If the embrace of alterity were the litmus test of modernity, Aslı Iğsız's book puts on display its record of failure. At stake is not the catastrophic legacy of the two world wars for minorities, especially in the wake of overtly racist and eugenicist discourses and practices that informed mass violence generally and dominated the field of culture specifically. Instead, and more importantly, it is the concerted postwar effort, both by individual nations and the international community, that aimed precisely to address that wreckage, which Iğsız's book analyzes, in order to show its limits and shortcomings in managing alterity. The book is a strong indictment of how, despite its best aspirations and certain limited achievements, humanism remains woefully inadequate, often complementary to and even complicit with a deeply racial logic that hierarchizes humanity, even as it asserts an aspiration of universal inclusivity on the basis of shared aspects of being human.
Humanism in Ruins examines the dominant modes in which the management of alterity is understood and practiced in the twentieth century and traces the transformation of these modes into the present by focusing on the aftermath of openly segregationist policies. The 1923 Greek–Turkish population exchange agreement, that monumental treaty that forced 1.5 million people to relocate, is the first international legal agreement of its kind and a precedent for forced migrations around the world to come. The lingering legacy of this treaty, or what Iğsız terms “segregative biopolitics,” can be observed, she argues, not only in the Postdam treaty, but also in the subsequent partitions of India, Palestine, and Cyprus. For Iğsız, this treaty is exemplary of the logic of “unmixing” peoples, populations racially construed as irreconcilable and with incommensurable differences, in the face of the challenges posed by their coexistence and in order to avoid organized violence. The treaty as the harbinger of many difficulties as well as honorable efforts to address the deleterious impact of such separationist as well as comparable fascist and eugenicist discourses in the twentieth century thus constitutes the book's starting point.
The book then turns to reconstruct these postwar efforts to manage alterity, both at the national and international levels, and presents their evolution by focusing on three main moments, each of which correspond to a dominant form of humanism. The first is the immediate aftermath of World War II and is defined by liberal humanism. This moment is epitomized by advocacy for and local efforts toward assimilating refugees. A whole host of institutions, including organizations for the study of refugees and sociological associations, step in to shape integration efforts, emphasizing the centrality of assimilating refugees, at least economically valuable ones. At the same time, the founding mandate of UNESCO exemplifies a new discourse of inclusivity entailed by the mottos “unity in diversity” and the “brotherhood of humanity,” which Iğsız finds concretized in the famous MoMA exhibition, “The Family of Man.” Through these instances, Iğsız explores how liberal humanism is offered as a panacea for the racist and segregative approaches to alterity, symbolized by the Greek–Turkish population exchange.
The second moment, corresponding mainly to the late 1980s and 1990s, is the liberalization and pluralization of identity claims against the state's monopoly on national history through the pursuit of family histories and heritage tourism by the descendants of those who were relocated via the population exchange. At the international level, this is echoed by the shift in UNESCO's policies from cultural assimilation to the recognition of cultural identity. Iğsız argues that this moment is defined by historicist humanism, which mobilizes a civilizational discourse to trace national origins and upholds figures of national genius to emphasize particular cultural contributions that delineate where a nation finds itself fitting in the tree of humanity. If liberal humanism is defined by the emphasis on universality and unity of humanity, historicist humanism, according to Iğsız, is distinguished by the emphasis on the diversity in humanity, indicating a new appreciation of cultural difference.
Finally, the third moment brings us into the twenty-first century, which is defined by what Iğsız calls the “museumization of culture,” or the statist appropriation of personal efforts to democratize history and their selective display as evidence of multiculturalism. In contradistinction from the first two moments, this most recent one is defined by what could be called neoliberal humanism. At the national level, this humanism is based on a romanticized narrative of the Ottoman past, exalted for its tolerance that enabled the peaceful coexistence of different religious groups, understood as standing in for different civilizations. The neo-Ottoman narrative allows for the selective and domesticated showcasing of diversity, turning state-sponsored multiculturalism into a marketable brand for Turkey. If the Population Exchange Museum, which puts artifacts symbolizing family histories on display, becomes emblematic of the Turkish turn to the neoliberal embrace of diversity, this is in broad agreement with regional and international trends, such as the principles enshrined in the 2001 UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity, as well as the United Nations’ Alliance of Civilizations and the European Union's Capitals of Culture initiatives.
Deftly moving through these three distinct moments in the postwar approaches to alterity, Iğsız argues, and this is the heart of her erudite book, that the various liberal and liberalizing solutions proposed and implemented—both at the national level and globally, by way of UN, UNESCO, and a host of regional, occupational, and other non-governmental organizations operating in the fields of culture and education—in response to the segregationist approach embodied by the Greek–Turkish population exchange are also deeply tainted and structured by racialized logics that hierarchize humanity. The book is thus a strongly contextualized critique of liberalism, insistently underscoring how the ostensible expansion in the recognition and appreciation of alterity remains inadequate and dependent on methods of identification and classification that essentialize and naturalize difference. Hence, Humanism in Ruins forcefully contends that the two broad paradigms of alterity—heredity and heritage—based on race and culture respectively are in fact deeply imbricated and mutually constituted.
Taking the reader through a dizzying range of complex and intertwined histories of influential figures, institutions, initiatives, and declarations, this meticulously researched book offers a treasure trove of material. Rich in detail and yet broad in scope, Humanism in Ruins is still broader in its implications. While it leaves no rock unturned in pursuit of the question of how the regulation of alterity took shape, locally and globally, it patiently unearths clue after clue that renders humanism suspect. Iğsız thus offers a strong corrective against the complacent celebration of diversity, showing what that celebration occludes: the ongoing history of human ruins.
