Introduction
What is the point of sport? For those to whom sport doesn't appeal, it seems futile, pointless. Yet a small child takes pleasure in his or her bodily capacities and adroitness. Gradually the child achieves a measure of physical coordination and mastery. Walking, jumping, dancing, catching, kicking, hitting, climbing, being in water, using an implement as a bat or racquet – all these offer a sense of achievement and satisfaction. Sport it seems to me is an extension of such activities.
This development in coordination is part of the development of a more unified self. Instead of being subject to more or less random movements, we learn to move according to central intentions or trajectories. We begin to know what we are doing and what we are about. The small child celebrates its ability to act in such ways. It begins to find a degree of rhythm and control in its movements. The child hones such skills.
So far, dance and sport are barely distinguishable. Activities that may be the forerunners of either enhance this sense of coordination. Increasing such control implies a pleasure in development, which may perhaps be seen as competing with one's earlier self: one source of pleasure in sport is to surpass one's own earlier achievements.
Sport proper starts to emerge when competition with others begins to play a more central role alongside the simpler delight in physicality. ‘I can run faster than you, climb higher, wrestle you to the floor; I score a goal against you, hit the ball when you try to bowl me out, win in some way or other’. Aggression combines with flamboyance. Sport is an area where aggression and the public demonstration of skills and of character are permitted and even encouraged. For many people who are otherwise inclined to be inhibited or self-conscious, sporting arenas offer a unique opportunity for self-expression and for spontaneity. Within a framework of rules and acceptable behavior, they can be whole-hearted. Such people owe sport a lot; here they can feel more fully themselves. Here they can begin to find themselves, to become the selves that they have the potential to be.
In this process, the child and the adult have to learn to cope with the emotional ups and downs of victory and defeat, success and failure. They – we – learn to keep going against the odds, to struggle back to form, to recognize the risks of complacency. We have to learn to deal with inner voices telling us we are no good, encouraging us to give up, or inviting us to fail rather than risk gloating. In sport the wish to triumph over one's near relatives, fathers and brothers, say, and their representatives, is often strong; there is a need to deal with such emotions, and we find our own ways of doing so, more or less successfully, more or less defensively. The balance between out-and-out aggression and respect for the other, empathy for the defeated other, identification with the winner when we lose – in sport all these processes have to be negotiated. Arrogance and humiliation have to be struggled with.
Spectators identify imaginatively not only with the skills of sportsmen but also with their characters, their characteristic ways of hanging in, of recovery, of fighting back or giving up. These are the dramas of sport.
Sport calls for a subtle balancing too of planning and spontaneity, of calculation and letting go, of discipline and freedom. Coach and former cricketer Greg Chappell said (personal communication); ‘premeditation is the graveyard of batting’. Yet one has to train oneself in the sporting skills, form a reliable technique, and work at it. At the peak of performance one is alert to possible lines of attack by individual and collective opponents, yet able to respond with more or less uncluttered minds to the next play or assault. Like parents with children, we have a complicated job to do in enabling our own selves to find the right balance between self-discipline and free rein. Moments when one is, as a sportsperson, ‘in the zone’, body and mind at one, in harmony, completely concentrated but completely relaxed, aware of every relevant detail of one's surroundings but not obsessed or hyper-sensitive to any set of them, confident without being over-confident, aware of dangers without being over-cautious – such rare states of mind are akin to being in love. They involve a marriage between the conscious control I mentioned above with the allowing of a more unconscious creativity through the body's knowledge. In such states the role of the conscious mind may primarily be a quiet watching.
I would like to raise three further topics before I move on to a more sustained consideration of competition, which will be the main theme of my talk. One is about what team sport adds over and above whatever is involved in individual sport. The second is: is sport a sublimation of war or fighting? Finally I wish to mention the question: is wanting to win neurotic? (I will return to this later.)
First, then: sport divides into team and individual sports. One of the aims of team sport is to turn a group of individuals from a collection into a team, from a group functioning according to basic assumptions (Bion, Reference Bion1961) into a team with differentiated roles, with room for individual expression but in a context of the whole team's interest – that is, into a team functioning more as a work group than as a basic assumption group. Team sport thus calls for the balance between self-interest and group interest. The members of the team have at times to constrain themselves in the interests of the team; they also have the benefit of the team's support when things are hard for them individually.
