Introduction: Haydn’s Unending Labour
Joseph Heyden will be received and treated as a house staff member. And his Serene Highness graciously places confidence in his belief that [Heyden] will conduct himself in a fitting manner, be mild, lenient, dignified, and composed with the musicians and not treat them in a brutal fashion. When the orchestra is called upon to perform, Vice Kapellmeister, as all subordinates, will appear in uniform, and this pertains not only to Joseph Heyden, but to all members, that they appear in white stockings and white shirt, with either pigtail or tiewig, and thoroughly powdered.Footnote 1
It is hard for teachers of courses on Enlightenment music to resist using this document: Haydn’s 1761 contract with Prince Anton Esterházy, when he was appointed vice-kapellmeister. Students often find the stipulations almost comical in their quantity and specificity: the call for Haydn to appear daily in the princely antechamber to coordinate with his employer, his lack of ownership over his music, the expectation that he maintains both the instruments and the singers, and the inclusion of even the details of his expected appearance (‘white stockings … pigtail or tiewig … thoroughly powdered’). The contract is a piece of historical evidence that makes Haydn’s servitude vivid to students, who are often incredulous (‘I wouldn’t take that job!’).
With this contract, Nicholas Mathew opens the final chapter of his recent book The Haydn Economy, which is simply entitled: ‘Work’. ‘For most of his life’, Mathew writes, ‘Haydn was constantly busy’.Footnote 2 In the chapter, Mathew deftly traces the common origins of the musical work concept and the economic concept of work. As Mathew builds his argument, he delves into Haydn’s varying forms of labour and work, and Haydn’s reflections on them. Mathew places special emphasis on Haydn’s career after the death of Prince Nikolaus in 1790: Haydn’s new-found ‘freedom’ brought yet more labour as he entered the London marketplace. Mathew argues that Haydn’s preoccupation with industry found an outlet in the finale of his Symphony No. 98 in B Flat Major, which makes zany fun of both Salomon’s labour as a violinist (as he gets ‘snagged’ on a two-note upbeat), and Haydn’s labour at the keyboard, with his tinkling solo, showing the ‘author busily at work’.Footnote 3 Mathew’s chapter achieves something unusual in Haydn literature. Focusing closely on Haydn’s expressions of stress, we catch a rare glimpse of Haydn as an ordinary man who was sometimes exhausted and homesick.
This chapter is also concerned with Haydn and labour: we focus not on his long days in the princely palaces in Eisenstadt or Esterháza, or his navigation of the bustling musical economy of London, but rather on the work that Haydn has done in music studies, long after his earthly productions ceased. From the nineteenth century onwards, Haydn’s career and large body of works have been marshalled to many distinct ends – historiographical, musicological, and analytical – to make various arguments about music’s social, aesthetic, and political efficacy. The sense of Haydn as a person that peeks through in Mathew’s chapter is distinct from the more abstract and distant Haydn who is called upon to exemplify bigger and broader ideas about eighteenth-century musical culture.
