John Stanley Plaskett (1865–1941) was easily Canada's most famous astronomer of the early twentieth century and arguably one of the best-known Canadian astronomers of all time. He was the visionary and directing brain behind the seventy-two-inch reflecting telescope at the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory in British Columbia, which was the second-largest telescope in the world when it was completed in 1918. Plaskett is best-known today for his discovery of ‘Plaskett's star’, a close binary star whose two components were easily the most massive stars known when the discovery was announced in 1922. Of possibly greater scientific significance was his confirmation that our Milky Way galaxy is rotating. Yet perhaps Plaskett's most important contribution of all was to put Canada on the astronomical map. In particular, he played an instrumental role in introducing observational astrophysics to Canada, helping turn his country into a leading scientific nation. Therefore it is perhaps surprising that no book-length biography of the elder Plaskett has ever appeared. This gap in the literature has now been filled by this meticulously researched and handsomely produced biography by Peter R. Broughton, a former president of the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada.
Born and raised on a farm near Woodstock, Ontario, John Stanley Plaskett was a classic example of someone who became a professional astronomer not simply through the standard route of a degree in mathematics or physics, but also through his expertise in instrumentation. After leaving school, Plaskett first trained as a machinist, before securing a job as a technician in the physics department at the University of Toronto. In this role he became an expert in spectroscopy and photography. Eventually, aged twenty-nine and married, he enrolled as a physics student at Toronto. In 1903, he became an assistant at the new Dominion Observatory in Ottawa. Like other national observatories of the time, the Dominion Observatory served as Canada's national centre for positional astronomy, timekeeping and surveying, but from the start it had a strong department devoted to the new science of astrophysics, with a fine fifteen-inch refracting telescope and spectroscope. Broughton very clearly brings out how Plaskett transferred his skills in spectroscopy and photography, originally learned in the physics laboratory, to the observatory. He used these skills to study the properties of stars, particularly a newly discovered class of stars known as spectroscopic binaries – binary stars whose components were too close together to be resolved visually, but whose spectral lines betrayed them as orbiting pairs through the Doppler effect.
In the book's central chapters, Broughton describes how attending a conference at the Mount Wilson Observatory in 1910, where a sixty-inch telescope had recently come into operation, gave Plaskett the idea for a large Canadian telescope. Such an instrument would allow Canadian astronomers to analyse the properties of much fainter stars than was possible at Ottawa and become world leaders in astrophysics. In the years that followed, the idea became reality with the seventy-two-inch reflector at British Columbia. In Broughton's account, Plaskett comes across as a self-publicist who sometimes irritated his colleagues, but this quality helped him successfully lobby his political masters to fund the giant telescope.
Broughton very successfully sets his account of Plaskett's life in the geopolitical context of Canada in the early twentieth century. Plaskett was born two years before Canada achieved dominion status and Broughton shows how, throughout his lifetime, many Canadians saw themselves as living in an outpost of the British Empire. Plaskett, himself of British descent, was no exception. He always looked up to Britain as the ‘home’ country and revered British scientific institutions such as the Royal Astronomical Society. At one point, when looking for an assistant to work at the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory, he informed Astronomer Royal Sir Frank Dyson of his preference for an English rather than an American astronomer.
Northern Star contains plenty of examples of Plaskett's encounters with his fellow astronomers, in Britain and Europe as well as North America. However, I would have liked to see the narrative set more fully in the historical context of early twentieth-century astronomy and astrophysics, as the text contains occasional oversimplifications. For example, Broughton claims that by the 1900s the Victorian world of ‘amateurs’ making astronomical discoveries was now gone, but this was not necessarily true everywhere and the boundaries between ‘amateur’ and ‘professional’ were not as sharply defined as they later became. It would be nearer the mark to say that in North America astronomers were consciously trying to ‘professionalize’ their discipline along the lines established in continental Europe.
Otherwise, Northern Star is an excellent book. It is profusely illustrated with photographs, in both a central section of plates and scattered throughout the text. These, especially the group photographs taken at conferences, give a vivid sense of what professional astronomy might have been like at the time. The author is familiar with astronomical terminology, though he explains this for the more general reader. The book is thoroughly researched, making effective use of archive resources to give an account of Plaskett's life and work that is both scholarly and readable. The text is backed up by some ninety pages of footnotes. There are also appendices listing Plaskett's published papers and lectures. I heartily recommend Northern Star to historians of astronomy and Canadian science – and also to historians of science in relation to imperialism. In addition, it will be of great interest to astronomers working today, continuing the tradition of observational astrophysics that Plaskett and others of his generation did so much to develop.
