Elite artists are curious creatures in contemporary Western societies. While they are known for their antiestablishment lifestyles and radical, inquisitive outlooks, they are also frequently upheld as symbols of national character and achievement. That most Egyptian artists, like the majority of their Third World counterparts, do not share this enigmatic status has sometimes led people to question the strength of artistic expression in their society. This study of elite artists and their promoters in Egypt explains why Egyptian artists have such a different role in relation to their nation–state and reveals why nationalism and socialism are by no means being swept away by globalism and capitalism in Egypt despite three decades of infitāḥ.
Creative Reckonings is as much an ethnography of the Egyptian nation as it is an ethnography of art making in Egypt. For this reason the book will appeal to scholars of nationalism, postcolonialism, neoliberal economic change, and political-identity struggles in the Middle East and beyond. Art provides a useful angle for approaching these topics because it is inextricably part of transnational circulations and hierarchy constructions, as Winegar shows, and cannot be assumed to belong properly to any national realm. Moreover, art has emerged in Egypt, in particular, through the intersections of colonialism and its counter movements, such that it is charged with “historically constituted East/West cultural politics, as well as North/South political struggles” (p. 279). By basing her study in such an “intercultural space,” Winegar is able to trace the urgency and ambivalence of Egyptians’ relationship to a national space that is sometimes held to be secluded and other times cosmopolitan, depending on one's social positioning in relation to the state or externally controlled resources. Taking fine art as a particularly revealing microcosm of Egyptian society and exploring the intersection of colonialism, socialism, nationalism, Islamism, market liberalism, and foreign political interventions in this cultural realm, Winegar is able to demonstrate the ways Egyptians negotiate the structural constraints forming their society. Thus, Winegar reveals that fine art—from painting to sculpture to installation—has provided an important means for people to make “claims about Egypt” that are simultaneously “claims on Egypt” (p. 25).
Winegar's central thesis is that the nation–state remains a potent ground for Egyptians’ agency in the context of the international expansion of liberal capitalism and that there is a symmetrical relationship between globalism and nationalism. Three analytical tools enable her analysis of this phenomenon. This first is genealogy: building on Timothy Mitchell, Dipesh Chakrabarty, and various art theorists, Winegar suggests that universal concepts such as “modernity” or “culture” are grasped through processes of interpretation that root them in competing origins. The second notion is “reckoning,” through which Winegar considers the role her informants play in discerning the meaning of these concepts for their lives and imaginations. The third notion is “generation,” a concept employed by Egyptian art workers to explain social organization and change in terms of common outlooks or lifestyles perceived to join age-mates and produce relationships between different age groups. With these three tools, Winegar traverses much of the same thorny ground discussed by theorists of the clash of civilizations, Third World recedivism, and the rise of militant resistance but sheds new light on the paradoxes and ambivalences that find Egyptians promoting nationalism and globalism, or authenticity and cosmopolitanism, or modernist and folk art, together.
Winegar uses a discursive ethnographic approach that allows her to grapple with strategies employed by her informants without ironing out their inconsistencies. While art workers and scholars may find this approach to be a weakness in so far as it deliberately diverts attention from the art objects themselves, and hence their social agency, the undeniable strength of this method is its foregrounding of the debates and stakes incited through interaction with art objects. In the first chapter, Winegar studies the consequences of the state-initiated art careers and educational institutions based on European models. Beginning with the assertion that art making in Egypt was as much about relationship making, Winegar is able to show that Egyptian artists may aspire to be beacons of taste and culture in their society but not mavericks cast out of it. As a result, Egyptian artists are particularly well positioned to continue to demand state protections in the name of social progress. In her second chapter, Winegar explores the different meanings given by artists to the notion of cultural authenticity, whether as rooted in ethnic place (such an artist is called “aṣī l”) or epic time (called “muʿāṣir”). Unraveling the conflicting meanings of these terms, she explains why neither a folk-based nor individual-based model has won out completely. Further, she calls attention to the importance given by Egyptian culture workers to fahm (understanding) as they negotiate a citizenship that is at once modern and rooted, pious and free thinking, individualist and nationalist. Her work here complements other agent-centered accounts of Arab cultural-political movements, such as that found in the work of Laura Deeb on Islamic mobilization in Lebanon.