Second, what is the relation of sport to fighting and war? Is sport a sublimation of the wish to kill and triumph at any cost? Murderousness does require sublimation by means of the imposition of limits, whether internalized or purely external and also by the shift from actual death to symbolic death. When the cricket batman is dismissed, he has to leave the arena, thus suffering symbolic death. Sport exists within a boundary, often a physical boundary, but also a time boundary; for so many hours or minutes, or until so many actions have taken place, or until such and such outcomes have occurred, for so long these rules apply, this game continues. Specially designated intervals occur, intervals, close of play, or gaps between innings, in which there is a lull, rest or pause. When the game is over, players shake hands, and may have a beer together. Aggression is constitutive of the game, but there are many limits; not any sort of delivery is permitted; there are penalties for breaking the rules, there are ethical issues beyond the rules themselves on which participants almost universally concur.
Such factors distinguish sport from violence or murder. But what about war? Is sport a sublimation of war? The problem with that theory is that in most war-encounters too there are rules of engagement, whether culturally agreed or laid down more formally in international conventions. Thus there are agreed rules regarding the treatment of prisoners of war, there are rules that require respect for the enemy's dead. There are conventions about the different responsibilities of combatants in relation to non-combatants. War allows killing and maiming, but not any killing or maiming. War is itself violence sublimated.
Moreover if one thinks of the play of young animals, or of playful interactions between the young and their parent, one sees that the limitations on aggression are built-in from the start. It is not that there is a an impulse to kill which has to be civilized; more that the impulse to kill is one thing, functioning in certain contexts, whilst the instinct to play – to wrestle, tickle, fight – is another, limited and controlled from the start. So I'm inclined to think that much of the partly aggressive play in sport is intrinsically different in motivation and outcome from the aggression in fighting or in war.
Third, is the wish to win neurotic or immature? Is the risk-taking in some sport (for example, mountain climbing) neurotic or narcissistic? I would say not (I will come back to this later), or, perhaps, not when the risk is realistically assessed and soberly taken; when nothing is done for show. Rather, unwillingness to win, or to strive to win, is often the more defensive outcome.
1. Competition and Cooperation
Rivalry and competitiveness are central to sport, and cricket is no exception. But cricket has a further feature that many other sports lack – that while all the individual dramatic moments that consecutively and collectively constitute the game are between two individual protagonists, batsman and bowler, each of these takes its place in, and is to some extent influenced by, the overall context of the contest between the two teams. So cricket, like baseball but unlike soccer or golf or tennis, involves individual contests in the context of team competition. Unlike baseball, however, cricket's contests between bat and ball can last for long time periods – days, even – and go through many ups and downs. A weather-vane in the shape of Father Time surveys Lord's Cricket Ground, the ‘home of cricket’ – symbolizing both the fact that time brings everything to an end and, perhaps, the timelessness of the experience of watching and playing cricket. Cricket is unique in its potential for drawn-out struggles between two people, each with his powerful narcissistic wishes for admiration and fears of humiliation, all within a team context. In every sport much is at stake in terms of bearing the threat of failure (for the batsman, as I've said, symbolic death, evoking the deposition of a king).
If human beings were not combative no one would have invented sport. But if human beings were not also cooperative neither team nor individual games would have found a place in society. For reasons I will come to, rivalry can – and indeed should – be taken close to the limit. But alongside this, cricket also involves the recognition of the unspoken or unprescribed realities of the spirit, respect and generosity of the game. This is not merely a matter of obedience to the laws (or rules) governing the game; it also involves the kinds of ordinary civilities that oil the wheels of relationships and collegial activities, the recognition of limits, the consideration and respect, and the give and take of a kind of dialogic interplay on the field.
2. Healthy Competition
Healthy rivalry between respecting individuals requires and fosters a developmentally necessary differentiation of self from other. In many contexts rivalry is a necessary feature of life. It supports proper ambition; it can help develop a full self, with a fuller growth of one's capacities; and it allows the other, in competitive situations, to strive and express him- or herself freely.
