From Jimmie Rodgers to Ben and Jerry's ice cream, Americans have been repeatedly reminded that the peach is synonymous with Georgia (4). These references are filled with a romanticism that harkens to past worlds, peaceful rurality, and sometimes, beautiful white southern women. The peach mythos is far too palatable. In The Georgia Peach, William Thomas Okie explores the fruit's mythos and the relationships among agriculture, environment, and culture by uncovering the strenuous work of white horticulturists, black laborers, scientists, boosters, educators, guest workers, and politicians that connected Asia, Europe, and Latin America to middle Georgia. Entwined in the human story is the power of peach materiality itself, its flesh and perishability. The results, “The fruit's cultural presence has been more lasting than and just as important as its physical presence because it emerged as a viable commodity at a moment when the South was desperate for an improved reputation—a new face,” Okie argues. And although the peach became harder to cultivate, “peach growers used this cultural capital to call upon local, state, and federal aid in the waning decades of the twentieth century” (5). Yet Okie's work does not aim to completely shoot down myths: he argues that environmental beauty of the peach and peach orchards are also an essential part of its history.
The peach mythos was entangled in boosterism and horticulturists’ visions of agricultural reform for the American South. Okie discusses horticulturists like Reverend Stephen Elliott who extolled fruit cultivation as a way to beautify southern landscapes blighted by cotton culture while subtly critiquing slavery. These visions were transnational as well, and Prosper Berckmans, a Belgian transplant, came to Augusta and began a journey to create wealth while diversifying and beautifying southern agricultural environments. Georgia native Samuel Rumph experimented with and refined peach growing and introduced the Elberta, named for his first wife. Today it is an heirloom, but during Rumph's life, Elberta was a mainstay and emblematic: the peach was indeed a white woman. At the end of the nineteenth century, J. H. Hale, a northern horticulturalist, built the industry with capital, expertise, and an enthusiasm to exploit African Americans and a long legacy of southern race relations. Within a few decades, the work of progressive boosters to create a county named for the fruit hardened its mythos. White booster Mabel Swartz Withoft was the heart of the Peach County campaign. She organized elaborate pageants and festivals that convinced onlookers that the pitted fruit would bring prosperity and splendor to Georgia while ensuring African Americans were ancillary or in subordinate positions in her displays. Horticulturists’ and boosters’ rhetoric contributed to notions that the peach was good for rural landscapes and people while signaling a shift away from cotton. However, the peach never fully replaced cotton and instead worked alongside the rhythms of cotton season. Horticulturists’ “progressive” outlooks depended on a history of white exploitation of black labor. As Okie asserts, “There could be no rosy sea without a black belt” (145).
The visions of black reformers are equally important to the peach story. As Withoft hailed the peach, Henry Hunt headed the historically black Fort Valley High and Industrial School (FVHIS) with the support of white northern philanthropists and horticulturalists like Hale. Hunt and other black progressives put their faith in agriculture as a means for uplift of African American communities. “For local blacks, FVHIS appeared to represent a kind of quiet liberation from the oppressive darkness of white dominance. For whites it seemed to be about the business of training a ‘punctual, hard-working honest and dependable’ labor force,” Okie argues (169). Despite Hunt's faith in agricultural education and rural improvement, by the 1930s, New Deal reforms and other agricultural changes made their goals increasingly untenable. However, black reformers’ visions were not all for naught. Armed with their own ideas of improvement, they fertilized the soils that grew civil rights activists who fought Jim Crow and eventually Woolfolk Chemical Company who polluted local watersheds with agricultural poisons. Peach culture was connected to the civil rights movement in Georgia.
Okie reveals the importance of materiality through market, labor, and environmental problems. Growers had to ensure that a fresh, bruise- and blemish-free peach hit the markets. Okie points out that “time, space, and weather,” coupled with the fruit's perishability, worked against farmers (141). Moreover, peach picking was labor intensive and growers needed workers with keen eyes and gentle hands to ensure the picked and packed fruit was high quality. This was labor-intensive and low-paying work: black workers engaged in an exodus from orchards especially during and after World War II. A labor shortage became apparent to growers. From the Bracero Program and the use of Italian and German prisoners of war to today's H2-A program, orchard growers looked to federal help for a continual global labor supply. Pests loved the peach as much as people, too. As early as the 1890s and throughout the industry's history, growers struggled with menaces like the San Jose Scale, the plum curculio, and peach tree short life disease. Initially, growers found that it was easier to control pests through the control of labor, but throughout the twentieth century, growers became gradually more dependent on agricultural research and chemicals. Okie reinforces the multiple ways materiality shapes agriculture and culture.
The Georgia Peach is methodologically innovative, thoroughly researched, and is an important contribution to several fields. This work demonstrates the importance of the materiality of commodities and is an approach that historians of labor, agriculture, environment, and science ought to consider. Okie's concept of environmental beauty, which undergirds this work, will prompt others to give greater complexity and nuance to the history of progressivism. The book is a joy to read as well. The stories of beauty are not just woven throughout, but are embodied in Okie's style. The Georgia Peach is brilliantly written. Okie begins the first pages asking the reader, “Would you care to read The Georgia Peach?” (2). Your answer ought to be, “Yes, please.”
