . . maintain that, to a proficient in the science, every woman walks about with a placard on which her leading qualities are advertised. (“Art of Dress” 375–76)
It is clear that this is a practice Lizzie is aware of and willing to use to her advantage. From the first to the last chapter of the novel, Lizzie's primary concern seems to be the capture, by any means, of a husband, and every physical object she possesses or desires is in some way related to this goal; the diamonds themselves are very obviously linked closely in her mind with the idea of a husband, whether real or fanciful: “The necklace during the whole day had been so heavy on Lizzie's heart, that she had been unable to apply her thoughts to the building of that castle in the air in which the Corsair was to reign supreme, but not alone” (45; vol. 1, ch. 5). Our initial experience of Lizzie, in fact, is of a girl who uses physical objects – her borrowed jewellery and her appealingly dangling curl – and the aura and connotations of physical objects – such as her soulful reading of poetry to the smitten Sir Florian – to create a superficial veneer of femininity for herself. The game Lizzie plays with her masculine admirers, however, is one that was well recognized as commonplace, even if it was for the most part at least outwardly condemned; as Mrs. Ellis wrote around Reference Ellis1842: “Society is often to the daughters of a family, what business or a profession is to the sons; at least so far as regards the importance attached to it, and the opportunity it affords of failure or success” (206).Footnote 8 This description makes society, and the associated female hunt for husbands, directly analogous to the masculine pursuits of business which, inevitably, concern trade and commodity. It remained true that in a society where upper- and middle-class women were discouraged from engaging in trade and employment, and were legally in a difficult position regarding absolute ownership of property and goods, marriage remained the only opportunity for ambitious and acquisitive women to engage in the market transactions which were the backbone of a commodity society.
The most obvious method in which women might, then, play the markets, so to speak, was through the adornment and presentation of their bodies, and at this art Lizzie is an expert: “She leaned forward her face as she asked her questions, and threw back her loose lustrous lock of hair, with her long lithe fingers covered with diamonds, – the diamonds, these, which Sir Florian had really given her, or which she had procured from Mr. Benjamin in the clever manner described in the opening chapter” (70; vol. 1, ch. 8). The combined effect of Lizzie's bold good-looks and flashing jewels is one of bedazzlement, but it is also one which signals not moral fortitude, but wealth: “There were men at this time who declared that she was simply the cleverest and the handsomest woman in England. As an independent young woman she was perhaps one of the richest” (18; vol. 1, ch. 2). This portrayal of Lizzie's eligibility as a bride is in direction opposition to the popular but idealistic view that inherent goodness was the key to success in finding a husband:
Hints to Ladies: Woman's mission is that of peace, charity, and love, and the brightest jewel in her coronet is that gentleheartedness which would rather extenuate than set down aught in malice. Good temper would recommend any woman to the attention of a gentleman, who would assure to her the proud distinction of being honoured and respected. If ladies were to respect themselves more, and not to indulge in vagaries of disposition and exhibitions of character, they would command the loving esteem of those whom they like best in their heart of hearts. (“Hints to Ladies”)
What is interesting in this passage is firstly the direct juxtaposition again of jewels (“the brightest jewel in her coronet”) and morality, and secondly the implicit acknowledgement that value is measured in terms of desirability. Lizzie's behaviour shows that she recognizes this, and is willing – and largely capable – of using both of these views to her benefit.Footnote 9 The diamonds, representative as they are of her financial and moral status, come to be the key card she uses in the marriage game; but they are also therefore a symbol of transferable wealth to which she feels she has a right in spite, or outside of, marriage. Lady Lithlingow points out that it is in this respect that society will frown upon Lizzie's continued ownership of the diamonds: “What good will they do you? You can't sell them; – and as a widow you can't wear ‘em. If you marry again, you wouldn't disgrace your husband by going about showing off the Eustace diamonds! But you don't know anything about ‘proper feelings’” (52; vol. 1; ch. 6). However, as Miller points out, the diamonds are no longer simply a tool which Lizzie must use, but also an integral part of herself, comprising as they do a piece of property to which she might claim a permanent right: “Her insistence on keeping the diamonds increasingly appears, I think, as a perverse and oddly modern form of pride, pride at work in a culture that defines identity through possession: the necklace, gained by marriage, comes to define its owner, to be felt as an essential part of her nature” (165). What is unclear in the novel is whether Lizzie is being denounced for trying to create a false impression of perfect femininity, or whether she is being denounced simply for being both female and independently wealthy; by drawing attention to the haziness of this distinction when applied to Lizzie's situation, it seems to me that Trollope is defending Lizzie's character in light of the kinds of discourse about commodity, consumption, and ownership by which she has been shaped: Lizzie, to sum up, is a creation of a hypocritical society, and a victim of the demands placed upon her by that society, which requires her to be at the same time an adept player and a reluctant participant in the game.