Rivalry does not entail lack of respect for one's opponent, whatever the outcome of the match or series. Test cricket – the highest level of the game, international matches played over 5 days – is, like many other forms of sport, rightly a tough business. But there is another side of these tough contests which can too easily be forgotten, and that is the playfulness and consideration between hard, high-powered competitors. When at Edgbaston in 2005 England won a Test against Australia by the tiny margin of two runs, England's hero Andrew Flintoff left the team huddle at the moment of victory and put his arm round his defeated opponent Brett Lee. He was not only commiserating with the pain of defeat, a boot which could so easily have been on the other foot. He also I think acknowledges the kinship between the rivals. For we not only want to defeat our opponents, we also depend on them and their skill, courage and hostility in order to prove and improve our own skills, to earn and merit our pride. There is a unity of shared striving, as well as a duality of opposition. The eleven players on each team form bonds through their shared skills and teamwork that are sometimes hard to replicate in the less dramatic intensities of everyday life. (Similarly after WW1 the closeness felt with their fellow soldiers could make domestic ties for the discharged survivors feel unreal and pallid by comparison). Somewhat similarly, the 22 players in a Test match go through it together, in a way that no spectator does. The Latin etymology of both ‘rival’ and ‘compete’ reflect this fact: rivalis meant ‘sharing the same stream’, competens meant ‘striving together with’, ‘agreeing together’, as in ‘competent’.
One motive for striving so desperately for success may link with the desire to refute earlier doubters; a ‘highly successful [musician] interpreted her whole career as an extended exercise in proving wrong the primary school teacher who had ignored her talents’, writes Ed Smith (Reference Smith2008). The writer refers here to a healthy bloody-mindedness in reaction to a snub. This is part of proper pride. Envy and jealousy also play a part in, and are not always easily accommodated within, ordinary rivalry. Dickie Dodds, the Essex opening batsman, was once out without scoring on a pitch that was perfect for batting. Essex went on to dominate the morning session, and by lunch had reached 150 without losing any further batsmen. Having had to watch his team's success from the pavilion, Dodds came up to Doug Insole, one of the ‘not out’ batsmen, and said, ‘Skipper, I hope you haven't been troubled by any bad vibes this morning?’ Insole replied, ‘Can't say I have, Dickie, been too busy enjoying myself – why do you ask?’ ‘Because I've been so full of bitterness I've not been wishing you well.’ Here is an understandable and very human envy; since there was also frankness, remorse and regret, it did not spoil the relationship.
In 1976–77, I was fortunate enough to play five Tests in India. One of India's formidable quartet of spin bowlers was Eripalli Prasanna. He was a short, somewhat rotund off-spinner, with large, dark, expressive eyes, and a wonderful control of flight. For some reason, he and I would engage in a kind of eye-play. His look would say, ‘OK, you played that one all right, but where will the next one land?’ And mine would reply, ‘Yes, you fooled me a little, but notice I adjusted well enough.’ He had that peculiarly Indian, minimal, sideways waggle of the head, which suggests that the vertebrae of the sub-continental neck are more loosely linked than in our stiffer Western ones. The waggle joined with the eyes in saying: ‘I acknowledge your qualities, and I know you acknowledge mine.’
I found it easier to enter in to such an engagement with a slow bowler, who might bamboozle me and get me out, but wasn't going to hurt me physically. But I had something similar with some fast bowlers, especially when we were more or less equally likely to come out on top. With such bowlers I could actually enjoy their best ball, pitching on a perfect length in line with off stump and moving away. I also enjoyed the fact that it was too good to graze the edge of my bat. There was the same friendly and humorous rivalry. The spirit of cricket – or more broadly, of sport itself – at its best, I think.
But how much do we really desire to be tested, in life or in sport? If the opposition's best fast bowler treads on the ball before the start of a Test match (as did Glenn McGrath in the match I referred to above) and cannot play, is one relieved or disappointed? There is no escaping the relief. We all want an easier ride. And it would be easy to be hypocritical, falsely high-minded, and say insincerely that we regret that the opposition team is thus hampered. But at the same time there is also a wish – in the participants as well as among spectators – for the contest to be fought with each side at its best, not depleted, so that no one can cavil at victory or make excuses for defeat; similarly, one might take more pleasure in scoring fifty against the great Australian bowlers Dennis Lillee and Jeff Thomson than in making a big hundred against lesser bowling.
