Men, Law and Gender is an ambitious, comprehensive and genuinely interdisciplinary work, ostensibly focused on gendered legal studies but with a reach far beyond any single academic boundary. Over the course of seven chapters, Collier covers a massive range of material (including the presentation of two novel empirical studies), developing themes that critically scrutinise the relationship between masculinity, masculine identities and law. This is achieved through discussion centred around: the conceptualisation of masculinity in legal scholarship (Chapter 1); mapping the relationship between the ‘corporatisation’ of higher education and gendered and class cultures within UK law schools (Chapters 2 and 3); exploration of the implicitly gendered representation of career success in UK law, derived from textual analysis of recruitment brochures and advertising material (Chapter 4); discussion of the ‘problem’ of fatherhood, tracing shifts in the relationship between law, policy, gender and parenting (Chapter 5); presentation and discussion of a qualitative study exploring male lawyers' experience of managing family life/work balance (Chapter 6); and finally an extended discussion of the relationship between fathers' rights activism, family law and the gendered male subject (Chapter 7).
What is perhaps most impressive about this book is the skill with which Collier handles what could otherwise be very sensitive material, where a careless word or casual phrase here or there could easily make one a hostage to gender-political fortune. That Collier manages to traverse such complex terrain without obviously alienating either side of the gender-political divide is testament to both the care of his writing and his meticulous scholarship. For example, although he explicitly frames many aspects of this book as a response to, or discussion of, the ‘problem’ of men, he takes care to assert that one need not focus on the negative aspects of men's identities in order to fruitfully explore concepts of masculinity, and he takes pains throughout to avoid such a trap. Similarly, he rejects the essentialist notion of there being a single, homogenous, male identity amongst people who identify themselves as men, whilst also acknowledging the force and cultural resonance of dominant modes of hegemonic masculinity. While this kind of middle-way positioning might initially appear to be fence-sitting, or even paradoxical, for Collier it is a reasonable and warranted response to the diversity of (often conflicting) gendered practices we see embodied in both law and legal scholarship. He states:
‘We are dealing with the heterogeneous nature of social practices in which progressive and regressive forms of gender politics can, we shall see, interact and co-exist in specific legal contexts, cutting across traditional political terrains in uncertain ways. This point has much to offer in developing an oppositional gender politics in the field of law, as well as challenging the existing frameworks through which these gender relations have been understood.’ (p. 5)
The ensuing chapters draw out these progressive/regressive tensions in a number of different but interrelated contexts, and serve as a springboard from which Collier seeks to launch a sophisticated, and very polite, attack on the relatively simplistic way in which masculinities have been framed and treated in law, concluding that ‘studies of law and gender … have much to gain from incorporating a more complex and multi-layered account of the gendered male subject and the interconnected nature of the lives of women, children and men’ (p. 241).
The breadth of material covered and the depth of theoretical sophistication are impressive. In a book with such ambitious scope, which draws on such a range of disciplinary traditions and perspectives, one might expect to have seen cracks appearing where these different perspectives interconnect. In fact, Collier does an excellent job of weaving together multiple narratives that would not traditionally sit easily together, so the book does not feel jumbled or contrived. What we find, rather, is a series of lucid and coherent interconnected chapters, which are as challenging as they are creative.
That is not to say of course that the book is flawless. First, there is an issue of methodological transparency. Chapters 3 and 6 present novel empirical data, reporting the results of a qualitative textual analysis of the advertising brochures of law firms, and a qualitative interview study of family life/work balance amongst practising male lawyers, respectively. The data and analyses presented are detailed and insightful; however, explanation of the methodology and analytic processes are relegated, if they are mentioned at all, to a few sparse footnotes. It is likely that this decision was made due to space constraints and concerns about maintaining narrative flow, but it is a striking omission, and one that prevents the reader from engaging fully and critically with the material. The presentation rather takes for granted that the reader will understand qualitative methodology, and gives the impression that qualitative research is a straightforward and homogenous process, when in fact there are many different approaches to data collection and analysis, all of which impact on the kind, and quality, of conclusions that can be drawn.
Second, the book is so complex that it is quite easy to lose track of the central arguments, and despite regular signposting and a definite attempt to guide the reader though the material, it is a challenging read, which is surprising because Collier's writing is, for the most part, very clear. The source of this is that at times the book feels like a series of interconnected but separate chapters, each espousing a different thesis. It is unclear to me whether there is a single and central positive thesis coming out of the book, or whether it is a collection of smaller negative theses that seek to problematise current ways of thinking about masculinity in law. Whilst all the chapters are related (and cross-referenced) one does get a sense that each chapter could stand alone. Although this does have benefits for the casual reader, at times it can give the impression that one is reading an edited collection – albeit a very coherent and well planned collection – of discrete bodies of work, rather than a single and linear argumentative thread. Having said this, perhaps all that is lacking is a clear statement of the argumentative structure, with even more obvious signposting. With criticism of this kind however, one must always bear in mind that a reviewer's perception of such a weakness may in fact be a reflection of his own limitations.
Finally, I was disappointed not to see the discussion of class (in the context of academic law, Chapter 3) extended into the discussions of fathers and fatherhood. Chapter 6, in particular, which reports the findings of Collier's empirical study into male lawyers' (family) life/work balance, seems to me to be crying out for reflection on the extent to which class and educational status might impact on the idea of fatherhood that these men buy into and thus might feed into the tensions that they experience. What we have in Chapter 6 is a sample of well-educated, middle-class, professional and successful men talking about the tensions they (and their colleagues) experience in balancing their aspirations to involved fatherhood and career success. Whilst Collier makes a point of not drawing generalised conclusions from this sample, he does not consider whether these tensions are symptomatic of a classed exposure and commitment to a mode of fatherhood that demands more of these men than they feel able to deliver. Maybe this is an unfair criticism, given that it is made in the light of research findings published after this book came out which suggest a positive correlation between educational status in fathers and commitment to child care (Sullivan, Reference Sullivan2010). Sullivan theorises:
‘… the moral panic around child care evident over the past 20 years or more has had a more pronounced effect on those with higher educational attainment because of their greater exposure to the written and professional media in which these panics are often manifested, thereby feeding in to a gendered moral rationality which emphasizes time spent in child care.’ (p. 729)
Perhaps this is not a criticism of Collier, but a lamenting of the fact that this angle is not explicitly covered given his likely insight into the subject.
In summary, this is a hugely impressive book, which is thoughtful, insightful, superbly researched and above all very human. Collier expertly weaves together multiple academic and personal narratives in an analysis that is not only academically robust but also highly sensitive to the human stories that demonstrate that this is not merely an academic exercise, but that these issues matter, and in ways that have not been examined before. The questions Collier raises have implications beyond the confines of gendered legal studies, reaching into policy, ethics, sociology and social care. Accordingly, this book lays the groundwork for myriad future interdisciplinary research agendas around masculinities, fatherhood and law, and should be required reading for anyone working in the area.
