Devyn Spence Benson's Antiracism in Cuba: The Unfinished Revolution is a landmark book. The past fifteen years have seen the growth of a robust scholarship on race in Cuba, especially in the colonial and early Republican periods, and in contemporary Cuba. But a detailed examination of the early years of the Cuban Revolution has been sorely lacking. Benson's study provides a masterful analysis of the crucial years 1959–62, which established patterns in racial dynamics and race-related political discourse that have persisted right up to the present. Benson argues persuasively that even as revolutionary leaders oversaw the deep redistribution of wealth and property and engaged in unprecedented levels of conflict with the United States, they also fell back on old ideas of a ‘raceless’ nation, rejecting more radical proposals in their midst. The book thus contributes to an emerging body of scholarship that reassesses the first decade of the revolution, showing that the Cuban 1960s were marked by continuities as well as ruptures.
One major intervention of the book is to document the way Afro-Cuban activists of different political stripes pushed the revolutionary leadership on the issue of racial equality during the first year and a half of the revolution. The Partido Socialista Popular (Cuban Communist Party, PSP), for example, had long positioned itself as the party of racial justice and had developed a large Afro-Cuban constituency and an arsenal of anti-racist demands. In March 1959, Communist Party leader Lázaro Peña suggested moving Afro-Cuban workers to the top of the roster for new job openings, above the white Cubans who, he argued, ‘had been privileged for decades’ (p. 104). Communist Party leaders also renewed their long-standing demand for legislation to criminalise and punish racial discrimination in employment. The new revolutionary leadership rejected these demands, instead opting for something like a race-blind approach to employment. Still, Benson shows, an alliance between the PSP and the 26 July Movement was partly facilitated by their shared priority of ending racial discrimination in employment and ensuring equal access to resources.
Benson also uncovers the more radical ideas that were floated in this early period by what she terms ‘black consciousness’ intellectuals such as Juan René Betancourt and Walterio Carbonell. In one of the book's most fascinating sections, she shows how these thinkers firmly rejected the integrationist, ‘raceless’ national ideal inherited from nineteenth-century leaders such as José Martí. Instead they called for autonomous black organising, demanded a deeper rethinking of African contributions to Cuban history and culture, and openly criticised Fidel Castro as ‘well-intentioned’ but misguided on racial questions (p. 117). Perhaps unsurprisingly, these thinkers’ legacies were virtually expunged from the island: their writings were banned, Betancourt fled into exile, and Carbonell was confined first to a labour camp (Unidad Militar de Ayuda a la Producción, UMAP) and later to a psychiatric hospital. It is possible that these ‘black consciousness’ intellectuals never enjoyed large constituencies in Cuba, unlike their counterparts elsewhere in the Caribbean. But Benson nevertheless demonstrates unequivocally that more radical paradigms for anti-racist thought and policy existed in 1959 and were forcibly foreclosed by the leadership. ‘Not everyone bought into the raceless ideologies that Castro claimed to inherit from José Martí’, Benson writes. ‘[O]ne of the consequences of the 1959 revolution was to once again prioritize the Martían vision over other competing ones’ (p. 120).
With her fine-grained analysis of the first few years of the revolution, Benson contributes significantly to a debate among Cuba scholars concerning the apparently sudden revival of racist discourse and practice during the economic collapse of the 1990s, known as the Special Period. Other scholars, particularly historian Alejandro de la Fuente, have suggested that while revolutionary discourses of anti-racism permeated the public sphere, racist ideas were nurtured in the private sphere and re-emerged as the state weakened in the 1990s. Benson challenges this ‘return of racism’ thesis, arguing instead that the revolution's public discourse was in fact characterised by a combination of racist and anti-racist elements from the very beginning. Here she makes particularly creative use of visual culture, analysing the way pro-revolutionary political cartoons continued colonial-era conventions of portraying blacks as child-like, savage, or indigent. These depictions reflected the latent conflict underlying different worldviews, as the 26 July Movement ‘positioned blacks and mulatos as unfit Cubans, who needed to move beyond blackness and/or poverty … to become citizens, whereas Afro-Cuban leaders … saw whites and the spaces they controlled as the objects that needed reforming, not themselves’ (p. 49).
Finally, Antiracism in Cuba looks at transnational exchanges, particularly between Cuba and the United States, as a crucial realm for the articulation of certain ideas about race and racism. Chapter 3, ‘From Miami to New York and Beyond’, uncovers the virtually unknown story of the small numbers of Afro-Cubans who left the island for exile, often for different reasons from those of their white counterparts. The overwhelmingly white exile community in Miami largely ignored questions of race in their prescriptions for a post-Castro Cuba and embraced a nostalgic vision of pre-1959 Cuba as a racial democracy. Their denial of racial inequality and, at times, their discrimination against their darker-skinned counterparts gave weight to revolutionary leaders’ constructed dichotomy of exile racism versus revolutionary anti-racism. Chapter 4, ‘Cuba Calls!’, examines the way revolutionary leaders sought strategic alliances with African-American tourists, famous athletes, or the Harlem community, in order to cement claims of the revolution's victory over racial inequality on the island and its leading role in anti-racist and anti-imperialist causes globally. Yet once again, Benson finds, visual culture belied a more paternalistic strain in revolutionary rhetoric. ‘At the same time that revolutionary leaders claimed to respect … African Americans in New York, they also belittled them by portraying U.S. blacks as inferior and in need of Cuban aid’, Benson suggests (p. 186).
By late 1960, Benson argues, an early period of openness regarding race had closed. By mid-1961, the killing of the Afro-Cuban literacy teacher Conrado Benítez, purportedly by counter-revolutionaries, gave the state endless fodder for a campaign that emphasised appropriate models of black revolutionary propriety and gratitude, while leaving little space for direct criticism or the expression of alternative ideas about race. After 1961, critical conversations about race were confined either to the private sphere or to the cultural world, where some Afro-Cubans used film, painting, or literature to gently prod the revolution's triumphalist claims. Benson's suggestive epilogue invites future scholars to explore the extent to which casually racist depictions of Afro-Cubans continued to plague revolutionary propaganda and how Afro-Cubans might have creatively reworked or appropriated official anti-racist discourse over the course of the next decades.
Perhaps one minor shortcoming here is that Afro-Cubans and revolutionaries are sometimes conceptualised as two distinct, rather than overlapping, categories. Benson carefully excavates the differences between various Afro-Cuban activist circles, but she might have similarly explored tensions within the broad and shifting revolutionary coalition of 1959–60, which was dominated by but not limited to the 26 July Movement. Such an approach might have illuminated differences, for example, between the racist caricatures found in liberal mainstream dailies such as El Mundo and in the 26 July's publication Revolución, but seemingly eschewed by the Communist press. Yet this is a small objection. Antiracism in Cuba is a deeply insightful, elegantly written and painstakingly researched exploration of race in the early years of the Cuban Revolution and an indispensable contribution to Cuban historiography.