There are many inevitable differences between spectators and participants: one is that the spectator wants to see the very best pitted against each other; part of the pleasure of watching a big innings by a great batsman depends on its being played against the best bowlers around, perhaps in conditions that help them. Spectators (except for the most partisan) enjoy evenly balanced matches, with both sides playing at their best, as well as being at full strength. Again, the players' feelings will be mixed. We all hope our opponents have an off-day, and that we win by a large margin. But the players also have another strand within them, one that values the close contest and relishes the battle. They cannot fully hope for it, as a neutral spectator can, but they can enjoy it and feel most fully alive through it.
Opponents challenge us. If we are up to it, they stretch us, call forth our courage, skill, cunning and resourcefulness; they force us to develop our techniques, or lag behind. Sometimes they compel an honesty about our limitations. In this way, they are like psychoanalysts, helping us to be stronger by revealing our shortcomings. But it is also the case that patients challenge their analysts.
3. Psychoanalysis and Sport
I retired from cricket some time ago; now I work as a psychoanalyst. One patient tells me his relentless denigration of me is for my benefit: it keeps me on my toes and stops me becoming complacent or arrogant as a result of the sycophantic adoration he assumes my other patients give me. This patient's trenchancy has different aims, motives and outcomes. For example, there is in his attitudes and behavior toward me the unconscious aim of letting me know what it is like to be unappreciated. One danger is that the psychoanalyst may get secret masochistic pleasure from such encounters, or may allow himself to become paralyzed. But what this patient says is valid and important in that there may often be something in his critical attitude, which I need to learn from. Moreover, patients need to be able to bring the whole of themselves to the analysis, including that which in ordinary life is often avoided or masked by politeness and insincerity.
This connects psychoanalysis with sport, as well as with art. In all three, within the safe (or safe-ish) boundary that separates each from ordinary or ‘real’ life, things can be said and done, and emotions expressed, that cannot otherwise be said or shown. For that freedom to be allowed or enabled by the analyst, without his losing his analytic capacities, patients are often deeply grateful. And the analyst too should be grateful for the generosity of the patient in thus risking so much. In parenthesis, there is a further link between sport and psychoanalysis and art, in that whilst nothing in sport, say, matters in comparison with the loss of a single life in, say, Northern Ireland or Afghanistan, it is often only through these safely set-aside areas of play and competition that the range of our qualities can be tried out, expressed and perhaps established as part of a fuller self.
The psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott (Reference Winnicott1969) addressed this when he spoke of the need for the child, and later the patient, to feel he has hurled the full force of his aggression at the parent or the analyst and yet has not destroyed them (or rendered them weak or ineffectual, unable to function properly in their respective roles). Winnicott argued that such visceral truthfulness is part of the process whereby the child or patient comes to accept the urgency of his own subjectivity while more fully recognizing the subjectivity of the other. It takes courage to risk all in this sort of way, and courage and generosity to accept it without either retreat or revenge. Martial arts like kung fu illustrate and teach this lesson. One has to defend oneself from attack by using the force of the opponent, by stepping back but then stepping forward to deliver a blow that hits home without necessarily being too damaging.
It is in this context that we see most clearly the need we have of wholehearted and skillful opponents. Without rivalry there could be no sport, but rivals also need each other in their cooperative role. They are co-creators of excellence and integrity, in sport as in analysis. As the old Yorkshire and England batsman Maurice Leyland once said: ‘Fast bowling keeps you honest.’
