No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
The Cyprus conflict has been on the international agenda for almost half a century. It entered the international spotlight as an issue of decolonization in the 1950s; was transformed into an ethnic conflict in the 1960s; and further metamorphosed into a dangerous regional conflict between two NATO allies—namely, Turkey and Greece. The United Nations has been involved with the Cyprus issue since 1964, and since the 1990s a wide range of countries and international organizations (such as the European Union) have offered to help in disentangling this protracted conflict. The latest U.N. effort was in March 2003, when Secretary-General Kofi Annan put his prestige behind the peace talks taking place in the Hague. Alas, his efforts proved as futile as the numerous other peace plans for Cyprus that have been put on the table since the 1960s.
The literature on the Cyprus conflict can be broadly placed in two categories: impartial works and partisan writings. The latter constitute the major bulk of the literature, as we have been inundated with books supporting either the Greek or the Turkish views. Clement Dodd's Storm Clouds over Cyprus is one of those rare dispassionate works that provides a well-balanced and judicious account of this long-drawn-out conflict. The author makes several accurate diagnoses, which are critical in understanding the nature of the non-solution(s) presented so far. He writes, “The UN Security Council began to try to solve the problem soon after it virtually created it in March 1964, with Resolution 186, which led to the recognition of the wholly Greek Cypriot government as the Government of the Republic of Cyprus” (p. 24). Dodd continues, “The UN Security Council seeks to act as an honest broker in the Cyprus dispute, but it cannot properly fulfill such a role because of its recognition of one side as illegal. Any arbiter in a dispute must be, and be seen to be, impartial, but unfortunately this the UN cannot be. It cannot accept the Turkish and Turkish Cypriot contention that under the terms of the 1960 treaties establishing the Republic of Cyprus the Greek Cypriot Government is plainly illegal” (p. 38).
According to the author, the involvement of the European Union in the Cyprus conflict in the 1990s further complicated the situation and tilted the balance in favor of the Greek Cypriots. The European Union's decision to admit Cyprus as a member, regardless of whether a solution is found to the conflict, will have many negative repercussions for all parties involved. Such a move will result in the worsening of relations between Turkey and the European Union, as well as those between Turkey and Greece, and will further isolate the Turkish Cypriots from the international community, resulting in the permanent division of the island.
As a man intimately familiar with the fundamental issues and nuances of the Cyprus conflict, Dodd presents his arguments in a clear and compact fashion. In eighty-four pages he manages to touch on every crucial point surrounding this quarrel. For example, he does a nice job of explaining the partisan writings and “conflicting readings of history” promoted by each side (pp. 20–23). He then proceeds to analyze the federation and confederation models that are often presented as the pillars of any possible solution (pp. 25–28). Further, Dodd provides a clear description and an objective explanation of the legal issues pertaining to Cyprus's accession to the European Union (pp. 42–46). This part is particularly useful for those who are new to the Cyprus issue, as it forces the reader to contemplate whether the European Union is a catalyst or a debilitating factor in mediating a solution to the discord. In the thirty-six–page appendix that follows, Dodd provides the reader with such important documents as a previous U.N. peace plan, Security Council resolutions, and the position papers of the disputants.
In all, this book is an invaluable source for all those who need to understand the essentials of the Cyprus conflict. However, because the conflict is like a moving target, the work needs constant updating to remain relevant. One would hope that if there is to be a third edition, the author will include the latest developments, such as the European Union's Copenhagen summit in December 2002, the Cyprus meeting in The Hague in March 2003, and, most important, the signing of the European Union accession treaty by the (Greek) Republic of Cyprus in April 2003, which modified some of the essentials of the Cyprus conflict. A new edition would also benefit from an index and the addition of more sources in support of the arguments made and the further readings that are suggested by the author.