As the last doctoral student of Werner Heisenberg (1901–1976), Helmut Rechenberg has spent most of his academic life pursuing a historic lead that his adviser had set for him, i.e. writing the history of quantum theory, quantum mechanics, atomic and nuclear physics and allied fields. He did so in his six-volume history of quantum mechanics, co-authored with Jagdish Mehra (published 1982–2001) and in various other publications, many of them centring on Heisenberg in one way or another. The book under review is the latest product of this work of mourning, a thousand-page first part to the scientific biography of Heisenberg. It covers his life and work only up to 1933. The second part will cover the much less ‘happy’ times under National Socialism, Allied occupation and the young Federal Republic of Germany, but it has yet to appear and might still take a couple of years to complete. The bibliography of part one (as in the Mehra and Rechenberg volumes) mostly constitutes primary sources with very little secondary literature. The illustrations are collected in a couple of image sections at the end of the chapters, with a few images in colour (such as his sketch of Zeeman splittings and line intensities for the second joint publication with his PhD adviser Arnold Sommerfeld, in 1921, on p. 141). But usually they are small black-and-white illustrations with relatively poor greyscale rendering, because the book is only printed on demand, implying that even the publisher expects a small print run.
It is a biography very much in the old style of the nineteenth-century life-and-letters tradition, with long (and often interesting) excerpts from letters, diaries and notebooks, and very detailed excerpts of most of Heisenberg's publications. Readers expecting deep reflection about ‘scientific biographies’ as a genre or about historiography will thus be disappointed and should stay well away from this text. However, readers dissatisfied with the superficiality of the factual information in the handful of mostly very short existing biographies (e.g. by A. Hermann, E.P. Fischer and G. Schiemann) may well appreciate this book. Unlike David Cassidy's biography Uncertainty (1992), this text is transparently structured and one can easily pick just the section or period one happens to be interested in. The choice of quotes and excerpts is well considered and balanced, and the style refreshingly smooth (this also in contrast to Mehra and Rechenberg, which was not well received in this and other respects) – the reason surely is that Rechenberg writes here in his native tongue, which is also the language of the quoted sources.
There is new material in this book even for experts in Heisenberg's life and work – not so surprising if one knows that Rechenberg is also the archivist of Heisenberg's personal papers and correspondence. I personally was most intrigued by the new material on Heisenberg's boy scout activities, which the author obtained from members of the group led by Heisenberg until 1922 (pp. xi, 40–65); the quotes about Heisenberg's attitude towards Hitler (e.g. pp. 194 ff.) and the Nazi party, whom he did not like but, like many of his contemporaries, underrated; and about politics in general, which he characterized as ‘pocket-size circus stunts’ (‘Taschenspielerkunststückchen’, p. 195).
Other little treasures revealed here are Heisenberg's initial insecurity when he joined Bohr's circle in Copenhagen (pp. 242 ff.); his friendly relationship with his motherly landlady there, Mrs Maar (seventeen entries in the name index!); the furniture and living conditions of young Professor Heisenberg in Leipzig (p. 651); and Edward Teller's suspicion that he only got his PhD so soon because of the obnoxiousness of his mechanical calculator – Heisenberg was living in the same quarters and was constantly disturbed by its loud rattling at night (p. 831). Also note Heisenberg's unhappy affection for Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker's younger sister Adelheid (pp. 915 ff.).
All locations in which Heisenberg stayed for longer intervals get short descriptive vignettes (e.g. Leipzig on pp. 633 ff. or Göttingen on pp. 151 ff.). Likewise, Heisenberg's many companions and colleagues (such as Bohr on pp. 223 ff., Bohr's assistant H.A. Kramers on pp. 242 ff., or Friedrich Hund on p. 828) are fittingly characterized, but the focus rests very much on Heisenberg – often I would have liked to learn more about how he was perceived by those sharing his environment. Only very few critical views are raised in the book (one on p. 655 where we learn from Rudolf Peierls that Heisenberg's lectures on thermodynamics were clear and complete, but uninspiring and wanting in enthusiasm).
Rechenberg's extensive neglect of modern secondary literature on Heisenberg, the themes of his oeuvre, and its contexts, leads to a corresponding omission of many issues that would have been very worthwhile – perhaps even imperative – to discuss. My selection includes the following points. There is no adequate portrayal of the Sommerfeld school (with Michael Eckert's nice study on the latter, Die Atomphysiker (1993), not mentioned once). Heisenberg's choice of words is not reflected upon, even for such intriguing terms as ‘symbolische Modelle’ in his April 1925 paper (p. 208). The crisis period of quantum theory, the intellectual and emotional roller coaster experienced from 1923 to early 1925, is not portrayed in full depth. Neither do we learn whether Rechenberg's choice (on p. 607) not to refer to the ‘Copenhagen interpretation’ but rather only to the ‘Kopenhagener Geist’ (spirit) is based on a recent discussion about whether there was anything like a Copenhagen interpretation, or whether this was only clever rhetoric on the part of Bohr, Heisenberg and their gospels (as Mara Beller has claimed, for instance).
This biography is clearly not written primarily for historians of science but rather for an audience of enthusiasts of quantum mechanics, and fans of Heisenberg in particular. However, the loving care for detail and exhaustive coverage makes it nonetheless useful for historians as well.