4. Fear of Competition
Competition can get out of hand, turning into cheating, vindictiveness and narcissistic destructiveness. Over-valuation of competitiveness can crush and inhibit the growing child. It can spoil relationships, and reduce love to trophy-seeking. I will come back briefly to this in the next section. But it can also be perverted in the opposite direction. Some people refrain from competing wholeheartedly because they are afraid of winning, and even avoid doing so. This may be because of their fear of triumphalism, or because they are over-identified with the pain of the opponent. I knew a young boy who desperately wanted to win the first game with his father, but then equally desperately needed to lose the second, so that neither party would lose face, or have to bear too much disappointment, or have to deal with his own tendency to gloat. One might think, loftily, that the mature attitude to winning in sport is not to mind. The opposite is true. Not minding often means avoiding really trying.
I once played for a spell as a guest player for an English professional side on a short tour involving a number of matches. During the first half of the tour, we had tried our best but lost more than we won. We had been facing good and talented players, in their conditions. The matches were played hard, even though they were not part of any ongoing competitive leagues or series. In the next game, we were led by the newly arrived captain, against a very strong side. This captain preferred to emphasize the entertainment element in the game, this being a supposedly ‘friendly’ fixture; not wanting to be too serious, he did not use his front-line bowlers, allowing the opposition batsmen to display their most powerful strokes. He thus ‘gave’ batsmen runs. They scored an even bigger total than they would have without his misguided generosity, bowled flat-out against us, and we limped to a crushing defeat. This gesture of giving runs patronized the other team and robbed each party of the satisfaction of doing their best and striving properly to win. We did not properly lose (though we did lose face and respect). The gilt on our opponents' win was tarnished.
Such dilution or evasion of proper rivalry can also occur out of a wish to look good in someone's eyes. One Test captain, whom I won't name, decided during the afternoon of the last day that his batsmen should play for a draw rather than take further risks in going for a win. He was, however, reluctant to be seen as, and be criticized for being, a defensive captain. This happened to be the first Test for a young batsman in the middle order; he hadn't scored in the first innings, and been given a hard time by the crowd, who wanted its local hero selected in place of the youngster. When he went in to bat the captain gave him the following orders: ‘Play for a draw, but don't make it look as if we're playing for a draw.’ This was hypocritical and cowardly; the task for the young player was difficult enough without having to act a role. This captain was more interested in how he himself looked than in competing properly or supporting and protecting a young player.
I even have some doubts about what was from one viewpoint a notable example of nobility and generosity. The great Surrey and England batsman, Jack Hobbs, said once that as Surrey had a lot of good batsman, and the Oval pitch was usually easy for batting, when he and Andy Sandham had put on 150 or so for the first wicket, he'd sometimes give his wicket to ‘the most deserving professional bowler’. (When the pitch was difficult, or Larwood and Voce were bowling, that was when he really earned his money, he went on). But in making a gift of his wicket, did Hobbs also belittle the recipient of the gift, who had not by his own skill and persistence forced an error? The bowler was treated not man to man, but man to boy. There was, or might have been, an element of the feudal in Hobbs' largesse.
In the great battles of sport, no quarter is given and none expected. These are occasions when observers tremble with awe. When highlights of Test matches in Australia were for the first time broadcast in UK, in 1974, England were blasted by fierce fast bowling from Lillee and Thomson on some bowler-friendly pitches; my Middlesex colleague, Mike Smith, reported pouring himself a large gin and tonic, and hiding behind the sofa to watch.
Many cricket-followers will remember the contest between South African fast bowler Allan Donald and Michael Atherton at Trent Bridge in 1998. A great fast bowler hurled all his aggression, power and skill at a defiant, courageous, gritty, slender English batsman, a battle given an extra tinge of menace by the umpiring mistake as a result of which Atherton had just been given not out when he had gloved Donald to the 'keeper. The most memorable contests are those where the aggression is raw, but contained, perhaps only just, within the bounds of respect for the opposition and for the rules and traditions of the game.
But there is still no need for unpleasant language, for bad-mouthing, for what is known in cricket as ‘sledging’. In my experience the great West Indian fast bowlers said nothing to the batsman on the field. One might say: they had no need to – first because of their superlative ability, but second because they were quite able to convey menace by eye contact. It happened that, when I played my first Test match, against the West Indies, in 1976, both teams were staying at the same hotel in Nottingham. I ran into Andy Roberts at breakfast. He gave me a quizzical little look, not crudely unpleasant, but conveying, I felt, something along the lines of ‘Shall I be eating you for breakfast or for lunch?’ Andy gave these looks on the field too; like Helen of Troy's face, which launched a thousand ships, Andy's conveyed a thousand words.