Haydn’s The Creation is a case in point. As we have written elsewhere, Haydn’s much-beloved oratorio can be described as a much-used work: it joined the welcoming party for the belated entry of ‘the Enlightenment’ into Haydn scholarship in David P. Schroeder’s pioneering study of the London Symphonies.Footnote 4 Analyses of The Creation heralded a shift to hermeneutic approaches to Haydn’s music with Lawrence Kramer’s essay on the representation of chaos and the divine creation of light in the oratorio.Footnote 5 In James Webster’s work, The Creation was pressed into service as an example of the Romantic sublime of terror and transcendence, an aesthetic category previously reserved for Beethoven.Footnote 6 For Matthew Head, it occasioned millennial reflection on Haydn’s music-historical consciousness; Mathew used The Creation to articulate the importance of the choral work concept to late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century music, setting the stage for Beethoven’s later choral experiments.Footnote 7 In Emily Dolan’s work, The Creation’s length and musical diversity made it useful for thinking about Haydn’s approaches to orchestral forces, timbre, and mediation.Footnote 8 The work’s text painting and moments of representation invited reflection on the status of mimesis in this period, and also invoked contemporary entertainments, such as the magic lantern show and shadow puppetry, as Deirdre Loughridge has explored.Footnote 9
These heterogeneous musicological uses of The Creation share a purpose: to take Haydn seriously as a modern, innovative composer, engaged with the foment of his age, with science, technology, aesthetics, and moral philosophy. In banishing stereotypes of Haydn’s music as ‘childlike’ and ‘naïve’, recent scholarship on The Creation engages an heirloom project, one that Leon Botstein traces back to the third Haydn revival of the twentieth century, in Washington in 1975 with the Haydn festival conference. In that moment, Botstein discerns a project of (so to speak) ‘rewilding’ Haydn, a reaction against presumed ‘elegance and refinement’ that sought to recover ‘passion and intensity’. Botstein might have given more credit to Donald Francis Tovey, Karl Geiringer, and H. C. Robbins Landon for developing a more complex account of the composer’s expressive and moral ambitions, but certainly the Washington conference ushered in no less a pioneer of the new Haydn scholarship than James Webster, co-editor of the conference volume when it eventually appeared in 1981.Footnote 10
Scholarly determination to take Haydn seriously has its critics. In his Making Light: Haydn, Musical Camp, and the Long Shadow of German Idealism, Raymond Knapp – who also references The Creation – finds Haydn scholarship unnecessarily burdened by a quest for depth and hidden meaning. Underwhelmed by Haydn’s ‘politely civilized’ representation of chaos, weary of earnest explications of musical humour, he urges scholars to make light of fiat lux.Footnote 11 In a broad-brush critique, he suggests that attention to ‘immediately appealing features’ in Haydn’s music, its ‘congenial’ manner, and ‘sympathetically human’ character is missing.Footnote 12 The entertaining pleasures of Haydn’s music, he contends, belong to the pre-history of camp, as a self-consciously theatrical, artificial, rebellious sensibility – though he stops short of adding Haydn’s wig and symphonic minuets to Susan Sontag’s index of camp practices and artefacts.Footnote 13
Knapp has a point. Interpretation of Haydn’s humour, for example, has sometimes occasioned a return to ideas of ‘absolute’ music and stirred a yearning after metaphysical significance. From Scott Burnham’s engaging essay, students infer that Haydn’s humour is a purely instrumental matter, involving the manipulation of compositional conventions embodied in the expectations of an ideal listener.Footnote 14 This formalist perspective figures Haydn’s humour as a holiday from the seriousness of absolute music without tainting the purity of that ideal realm. From Mark Evan Bonds, students glean that Haydn is less comic than Romantically ironic, that he annihilates the aesthetic illusion conjured by art.Footnote 15 Certainly, these readings – downplaying the explanatory significance of folly, of the carnivalesque, and of Haydn’s time in the theatre – demonstrate a recuperative preference to relate Haydn forward to the nineteenth century, not back to the early modern era.
