In recounting the history of rock, textbooks and documentary films generally ignore American hardcore punk. American Hardcore: The History of American Punk Rock 1980–1986, a documentary film by Paul Rachman and Steven Blush, seeks to redress this omission. The definitions of “hardcore” and “punk” are contested among those who see themselves in close relation to these musics. But generally speaking, hardcore is a faster, more aggressive variant of punk rock that supported the development of an American underground during the 1980s, establishing a network of scenes, venues, and labels, and inspiring such later genres as grunge, alternative, emo, and speed metal. Rachman and Blush depict hardcore as a grassroots, anticommercial music that reaffirmed the essential “values” of punk. These values emerge in the film as impulses towards individualism and the rejection of predetermined social roles. The film documents hardcore as a movement marked by political radicalism and antimaterialism, positive thinking and youth empowerment, but also by violence, juvenile delinquency, and puerile chauvinism fostered by the boredom and disillusionment of suburban, middle-class youths living in Reagan's America.
American Hardcore offers an excellent history of music the filmmakers define as hardcore, but theirs is a narrow definition; given the film's limited scope, its subtitle, “The History of American Punk Rock, 1980–1986,” seems intentionally antagonizing (a very punk gesture indeed!). The film works to establish American hardcore's claim to the legacy of punk, taking for granted that the music and the scene surrounding it were the last and truest expressions of the punk impulse, even as it distinguishes the genre as a separate entity from earlier and later manifestations of punk.
American Hardcore comprises a series of informal interviews with people who shaped the hardcore scene, mostly musicians but also promoters, fanzine editors, visual artists, photographers, recording engineers, and record label owners. The film juxtaposes these interviews against images documenting hardcore: collages of snapshots, flyers, album art, fanzine covers, and concert footage capturing the youthfulness of the participants and the lack of distance between performers and audiences, as well as the primal energy and violence of a typical hardcore show. The filmmakers work to establish the genre as a radical reaction against the authoritarianism and economic crisis of the Reagan regime, and as a musical response to the “corporate rock” of the Eagles, Journey, Fleetwood Mac, and other staples of AOR radio. Closing in on the zero hour for Orwell's prophecies in 1984, the nation's new conservative leadership and its policies took on threatening symbolic power; suburban youths across the nation rejected the bland materialism and apathy of the decade, along with what they envisioned as an oppressive turn in American idealism. The rapid underground spread of hardcore resulted both from the necessity for alternative communities, spaces, creative opportunities, and media outlets for these youngsters and their determination to create them.
Researchers interested in the history of punk will likely find American Hardcore a useful resource for understanding the music's development in the United States during the 1980s. The film presents an excellent explanation of punk's “do-it-yourself,” or “DIY,” ethos and the cooperative efforts of people in local scenes across the nation connected by a sense of participation in a trans-local music community. Respondents recount the construction of an American underground—including Black Flag's early tours that carved out a circuit of contacts and venues for touring bands, and an illustrated step-by-step account of the DIY manufacturing process, showing how small labels managed every facet of production and packaging by hand, from printing to folding record sleeves and mailing out orders. The greatest strength of American Hardcore is its live footage, including extremely rare and well-shot performances by Minor Threat and Bad Brains. The DVD's extra features present uninterrupted video footage of several hardcore bands. This documentation of the gestures of the performers, the sounds of music in live performance, the reactions of the audience and its interactions with the music and musicians are effective and visceral, capturing the energy and experience of hardcore punk at its most powerful. The film could be especially useful for students interested in current popular American punk bands who have their origins in hardcore, or in the musical sources of such popular rock genres as emo.
While the film does a good job of capturing the feel, and even the internal contradictions of a particular genre, American Hardcore is a far less artful and complete treatment of the 1980s American punk scene than two others films—Penelope Spheeris's The Decline of Western Civilization (1985) and Don Letts's Punk: Attitude (2005). Working in the hardcore moment, Spheeris is far less concerned with the division between hardcore and punk, which often seems artificial in Rachman and Blush's account and certainly does not match my own memory or experience of the music. For Rachman and Blush, the hardcore (anti-) aesthetic is anti-art, and judging by their final product, that means a de-emphasis on affect, analysis, or interrogation. Many social prejudices disfigured the hardcore scene—senseless violence, misogyny, racism, homophobia—but American Hardcore does not challenge or at least expose these problems in the way that Spheeris's film does. Nor does it engage satisfactorily with the role of women in punk as Letts is careful to do in his documentary, especially in the extra features, which include a whole segment on the subject.
American Hardcore is a celebratory, elegiac film by two men who were part of the scene they portray. The major flaws of the film result from this personal involvement. Hardcore, as understood in the film, is artificially distinct from other American punk music of its time. It is also artificially limited in its time span: while hardcore may have ended for Rachman and Blush in 1986, this finality has little to do with the younger fans and audiences who have perpetuated similar musical scenes in the ensuing decades. Rachman's association with the city of Boston perhaps explains why there is little coverage of such major acts as Dead Kennedys and Butthole Surfers, but extensive emphasis on SS Decontrol, Negative FX, and other Boston groups. Such spotty geographical coverage has no justification beyond the contingencies of the filmmakers' experiences. Nonetheless, while limited, this film will be an invaluable resource for anyone who wants to learn about this period of American popular music, including those prepared to take a more critical perspective than Rachman and Blush.