When England were about to tour India in 1976, some of us who were in the team took the opportunity to ask Len Hutton, one of the greatest batsmen of all time, and a Yorkshireman noted for his dry, enigmatic comments, for advice. Len appeared characteristically guarded. He then uttered a single short sentence: ‘don't take pity on them Indian bowlers’.
I am aware, of course, that recreational sport played for fun also has an important role, to do with giving people a chance, sharing the batting and the bowling; of one recreational captain it was said that ‘his captaincy had twin aims: to give every player a good game and to beat the opposition as narrowly as possible.’ But in sport we have the opportunity, and the license, to assert ourselves as separate and authentic individuals against others who have the same license; and this potential can allow us to find our own unique identity, while respecting that of others. And this is part of a wider growth of the personality, of which one aspect would be the Quaker capacity to ‘tell Truth to Power’. One element in telling the truth is being able to say no, to stand firm against powerful and sometimes bullying forces, without becoming a bully oneself. The more strenuous and spirited aspects of competitiveness enhance self-development, courage and sheer exhilaration. They can also be the occasion and source of the development of new methods and techniques. Correlatively, being less than wholehearted is liable to be, though it may not be, a kind of evasion or cowardice.
5. Contempt for the Opponent
However, competition is not always so straightforward or so simple. It is often contaminated by disrespect, contempt, envy and other factors. When such things predominate, competition is corrupted into triumph at any cost, friendly rivalry turns into poisonous scorn, and defeat becomes a humiliation to be averted or reversed at any cost.
There are differences that would be hard to define between appropriate shrewdness in undermining an opponent and boorish expressions of contempt. Cricket is after all not only a physical game; it includes bluff, menace, ploy and counter-ploy. Setting a field is not only a matter of putting someone where the ball is most likely to go, but also of making the batsman wonder what is coming next, or making clear to him that the captain thinks he lacks certain strokes. The aim is that he will be undone by such a ‘statement’ either into loss of nerve or into reckless attempts to prove the captain wrong. Words may enter into this; a captain might say within a batsman's hearing ‘you don't need anyone back there for him’ – and I would be inclined to see this as a fair enough nibble at the batsman's state of mind. Viv Richards' swagger at the crease and Shane Warne's slow, mesmerizing nine-step walk which took up most of his so-called ‘run-up’ allowed each to state unequivocally that this was their stage, and that their opponents had little right to share it with them. All this seems to me to be acceptable, even admirable. But such attitudes can tip over into arrogance, superiority, contempt – even a sort of gang warfare.
Superiority and arrogance may be endemic in a person or a culture. The British Empire was riddled with it. Military and administrative power was identified with cultural superiority. The British had many terms of abuse or disparagement for members of subject races or cultures. Such attitudes, which were often unconscious and automatic, involved stereotyping, projection, and splitting. In the atmosphere of colonial times, these psychological processes allowed white people to represent black players as all spontaneity and exuberance, but lacking in resolution and solidity, technique and discipline. They were said to fall apart in panic more quickly than we whites do, as if children in comparison with us, the adults. Of course this meant that for many years it was out of the question for a black man to captain a national team, for children cannot be adults, and children need mature parental leaders.
If one is treated terribly there are various possible psychological outcomes. Perhaps the most insidious is when a person takes on the identity that is attributed to him and becomes in his own eyes worthless. The racist is internalized, becomes part of one's own self; one begins to treat oneself as an object only. The psychoanalyst Fakhry Davids, for example, describes a young black boy in England who came to see the brownness of his skin as dirty (Reference Davids1996).
