Aptly named, Empire on Edge captures the precariousness of the settlement of Belize, perched as it was in a remote corner of the Yucatán Peninsula that was to become a British colony in the second half of the nineteenth century through happenstance rather than by grand design.
The first English settlers, a mere handful, arrived sometime in the mid-seventeenth century – not before 1660 but certainly by 1699. According to Burdon's Archives, the Baymen, as they called themselves, aboard the Seaflower on a return trip from Venice carrying a cargo of Venetian beads, were arrested by the Admiralty for non-payment of taxes. Upon trial the Baymen were freed and the judgement was that there could be no payment extracted as Belize was not an English colony and therefore the English government had no jurisdiction over them.
At that time colonies were established with the permission of the Crown. However, in the case of Belize no such permit had been sought and none given. As a result the settlement persisted, making a living from the cutting and sale of logwood, and grew – modestly – against all efforts by Spain to close it down and all efforts by England to ignore the claim of the settlers (when it suited them) that, as English subjects, they were owed protection against the Spanish.
The so-called Mexican Caste War was of seminal importance to Belize on four counts: (i) it quadrupled the population to 25,000 in 1861 with an influx of both Maya and Mestizo people; (ii) it led to a settlement of the northern border question; (iii) it brought an industry, sugar growing and processing, at just the moment when Belize's economic staples were waning; and (iv) it brought changes large and small to the way the country was governed.
Belize formally became a British colony in 1862. Many would consider this inevitable, arguing that things were headed that way from the time of the signing of the Bulwer–Clayton Treaty (1850). On the other hand, there persists a view within Belize that opinion was only shifted because of the need for protection of the Baymen during the Caste War, while at a less substantial level the introduction of the alcalde system to the newly founded Maya villages was also something to be taken into account.
That events of such importance should have been so little treated by historians of Belize gives special importance to Rajeshwari Dutt's work. Apart from the odd paragraph in larger works and some journal articles, there has been only one other substantial study: a PhD thesis by Angel Cal (‘Anglo Maya Contact in Northern Belize: A Study of British Policy toward the Maya during the Caste War of the Yucatán, 1847−1872’, University of Calgary, 1983).
The Caste War has been shown to be a misnomer as a bewildering mix of constantly shifting affiliations gives the lie to any easy attempt to categorise the warring groups along racial or ethnic lines. However, the fighting groups broadly identified themselves as Maya.
Perhaps it needed the insights of borderland studies to properly address the complexities of the cross-border conflict by bringing together different perspectives as well as cultural considerations of the different polities. Here Dutt takes her guiding definition from Jeremy Adelman and Stephen Aron, who make a distinction between ‘frontiers’ as a ‘meeting place in which geographic and cultural borders were not clearly defined’ and ‘borderlands’ – ‘the contested boundaries between Colonial Domains’ (‘From Borderlands to Borders: Empires, Nation-States, and the Peoples in Between in North American History’, American Historical Review, 104: 3 (1999), pp. 814−41).
Dutt takes the case of Belize to singularly embody both frontier and borderland. As frontier, it is well known that a friendly relationship was fostered by trade, and also personal relationships – friendships, marriages, almost certainly of long standing – existed between the peoples on either side of the Río Hondo, the river that marks the northern boundary between Mexico and Belize.
On the other hand, as borderland, from its inception the presence of British individuals on the mainland of Central America was hotly contested by the Spanish Crown during the seventeenth and eighteenth century and intermittently after Mexican independence during the rule of Emperor Iturbide (1821–3) and the imperial reign of Maximilian (1864–7), both of whom wished to reinstate the claim to the original Spanish Empire thereby posing challenges to the British.
Unravelling the many layers of tensions between seeming opposites is the strength of this book and it allows the author to closely examine the role of the Baymen separately from that of the British colonial government in the person of the resident superintendent. As such, it throws new light on the question often asked in the Mexican Caste War literature about the British involvement in the rebellion.
Very well annotated throughout and supported by copious archival material, this book consists of an introduction that sets the context and establishes the theoretical framework. This is followed by Chapters 1–2 detailing the various stages of Maya and Mestizo migration into Belize and developing official policy towards them as they settle in towns and villages of Northern Belize.
Chapters 3, 4 and 5 deal with difficulties arising from Maximilian's claim and cover one of the most terrifying episodes in Belize history – the raids of different Maya groups from the Yucatán into Northern Belize over two decades that culminated in the death of one of the fiercest and most determined leaders, Marcus Canul, who was shot in Orange Walk town by a Mestizo.
Chapter 6 deals with the process of melding the Mestizo/Maya incomers into a creolised society through the agency of the Battle of St. George's Caye (1798) celebrations. The book concludes with the signing in 1893 and later ratification of the Spencer−Mariscal Treaty between Mexico and Britain, ending Belize's supply of arms to the Yucatán and defining the boundary.
A disconcerting fact is that although Dutt explains in her use of terminology she has chosen ‘Hispanic’ to refer to Spanish-descended people to avoid ‘historical inaccuracies’, it is puzzling then that she chooses not to use the name they call themselves, i.e. Mestizo. Notwithstanding, this is an excellent and detailed account of a little-known, but important, episode in Belizean history. It will be of value for many years to come.