The main issue with Knapp’s critique – which arguably pushes Haydn from the modern world into a postmodern one – is that it ultimately takes too monolithic a view of Haydn scholarship. Since David Schroeder brokered Haydn’s marriage with the moral philosophy of the Scottish Enlightenment, since Elaine Sisman invited the German and French theatre to take up residence in the Esterhazy symphonies, and – perhaps most influentially – since James Webster tore up or perhaps renegotiated Haydn’s contract with Viennese Classical style, many Haydns have entered the scholarly stage, far more than can be captured even through the wide lens of The Creation.Footnote 16 Driven by, and driving, disciplinary change, they have risked the appearance of unruly multiplication. But there is a common denominator – the Enlightenment. But we need to be expansive in our understanding of the Enlightenment, as the older notion of it as ‘the age of reason’ is rarely at stake. Indeed, few have followed Leon Botstein in mapping the era’s philosophical temper onto the ‘systematic coherence’ of Haydn’s instrumental music – music purportedly exemplifying the unity of ‘reason’, ‘beauty’, and ‘truth’.Footnote 17 Rather, closer attention to Haydn has challenged a Classical understanding of the Enlightenment as something that can be captured purely with these values. David Wyn Jones’s observation from 1991 proved prescient: ‘if the accepted tenets of the Enlightenment cannot be applied to [Haydn], then they will have to be modified’.Footnote 18 In 2019, almost three decades later, Andrew A. Greenwood imagined a time – surely now upon us – when Haydn scholarship would offer a multidisciplinary home for rethinking Enlightenment itself – re-imagined as a ‘multiple Enlightenment’ – and the roles of music and sound within it.Footnote 19
Enlightening Haydn
It was apt that Greenwood’s recommendation to imagine a multiple Enlightenment appeared in a volume modelled on the Encyclopédie (1751–72), that icon of enlightening publication. The Cambridge Haydn Encyclopedia (CHE) eschewed ‘entries on works, individuals, or genres’ in favour of ‘clusters of ideas’. The intention, the editors declared with Diderot, was to ‘throw off the yoke of authority’, to be ‘thought-provoking and opinionated’, to capture not eternal truth but the processes of thinking and writing through which knowledge is produced and contested. Alphabetical ordering of articles and ample cross-referencing invite readers to engage actively with an unabashedly partial and emergent scholarship.Footnote 20
Greenwood proposes not an Enlightenment of ‘abstract and universal notions’Footnote 21 but ‘a holistic Enlightenment [of] “arts and sciences”’,Footnote 22 ‘a complex social and intellectual formation’ comprising diverse movements, moments, networks, and media.Footnote 23 Potentially all-encompassing, this capacious concept of Enlightenment triggers a proliferation of editorial cross-references, the reader directed to consult entries on ‘sociability, sensibility, cosmopolitanism, the sublime, folk song, technology, science, social development, knowledge, … reason … networks … place, [and] institutions … instruments … musical materials, editions, publishing, and performances … the Catholic Church … education and Freemasonry’.Footnote 24 Exceeding the awareness of any one contributing author, Enlightenment emerges as the foundational concept of the CHE.
Although Greenwood and his fellow authors do not state it explicitly, their concept of Enlightenment is predicated on a notion of transformation. Transformation – or metamorphosis as Head and Pierpaolo Polzonetti style it in another Haydn context – captures the period’s self-consciousness about radical change in human affairs, without signing up to the now embattled period notion of ‘progress’.Footnote 25 As Polzonetti had earlier observed, it is also apt for describing Haydn’s music itself, particularly the metamorphic motivic and thematic working.Footnote 26 An aspiration to transformation attended various enlightening projects – anthropological, medical, and technological – to which Haydn contributed. Developing material sketched in the CHE, Greenwood connects Haydn’s arrangements of traditional Scottish melodies into anthropological discourse on Scottish ‘improvement’. According to the stadial historiography of Adam Smith, among others, society moved progressively from hunting, through animal husbandry and agriculture, to cosmopolitan commercialism.Footnote 27 In this context, Haydn’s arrangements of Scottish songs, though offering nostalgic encounters with a pastoral stage of social development and with a vanishing orality, acted as catalysts of commercial modernisation. Something more than buying and selling music was at stake in this final phase of Scottish improvement. Song culture, fostering bonds of sympathy and feeling between fellow Scots, was a medium for nurturing sociability and social cohesion.
