This is the first biography of Michael Polanyi, chemist, social theorist, philosopher and religious thinker. The book is based on theoretical physicist William T. Scott's thorough and extensive research. Scott devoted seventeen years to the study of Polanyi's life and work, consulting a wealth of sources, including unpublished letters and diaries, and conducting interviews with over 120 people. After Scott's death in 1999 the theologian Martin X. Moleski revised and completed the manuscript. Moleski notes that the finished book is not the book that Scott wrote, nor the one he would have written had he been on his own; nevertheless, the book before us tells a very readable story. It offers a vivid account of Polanyi's intellectual trajectory, interspersed with vignettes from his family life. It also does enough to give the reader a sense of how Polanyi's career was shaped by major developments of European history: the First World War, which saw him as a medical officer in the army; the Hungarian revolution and its aftermath, which forced him and his family to emigrate to Germany; and the oppressions of the Nazi regime, which brought him and his family from Berlin to Manchester. The book also contains a comprehensive bibliography of Polanyi's works (they cover more than twenty pages) and a few images.
The four parts of the book trace Polanyi's moves from country to country. Part I deals with his early years in Hungary, his medical education and army service there, and the beginning of his engagement with physical chemistry. Part II takes us to Germany. Polanyi and several members of his family left Hungary in 1919 when the anti-Semitic Horthy regime had gained a strong foothold, making it highly unlikely that Polanyi, who was of Jewish origin, would find a permanent scientific post. The very detailed summaries of the researches on physical chemistry Polanyi pursued in Karlsruhe and Berlin clearly benefit from Scott's expertise as a working scientist. We also learn in this part about Polanyi's family life and, particularly in the later chapters, about the tyranny of the growing Nazi movement that he and many of his colleagues experienced. Part III opens with an account of Polanyi's negotiations with the University of Manchester about a position in the newly founded physical chemistry division. The unstoppable rise of the Nazi regime made life in Germany intolerable for Polanyi and his family, and led him to take up the Manchester post. It was in Manchester that there occurred the fundamental reorientation of Polanyi's career, from physical chemistry to the ‘philosophy of freedom’ and what Moleski calls Polanyi's ‘defense of faith’ (p. xii). Polanyi made the change from physical chemistry to social theory and philosophy official in 1948, when he took up a post in the Faculty of Economics and Social Studies at Manchester. At that time, he had already produced a substantial body of work on economics (including motion pictures), on patent law and, above all, on the freedom and autonomy of science. Now he struggled with the ideas eventually expressed in his Gifford Lectures, in which he developed his standpoint on questions of faith, doubt and the threat to truth and objectivity that he saw in nihilism and Marxism. This part ends with Polanyi's work on Personal Knowledge (1958), a book that seeks to provide an alternative to the scepticism of the Enlightenment and emphasizes the role of belief as the source of all knowledge. Part IV follows Polanyi, now senior research fellow at Merton College, Oxford, on his numerous trips to various European countries and especially to the US. His many travels seem to have been attempts to escape the feeling of isolation that he experienced among the Oxford philosophers, with their strong analytical bent. Polanyi found his most appreciative audience in the US and lectured there often, sometimes for extended periods. He also committed substantial time and energy to working with the anti-communist organization Congress of Cultural Freedom.
The book's narrative opens up many avenues for further research. The authors occasionally identify specific aspects that may have inspired Polanyi's writings about the relation between scientific knowledge and research, freedom and religious belief. Some of his early reflections on the organization of scientific life were clearly influenced by the sociopolitical context in which he worked, such as the British debates about centralized control of science in the 1930s. The authors also claim that certain principles Polanyi expounded in his later philosophical work, particularly in Personal Knowledge, resonate with his early experiences as an active scientist, notably his involvement in the controversy about the chemical nature of isotopes in 1915. The authors also seek to explain why Polanyi's philosophical work was little heeded during his lifetime. They suggest that because his approach to philosophy was grounded in chemistry and medicine, and because he did not have formal training in philosophy, his works were undervalued by other philosophers; he was regarded as a dilettante and an interloper, and as a consequence remained isolated as a scholar.
It would be intriguing to go more deeply into these issues, to analyse in depth how Polanyi's science, philosophy and religious and political views informed one another, and to assess the impact he had on the new turn philosophy of science took in the 1960s. For such inquiries, and others touching on Polanyi's rich and wide-ranging oeuvre, Michael Polanyi, Scientist and Philosopher will serve as an indispensable source of information.
