The subtitle of Paul Ryscavage's biography of fin de siecle Chicago speculator and director, Norman B. Ream, is “forgotten master of markets.” But Ream might be better described as a “jack” than a “master.” Ryscavage is unusually motivated, even for a biographer, to rescue his subject from the unjust neglect of history or historians. Drawing almost entirely on published sources, Ryscavage has managed to construct a thorough biography of a man intimately involved in the growth of both Chicago and the “interlocking directorate” of American corporate governance after 1890.
The book is devoted to chronicling Ream's personal and professional life, with just a short conclusion lamenting Ream's absence from the pantheon of famous corporate leaders. Ream was born in Pennsylvania in 1844. After service in the Civil War and studying accountancy, he began his business career in rural wholesaling in Illinois. After arriving in Chicago in 1871 (Ryscavage says that “simple probability” makes it likely Ream arrived before the October fire), Ream began trading on the Chicago Board of Trade. Ream's success at commodities trading, both current contracts and futures, gave him the money to invest in brickyards, fire insurance, and from the 1880s, Chicago real estate. Having met architect Daniel Burnham in the 1870s, Ream invested in the construction of the Rookery and the Chicago Auditorium, and served on the boards of the two companies responsible for erecting those buildings. A measure of Ream's rising position in Chicago society was his service as a director of both the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition and then the Field Museum. Ream's association with Field grew closer when they lived as neighbors on the wealthy 1900 block of Prairie Avenue after 1886.
Ream invested his growing wealth, the magnitude of which Ryscavage is mostly unspecific on, in an even greater variety of companies in the 1890s, including sugar, bakeries, insurance, steel, and railroads. Personal and professional ties began to draw Ream back to the East Coast from the late 1890s, with the move complete by 1907. Ryscavage argues that the pinnacle of Ream's career was his director's position with U.S. Steel at its founding in 1901. The last quarter of the book is dominated by Ream's involvement with U.S. Steel until his death in 1915. Ryscavage argues that Ream was a confidante of J. P. Morgan, citing their long association in U.S. Steel and other companies. But there is little concrete evidence of how close Ream and Morgan were, for Ryscavage relies entirely on published sources, ignoring the corporate archives which exist for several of the companies for whom Ream served as director. Ryscavage's biography is saturated with affection for the achievements and “character” of Ream, but he might have conveyed a deeper understanding of his subject by using manuscript sources. Ryscavage argues that few exist, writing that “most of the Ream financial ledgers have been lost with the passage of years,” and speculating that “great-grandchildren may be in possession of similar documents.” It does not appear that Ryscavage made much effort to use unpublished sources. For example, Ream's fundraising efforts for the Field Museum are well-documented in the archives of that institution but go unused in this biography. The lack of effort to go beyond published sources contributes, perhaps appropriately for a man who got his break in business speculating, to a speculative tone throughout the volume about what Ream thought, and about the precise timing of some events.
Ryscavage argues that historians have unfairly neglected Ream, while his contemporaries and associates Marshall Field and J.P. Morgan are remembered to this day. It is not that Ream lacks significance: dying in 1915 with a taxable estate of $5.7 million he was one of America's wealthiest men, and was one of the 24 founding directors of United States Steel. But Ream's wide-ranging involvement in many businesses meant he left his name to none. Ream did not have his name on the door, or anywhere else on the building. Without a bank, department store or museum to continue his name in the public eye, it is hardly surprising that a public with skimpy knowledge of their current political leaders will forget a recently or long-past businessman. In the conclusion, Ryscavage compares Ream to his more well-known peers like Morgan, Field, Rockefeller, and Carnegie who “specialized in one industry or pursuit,” and argues that “none of them were as adept and comfortable in a variety of markets” as Ream. Unintentionally, the frequent comparison upwards to wealthier and more famous men does Ream a disservice. The better comparison would be to other diversified investors who made a profession of directing companies, but without leaving their name to those companies. Comparisons to other members of the “interlocking directorate” would be possible had Ryscavage delved deeper into more recent scholarship on corporate America at the turn of the century than he did. While Ryscavage has uncovered a wealth of primary, published material about Ream's career the argument of the book is largely disconnected from contemporary scholarship on the Gilded Age. Ryscavage is right that we need to know more about the careers of America's corporate leadership from this era, where they came from, and the networks they belonged to. This book shows that there is a wealth of published material to construct these biographies. Future biographers of corporate leaders could improve on Ryscavage's work by delving deeper into the archives, and finding a way to standardize their data for comparison and more systematic analysis.