Exploring another fugitive repertoire – Haydn’s English canzonettas with texts by Anne Hunter – Sarah Day-O’Connell identifies the Enlightenment’s forensic gaze in Anne’s musical–literary salon and the anatomy lab of her surgeon husband in the adjoining room. John Hunter’s melancholy demonstrations and drawings of the reproductive structures of pregnant women formed a macabre counterpoint to Haydn’s minutely observed settings of Anne’s feminocentric lyrics, often concerned with beautiful women in love, and with the somatic and psychological symptoms of their lovesickness. As Day-O’Connell puts it, Haydn, Anne Hunter, and her husband John ‘shared medical and musical discourses regarding the nature of femininity’.Footnote 28
Music and Enlightenment technology converge in Deirdre Loughridge’s account of musical corollaries of ‘magnifying instruments’ – the telescope and magnifying glass – in Haydn’s opera Il mondo della luna (1777).Footnote 29 In one of the three intermezzi for the opening ‘observatory scene’, Haydn employed ‘muted violins to draw the audience into the [onstage] telescopic observation of a lunar world’, a lontano effect that creates ‘a change in auditory perspective’.Footnote 30 Each intermezzo opens with a phrase that ‘evokes the stasis of absorbed spectatorship’, while divided violins and double stops in the violas ‘manipulate the senses … implying perception at a technologically mediated distance’.Footnote 31 This moment offers a glimpse of Loughridge’s compelling account of ‘the pleasures and promises of sense-extending technologies’ in Haydn’s world.Footnote 32
In Loughridge, Day-O’Connell, and Greenwood, Haydn’s music is not just keeping company with Enlightenment themes but is imbricated with them. Though they allow Haydn agency and shed light on specific compositions, these authors decentre him and his works. The autonomy and unity summoned by the name ‘Haydn’ – Haydn’s author function, in Foucault’s terms – are dispersed across media, places, and actors.Footnote 33 A deep multidisciplinarity lends a decentring effect to these important studies of Haydn – one we might even call ‘post-Haydn’. Day-O’Connell and Loughridge, writing on music, medicine, and technology, engage a multidisciplinary nexus with broad currency in twenty-first-century music scholarship – the varied relationships between music and the histories of science. This nexus encompasses a diverse range of scholarship, including Ellen Lockhart’s Animation, Plasticity, and Music in Italy, 1770–1830 and her volume, co-edited with James Q. Davies, Sound Knowledge: Music and Science in London, 1789–1850.Footnote 34 And Haydn has been prominent since some of the earliest scholarship that took steps in this direction: for instance, in his exploration of evolving notions of musical organicism, Daniel Chua turned to Haydn’s instrumental music to illustrate how ‘conscious life had seeped into the score’.Footnote 35 In the opening chapter of her posthumous The Secular Commedia, Wendy Allanbrook considered Enlightenment fascination with polyps (the ambiguous life form, not the ailment that plagued Haydn, which Allanbrook took care to clarify.) Tracing how these creatures behaved simultaneously like plants and animals and ‘exhibited stunning generative and regenerative behaviors’, Allanbrook proposed an action-based and distinctly anti-Classical way of approaching eighteenth-century music, one that prized scintillating and ever-changing musical surfaces over depth.Footnote 36 After delving into Pergolesi’s La serva padrona and showing Uberto’s ‘polyp-y’ nature, Allanbrook turned to the first movement of Haydn’s Symphony No. 59 in A Major, drawing attention to its changeable surface: ‘The opening’, Allanbrook wrote, ‘is successively annunciatory, misterioso, purposeful, agitated, urbane, rollicking, valedictory, and all in just over a minute of music’.Footnote 37
But beyond these scholars’ linking of music and Enlightenment natural history, there is a broader and more diffuse sense in which Haydn’s music and compositional style have inspired quasi-scientific experiment. Perhaps it is the sheer volume of Haydn’s output – with its impressive variation –over his long career that invites us to think about his musical style as one full of experimentation in form, melody, rhetoric, and orchestration. Indeed, it was Haydn’s pervasive timbral experimentation that motivated Dolan’s creation of her experimental ‘orchestral graphs’, designed to visualise what we might call the large-scale ‘orchestrational structures’ in the slow movements of Haydn’s late symphonic works. Dolan’s concept has since been taken up by the McGill-based ACTOR project and systemised into the Orcheil programme, which automatically produces visualisations based on MusicXML files.Footnote 38 This spirit of experimentation has also inflected creative output on Haydn: in a feat of virtual acoustic engineering, Tom Beghin produced The Virtual Haydn recordings.Footnote 39 They present Haydn’s complete solo keyboard repertoire, performed in virtual spaces created by capturing the acoustics of nine rooms, and creating acoustic ‘replications of actual rooms where Haydn or contemporary players of his keyboard music would have performed’.Footnote 40 Beghin’s performances are certainly compelling, and yet even here, with actual performances of Haydn’s core repertoire, this project also looks past Haydn – towards space, sound studies, and ideas of virtuality – in a way that echoes the ‘post-Haydn’ quality of Day-O’Connell’s and Loughridge’s work. Haydn scholarship is currently responding to critique of the interpretive constraints of ‘the author function’ (again, in Foucault’s term) even as it retains a fascination with Haydn’s agency.Footnote 41 Perhaps we could think of Haydn less as a discrete author figure, and more as an invitation to experiment.Footnote 42
Global Haydn?
