This volume is based upon a 2009 conference at the London School of Economics co-organized by English Heritage, the University of the West of England, and the National Trust. It was held in conjunction with “the bicentenary of the formal ending of the British slave trade in 2007” (p. xiii). “This conference brought together academics, heritage professionals, country house owners and community researchers” (p. vi) to describe and discuss the relations between wealth derived from slave ownership in, and the slave trade to, the British West Indies and the building, ownership, and occupancy of country houses in England. Also, as part of its public charge, it was to make the English population, both black and white, aware of this relation and the role of slavery and Africans in British society and life. The focus is on examples of people involved with slavery, to demonstrate the many evils committed by the British at the time (and later), and to correct and atone for the very limited discussions of this topic in most British histories. While there are some estimates pertaining to the question, raised by Eric Williams, of the magnitude of the contribution of slave-related activities to British economic growth, this is not the primary interest of this volume, which is more to describe British involvement with slavery. Nicholas Draper's study, based on his ongoing work with the records of the Slavery Compensation Commission, estimates “that 5 to 10 percent of the national elites were close enough to slavery to appear in the Slave Compensation records” (p. 4), and “slave wealth could be incidental in the sense that other sources of wealth appear to dwarf it in the composition of an individual's overall net worth” (p. 7).
The volume includes 13 essays, with most contributions coming from academics, mostly historians; two are by freelance scholars, two from media units, and one from English Heritage. Among the historians who have published books on the British West Indies with essays in this volume are Nicholas Draper, Madge Dresser, Simon D. Smith, Nuala Zahedieh, and Natalie Zacek. The overall volume is quite attractive. In addition to the high-quality essays, there are numerous paintings and photographs of country estates in the care of English Heritage, copies of portraits of slave owners, slaves, and free blacks, and finely detailed maps of relevant sites in England and the British West Indies. There are detailed discussions of the history of several of the country estates and their owners and other residents as well as some extremely useful guides to relevant primary sources.
The essays by Dresser and June Longmore provide interesting discussions of slavery and country houses in the West Country and Liverpool, respectively, while Roger H. Leech describes houses and gardens in the West Indian islands, we well as in England. Smith describes the trends in slave ownership in St. Vincent and describes some demographic patterns. He also presents interesting information on absentee ownership, planter indebtedness, and slave names. Zahedieh's major concern is with the mobility of the slave-based wealth holders, about which she strongly disagrees with the arguments of the Stones on social mobility. She makes the point that “some of the profits of the slave based colonial trades went to finance the Industrial Revolution but much was siphoned off into country house building” (p. 77). Sheryllynne Haggerty and Susanne Seymour compare two country homes and the behavior and attitudes of their owners, concluding that “while involvement in the slave trade and slavery was not a route to instant wealth, it was central to ideas of property, status and authority in 18th-century Britain” (p. 90). The focus of Laurence Brown's essay is a comparison of two British country houses, but he also describes the shipment of French convicts to Louisiana in the early eighteenth century and the role of the House of Baring in the early nineteenth century. Victoria Perry describes garden and landscape aesthetics, and their financing based, at times, on profits from the plantation economy. Zacek describes the holdings of the Codrington family in England and in the West Indies and also provides an interesting description of the controversy concerning the 1980 sale of the Codrington Papers. Caroline Bressey's discussion of two country houses includes information about both African residents and several “Indian types.” She berates the failure of the estate's presentation to ponder the meaning of these nonwhites for understanding British history. The last two essays—by Cliff Pereira and by Rob Mitchell and Shawn Sobers—are mainly concerned with issues relating to exhibits and their presentation and the successes (and failures) of this means of imparting knowledge to the public due to the need to correct what are often considered the myths of the British past.
While the diverse nature of these essays will mean that all may not appeal to all economic historians, this volume does succeed in achieving its stated goal of presenting useful information in an unusual manner.