The third chapter of Creative Reckonings details the convoluted relationship between art workers and state institutions. It traces the changes in art policy from Nasser to Mubarak that have promoted private-sector involvement in the arts while triggering both neocolonialist appropriations of Egyptian art by Western curators and anticolonialist productions of national sovereignty by artists who saw their new social autonomy as something of an imposition. Extending this, she considers the state promotion of “free” art as a figurehead obscuring the increasing authoritarianism associated with a liberal market and a political distancing from the populace. Winegar concludes, “The battles within the field of artistic production that I have documented here could also ‘produce’ or ‘induce’ nationalism among people who were not otherwise blind patriots” (p. 173). Here again, art is shown to be an especially revealing frame for understanding the struggles of contemporary Arab politics. The fourth chapter continues the study of state–citizenry relations through the funding of public art projects and documents the invocation of “bad taste” to explain state projects run awry and to make claims on national resources. Given that such a sensibility is a common, yet mostly unexplored, theme in Middle Eastern politics and daily life, this chapter will be particularly helpful to scholars. Perhaps most innovative is Winegar's analysis in the fifth and sixth chapters of collecting practices that bring Egyptian art into the homes of elite citizens and Western curating practices that pretend to “put Egypt on the international art map.” Here the author's interests in taste, generation, genealogy, and reckoning converge, as different classes and ages of Egyptians are shown to take up particular art objects and opportunities to produce livable, if contentious, understandings of their nation, although often in unanticipated conflict with neocolonialist discourses about their production.
Interspersed between these theory-rich chapters are much shorter, artist-focused “interludes” that take up these issues through a single career and a handful of specific, nicely illustrated works, several in color. Included are some of the paragons of Egyptian art, such as Gazibiyya Sirri, internationally ignored “pioneers” such as Raghib ʿAyad, and upcoming talents such as Amina Mansour. The fact that their works are cordoned off, as it were, in mostly nontheoretical chapters points to areas where Winegar, and the anthropology of art generally, could do further work: the relationship between discourse and materiality, the role of visible media, and the value of innovation in given media. If the social interpretation and analytical theory always precedes the objects, how are the latter important to social interaction, and how do they inform changing visions of the nation? Assuming that art acts as a vehicle of meaning requires that meaning be largely preformed, not affected significantly by the medium, and thus that art has relevance only after discourse comes into play. This does not explain why the rendering of ideas in certain media is important or how vision becomes a cross-cultural tool. Finally, although it is important to indicate the creativity of artists evidenced in their work, is not creativity, like art, a historically produced, politically valuable category? These gaps are minor areas that invite more work rather than diminishing in any way the value of Winegar's ethnography.
In sum, Creative Reckonings exemplifies an altogether original approach to understanding the contemporary Arab world, studies of which too frequently confine themselves to demographics, politics, sectarianism, or violence and in so doing tacitly reinforce the idea that these are the only areas in which Arabs’ efforts should be recognized. However, before we praise this book for showing the “human” and “creative” side of Arab lives, Winegar invites us to consider how art has come to have such a central role in representing these values at cross-cultural junctures. Here lies what is perhaps the most promising aspect of Creative Reckonings: its likelihood, due to its clear structure, sound methodology, and well-stated social relevance, to inspire more attention to such areas among novices in the field. Written in an engaging style, Creative Reckonings makes for a vivid read, one that can introduce students to the modern Middle East, set a model of socially relevant ethnography for advanced students, or provide a holistic account of life in postcolonial societies. University libraries will find this book an important asset, but so will gallerists and art workers concerned with the Arab world.