Looking at musicology more generally, we might say that the ‘post-Haydn’ quality of recent scholarship is part of the larger ‘post-composer’ and ‘post-work’ turn of musicology. In writing about the field’s current obsessions with mediation and materiality, Mathew recently quipped: ‘In the context of present-day scholarship, the musical work thus becomes the inverse of Bismarck’s proverbial sausage – nobody talks about liking it, but everyone wants to see how it was made.’Footnote 43 This is arguably not so distant from earlier analytical preoccupations regarding music; the idea of making is now accounted for not by formal analysis but by turning to the history of technology.
Once it is dethroned from aesthetic autonomy, and score-based analysis, music becomes another ‘thing’ in the world. The challenge is to discern where music goes and what it does. At least this is one possible way of interpreting the rise of global music history, which has brought increasing attention to questions of transcontinental exchange, the musical structures of colonialism, and mechanisms of circulation. Indeed, it is telling that the two most recent articles to explore music in the eighteenth century in the Journal of the American Musicological Society turn not to Haydn, Mozart, or any of the vaunted European hubs of music-making, but instead to Bolivia and Guatemala.Footnote 44 As of now, Haydn has not been a central figure in this proliferation of ‘global’ music history. He is not entirely absent – Haydn appears, for example, in Thomas Irvine’s Listening to China: Sound and the Sino-Western Encounter, as one of the composers performed by the British bands brought to the China of Emperor Qianlong by George Macartney on behalf of George III – but one might well wonder if Haydn will be left behind.
And yet there is also a sense in which Haydn might become newly relevant: after all, he is a composer who, despite being largely confined to courtly service, famously achieved international fame in his lifetime. Shortly after Haydn’s death, Ignaz Theodor Arnold could write that his music was praised in ‘St Petersburg as in Naples, in Moscow as in Madrid, in Paris and London, just as in Lisbon or Stockholm, through all of Germany and France, as in Philadelphia’.Footnote 45 Giuseppe Carpani could trace an even more impressive global zigzag, claiming Haydn’s music was known ‘from Mexico to Calcutta, as from Naples to London, from Pera to Paris’.Footnote 46
But while these geographic enumerations are well known, musicology has not always fostered much curiosity about what might lurk behind them. This has started to change in recent scholarship. Miguel Ángel Marín’s editorial in Eighteenth-Century Music – ‘Haydn from the “Frontier”’ – opens by bemoaning the lack of engagement with Robert Stevenson’s 1982 article ‘Haydn’s Iberian World Connection’: the essay was largely ignored not only by canonically focused musicology but also by scholars of Iberian music, whose attention was trained on native composers, genres, and institutions.Footnote 47 And yet, as Marín shows, Haydn was an important virtual presence in Spain. Marín estimates, for example, that forty different editions of Haydn string quartets circulated in that country.Footnote 48 Recently, Thomas Tolley delved into Carpani’s biography of Haydn, exploring Carpani’s claims that Haydn composed a ‘New World’ symphony (Carpani also likens Haydn to Christopher Columbus). While Carpani’s account of this symphony and its programme has typically been dismissed, Tolley takes seriously Haydn’s interactions with seafarers and his fascination with ‘all things nautical’, to paint a picture of a composer who was far savvier and more aware of his growing global presence than we typically have given him credit for.Footnote 49 We note that, in this account, Haydn’s Eszterháza ‘isolation’ was less a hurdle that Haydn improbably overcame and more the source of the preconditions for his future global reach, as his career grew through his virtual circulation in print. Indeed, we might say that Haydn’s preoccupation with circulation – as Mathew explores in The Haydn Economy – helps provide a model for the very idea of a global music.Footnote 50
The global export of Haydn’s music was bound up with its import or meaning, as construed in Western European journalism, historical and critical writing, and iconography. Before they were heard on far-flung shores, Haydn’s scores were freighted with notions of creative freedom, technological innovation, moral improvement, and the progress of civil society. In other words, Haydn’s music was widely conceptualised as enlightened and enlightening. This constellation of validating concepts crystallised in commentary on Haydn’s visits to London in the 1790s, and in the reception of the London Symphonies (Nos 93–104), in part through spontaneous critical effusions in the press, in part through the strategic, didactic interventions of Charles Burney, who sought to reconcile his countrymen to modern orchestral music. In David Schroeder’s reading, bookended by two authors in Haydn’s library – the Third Earl of Shaftesbury and Adam Smith – Haydn’s music offered living proof of music’s power to awaken human sensibility, stir sensitive response, and stimulate sympathetic ties. In a hermeneutic turn, he even suggests that Haydn’s symphonies modelled Enlightenment ideas of tolerance, equality, and democracy by bringing together different types of material on relatively equal terms and eschewing narratives of conquest and domination.Footnote 51
