Creating Medieval Cairo is an examination of architectural heritage, conservation, and colonialism in Egypt in the 19th and 20th centuries. Paula Sanders contends that “Medieval Cairo” is not “Cairo as it was in the Middle Ages,” but rather an urban identity created by Europeans in the 19th century (p. 2). To shed light on how Cairo became “medieval” she examines the “Anglo–Indian” colonial experience, which, she argues, influenced the way in which British policymakers approached and understood Egypt. Sanders reasserts Egypt's place within the context of British colonial history and argues that the “Anglo–Indian experience” is not taken into consideration in Egypt's historiography. This lacuna in the literature on colonial Egypt, according to Sanders, has made Egypt stand out from the history of British imperialism as a unique example disconnected from Britain's prior colonial experience. She furthermore asserts that the Ottoman aspect of Egypt's history has also largely been left out of Egypt's historiography, just as Ottoman Imperial historiography has excluded Egypt. Sanders locates her story of the role and influence of preservation in the practices of the colonial administration in order to explain these missing historiographies.
The book comes after a series of studies on preservation in Cairo—most significantly those included in Jere Bacharach's edited volume, which was a response to the 1992 earthquake and the ensuing questions about restoration and preservation. The topic of conservationist practices in Cairo is a particularly rich one because of the vast historical record of remaining structures and has become an intensely political one due to the multiplicity of “heritages” that claim a variety of spatial and material legitimacies to those artifacts. Thus, Sanders’ study raises significant and relevant questions. One of the book's most valuable aspects is that it brings theory to bear on conservation and its practices by conflating aspects of cultural history, colonial rule, and architectural practices to theorize Egyptian modernity and political and religious intentions through the built environment. Also important is that the book deals with the question of Cairo's “medievalness” quite differently from the collection of essays entitled Making Cairo Medieval (Nezar AlSayyad, Irene A. Bierman, and Nasser Rabbat, eds., Making Cairo Medieval [Lanham, Md.: Lexington Books, 2005]), which argued that conservationist practices, combined with colonial imperatives, were largely responsible for these perceptions.
Sanders attributes much of the responsibility of Cairo's perpetuated “medievalness” to the conservationist practices of the Comité de Conservation des Monument de l'Art Arabe (Comité), which was founded in 1881 by Khedive Tawfiq and charged with the preservation and restoration of Islamic monuments in Egypt. She asserts that Britain's policies and experience in India directly influenced the way the British ruled Egypt after occupying it in 1882 and articulated this through its conservationist policies and those of the Comité. Acknowledging that there are only a handful of studies on the Anglo–Indian transfer of colonial knowledge from India to Egypt, Sanders links the Egyptian colonial administration's view, formed while in India, that Islam is a backward religion incapable of reform to the Comité's obsession with “medievalizing” Cairo by restoring only its Mamluk monuments and ignoring other buildings such as those from the Ottoman period. She specifically highlights the role of Lord Cromer, the first Consul-General of Egypt and main representative for the British colonial administration from 1883 to 1907. The suggestion that Cromer's experience in India had a direct influence on the policies of the Comité, however, is tenuous at best because Cromer's Indian experience is neither given adequate space in the text nor thoroughly articulated by Sanders as having a direct relationship to conservation practices in Egypt at this time. Additionally, with regard to the influence of Britain's Indian experience, she briefly introduces the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) (founded by the British in 1861), yet her discussion does not include a comparative analysis with the Comité, which could have been productive and provided specific insights as to their similarities. Unlike the ASI, however, the Comité was founded prior to the British occupation by Khedival order and thus was not conceived as a British colonial instrument but rather as an organization to save Egypt's Islamic heritage, which was being rapidly destroyed by urban modernization efforts or bought or stolen by hordes of European tourists and collectors. Thus, a broader consideration of the Comité's intent and critical comparison to similar British conservationist groups could have yielded valuable insights into the Comité's actions and intentions and more fully supported her argument. More evidence is needed to convincingly demonstrate that there was indeed a connection between the Anglo–Indian/Anglo–Egyptian relationship and architectural heritage and more important, why the connection is significant.
After her analysis of Egyptian reformers and modernity, Sanders argues that the Comité's insistence upon the restoration and preservation of medieval Mamluk Cairo (at the expense of Ottoman and Fatimid Cairo, for example) rejected any notion of a Muslim modernity, including both an Ottoman and an Egyptian modernity, by preserving the “medievalness” of its architecture. She thus paints a familiar picture of how a Western colonial power held back the modernization efforts of an “indigenous” group keen to reform and modernize on their own terms. Yet Sanders does not do justice to the complexity of the Comité and its relationship to the British colonial government, many of whose members were neither British nor interested in the colonial administrations’ policies. The diverse and cosmopolitan nature of Cairo's population and its reflection in the Comité is not discussed, leaving the agency of its German cofounder (Julius Franz) and Austro-Hungarian successor (Max Herz) almost completely out of the picture—not to mention the French, Armenian, and Egyptian competing agendas. In addition, there is almost no discussion of the backgrounds or motives of the individuals on the Comité, though Sanders does invoke an alleged British obsession with the Orient and stories of the Thousand and One Nights, to which she dedicates her third chapter. Moreover, Egyptian reformers such as ʿAli Mubarak and Muhammad ʿAbduh receive less attention than they should. This is especially true of ʿAli Mubarak, a multifaceted man who played a significant role in Cairo's urban renewal and modernization efforts.
The last chapter of the book brings us to the contemporary period and details the most recent restoration work being done in Cairo by the Bohras, a subsect among the Ismaʿilis who are largely from the Indian sub-continent and trace their lineage to the Fatimid Caliphate. Sanders explores the complicated and sensitive issue of religiously motivated preservation and restoration and weaves an interesting portrait of how preservationist practices have changed to include religious groups with specific agendas alongside continuing European interests in preserving Cairo's perceived medievalness. She also points out the influence of these practices on local projects and how the choices the Bohras make in their restoration of Fatimid mosques have citywide ramifications. The chapter successfully argues that preservation and restoration practices not only have a substantial impact on how a city like Cairo is experienced but also that the meanings associated with those experiences are susceptible to the intentions, whether religious or political, of certain groups. Surprisingly, the vast amount of conservation work being done by the Aga Khan Development Network, particularly in al-Darb al-Ahmar near Al-Azhar Park, where substantial work on revitalizing religious as well as residential architecture has already had an effect on Cairo's skyline and overall experience, is left out of this discussion altogether.
Creating Medieval Cairo will certainly be useful in an architectural history or preservation course, particularly one dealing with colonial contexts, not only for the issues it raises but also because the book itself is an example of the complexities in dealing with the topic. Additionally, it would be useful for a seminar on Modern Egypt dealing with the palimpsest of Cairo's architectural history because the book addresses many themes regarding architectural heritage, meaning, and colonialism and raises important questions related to national identity and the influence of architecture. For the story of conservation of Islamic monuments in Cairo to be complete, however, it would be necessary to include a critical examination of the wide variety of foreign and Egyptian institutions engaged in restoring monuments in Cairo and the interests and motivations behind this engagement. This would certainly reveal the crucial role that Egypt's architecture plays in world heritage debates and contribute significantly to theories about who claims these cultural and historical identities and why.