But of course traumatic abuse (of which colonial and racist attitudes are an example) can have other outcomes in its victims. One is a countervailing arrogance and even cruelty: the leaders of the French Revolution degenerated within a few years from high principles to self-righteousness and a frenzy of base revenge. Sadism can be exciting. Moreover we defend ourselves against a feeling of inferiority, envy and humiliation by projection, by ridding ourselves of these feelings in ourselves and placing them in others, whether those who are below us in the pecking order or those who previously formed the powerful elite.Footnote 1
One example is of a bowler who regularly expressed contempt for the captain's ideas, provoking sharp and mutually hostile exchanges. It took a long time for the latter to realize that part of the bowler's contempt grew from his own insecurity, that he felt at times humiliated and inferior, and that he tried to deal with such uncomfortable states of mind by inflicting something similar on others and especially on the captain. We are all liable to identify with powerful figures in our attempt to escape from inferiority (whether this inferiority complex is inflicted on us, or becomes part of ourselves, or derives more from our own anxieties), thus trying to reverse the experience of being put down from above.
In other words, the weapon can turn into an inverse racism, fueled by hurt and resentment. What is one to say, for example, of one writer's description (whether accurate or not) of Viv Richards batting at Lord's: ‘he intimidated, mocked, and perhaps humiliated such gatherings. It was political. The score had to be settled.’ Is this an admirable and honorable part of a proper pride in response to centuries of humiliation? Or is it a counter-racism? The writer also stated as part of the player's attitude this sentiment: ‘We must not let the brothers down.’
6. Transcending Contempt
Competitiveness can also be a route to, and expression of, proper pride. Cricket was the quintessential game of the British Empire. In the early days, the colonial cricket authorities in most West Indian islands kept blacks (and ‘coloreds’ according to the designations of the time) out of many clubs and out of representative teams. They sometimes dishonestly based such exclusion on the grounds that black players were professionals, not amateurs. Trinidad was a partial exception in the 1890s, allowing their fast bowlers, ‘Float’ Woods and Archie Cumberbatch, and batsman Lebrun Constantine to play in matches against visiting English teams. The same bowlers were not, however, allowed to play in inter-island matches (Seecharan, Reference Seecharan2006) Exclusion is a powerful form of splitting. They are not like us; we do not want to play with or against them.
Yet sport can transcend such constructions: it is not easy to keep good players out indefinitely – skill will out. In the West Indies, small integrations led to recognition of the qualities, personal and technical, of the trailblazers, which in turn forced the extension of recognition to other non-white players. Moreover, there were also voices for inclusion amongst the local whites and visiting grandees, just as there were advocates of education, enfranchisement, and human rights. In Jamaica, for example, there was a prominent advocate of Fabian socialism in no less a figure than Sydney Olivier, who was Governor of that island between 1907 and 1913, having previously been its Colonial Secretary. In 1928, the West Indies entered the world stage with a multiracial team captained by a white man. In 1948, George Headley became their first black captain, though his reign lasted for only a single match. And then, finally, after a long campaign led by the Marxist critic C.L.R. James, Frank Worrell was in 1960 appointed the first permanent black captain of the West Indies (see James, Reference James1963). Talent and capability had conquered prejudice.
What is so remarkable about the story of the rise of West Indian cricket – a rise that culminated in an extraordinary period of world dominance during the 1970s and '80s – is that people who had been enslaved and then released into a world of prejudice, arrogance and power, with many of these arrangements extending into cricket, should have been so patient, so keen to learn, so open to values that they found in this colonial game. Self-disparagement is one consequence of racial and other kinds of trauma, yet cricketers like Wood, the Constantines (father and son), Headley and Worrell were able through their exploits and attitudes to build up the self-respect of their fellows, so that the next generation could be stronger, more determined, more in touch with their proper pride. It seems to me that those West Indians were able to be humble (in the sense of knowing they had a lot to learn) without being abject, and proud without being arrogant. They were prepared to celebrate the glass as half full rather than rage against its being half empty. They were willing also to wait. It was thanks to their pride and forbearance that the next generation of West Indians, Richards included, could triumph so memorably in what was able to be, by then, healthy competition between true equals.
7. Conclusion
One central element in sport is competitiveness. I have argued for its value in our development. It is important to have arenas somewhat set aside from ordinary life where such things are permitted and even encouraged, for only in such ways do we give ourselves the chance to challenge our complacency or mediocrity. Our opponents thus become our collaborators in the search for excellence.