This good news comes close to suggesting that Haydn is a ‘great composer’ of ‘canonical works’ for a time, like ours, weary of greatness and canonical works. What Schroeder does not consider, however, is how ‘enlightening Haydn’ converges, even collides, with ‘global Haydn’. The discursive validation of orchestral music in terms of individual, societal, technological, and compositional progress rendered Haydn’s music vulnerable to appropriation not only as a staging post in narratives of Teutonic musical universality but as a colonial sign in European overseas expansion. The potential of Haydn, enlightened gentleman, to metamorphose into Haydn, musical conqueror, is already evident in the opening of his first full-length biography, where Griesinger observed:
Joseph Haydn had ended his glorious career. By his death Germany again suffers a national loss; for Haydn was founder of an epoch in musical culture, and the sound of his harmonies, universally understood, did more than all written matter together to promote the honour of German artistic talent in the remotest lands. … [His music is] treasured and admired across the sea as in our own part of the world.Footnote 52
Prospects and Goodbyes
But what of Haydn’s ‘musicological’ career? That this volume exists is evidence of Haydn’s endurance. But we cannot help but wonder what the Haydn studies of the mid twenty-first century will look like. The Haydn panel at the 2009 meeting of the American Musicological Society (AMS) – the bicentennial of his death – drew a large crowd with the single-word title ‘Haydn’; since then, single composer panels have become increasingly rare. There was a ‘Haydn and Mozart’ panel in 2010, and a ‘Late Haydn’ panel in 2018, and since then Haydn’s presence has grown increasingly slight. Is the anglophone tradition of Haydn scholarship facing extinction? Is it time to say farewell to the formerly hegemonic vision of Haydn the innovator, the original, the master of instrumental-musical logic – a figure whom Lawrence Kramer traces not to those late twentieth-century scholars who felt they created it, but further back to Donald Francis Tovey, writing programme notes between the two world wars. As Kramer illuminates, this version of Haydn as ‘genius and model citizen’, ‘not bound by rule … [but] no mere rulebreaker’, was freighted with cultural politics, the composer serving to reconcile ideals of creative freedom – of genius – with the compliance exacted by a bourgeois social order.Footnote 53
This Haydn, a beacon of musical rationality and expressive warmth, entrepreneurial craftiness and creative freedom, is simply too alluring, and too consoling, to vanish completely. Even more than a quarter of a century on, there is something hard to resist in Sisman’s millennial call to recover ‘the intensity of the earlier [contemporary] response’ to Haydn, to look beyond ‘Haydn as formalist’, to discover ‘greater emotional verisimilitude’ in his music by ‘understanding [the] music in its philosophical and moral richness’. This injunction to hear and feel afresh might stand as the rallying cry of millennial studies not only of Haydn but also of later eighteenth-century music more broadly.Footnote 54 However, it is time to reflect on the achievements and the appeal of a rescue mission that may strike some as nostalgic, even antiquarian. Undeniable achievements notwithstanding, Haydn’s recovery from the grip of formalism was hampered by the analytical methodologies employed to set him free. It is one thing to enjoin the listener to feel and to understand Haydn anew, another to develop the critical tools adequate to account for his ‘emotional verisimilitude’. Neither the rhetorical analogy for music nor the theory of topics have delivered all that was hoped of them as theories of musical expression. Neither have been fully substantiated as historical modes of audition, even though both have some basis in period theories of composition. The reasons they have fallen short are identified by Danuta Mirka in an authoritative critique of research inspired by two influential publications of 1980: George J. Buelow’s ‘Rhetoric and Music’, and Leonard Ratner’s Classic Music. Currently, Haydn scholarship shares the broader dilemma faced by studies of eighteenth-century music: there is no consensus about how to elaborate the period’s axiom that music is a language of feeling. Michael Spitzer’s imaginative venture into emotion history will likely inspire further attempts to link musical scholarship and this fledgling discipline but appears not to offer a robust methodology for Haydn, whom Spitzer views through a vortex of Adorno, Marx, Kant, and Classical style.Footnote 55
More productive for Haydn scholars, because alive to music’s place in the culture of sensibility, is Dean Sutcliffe’s rich account of music and sociability. Under the heading of ‘sociable feelings’ – a rubric that highlights not untrammelled self-expression but regulated, interpersonal display – Sutcliffe teases out the beguiling warmth, even the hidden intensity, at stake in familiar notions of sentiment, simplicity, moderation, songfulness, the galant, the comfortable, the familiar, the pleasing, and the polite. In affirming the artistic sophistication and currency of sociable feeling, Sutcliffe offers a different way to cherish those appealing, seemingly naïve, and fun features of Haydn’s music that Knapp defended under the heading of camp.Footnote 56 The moral and artistic dignity of sociable feeling is neatly encapsulated in Haydn’s comments on The Creation as a work offering refreshing respite for the overworked and stressed:
Often, when struggling against the obstacles of every sort that oppose my labours … a secret voice whispered to me: ‘There are so few happy and contented people here below; grief and sorrow are always their lot; perhaps your labours will once be a source from which the careworn, or the man burdened with affairs, can derive a few moments of rest and refreshment.Footnote 57
These green shoots notwithstanding, Haydn seems to be slipping from prestigious AMS panels – those barometers of the North American musicological atmosphere – into enthusiastic online journals that take the composer for their name. It probably should worry Haydn scholars that anglophone Haydn – man, music, and musicology – is now approached in a spirit of advocacy and commemoration. To mark the 250th anniversary of Haydn’s composition of Symphony No. 45 (‘Farewell’) in 2022, the editors of Haydn: The Online Journal of the Haydn Society of North America – seeming to elide the symphony and its scholarship – published a virtual panel assembled in deserved praise of the thirtieth anniversary of Webster’s book on the piece.Footnote 58 Epithets that Webster bestowed upon Haydn – the bold innovator, the pioneer – now rained upon Webster, whose voice was aptly characterised as serious, agitated, and rhetorically masterful. In this heady, reflexive atmosphere, curation of an anglophone Haydn went hand in hand with programmatic, sometimes defensive, disciplinary statements. Discerning in the symphony’s third movement a Shakespearian trope – ‘parting is such sweet sorrow’ – L. Poundie Burstein, speaking of reluctance to depart, affirmed Webster’s injunction to ground interpretation of Haydn in a flexible music-analytical methodology. Subscribing to that principle, Elaine Sisman deployed her trademark analytical categories – genre, topic, affect, and rhetoric – spinning gold with them, even as she acknowledged they ‘have come in for some serious interrogation’ since the publication of Webster’s book. Having acknowledged those critiques – and indeed the critique of score-based analysis more generally – she nonetheless proceeded confidently to instantiate ‘presumed [musical] conventions … based on the shared presumptions of performers and listeners’.
Sutcliffe was still more trenchant in his praise of Webster’s analytical technique, despite its arguably arbitrary segmentation of motifs and tendency to park the symphony’s programme at the door of graphic analysis. Noting that Webster rarely invoked musical topics and galant schemata, he concludes that little of value is lost. Concerned with ‘closed units’ and common property, these now modish analytical conceits fail to account for the exceptional organicism of Haydn’s technique, Sutcliffe warns the reader, even as he admits to ‘caricaturing what one might call a nominalistic perspective’. Unwary readers might be left with the sense that less modish, or ‘nominalistic’ analytical techniques – presumably those on which anglophone Haydn was founded and built – enable us to trace the process of composition itself. There is a danger in using Haydn’s music to fight sub/disciplinary battles, to shore up ways of understanding and constituting ‘the music’ that are themselves embattled, and perhaps nostalgic. This commemorative discourse of Haydn-as-modern, built around the ‘Farewell’ Symphony, is reluctant to say goodbye. What remains to be seen is which of the many Haydns will linger in musicology, what they will tell us, and what we will do with them.
